HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 04011997 - P1-SD4 P /
IN THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
OF
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN THE MATTER OF PROCLAIMING )
APRIL 1997 AS EARTHQUAKE ) RESOLUTION NO. 97/ 147
PREPAREDNESS MONTH )
WHEREAS, the Governor has proclaimed April 1997 as Earthquake
Preparedness Month; and
WHEREAS, all local jurisdictions are encouraged to support the
concept of Earthquake Preparedness Month; and
WHEREAS, the San Francisco Bay Area includes several faultlines
which serve as a constant threat of a devastating earthquake; and
WHEREAS, the United States Geological Survey has recently announced
that the probability of a major quake occurring in the Bay Area is
greater than originally predicted; and
WHEREAS, the Hayward Fault, which traverses the western part of
Contra Costa County, has the potential to generate a powerful
earthquake and poses one of the greatest natural disaster threats
in the nation in terms of possible deaths, injuries and property
damage; and
WHEREAS, mitigation measures taken now can significantly reduce the
personal harm and property damage resulting from an earthquake,
IT IS HEREBY BY THIS BOARD RESOLVED that the month of April is
proclaimed as Earthquake Preparedness Month in Contra Costa County
and all county residents are urged to take steps to prepare their
homes and families to cope with the afermath of a major earthquake
by developing earthquake response plans and stocking emergency
supplies such as extra water, food, flashlights, batteries, first
aid kits and portable radios.
I hereby certify that this is a
true and correct copy of an
action taken and entered on the
minutes of the Board of
Supervisors on the date shown.
ATTESTED: April 1, 1997
Phil Batchelor, Clerk of the
Board of Supervisors and County
Administrator
By Deputy Clerk
Orig: Director, Office of Emergency Services
cc: All Cities via OES
SD , a�
To: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Contra
G'
FR°M` SUPERVISOR JIM ROGER$ ;, Costa
County
April 1, 1997
DATE: srq`fouri
ESTABLISH COUNTY POLICIES TO REQUIRE DEVELOPERS TO
SUBJECT: PROVIDE AFFORDABLE HOUSING OR TO PAY AN IN-LIEU FEE FOR
CONSTRUCTION OF HIGH DENSITY HOUSING AT BART STATIONS
SPECIFIC REQUEST(S)OR RECOMMENDATION($)&BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
RECOMMENDATIONS:
A. REQUEST that the Community Development Director prepare a report for the
Board of Supervisors with the following information:
1. Previous history of Development Agreements that had required an
affordable housing component and an assessment of the effect of this
requirement on the marketability of homes.
2. Evaluate the 1992 Report/Recommendations of the Housing Trust Fund
Task Force in view of current circumstances, including:
a. Trust Fund Revenue Sources
b. Institutional and operational issues
C. Issues needing reassessment
3. Identification of steps that must be taken to amend the County General
Plan and to place into County ordinance the following requirements that
developments would be required to follow when proposing housing
projects:
CONTINUED ON ATTACHMENT: —YES SIGNATURE:
_RECOMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR RECOMMENDATION OF SOA41)COMMITTEE
...—.APPROVE ...—OTHER
SIGNATURE(S)' Illlfi RO GFRR
ACTION OF BOARD ON APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED K OTHER X
PLEASE SEE ADDENDUM (Attached) FOR A LIST OF SPEAKERS AND FURTHER BOARD ACTION.
VOTE OF SUPERVISORS
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A TRUE
X UNANIMOUS(ABSENT V 1 AND CORRECT COPY OF AN ACTION TAKEN
AYES: NOES: AND ENTERED ON THE MINUTES OF THE BOARD
ABSENT: ABSTAIN: OF SUPERVISORS ON THE DATE SHOWN.
CC: County Administrator ATTESTED April I, 1997
Director, GMEDA PHI HELOR,CLERK OF THE BOARD of
Community Development Director P SORS AND COUNTY AD ST ATOR
County Counsel
Internal Operations Committee (via CAO)
Mayors' Conference (via CDD) BY UT
M392 (10i88)City County Relations (via CDD) IV I
Option #
Require developers to propose units of affordable housing based on the
Dougherty Valley model, i.e., develop 25% of total units in affordable
housing according to the following ratios:
10% affordable to very low income families
25% affordable to low income families
65% affordable to moderate income families, or
Option #2
Pay in-lieu fees to a Mass Transit-Oriented Housing Trust Fund which
would be established by the County to subsidize affordable high density
housing near BART stations in Contra Costa County, or
Option #
Some combination of Option #1 and Option #2.
4. Recommend threshold size of housing development in which these
would be required.
5. Recommend provisions to ensure that County General Plan policies will
be sensitive to concerns of adjacent cities.
6. Recommend process to set up Mass Transit-Oriented Housing Trust
Fund.
7. Identify revenue source to cover the costs of undertaking the above.
B. REQUEST that the County Counsel propose language for ordinance(s) that
would effect these changes.
C. REQUEST that this report be forwarded to the Internal Operations Committee
in approximately 90 days.
BACKGROUND REASONS FOR RECOMMENDATIONS:
This will ensure that the Board's goals of supporting affordable housing and mass-
transit based housing will actually be accomplished,
Given the decrease in federal and state funding in this area, the County should
ensure that new development helps meet this pressing need.
In addition, Measure C, the half-cent sales tax, passed by the voters in 1988, and
administered by the Contra Costa Transportation Authority, requires that jurisdictions
work toward jobs-housing balances with the purpose of reducing traffic congestion.
Housing advocates support a mix of housing in all areas and encourage
development which ensure access to those who do not drive.
-2-
S�2
SD.2
ADDENDUM
Item SD.2
April 1, 1997
Supervisor Rogers presented recommendations to the Board for establishing County
policies to require developers to provide affordable housing or to pay an in-lieu fee
for construction of high density housing at BART stations.
The Board members discussed the issues and then Chairman DeSaulnier invited the
public to comment on the issues. The following persons spoke:
Kathryn Smick, League of Women Voters, Diablo Valley Chapter, 1115
Oak Hill Road, Lafayette;
Guy Bjerke, Home Builders Association, P.O. Box 5160, San Ramon;
Reva Clark, Co-Chair Housing Committee, Co-Chair Advisory Council
on Aging, 4556 Appian Way, El Sobrante;
Trudi Riley, Contra Costa Advisory Council on Aging, Co-Chair
Housing Committee, Moraga;
Brian Harradine, Independent Living Resource, 3811 Alhambra Avenue,
Martinez;
John Metzler, Independent Living Resource, 3811 Alhambra Avenue,
Martinez;
Merlin Wedepohl, Shelter Inc./AHHSP, 1070 Concord Avenue, Suite
200, Concord;
Joan Bartulovich, Mental Health Commission, 7102 Donai Avenue, El
Cerrito;
Kagey DorosI, West County Senior Coalition, 1015 Nevin, Suite 102,
Richmond;
Darlyne Houk, CCAR, 111 North Wiget Lane, Walnut Creek;
Ethel Dotson, Welfare Rights, 396 South Street, Richmond.
All persons desiring to speak having been heard, Chairman DeSaulnier ended public
comment on the matter.
The Board members continued to discuss the issues and then took the following
action:
1. REQUESTED that the Community Development Director prepare a report on
the issue of low income housing including the recommendations as set forth
in the recommendations presented (Attached);
2. REQUESTED that the report address issues including: consulting with
concerned private sector parties, consulting with the City County Relations
Committee and the Mayors' Conference, taking a position of non-interference
with city land use jurisdictions, and recommending a plan which will provide
affordability as well as preserve affordability of low/moderate income
developments into the future; and
3. REQUESTED that the Community Development Director submit the requested
report to the Internal Operations Committee for further study and
recommendation to the Board.
cc: County Administrator
Internal Operations Committee (via CAO)
Director, GMEDA
Community Development Director
Mayors' Conference (via CDD)
City County Relations (via CDD)
County Counsel
S� 3
TO: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS n Contra
%' •:
FROM: SUPERVISOR JIM ROGERS { ; Costa
T -
. _. ` County
DATE: March 27, 1997 zac
SUBJECT: WORKERS MEMORIAL AND SAFETY DAY
SPECIFIC REQUEST(S)OR RECOMMENDATION(S)8 BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
RECOMMENDATION:
DECLARE April 27, 1997 as "Workers Memorial and Safety Day" in Contra Costa
County, ENDORSE the "Workers Memorial Day" event at Pacheco Boulevard and
Howe Avenue in Martinez on April 27, 1997 at 2:00 P.M., and URGE citizens to
attend the event.
BACKGROUND:
The recent death of a refinery worker at Tosco's Avon plant was a tremendous
tragedy for his family and co-workers. The unfortunate reality is there have been
hundreds of deaths in Contra Costa County due to work place accidents and injuries.
In order to bring to the public's attention the importance of maintaining high
standards for work place safety regulations, the Building Trades Council and the
Central Labor Council are sponsoring a Workers Memorial Day on Sunday, April 27,
1997 from 2:00 P.M. to 3:30 P.M. The event will be held in front of the Shell
Refinery at Pacheco Boulevard and Howe Avenue in Martinez. This is a nationally
coordinated event that occurs each year on the date that the Occupational Safety
and Health Administration was created in 1970.
CONTINUED ON ATTACHMENT: -YES SIGNATURE:
RECOMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR RECOMMENDATION OF BOARD COMMITTEE
APPROVE _OTHER
SIGNATURES: i.� �•{��� /
ACTION OF BOARD ON April 1, 19I APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED x OTHER x
The following person addressed the Board regarding the event: John Dalaymph, Contra Costa Labor Council ,
525 Green Street, Martinez.
The Board discussed the issues and took the following action:
APPROVED the recommendation as set forth above; AMENDED the Background section of the Board order as
follows: strike "hundreds of deaths" and replace with "far too many deaths"; INTRODUCED an urgency
matter to consider closing a lane of traffic at Pacheco Boulevard and Howe Avenue on April 27, 1997,
for the "Workers Memorial and Safety Day" event and; GRANTED permission to completely close a portion
of Pacheco Boulevard and Howe Avenue on April 27, 1997, from 1:00 p.m. through 4:00 p.m., for holding
the event.
VOTE OF SUPERVISORS
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A TRUE
X UNANIMOUS(ABSENT V ) AND CORRECT COPY OF AN ACTION TAKEN
AYES: NOES: AND ENTERED ON THE MINUTES OF THE BOARD
ABSENT: ABSTAIN: OF SUPERVISORS ON THE DATE SHOWN.
CC: ATTESTED April 1, 1997
See Page 2 PHI A HELORCLERK OF THE BOARD OF
gal
V ADMINI TOR '
BY PU
M382 (10/88)
s.�.3
It is entirely appropriate for the Board of Supervisors to join with the Building Trades
Council and the Central Labor Council in honoring the memory of those workers who
have died or been seriously injured in industrial accidents by declaring April 27, 1997
as Workers Memorial and Safety Day in Contra Costa County, by endorsing the
event on April 27, by urging all citizens to attend the event on April 27, 1997, and by
reaffirming the Board's belief that safety comes first.
cc: County Administrator
John Dalrymple, Executive Secretary-Treasurer
Contra Costa Central Labor Council
P.O. Box 389
Martinez, CA 94553
Greg Feere, Executive Secretary-Treasurer
Contra Costa Building and Construction Trades Council
935 Alhambra Avenue
Martinez, CA 94553
-2-
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
AND
THE AUDITOR-CONTROLLER OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
Adopted this Order on April 1,1997, by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisors Rogers, Uilkema, Gerber and DeSaulnier
NOES: None
ABSENT:Supervisor Canciamilla
ABSTAIN: None
and the Auditor-Controller by his following signature.
SUBJECT: Implementation of the )
Property Tax Administrative ) RESOLUTION NO. 97/177
Cost Recovery Provisions of )
Revenue and Taxation Code )
section 95.3. )
A public hearing having been held during the Board of Supervisors' meeting of April 1, 1997
on the Auditor-Controller's report of the property tax-related costs of the Assessor, Tax Collector,
Auditor, and Assessment Appeals Board proportionately attributable to each local jurisdiction in
Contra Costa County;
And no written objection to the report having been received;
And the Board of Supervisors and the Auditor-Controller having jointly and severally made
findings and determinations on the report;
The Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors and the Contra Costa County Auditor-
Controller hereby jointly and severally determine that the property tax administrative costs
proportionately attributable to each local jurisdiction for the 1995-1996 fiscal year are as set forth in
the Auditor-Controller's report, Exhibit A attached hereto. The Auditor-Controller will collect from
each local jurisdiction such property tax administrative costs in accordance with Revenue and
Taxation Code section 95.3 as provided in Board of Supervisors' Resolution No. 97/129
So found and determined
I hereby certify that this is a true andcorrect oopyof
an action taken and entered on the minut9a of the
"`- Board of Su Isors the date shown.
Kenneth J. rcoran ATTESTED:
PHIL BA ELOR, lerk of the Board
Contra Costa County Auditor-Controller ceryl and Coun ministrator
BYAA P .Deputy
MAM:fjb
h:\fbent\m a m\proptax 1
RESOLUTION NO. 97/ 177
-1-
d
' rn_NT _
Office of
AUDITOR-CONTROLLER
Contra Costa County RECEIVED
Martinez, California
February 20, 1997 FEB 2 5 097
CLERK BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
TO: Contra Costa County Board of Superyisors CONTRA COSTA CO.
FROM: Kenneth J. Corcoran, Auditor-Controller
SUBJECT: 1996/97 Property Tax Administration Charges
Commencing with the 1990/91 fiscal year, Revenue and Taxation Code §95.3
(replacing R&T §97.5), provides for the County Auditor-Controller to annually
determine property tax administration costs proportionately attributable to
incorporated cities and local jurisdictions for fiscal year 1989/90 and thereafter.
For purposes of this section, property tax administration costs are the property tax
related costs of the Assessor, Tax Collector, County Board of Equalization and
Assessment Appeals Board, and Auditor, including applicable administrative
overhead costs as permitted by Federal Circular A-87 standards.
On February 9, 1993, the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors adopted
Resolution No. 93/56 governing the procedure for implementing in Contra Costa
County the provisions of Revenue and Taxation Code Section 97.5 for the
recovery by the County of property tax administration costs. Due to the above
Revenue & Taxation Code changes, on February 7, 1995, Resolution No 93/56
was repealed and replaced by Resolution 95/52. The following attachments
comprise the report of the Auditor-Controller pursuant to Resolution No. 95/52 for
the 1996/97 fiscal year.
Attachment I summarizes the direct and overhead costs of the Assessor, Tax
Collector, County Board of Equalization and Assessment Appeals Board, and
Auditor-Controller for the 1995/96 fiscal year. Also included are all offsetting
revenues received by the County for providing property tax related services.
The 1995/96 net cost of property tax administration was$8,500,532.
Attachment II allocates the $8,500,532 net cast to each incorporated city and to
each local jurisdiction receiving property tax revenues during the 1996/97 fiscal
year. This cost allocation to each entity is based on the net revenues of each
entity as a percentage of total revenues. School districts, community college
districts, and the County Office of Education are exempt from those provisions
authorizing County recovery of their proportionate share of property tax
administrative costs.
ATTACHMENT I
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
AUDITOR-CONTROLLER'S REPORT
on
Property Tax Administration Charaes for 1996-1997
Table of Contents
3 Summary Calculations
4 Contra Costa County Assessors Department
5 Contra Costa County Tax Collectors Department
6 Contra Costa County Auditor-Controllers Department
7 County Board of Equalization and Assessment Appeals Board
8 Federal A-87 Overhead Allocation
9 1995/96 Department Revenue Offsets
10 Allocation of Cost to Taxing Agencies
2WSL96.xI5 Page 2
ATTACHMENT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tax Administration Charges for 1996-1997
NOTE: Per Revenue and Taxation Code Section 95.3,the property tax administration
fee to be charged in the 1998-97 Fiscal Year shall be based on the 199596
property tax related costs of the Assessor,Tax Collector, and Auditor,
including applicable overhead costs as permitted by Federal Circular A-87
standards.
Property Tax Related Cost, 1995-96 Fiscal Year.
Assessor 8,086,496
Tax Collector 1,647,448
Auditor-Controller 832,479
Assessment Appeals Board 74.880
Total 10,641,303
Overhead Cost per Circular A-87, 199596 Fiscal Year.
Assessor 556,929
Tax Collector 134,774
Auditor-Controller 84.745
Total 776,448
Less: Fees Received for Property Tax Related Services, 199596:
County General 534,843
Assessor 218,914
Tax Collector 1,365,834
Auditor-Controller 797.628
Total -2.917.219
Net Property Tax Administration Cost,
1995-96 Fiscal Year: 8,500,632
2557sE96.xis Page 3
ATTACHMENT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tax Administration Charoes for 1996-1997
ASSESSOR'S DEPARTMENT
DIRECT AND ACTUAL
INDIRECT DEPARTMENTAL COST 1995-96
Salaries& Employee Benefits 7,063,343
Services&Supplies 1,048,107
Other Charges 6,028
Fixed Assets 122,591
Gross Cost 8,240,069
Less:
Intrafund Transfers -24,954
Lease Purchase -6,028
Fixed Assets -122,591
TOTAL ASSESSOR COST 8,086,496
TOTAL ASSESSOR REVENUES 218,914
NET ASSESSOR DEPARTMENT COST 7,867,582
2557SC95As Page 4
ATTACHMENT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tau Administration Charues for 1998-1997
TAX COLLECTOR'S DEPARTMENT
DIRECT AND ACTUAL
INDIRECT DEPARTMEQITAL COST 1995.98
Salaries&Employee Benefits 1,648,741
Services&Supplies 616,282
Other Charges 5,945
Fixed Assets 1,616
Gross Cost 2,272,584
Less:
Treasury -519,127
Business License Program -104,393
Fixed Assets -1,616
TOTAL TAX COLLECTOR COST 1,647,448
REVENUES
Gross Revenue 1,701,636
Excludable revenues -336,002
TOTAL TAX COLLECTOR REVENUE 1,365,834
NET TAX COLLECTOR COST 281,614
2557SF9 AS Page 5
6T ACHMENTI
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tax Administration Charges for 1998-1997
AUDITOR-CONTROLLER'S DEPARTMENT
PROPERTY TAX DIVISION-DIRECT AND ACTUAL
INDIRECT DEPARTMENTAL COSTS 1995-96
Salaries&Employee Benefits 567,406
Data Processing Charges 217,048
Department Indirect Costs 9,238
Accounts Payable-Supplemental &Other Tax Refunds 38.787
GROSS TAX DIVISION COSTS 832,479
TOTAL TAX DIVISION REVENUES 797.628
NET AUDITOR-CONTROLLER COST 34,851
2557sF96.zls Page 6
ATTACHMENT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tax Administration Charoes for 1998-1997
COUNTY BOARD OF EQUALIZATION AND ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD
ACTUAL
DIRECT AND INDIRECT COSTS 199596
Clerk of the Board 56.656
Assessment Appeals Board-allowances and postage 16,130
County Counsel 2,094
TOTAL ASSESSMENT APPEAL BOARD COSTS 74,880
2557SM96.be Page 7
ATTACHMENT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tax Administration Charges for 19961997
A-87 OVERHEAD ALLOCATION
Percent
A-87 Plan Prop Tax Net to
Deoartment 95-96 Actual Related Allocate
Assessor 556,929 100% 556,929
Tax Collector 187,186 72% 134,774
Auditor-Controller 84,745 100% 84,745
TOTALS 828,860 776,448
2557sK96.xls Page 8
ATTACHMENT
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Property Tax Administration Chames for 1996-97
REVENUE OFFSETS
County General Revenues
0005 9608 Supplemental Administration Fees 534,843
534,843
Assessor
0016 1600 Administration 1,280,877
1600 Excludable revenues:
Prior year SB 2557 revenue -530,000
AB 818 revenue from State -617,218
0016 1605 Drafting 2,808
1647 Roll Maintenance 77,447
1650 Training 5.000
218,914
uditor
0010 1004 Tax&Special District Division Revenue 1,236,821
Excludable revenues -439,193
797,628
Tax Collector
0015 Net Tax Collector Revenue 1.365.834
TOTAL REVENUE OFFSETS 2,917,219
2557SH96.)ds Page 9
m
x�x
7l
0) � (N710f N N N N W W N NNOODA NOAOD CAmD V oON Om 'JO W N 8 6z .
N NN NNN (fi
V Ol N W N + w W W A N + O + O V + O N W n
TTTTTTTTTTTT
O Oc O7 m75• O��m!' w0OW .007v.. .0070. .�0>'. .00>p0i wOm7 �0 0 0 .�N. �OO mN(m7 N �r �r ;mo
6 � 0 ,
. qSTai O� mpT 3TO
coo
Q m2
0nn ( o
OOOOO OO ONZkkkoO O9
o
cab.
003Dnm om 0 0 0m0 nt � � ; gyDmmmmmmm V � w
_ JDWW � m $ G �0 m
QC
L
m
w
5. —
0 O
D
cor _
JJ JAJ W m Nl O O
p�mNN,fO t+0V -4 "4
ANNW 47NAm jW
aD
tO m NN O ANAT G + 01N40Dp04
wm " OW V !pwACD 0 ()) �G
NN " wNO W mW0 W � NV mNODmmNI + m � -1Vim " OifW N
N .V
mD Nmmb) -4Olw N O
O V A N m V N N w W W W N N W m m m W O C V N m W V m fJ N V CD
O+� �Jpp W (pip
j
GD m JJNJ N J NmCD tO ANN W �1 N m �0 N
J J J J � fY
W 0 m W + W +A A N A O f0 N J J V W N V N m m V
w00 V A W mN W JJJm + m V NA V V wtO ONNN W O NOC O PJ W V m
40 V m CD m tO N w0mm0 W A V OI OOOw V NN + O V Nm V V ON t0 2
� -4
G
m0 -PL z
d D
W NN m CD ��0 0
tri
O w N + N A N m N C y
r 1
n D
N J J N A + w t 0 V m > n
VJ N (O + tO N A NOi W 0 � W m � Z O O
N3
N � mm N t0 + + NtJN V V V J m + W A V m N V O O Z C
W V N A t0 V A V N + W O m W +m!O A N t0 + O V V 11 A 0 OD A t0 N m
CD CD N m J(n N m W O N V w m w m W O V N A W WN W V w fJ A O V_ W O 2
CpJJ NO tOtOm + + 00 � + t0 (ONN V pp V 001 (i1 W m J O) A +
Q tD N w 0 + m V J V + m N A W N m 0 V N m N A A 0D + N m t0 W A O
J <
m
988 § § 80 § 80 § 00
O O p C 8 8 0 0 C p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 G S O O O C $ $ O O g 0 t0
O w 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C 0 p 0p 0 0 0 O N G O O 80 pC ROSS
C O p O + ON pp p ig N n V
+ 000
o O + 0 0 0 0 $ w m V A O O O A O m f0J W N f T m A m
pp AJ O + J + p Op+po
NtOVJN _ C
SvWmA OO N 0n �VGowmm A ptON T
Co 01
W NANO W A tJ O A W to0 V
m NJ p� J V A NW NN m W O A m V mmomt0 poNO O J
pJ N O A fmly + NNpp
Om01
A V m V
N J O n p 0
W N N N W D Im»q D
mwmJ JJ N W(p ? No tJW tT tJ �4ppf 4) tD Q10y1A CD 41
N fJ A 8 0 0 0 Z o m N OD V N N DVD O m m W tW0 fJ N O O V O tW�t tVi� A m N N
m
z
'o
V
WW W W W W Of N N N A A. A A A A A A A A A (Wil N N O O O W V V v v v v IZ C
V V V p Vp V N o Ol
OON NNO (Oil + (N71 ONN OWN 010) -t, 0CD O (N71N " -40 O0Nm � W NO N On
zvOmDmgo r000nmy � Aa � C1nOT. 0 29
om o7m ommmmo `< 90 3005u . i > > Ogg > DDD
m p' o• O m S � 0r� � < scan m 0 rrrr
co 030 � � O o � A• - -• -• -
a
m��3 _m+, .m�S�y.. m:cyfeiavpvmD3SS �m - Bmmg ?ng � ma Om _ ° c< m D
2 05 SE SE � 0m nA,o ma
oco30cor_ c � am9mowuac <
y O
� m � � � ° 0gNYJo°� Nc; o
$ ( mmm �mva� 0) oa! mo'nm 'om = o . � y3 40mmVi
no'
J
y
93
ca Q
J J ()1 J J J
29
WONN + Np� W � 4 -
NO04 " @8 - Wop (9
-4C
n
OWN NNAN (00) IJ VW V V V mm -4
ca WWAVN N ° 4VDNONmVNNtONAD CA !g O W AOWD "MAN
NCO O V N VVNOVVAA � � poOV NSNN . J . m � SIJ . O . m . m . t0 OW f0 4 0
OAv � 0CD CD W0 " WyV 0) Oamp
OD co m 0 00 " W AW00mm ^g
K)
CD
21 z
W A A O) (T N W 4 J W OD W W A 01 V N m J 01 A (N11 OD O O O) N O (�
W N V � mOW NNJNNJN07 W V 0) NOO W 4O O N tQ MN N V mOD W O �'.z V 1 0
A m A �[1
O N )D m W A N K V OD J N N A CO OD V O W V OD N V N W N 2
� V
m
m m D
m A O
N N N J N O O N V O m
co)
0
AWpp W O W S D V 1D
N W J NA NN N Nm W (D 00)) W C F O
J + y
O -4
0 D
NJ JJm I�
N IJ N N J V J N A N W J J A •+ J N N 4. " w
N W L Z Q O
((�� N O D7 O m NOD V W O J N m N OD O J W m OD A V W W N A„A•, m
O N O O) J N O W V W N m A (11 OD fJ N (O N N W (JO A O (J (O OD m W A Z C
0m0) N V Co W NN C" -� AJyV ODNQN� CO JJ (pp0 V N opN a!
V p0 PA 2
(OCDO W mN W 41 A m 0 W A � O � N N A � (OJ W N W v V N V N J ANV ONDN O (011 07
GO (0 M O J V V A
J �
(D
pp p
'00 b
'8 ,80 '8 '00
O _ pIpmppp(�
00
OD K) 0tpppp opOp
0 0pp� ISD0GG0 � O
W jppppAOl (yy�� Ap� pbm W 8i V 0) W AO CAO NA S � .P NI:3O
W A N -4 Am WAO0
V (N� pyJ OD
(C,) (D�� V V O1 SOD (O NO (ON �i10DN � N0 (�p W W N � N N S o W
0+W p�, V A N (0 N O v N 0pA�1 A co (Np N to COD (yN(ypp N (OJ O (�0�1 A m 0 N W v (W0�1 O V (pNoj1 0 OA1
N W V m m A (011 00D + (011 A O V fN0 + A W V A + m W (V/1 O O V 0) O co N m
D �OpOp11
N co W 000
(OJ W N A 0NJON (a10 f0 V AN V t00 JPO NA W 0JN W •+ N J V VI m N (D7
ONNO V A J (D V W NAJN W W JAN V
(O 0N0O) ON W =
NOD V N N J 0 N N O A m t0 J m W V W 0 J m A N (0 A O 0)) J V N O J to co
m
zI
,A A A A A ,h A .V• A .p A A A A A A A A A
tNieAdA W N .N+ � � N+ N+ � N„ jNN pNNpN pNNNN -+ .+ .+ s0 C7SQ� g �
< l
Nal + OOhVt OD V OlN A W N � Omlb V Qf � A W Na � O � OaIO nCV1N -Y O W �o.
j$$ m a
m C d• -a• O � aAAr. 0 �i m �, "'� � C w w o
moi' aci - 0 CD
o ' o 0 ;u C8
� ,�c, mo $
N = a` 0
00R � nn� � m -'
n g 0 a _ ' {mmV7} O
vT 0 "� mOm m1 Nw D
(,� f(t,��1,1i1
f0 S V 0_CR At h W W A W M
Wcnooc, cWp6 � �wp� �ro.� (o7� aerir.� ppNCD-
a� CA
(p p ��pry �p a� a� �DyS�pr
� aOA�1pOp (q�1O W W 41 tO .NP Cw11 j mC? Qri tJ W �i tGN W N V S O.l COS MN " D� m�+
apiGA (N(pp V O m
W NNOOVo wV m W O A NIOJ fns 0VV1' O .yP -V+ S � O4A1 tN71 DND j01n A tMM NN W V
Q
A n C _�
ANyr� tWa� � 4tOO Of .VOT_fWif A� y+ tA10
ao rO .ap•'� -pp• �,'y� Z
OnmNr4tVn OD' A +V � N ' O Y � N � W S V cwA W NNNOPONDg ONJNmKAn �� V Z"
_I 1
m
N � ) pOb
O'er Cf
b
�'i O N $ ? O D 0
N y F
O 1
0 b
((J��
z 60
(4t al Q� aW�1 m.CppNpU}��� (pNTNA_RpOJ 'OA OtwJ (QNW�y Scnm VO W O ayWt} (Opf fA (�� {}N�� (AJI gyVy ,aWpp�� m NA N a .m+ Z (�,.
W A1AffiST 0/ N W W A W SSM O RSH HD 0011 C"" j m
N of n O
K'
po pp pp pp pp
co w
�tWWSpO.pO(A'3�"� V(IASpOV�tS NpOSWD AVOppNwQ d,(ppapiil� NWWNO ,oWpf NOWVOaJ1 WNO COp[[-��r�1i� �OnOOD1tAOJImwOf0l aOO4aVV,DM1� `Nta6Oy/ljOOpaN1N0p1yaOpWtl (ppN�IW-OprNLM (Ta� S tV0OV Qp-p� ONpaa �tp
S5
V
aal OOl 8 W & S+b T
� ww
b. ���
2�,0Vna � A � A y -
wayA N SVVNOA � 6
Vi � WQ0Splp4�� OSNNO !29CA
y W V A OD
MVtDMV
O
-+ -+ S7t of fpOnN VOO V V 1A
N N + 4D V.two N t0 O M m 04,
A O O
-� V NfnNANDp�, V mO�f^+IOOtM y AC6 (Wps W {aD (}fNCDy 'CA8--4
-+ W OVAD � OmVV71 V OO) tND � W .4 W V Ol ONEO � W OAD 01 W yN � V .V+ V hi W of al .ta S
iV
A A a A a A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Al A A A A A A A A A a A A A A �Z T
V V V V V V V V V V V V V N 10
V V V V V V V V V V V V V V N N N N N N N c
AAAA (�1 W (� W W W W t� NNNl + ! ! g0 $ O � OONO ODm V V V
W W W w LZ
n
Ap � � vvvvvvvv, v, mmmC) omzwm � � p � � c — a00 � � m
n nst � 9 9 m
rs rs � � F�ncc Qvvv ( o o m m 2 � 4mo 0 2 � O
o 3 a 3
n rn m a —
00oo65 � m � S « » m ' am � ' < m � onnn �l
CL 9x x o o m o -V -0 r -V -- < m m y
! ! Joco oom_ mM ; 99 � � 0o0p o ` oo G' c _ � _ t' o0) 5
mgDD � 33 �� � m 3 a3
mm � n a3yAAWN
m m m � a
- - - J m D ! o
0
W W N O N W N ! IJ O ON W m W CIN N a) W O W O 0 O
N ! m V pppp Coo y ! W 010 O N V V �(pp N�ONNlNN (oN ! N N (0�1N�
N Q V(pp V O A W 0 01 tO O oNo A W O W OD 0 0 0 A N W W V)
!pp W V O CD W O O W OD .86O COCO L N W CPO O) ! 0 O, O O) � O N O V ! N O
A J ! (N(ppQOQ . WW go 01W (C(�DDOt� ON(�� O) N (�(p (d(ppf" S/y�� !14CD PD .0p1t fmJ1 � (A(pp ,SNI (NN� V � � (�(�� N � �v � ma
O+ O -W+ ODO W � mfNC OtVit (OJ Oi O) O w W 01 (oW Pa co V A Q W N00f OOm
D
N O) N N N N W N N
W WaO ANWA � JAA (CmlVJ 0101 O N ((��l� »m � n
W ANN NN W N fo tol CA 0pNp NN 0) :t
mf00 �f W CO OD m0 V J (N11N W V A �� V 0
� � NOOONOOaff � N OW -4 V 0 (NA) OO N Om O) 10 m N (o 0 (0A wK) ONN
2
ro m �
0 D
IN
N� tJ to W w 0 c) A
W 0`OD SSE cDV � N
0 0 -(
D
(o ! W J O N ;7 o
((�� O) N + WW N J W pl17D W (o N N 0 WV I� z 60
N A m fD a ! pp Ot 0 0 A N O V N W (.� W fT a A 0 V a) J O) N N N m » -L
a1 O tC V1 A O W Vt O ! N (O m OD CD A OD V (T V (J W V to O A N (J GD Ot C
AO) W w0)A W N� lOIJ co co V tJtlNg -+ 0) N (O V O w2 0) K) 0)r O)OD fJ m T 2
V + A V W V O N W ! O N A N V ! J w C) W m 0 N N WO N V m 0
fAN (CONGO ! V 00 W J V OAOlN V O V ChJ0 W V NO)
O GD M
J <
(mp
g0000g0000000
ogg0000o � 000goOo � OOoi000 $ O
`Q�' ppool p�000 8
(O A O OmD t0 L O (�p N `pf .�+f O GaD (0f1 W GWp �p N SOi) ppOpff (WO. S ppNp1 Ow (O� M W �
! m O (((Cpp O O N V V A 0 0 GD W V CA 1 1)N0A�� N N Oa0t,t W N(C Ap Nf GVO W 000A0A��,,1, A (U1a1 W !(� (O V"'IO 5-4
m a Cat A O N V (Oi) W cob.
(Ao O O N f f m O N v m N m 00 0) m O O N O V O fO � m y 0
po
! W (D m O V W J W ttpp V ANp O) Nt (W(pp W ar N A (T at W -4 (C W O (0(p 01 Ct W V 00tt
CD -4 V V 00 (DN 0) if riN. AN � r O GVD W W V9
(N11 W 9 0 GOON W 8I (AC
V W W N O W N W W O O N
! J j A101GD WW JA O! V V ANON -+ A mO O N CIN lO N (at�f ! O) -pNy-4 W pp V W
N n
OmNNONONDO V � (OItL ONN � OO W (WO Jd � ANtNOA OD Ol4 A tai) A W NrA (NJN =
m
z
w =
V
A A Amm A A A8 -4 -4 -4 -4
A a a a A A4 A A AS Am a A a A A (a�I A (A� AA A A A a A AA T
T fTJt A4mi N -+ O � W Ol NA W NT+ OODN A -N+ Ofa00aD v Olm A �n
m W .ZlOnnnnfA � � � � TTTNTTNfA (DO � � .Z1 .Z1 .71 .ZI .0 .ZI
CL IMX C o m o 0 o o m q m m m m m m m m m 0
o 0 0 o A� g q v v v v v v v v = 3 3 'c, ' 3 3 3 3 3 3
n o n C) m S m m m m m m m m m m m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
00oo3 = 2, � IrvvvccU47cr n = 00m = > 0 = 0
x 'a � 4 44 � g � 440na � � naaannm'a z -u� ao
� Dffnmsm mo70 000 � Dc0 0omgg D3tn 0CL W �,, x 3 3 m
m O n m m m m 0
3 � 30 -4ODro n atro° o
q 0 t0 f0 J O CL
CL0 +
m
m 0 m n D
+
3 n
9 p
� m
J J J JJ J w
0+ 3 Nj TWfJi�N(0I N+INV0V 0+ANmm� N+ Tmm mN J O NW m _mNmN O T
O f4T wW + 0 0 p-I 0 V w0
cVd � l
lz
m m T .(pyN fOV1 �ImT V V VIO NN m0DD
v oNNaNAWVaaNONtQp ODJ J mNWm0 J N J + T U1 V + m A N J T + T V W W V J O T N A O 0 V --� O
N ONJNA JN W NT W f0 W V V V m f00 fD 80 V N (JIJ > �l
m mt0 W m Vtm TO TN V w T T TJ + AT OD JO + V Ut W m 2
L
� mM
Z IN ;a n D
jON O_oA7N + m V �DO CD
N A
.N. J ,.V..V.
nD
o
p .9.
J J w
Owl Oi aW V TTwomN W + tO VI W a A T W N N 0 O F. Iz 50
Ip W J N V t V m V O O W f0 W A m »
W
z C
W W N:I O OD W f0 IT fO N O m fJ OD N OD O V /J N OD
(� w M t0�I d 4l w a cn m a v en Jam m t0 W w v +O A tD O W O w t)t C T 2
N f0 W VIA N A T N V J m m V 0 w T T m W m N w J N V m m m V W O
T V V NmNAJ VIO fOmwONwlo (O V OIm + V mJfD V mm V Jf0 M
J <
(S�
RM -4
pp ppp p p p o pp p pp pp 8Q8Q p Sp 8Q p t 0
O A T pOf O �I 0N 00 0 p0 0 0 0 0 0 0 S O O A O W N V V O o� O m
O m W tD N N J tV DOD 6CC A L COfll m V w W V O V N A m N N J p� m A N m V
N m Twp �I J V V N�Om NpVp W V pNNm� {Ap fp QW ,pLptj mA (01001 NQm� W N.�.
N0 VW co
AI UI O CNV• 0 A m � ff0Jp1 p� 00 (.n( NA N V 0DM A W � � O VAI OOD
imp v N ?m
.p VVaII a+ N CDDO �Op fO p+p�l mO J ANOVfO VVOII pmp �Ntpp — " � 8 NOD wen o CJI O) OND
w A T m w <OO TAO Aw V 0 V T m VIA R8 T NA W TAm OmN (D OD
P D
mT
VA a W (T OD W tD J O N O N A T J N� w iT 0) T ^ q
m ID frO 4 W m O VI V V A W W A T O m^ VI V t0 V V w N j j V j w N n
A m V (D ) OtOANAO mf0 t0 fD ND V m gmAOO O =
W t0 O W O ut J N tD T N + T W O O V N T W W W A w w t0 O 0 N + V N (D
z
a _
V V pVmp �J�jl f}VCl�� J
000000oV0
JW0OOpD�3 OW ONO� OO009 jOI OOI O(ry oA .A A A �ZT
rA
r mo gi -° m Ouo OOf mC OTi C7 -+ 0mr-
ts
i
goo oo ° acCxNm � mlo
= Vmm , m_ � ms `� m
N 3 3 n c > > y O a N a 3 m m m 3.3 m 3 = � � o S c
3 a d 3 n
312 , o
o $ m
'oonWiA.wow � ODON + ra0YA/ N27 �: ��
Q1 mO.drO
tOA W Oa O� N W AJ N GnNN890')
N V T r mr
03 -�
rNO} W N ���AAP_ fJ� Ol tJ4 W W OCDN (O fT� N Cn OJ OY O) W A+ yNp
m (n �f�m7�pp NpCp7�� KpI Aam N (A�/ A W �. W Of W W p0) N
9 ym W N V AN W@p ,tmO yW��D NJ+ O+ fD ,aJDyy IN [OdmE V N �Of�yy� ,.W,pp� OCy
W CCDD O CO/I W WCD D -q CA y V N W to W CC DD N N 0)
N g
(0
N .A J r J 1111 Z
NOl NfO pp O ,,pp,, O oyN0(D
m fD fDW C pO3 V O W Obi p1 W wACJ1mr V CD A.. D1m t0 W C7
O N V V (O�DplA (�,1 tT V N CONON2,� CDNO (O(�� t1f V NA -� O.z
2a71 10 V W f2AlY N D3 m (A O O CD 2rJ m W (D N N L COD wWm a
z
4 -.4
v m
w w aD r S,�Zi N AQ O p
W V LA N N W A A
Vt
C" 0) m N i'� t7f A �Ofppf A "') y W
rp
O H
to 0
m W A W A r fD r > n
twit N 03 O3 fmJ ori. 2A� rO v 213 m WN N A O N t76 > N t Atpp NA Z O O
V C fll Di p f11 CD k �+ V 01 fD V V N VI V a, V W r CD ` m C
W fJi 01 W 070 NCC NiDNO W/J J> f71N CDr V �CO.D3 tllm W T 2"
-+ v w aV W O N W W Or CCADNNmNOCD V mA mr � m V O 1
.ZI -4
O
c
oOOO f71 WrCABC o0iO •t@pC�PDoAµ4W3 fCWNpJJ� on1rpow00O.A31 Q�p0aQ11 mVV1 Nf`Q�fD7� opWJ ��oNV,,33c�f2D!� cOOI boOJNOaJ oOOA o7aV(AD3OooOfD CNiwQOaIi
copaL N-oUQA+
Go
DuoS
ppn V n
NmD V � 0O tO NJNW + OAW -4 (DD 0O CD OOAAanpA
O HWOO NOfVN WNO � WWOfOOOAAOVVO V
W
r.
O r A r W fD 0 V A N V O Df C71 W m N V A N V DD O V W W
A �D
in W cn w r A c A
O A fA m .+ O W VNAA rNw NmmA W m V y
W A �1�3l
O A y A V A tD m m CD CD N (A 0 A N 41 N V N w D7 m N lD J. b
N Op W (A� 0rON41271 C3 pQpDD) V A Oi 2Wf/l��OwA �yp gf�yypp
N CA m O! + N fell -1. N CNDO L CWD v m W, ('A Lm. fDONw } O N A OS =
fD O w 0 V
Z
-i
C�+
SO
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
AND
THE AUDITOR-CONTROLLER OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
Adopted this Order on April 1, 1997, by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisors Rogers, Uilkema, Gerber and DeSaulnier
NOES: None
ABSENT: Supervisor Canciamilla
ABSTAIN: Done
and the Auditor-Controller by his following signature.
SUBJECT: Implementation of the )
Property Tax Administrative ) RESOLUTION NO. 97/ 176
Cost Recovery Provisions of )
Revenue and Taxation Code )
section 95.3. )
A public hearing having been held during the Board of Supervisors meeting on April 1, 1997,
on implementation of the property tax cost recovery provisions of Revenue and Taxation Code
section 95.3, as provided in Board of Supervisors' Resolution No. 97/129, the Board of Supervisors,
and the Auditor-Controller, hereby make the following findings and determination.
A.
Property Tax Administrative Cost Recovery
1. On February 25, 1997, the Auditor-Controller filed with the Clerk of the Board of
Supervisors a report of the 1995-1996 fiscal year property tax-related costs of the Assessor, Tax
Collector, Auditor and Assessment Appeals Board, including the applicable administrative overhead
costs permitted by federal circular A-87 standards, proportionally attributable to each local jurisdiction
and Educational Revenue Augmentation Fund (ERAF) in Contra Costa County, in the ratio of
property tax revenue received by each local jurisdiction and ERAF divided by the total property tax
revenue received by all local jurisdictions and ERAFs in the county for the current fiscal year. The
report included proposed charges against each local jurisdiction excepting school entities, for the
local jurisdiction's proportionate share of such administrative costs.
2. On April 1, 1997 at the Board of Supervisors meeting a public hearing was held on the
Auditor-Controller's report, notice of which was given as required by law and by Board of Supervisors'
Resolution 97/129.
3. The report of the Auditor-Controller filed on February 25, 1997 is hereby adopted, and the
Board of Supervisors and the Auditor-Controller find that amounts expressed in said report do not
exceed the actual amount of 1995-1996 fiscal year property tax administrative costs proportionally
attributable to local jurisdictions.
4. The additional revenue received by Contra Costa County on account of its 1995-1996 fiscal
year property tax administrative costs pursuant to Revenue and Taxation Code section 95.3 shall be
used only to fund the actual costs of assessing, collecting and allocating property taxes. An
equivalent amount of the revenues budgeted to finance assessing, collecting and allocating property
taxes in fiscal year 1996-1997 may be reallocated to finance other county services. In the event that
the actual 1996-1997costs for assessing, collecting and allocating property taxes plus allowable
RESOLUTION NO. 97/ 176
-1-
overhead costs are less than the amounts determined in the February 20, 1997 report by the Auditor-
Controller, the difference shall be proportionally allocated to the respective local jurisdictions which
paid property tax administration charges.
B
FINDINGS
1. No written objections were received at the April 1, 1997 public hearing on the Auditor-
Controller's report of February 20, 1997.
2. The Board of Supervisors and the Auditor-Controller find that AB 3347 (1994 Statutes,
chapter 1167) and AB 1055 (1996 Statutes, chapter 1073) are lawful enactments, lawfully adopted.
3. The amounts expressed in the Auditor-Controller's report of February 20, 1997 are correct.
4. Notice as required by law was given of the public hearing on April 1, 1997.
5. The grounds stated herein to support findings are not exclusive and any findings may be
supported on any lawful ground, whether or not expressed herein.
6. If any finding herein is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect findings which can be
given effect without the invalid provision, and to this end, the invalid finding is severable.
So found and determined
Kenneth J. qrcoran
Contra Costa County Auditor-Controller
I hereby certify that this Is a true andcorreeteopyol
an action taken and entered on the minutes of the
Board of Su ors o the data ann
ATTESTErn
D:
PHIL BA LOR, r,erk of the Board
penis and Count ministrator
Rv o
.�,Deputy
Orig. Dept: County Counsel
cc: County Administrator
Auditor-Controller
Clerk of the Board
MAM:fjb
h:fbent\roam\pro ptax2
RESOLUTION NO. 97/ 176
-2-