HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 05201997 - D2 D.2
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
Adopted this Order on May 20, 1997, by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisors Rogers, Uilkema, Canciamilla and DeSaulnier
NOES: None
ABSENT: Supervisor Gerber
ABSTAIN: None
SUBJECT: Animal Services Department - 1997 Performance Report
Mike Ross, Acting Animal Services Director, presented both a written and oral
departmental performance report.
Subsequent to the presentation by Mr. Ross, the Board took the following action:
1. ACCEPTED report from Mike Ross, Acting Animal Services Director, on
departmental performance.
I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and
correct copy of an action taken and entered on
the minutes of the Board of Supervisors on the
date shown.
ATTESTED: May 20, 1997
Phil Batchelor, Clerk of the Board of
Supervisors and County Administrator
e Wampler, Deputy Clerk
cc: County Administrator
Animal Services Department
1 ' r
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
1997 PERFORMANCE
REPORT
MICHAEL G. Ross
ACTING ANIMAL SERVICEs DIRECTOR
1 ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 1
DEPARTMENT OVERVIEW 2
DEPARTMENT RESPONSIBILITIES 2
HISTORY 2
GOALS AND OBJECTIVES: 2
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE 3
RESOURCES 4
FINANCIAL RESOURCES 4
PERSONNEL RESOURCES 5
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION 5
SICK LEAVE 5
STAFF DEVELOPMENT 6
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS 6
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 6
AUTOMATION 6
CUSTOMER SERVICES 7
SERVICE DELIVERY SYSTEM 7
SERVICE PROGRAMS 7
SERVICE MANDATES 7
CUSTOMER PROFILE 11
CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIPS 11
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE 12
WORKLOAD INDICATORS 12
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS 12
12
COMPARISON WITH OTHER AGENCIES 1996 13
ACCOMPLISHMENTS 14
DOING MORE WITH LESS 14
HUMANE EDUCATION 15
SCHOOLS PROGRAM 16
AWARDS 16
FACILITIES 16
CHALLENGES AND NEW DIRECTIONS 16
CHALLENGES 16
FACILITIES 16
GROWTH 17
NEW DIRECTIONS 17
EFFORTS TO INCREASE REVENUE 17
LETTERS OF COMMENDATION 18
SCHOOLS PROGRAM COMMENTS 19
f f
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 2
1997 PERFORMANCE REPORT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
DEPARTMENT OVERVIEW
DEPARTMENT RESPONSIBILITIES
HISTORY
Prior to 1979, the animal control functions of the County were
performed by the Animal Control Division of the Department of
Agriculture. The Animal Services Department was created by
Ordinance 79-17 and began operations as a separated Department on
April 1, 1979. On December 23, 1980, .the Board of Supervisors
adopted the revised County Animal Control Ordinance. This Ordinance
sets forth the legal authority for the Department's operations and
defines the scope of those operations.
GOALS AND OBJECTIVES:
• To protect the citizens of Contra Costa County from animal
related disease and injury.
• To encourage responsible pet ownership and the humane
treatment of animals.
• To enforce State laws and County ordinances relating to animal
control and welfare.
• To minimize animal suffering.
• To provide a safe and fulfilling work environment.
• To reduce the number of animals that are euthanized by the
County.
• To maximize the number of licensed dogs in the County.
• To educate the public regarding responsible pet ownership.
' ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 3
• To provide a high level of humane care for animals in our
custody.
• To recognize that the public is the reason for our work, not an
interruption to it.
• To encourage employee achievement and productivity.
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
The Animal Services Department is divided into two major functional
divisions: Operations and Administration.
Mike Ross
Acting Director
Ilona Robertson
Volunteer Coordinator/Humane Eduacation
70
Vokmters
TedBrasier i/sCas>t
Chief of Operations Admhi�raHve SetvioesOtfi
Shelter Operations Field Operations Clerical Support Fiscal/Personnel
Licensing Spay/Neuter Cynic
The Operations Division is managed by Chief of Operations, Ted
Brasier. This division is responsible for all field and shelter activities.
The Administrative Division is managed by an Administrative
Services Officer. This division is responsible for: providing clerical
support for the Operations Division, managing the Department's
budgeting, personnel, affirmative action, safety, animal licensing,
spay/neuter, records retention, vehicles, facility's management, and
data processing programs.
In addition to paid staff, the Department has an active volunteer
program involving more than 70 citizens who assist the Department
with lost and found pets, adoption counseling and spay/neuter
appointments.
ANIMAL 8ERVICE8 DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 4
The Department also has a close working relationship with several
animal groups. These community-based organizations are primarily
concerned with reducing the number of animals that must be
euthanized. We share a common goal and work with these
organizations on adoptions, spay/neuter promotions and educational
programs.
RESOURCES
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
1996-1997 Budget
Salaries and Benefits $3,217,887
Services and Supplies $379,386
Leases $8,100
Fixed Assets $18,764
Total Expenditures $3,6249131
Animal Licenses77 $1,100,845
City Contracts $1,079,208
Fines And Fees $650,737
Surgery Fees $140,661
Animal Adoption Fees $30,000
Miscellaneous $595
Total Revenue $3,0029046
Net County Cost 1 $6229085
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT rj
PERSONNEL RESOURCES
Allocated.Positiolls
Director 1
Chief of Operations 1
Administrative Officer 1
Executive Secretary1
Animal Clinic Veterinarian 2
Animal Services Lieutenant 5
Animal Services Officer 24
Senior Animal Center Tech. 2
Animal Center Technician 5
Office Manager 1
Clerical Supervisor 1
Senior Clerk Lead Specialist 2
Senior Clerk 10
Experienced Level Clerk 7
Animal Health Technician 2
Total 65
Staffing has remained constant over the last five years while service
demands have increased.
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION
As of January 1, 1997, the Department was allocated 65 permanent
positions. Of these 65 positions, 59 are filled. Of these 59 employees,
15 are minorities and 31 are female. The Department meets or
exceeds parity for all ethnic groups except Asian and Hispanic. One
employee needs to be hired in each of these categories for the
Department to be at parity for all ethnic groups.
The Department is committed to continuing our affirmative action
efforts. We will continue to work closely with the Human Resources
Department and Affirmative Action Division of the County
Administrator's Office to ensure that the Department's workforce is a
reflection of our diverse community.
SICK LEAVE
Sick leave usage is reviewed for each employee on a monthly basis.
Employees who experience excessive usage are counseled and
monitored. Usage for the first quarter of 1997 is 63% of accruals. This
compares with usage of 77% for calendar year 1996.
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT G
STAFF DEVELOPMENT
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS
All staff in the Department are evaluated on an annual basis using
occupational-specific performance factors. Evaluation results are
reviewed with the employee by his or her supervisor. The division
manager and the Department head must sign off on the evaluation.
The employee is afforded an opportunity to discuss his or her
evaluation with the division manager and/or the Department head.
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
Training sessions involving the entire staff are held on a monthly
basis. Job-related topics are covered for all occupational groups. Staff
members are encouraged to utilize the Training Institute for additional
training that they feel will be of benefit to their professional
development.
AUTOMATION
The Department utilizes an IBM AS400 computer system to link with
the County mainframe computer. Local area networks and remote
location controllers are used to link' the Department's personal
computers and terminals with the mainframe and the AS400. The
Department has developed, in conjunction with Data Processing staff, a
computerized animal licensing and tracking system that is used to
ensure that the maximum number of animals are licensed in the
County.
The Department was the first to install an optical disc filing system to
allow us to more efficiently manage and retrieve the tens of thousands
of records we must handle each year.
The Department is currently exploring the purchase of a software
package that will automate the majority of the Department's operations.
This system integrates field services, kennel management, licensing,
billing and record retention into one package. This system will bring
needed efficiencies to the Department's operations by reducing the
amount of paper that must be processed and retained. We hope to pay
for the system through reduced Information Technology charges.
' ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 7
CUSTOMER SERVICES
SERVICE DELIVERY SYSTEM
SERVICE PROGRAMS
Service is provided primarily in each of four major program areas.
These programs are: field services, shelter services, animal licensing
and the spay/neuter/vaccination clinic. Some of these services overlap
depending on the situation. For example, a person may report a dog
bite to our clerical staff at one of the animal shelters. An Animal
Services Officer would be dispatched to the scene of the bite to
impound the biting animal. The animal might be impounded at the
owner's home or brought into the animal shelter. When the person
comes into the shelter to reclaim the dog, they may have to purchase a
dog license as well as pay impound and quarantine fees.
SERVICE MANDATES
Rabies Control State law requires counties that are
declared rabies endemic areas to:
• Investigate animal bites
• Quarantine biting animals
• Maintain a pound system
• Operate a dog licensing program
• Conduct low-cost rabies vaccination
clinics
California Code of Regulations 2606
Health and Safety Code 121690
Euthanasia Sick, old and unwanted and or
unclaimed animals are humanely
euthanized by injection. Food and
Agriculture Code 31105
ANIMAL SERVICE8 DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 8
Leash Law Enforcement Dogs must be kept on a leash when not
on the property of their owner. Owners
in violation are either issued a court
citation or the animal is impounded.
Food and Agriculture Code 31105
Dog Licensing The State Health and Safety Code
requires the licensing of dogs in rabies
endemic areas. The State Agriculture
Code also requires dog licensing. The
Department uses a computerized system
to identify owners who have vaccinated
their dogs against rabies but who have
not obtained a license. Follow-up is
done by Animal Services Officers who
issue court citations to owners in
violation.
California Code of Regulations 2606
Health and Safety Code 121690
Cruelty to Animals Cruelty to animals is a violation of the
State Penal Code. Reports of cruelty are
investigated by Animal Services Officers.
Officers testify in court if the investigation
substantiates the allegation and criminal
charges are brought. Domestic animals
that are sick or injured must be treated
by a veterinarian. The County becomes
liable for these charges if an owner
cannot be located.
Penal Code 597
1 ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 9
Discretionary
Dangerous Animal Investigation Repeated biting incidents or citizen
complaints relative to aggressive dogs
are investigated by Animal Services
Lieutenants. Owners charged with
possession of a dangerous animal are
allowed to challenge this assertion at a
public hearing conducted by the
Department's Hearing Officer.
Barking Dog Complaints The department investigates complaints
of barking dogs and works with the
District Attorney to alleviate these
problems.
Dead Animal Pick-up Dead animals pose a health risk. The
department receives requests to pick up
dead animals and Animal Services
Officers perform this function as a part of
their regular patrol duties.
Police Search Warrant Assistance Drug dealers often protect their property
with aggressive and potentially dangerous
dogs and other animals. The department
assists various police agencies by
subduing these animals when a warrant is
served.
Adoption Animals are sold to citizens desiring a
pet.
Spay/Neuter Vaccination Clinic This self-supporting program provides
low-cost spay/neuter services to the
public and has in part been responsible
for the decrease in the number of dogs
and cats euthanized by the County. (From
over 45,000 in 1971 to 10,655 in 1996. A
reduction of 77%)
•. ' ANIMAL SERVICE8 DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 10
Education Program "Safety Around Animals" and humane
education programs have been given to
over 100,000 school children, the Post
Office, PG&E, and numerous service
clubs. The safety program has resulted
in a significant reduction in the number
of dog bites, particularly to children.
(From 1,721 dog bites in 1980 to 1,209
dog bites in 1996. A reduction of 30°x)
Lost And Found Persons who have lost a pet and those
who have found an animal can use the
Department's services to reunite
animals with owners.
Volunteers Over 70 citizens concerned with animal
welfare issues volunteer their services to
assist with the lost and found program,
animal adoptions and in scheduling
appointments at the spay/neuter clinic.
Citizen Requests For Service Animals create many problems for
citizens living in an urban and suburban
environment. Calls include:
• Animal rescue
• Loose exotic animals
• large snakes
• alligators, lizards
lions, and other large
cats kept as pets
Wild Animal Complaints
• skunks
• deer
• raccoons
rattlesnakes
• Female in season
Loose livestock
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT I1
CUSTOMER PROFILE
The Animal Services Department provides service to the entire
County with the exception of the City of Antioch. Our customer base is
therefore over 800,000 people. Citizens from every socioeconomic,
ethnic background and occupation have at one time or another contact
with our staff. Last year we responded to over 65,000 requests for field
service. On a typical day our main office clerical staff will handle 400
to 500 phone calls and over 100 walk-in customers.
CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIPS
The relationship between our Department and the public we serve is
diverse. We provide many services to the community. Some of these
services require that we enforce State and County laws relative to
animal control issues. A person who receives a citation for not
licensing their dog will not be as happy with us as a person who has
just been reunited with a lost pet or who has adopted the perfect puppy
or kitten.
Our staff is trained to do a difficult job with what could best be
described as assertive compassion. Our personnel are courteous and
thoughtful in their dealings with the citizens of the County. We
emphasize good customer relations with all of our staff. We have no
survey data to share with the Board in this regard. However, I receive
far more complimentary letters than I do complaints about our service.
Some examples of recently received letters are attached.
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 12
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE
1 -1994 1994-1995 -1996
993 1995
WORKLOAD INDICATORS
Dog Bites 1,176 1,141 1,253
Dogs Quarantined 1,060 1,034 1,199
. . . . ,
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
Calls Handled Per Officer 3,643 3,998 4,527
Citations Issued Per Officer 295 327 319
Animals Impounded Per Officer 1,141 1,181 1,374
Animals Licenses Issued 46,035 43,256 41,262
. . . . 1995-1996
O.
Animal Licensing Revenue $866,946 $913,349 $918,595
Total Revenue $2,381,303 $2,541,426 $2,589,313
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 13
COMPARISON WITH OTHER AGENCIES 1996
PER CAPITA REVENUE
1/ -•
.. COSTA
$3.50 0 LOS ANMM COUNTY
11 M SAN 0830
ASM1N VENTURA
$1.50 0 KERN COUNTY
$1.00 to LOS ANUM CFTY
$0.50 m SACRAMENTO CRY
0 SAN MANCISCO
PERCENTAGE OF • EUTHANIZED
90.00% mCONM• COSTA
N SAN DIB30 COUNTY
80.00% - - COUNTY
50.00% rm LOS ANGMM CITY
�'��_
40.00%
1'
30.00% E3 LOS ANGELES COUNTY
20.00% - 0 SACRAMENTO CRY
10.00%
.0.00% P •Gj f
_ _ _
KERN COUNTY
PER CAPITA DOG LICENSES
0.000 a COWM COSTA
0.050 .
N'
1 1 K 1
aLL'�.x •ti •S ANMIS C0 SACROWSM CITY
ITY
0.010 -
0.000 -
1 1
�¢
• ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 14
ACCOMPLISHMENTS
DOING MORE WITH LESS
Since 1981-82 the Department has reduced its dependence on the
County General Fund by 40% while experiencing an increase in
population served of 27%. In 1981-82 it took $1.63 per capita in
General Fund revenue to provide animal control services to the citizens
of the County. In 1996-97 it cost $.77 in General Fund revenue to
provide a higher level of service to those citizens. This is a reduction of
54%. From 1981 to 1996 the consumer price index rose 70.86%.
1981-1982 BUDGET $1,586,840
REVENUE
35%
NET COUNTY
COST
65%
1996-1997 BUDGET $3,598,466
NET COUNTY
COST
17%
REVENUE
83%
1 ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 15
HUMANE EDUCATION
ADOPT A TEACHER PROGRAM
The Adopt-A-Teacher Program, run by the Contra Costa County
Animal Services Department, helps students to learn kindness and
compassion toward animals, the environment, and people.
Through this program, classrooms receive a bundle of 32
newspapers (KIND NEWS) for students each month. The teacher
receives a teaching guide to accompany each issue, and also receives
a 60-page teaching guide, posters, and Kind Club cards at the
beginning of the school year.
The cost for this program is $20.00 per classroom, and is paid for by
the "adopter" or "sponsor" of the classroom. The Animal Services
Department finds sponsors for this program, and then matches the
sponsor with a classroom in Contra Costa County. The classroom is
notified that they have been "adopted" and are given the name of their
sponsor so they can write thank you letters if they would like to do so.
The newspapers have information on domestic animals, wildlife, the
environment, and each issue also contains an anti-drug message. The
newspapers are printed by NAHEE (National Association for Humane
and Environmental Education), which is the educational division of the
Humane Society of the United States.
This partnership program has been very successful, and KIND
NEWS has won numerous awards, including the Partnerships in
Education Journal Award of Merit, 1990, APEX '92 and '93 Award of
Excellence, and The National Environmental Awards Council Certificate
of Environmental Achievement.
The Animal Services Department has adopted over 200 classrooms
through this program, and we hope to add more classrooms to our list
each year.
• ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 16
SCHOOLS PROGRAM
We have continued our program of sending staff and volunteers to
schools throughout the county to provide humane education and safety
around animals instruction. Attached are teacher and student feedback
relative to this well received program.
AWARDS
Exceptional Humane Education Outreach Award Issued by The
National Association For Humane And Environmental Education
Certificate of Caring Issued by The National Association For The
Advancement of Humane Education, A division of The Humane Society
Of The United States, in recognition of the Department's Adopt-a-
Teacher Program
FACILITIES
By mid June we will have completed an addition to the Martinez
Animal Control Center. This addition will add 500 square feet of much
needed office space. Our thanks to the County Administrator's Office
and General Services for their support and assistance on this project.
CHALLENGES AND NEW DIRECTIONS
CHALLENGES
FACILITIES
The main parts of our animal control centers were constructed in the
late 1940's and early 1950's. These buildings do not: meet Americans
With Disabilities Act standards, meet the current needs of the citizens
of the County and are a source of low morale for our staff. We are
working with the County Administrator's Office on the feasibility of
replacing our Martinez facility. We are hopeful that the Interstate 680
widening project will require the State of California to pay a major
portion of the cost to rebuild and relocate the facility.
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 17
GROWTH
The County is growing rapidly in the eastern and southern sectors.
In order to provide a reasonable level of service, satellite animal control
centers should be built in these areas if we are to provide efficient
service to these locations in the next century.
We will continue to work with the County Administrator's Office to
plan for these challenges.
NEW DIRECTIONS
EFFORTS TO INCREASE REVENUE
Credit Cards
We will be implementing a credit card payment system within the
next two months. Allowing the option of credit payment will result in
reduced billing and therefore fewer bad debts.
Internal Collection Efforts
Currently we bill for some services. Thirty days after an invoice is
issued we refer the account to the Office of Revenue Collections. This
time lag has resulted in an unsatisfactory collection rate. Within the
next thirty days we will begin our own internal collection effort before
referring the account to ORC. We are hopeful that we can cost justify
the clerical time required through increased revenue.
' ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 18
LETTERS OF COMMENDATION
g
�i
V
f"011�
94,
Ur
1917 Whitecliff Ct.
Walnut Creek, CA 94596
Ms. Diane Iwase, Director
Animal Services Department
4849 Imhoff Place
Martinez, CA
Dear Ms. Iwase,
On Sunday, February 11 , we had occasion to solicit the services of your
department. We cannot praise highly enough the attention paid to our
problem ( an injured cat which had bitten my husband) by the responding
Animal Control Officer, Mr. Manuel Morales. In ati our dealings with public
servants over the years we have never come away from an encounter with
such positive feelings.
Whether it was your training or his own natural instincts that produced
such a combination of professionalism tempered with true compassion for
our injured animal and our situation (our suspicion is it was both), you
should be proud to have such an employee in your unit.
Additionally, when I called your office to obtain your name and title for
purposes of this letter, the person who answered, Jan, was equally as
helpful and pleasant. You are obviously a fine manager who inspires her
employees to treat clients with dignity and respect.
Please convey our thanks to these fine employees.
Sincerely,
Kathy Castro
cc: Mr. Manuel Morales
Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors
May 8, 1997
Chief Brasier
Contra Costa County
Animal Services Department
4849 Imhoff Place
Martinez, California 94553-4314
Regardting: AHn 193777
Dear Chief Brasier,
My husband and I would like to take a moment of your time to make you aware
of a very special Officer who we feel strongly should be highly commended,
and recognized for the very special person he is.
We had placed a few calls to your department regarding a black .lab who had
been wandering our property and the surrounding area on Bethel Island.
It appeared to my husband and I that either the dog had become lost, or that
some heartless person had just dumped this defenseless sweet little dog on the
side of the road, leaving her to fend for herself.
We were not only greatly concerned for the dogs safety, but also had concerns
about the dog, due to her state of starvation getting into our yard and going
after our ducks and geese.
The poor little thing was starved to the point of near skin and bones, and was
absolutely terrified.
After several days of attempting to coax the dog over to me, on May 7, 1997 I
was finally able to get her to trust me enough to let me get within a feu- feet
of her.
As I was in this process of this praying that God would help me to set close
enough to get a leash on her, afraid that if I left to get my husban to help
i would never get the chance to get that close again, when Officer Rassell
appeared like an Angel from Heaven just at the right time as if in answer to
my prayer.
From the moment of Officer Russell's arrival he showed such compassion and
patience for this hungry, terrified, sweet little baby. The kind of love Officer
Russell displayed for this lost little dog is not something that can be learned,
nor can it be faked, it is something that has to come from the heart.
I can't tell you how impressed I was with how this Officer handled himself, God
has truly provided the lost animals of this County with their own special
Guardian Angel, Officer Russell.
My husband and I both would like to express our heartfelt thanks to Officer
Russell, and make you aware of just what a special blessing this Officer is.
Our prayers will be with this sweet little dog in the hopes that Officer
Russell's efforts will not be in vain and that she is blessed with a caring and
loving home.
Sincerely,
Ro ert and Michelle Jones
Copy to: Officer Michael Russell
Bethel Island Beacon - Gazette
ANIMAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PERFORMANCE REPORT 19
SCHOOLS PROGRAM COMMENTS
Q Q,�GG�QQST4 4Q 4?434142
Evaluation Sheet
1 Humane Education
School
Teacher C `7 /'iS 17 h e AA/-rL5 Grade Level oc h G
Please fill out the following evaluation. Your evaluation will
help the Humane Education Department improve our presentations .
Your comments as a skilled educator are needed.
1 . Information given was (check as many as applicable ) :
Clear V Too much information to be absorbed
Unclear Not enough information Interesting �s .
Dull Other
2 . Vocabulary used was :
Appropriate for grade level V Too difficult
Too simple for grade level Other
3 . Rapport among students and presenter was :
Good Fair Poor Other
4 . Topics covered were :
appropriate for grade level Too difficult
Too simple Other
5 . In your judgement , whichart o,f /the program was least liked
by your students? 7* 7, 64/ aiz
6 . Which part of the, program was most valuable to your
students? iJ00 //
—Z li t-h,a h. l !/�S (� ��ti es aq-r_ 7 L
7 . Please write any criticisms , comments or suggestions you may
have :
Please give me a call if you would be interested in having a
follow-up program for your classroom.
Ilona Robinson 672-2829
THANK YOU for your time and class time !
QQQ`�QQQQ 4'QQ4��1Q
Evaluation Sheet
+ . Humane Education
School ,L� /-x
Teacher -APME Grade Level
Please fill out the following evaluation . Your evaluation will
help the Humane Education Department improve our presentations .
Your comments as a skilled educator are needed.
1 . Information given was (check as many as applicable ) :
Clear Too much information to be absorbed
Unclear Not enough information Interesting
Dull Other
2 . Vocabulary used was : v
Appropriate for grade level /* Too difficult
Too simple for grade level Other
3 . Rapport among students and presenter was :
Good Fair Poor Other
4 . Topics covered were :
appropriate for grade level �_ Too difficult
Too simple Other
5 . In your judgement , which part of the program was least liked
by your students?
6 . Which part of the program was most valuable to your.
st dents?
unluaZple and s a ,r_e C.e Lt(
7 . Please write any criticisms , comments or suggestions you may
have :
Polot,klsNt ��or�� SO
�C i 11 I rp n- d C Y.( ( Les fs Gffnlowod �-ej—
a nd 1-ea/-/7 e. 1v e
Please give me a call if you would be interested in having a
follow-up program for your classroom.
I Ilona Robinson 672-2829
THANK YOU for your time and class time !
4
V 'QN `
j�Av
\FV Olt
115�
SN� G6,0
1.tlY .ter. _ ��_ `� •�` 7�y'.�i3'j�!'S e_. ��.
:'M'.L.��• �. '.J'�
s
-Mit:•�-
w!'
al
-b&--n-i G a --
_ r►_S�o -_S_------ - - -- ---
i.-.-i y
i
�' '•- `'moi � �
� a
y i
J