Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 04231996 - MR1 (3) i Vj w► r uv Ul O Cj p� VO ' Q Q, N LAG CD � ,.� oz O I v Ul o z u m 1 o r vG 2 u� i o V* ° r � a OG N ? ct� vG d UG p p p uo Ul M d p Ul � O ul -� r UA�-, d Ctl N >' uJ vJ � oG d m uv • t c� N Tab — 1 0 Z W F- Z I W U 1- W H Q W H Q L O V ry aD 4-1a 0 .o V 0 0 0 0 0 00 Cfl d' N lu9OJ9d V O N W d v V to •r+ N L W � O i ,O di O Omo •O O ._ 3 O N d p z cn a cn U) W 4- �• a- y- y- y- w- N N F— v o L) I u UI U v I v I L) L) I co L) L F- LU w v w m i � s s c > � V O c�a > c O O _ CL OC o D a n n P a = a 0 = I ull 00 To- 6 O O Z Z L l000000lV N N Z > w 0 W E •U L Low L � ~ v .L rf.i .N /L+ L W W � soo, d 'o Rf ca lo- a� — O o >+ � ' W O V C C = = O O .? � V V W u) to c) > Oca ca L. (L O O Gi O O O O O O O O G. Z p .- .- .- 3 •- •- •- = a I_ o O U) O W o F- - C.� V � O >+ O > N fE•- O O _ � •� V� Rf O O c0 K .E O J J Q V Wcl) to (1) > 0 V) to Tab — 2 W H V H Cl) W F- W H Q D m W o p y.+ to c � mC a Noun U) W O = c 0) 0 son 0L .,r tv G? NORM O "m . fp VI M "` _ VA Soma tTt •ng. Los = p o W m i t� L L C9 LM 0 co c CA onool `p ,cv CL L L L 40—samon W 0 d C C 0 v E tJ.t 3 'o C d3 E VON, ts' i 40 L3") LT CL W 4 ._ Eco i.(.. .-. CL /rt0;1 0 Q i V � •_ / 1 R N � W is Gf MONO CL J N U MOOM CLU)N = ... L) .0 L R� z . ' 4.i >% .rte OC N cc vMNOO L NN t,S E L low C 0 MOONS co Q3 N N N a >Low, wmmi� _ y.. ON sm t3 = cva .� '_ Q 0i*VOOO r. L C ..., E *-+ CL d cn .5 C 0 1— `� v "Q O tJ3 Gi r. 0 Q L N .N = i ,_ 4 ty N N _ -a CL WOOMM Im C00000 � U d i `..► 2 � ++ LOW .� � C 0 tU N tCt r 20 0 DO C = v W ,� z • • 0 M tQ M. �y 7 ONO �1 N cU jr DG •� nr O i 2 0 in M p. co co OG r, 2 0 VO d t„) _ o 0 p ©.� p M M 000) � o o 00 oG �„ Is Ul cn L L � � 4 G E d E- OMr. }' O w a. >► ° T.E o N 4w z E0Q NE _ '0 o a ycaE cN .o = .� 2 N = N � = c, o o = = W 3 3 N E -a E O u 0 LN 00 U 0 •O 0- G1 N O N E 0- Vi .� > LL..i LU i r N LO 1- __ d O co > •C O J L� Q � ti ~ z LJ.I V N N N L .- BE C CL 13 � ~ r M U.. i CL Cr _ Z L N I- LL W i Ce) a' UlL .� , r ,� �• tQ M tT} M y � N `0 W, 7 04 O� �y N d' -` N , co M• I ' ay s o N vuo ��„ kft f• D? r VOO r COMPARATIVE RESIDENTIAL WATER CHARGES Annual Charges for 16 CCF/Mo - December 1995 Contra Costa $530 Marin $503 Los Altos $361 Palo Alto $357 San Jose $322 EBMUD curt .N, :, ,,,, $317 Los Angeles $317 Livermore $274 Hayward 273 Alameda Co $271 San Francisco $263 North Marin $228 $0 $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 $600 Tab — 3 M O N N m Q tp co ,000 N •� ca 0 000- y $ O w •� O 0� � � V d N tU ro- .•. 00 �•+00 o th T C3 v N w 0 0 o o O O © © N N � O{� ••• O N y ' uo N . m Q O p p f d d woo- . tp .- m o ~Q, Hca co O Z Cts d S •OO w y o� O o N ?+ �, � W � O to ' 00 it'd s�- S Soo i P ''' Y *ioro O, N O • N d WS to ti, D? •�% �, �', `�' iSoo d o f d t4 i so N d 3 H 0000 100 dam,. t� 4TJ Otp � too $goo 4000 O y� tp 00-0 Soo o- Stp N d r.. �jy � ca �► O o �.-U. ° .• 400 O 0> � `� � ♦,,,, sem. � � dN � � . � � m � _ � , N �, d r, W Go .0_ O "t3 O U. oc '10 Uo ca7� ' d • m c� r e^ C- N r s : a ' t t s � 0000 FPO •000 �S 4 Ga '' ?'+ ce saw 0to � c1 f• Q 00 '0 z as ce) 000 0? N L 0000 a •� L N � W swoo 000 ul tCS ti? • u. to 0 woo t3� , N cJ� 0000CDC - 0 %b- lawn Eo o o low U Q M d? Q pct' SELECTED EXAMPLES OF COMMUNITIES WHOSE WATER RATES WOULD BE STRUCK DOWN UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF AB 2203 AGENCY LOWEST TIER HIGHEST TIER % DIFFERENTIAL City of Santa Cruz $0.69 $3.14 355% City of Mountain View $0.79 $3.25 311% Marin Municipal Water District $2.13 $7.56 255% City of Pasadena Winter $0.40 $1.27 220% Summer $0.44 $1.27 191% Los Angeles DWP Summer $1.13 $2.98 164% Winter $1.13 $2.33 106% City of Redlands $0.30 $0.72 1400/c City of Sunnyvale $0.59 $1.35 129% City of Riverside Summer $0.43 $0.93 118% Winter $0.43 $0.85 98% City of Livermore $0.87 $1.85 111% City of Long Beach $0.87 $1.61 85% City of Napa $1.30 $2.40 85% East Bay Municipal Utility District*` $1.09 $1.95 79% City of Pomona $0.37 $0.63 73% City of Palo Alto $1.30 $2.04 57% City of San Jose .$1.13 $1.75 55% Dublin-San Ramon Services District $1.77 $2.30 30% City of Hayward $1.25 $1.56 25% City of Glendale $1.65 $1.99 20% City of San Diego $1.29 $1.52 18% RATE DIFFERENTIAL UNDER AB 2203 10% Based on Water Rates Study(November 1995),compiled by the Calif.Municipal Utilities Assoc. "Rates shown are those adopted by the EBMUD Board of Directors in December 1995. tQ low Z CNO .� N Q U. ._ uj cn �- 0 W •- v lo- N _ W L _ Z � Y W L Low 0 loo— U LU 0Loo oom ,�.. — •— QAe CL low. low m •� S � L 0 N .X ,� x LM Y.1' AMA L = 0 W LL _ _ V W v m MOOMMI > 4 .� s 3 3 s NN. = O _ mr- O ++ mW000 OMENS CL •— - - = — Z O d O r . m 4) O CL M M N m Q Y O 00 ♦r+ to d N V 0 O V Q• op o °= •gin c V A�► ♦V�♦ `VA(1 O _ ea d y o = 3 a G1O O_ v CL 0 10d . _ 40. V� d' O `````` � `` •- O v = O Q . 419, CL 0 M V O N �t N = _ >: 0 L V m Hca c � Nam i v, o _ 0 '- _ _ 'G1 to Eft i O CL M 8D c 0 to 4m = O N p G1 8. UJ N O N 0 _ L 0 E � 0 75 to O LL Q v Q v �ss i y �Y 00o 00yopco % Woo to L" s•► a O y O i N y 3` %400- 0 op 00 d Q. N 1 Tuesday,Aprll 23,1996 EDiToRuLS : Pq :X_."MUDbills unnecessary NO reason for state t0 AB2203,the bill to limit the dis- trict's ability to set rates goes before intrude into local problem the Local Government Committee, wo bills wending their way chaired by Rainey,Wednesday. through the Assembly could As EBMUD officials fficials rightly note,the have serious implications for concept of tiered rates has passed water users in the East Bay Municipal muster in the courts.Today nearly 40 Utility District. Both bills, introduced percent of water districts in the state by Assemblyman Richard Rainey, R- use them because tiered rates encour- Walnut Creek, are an unnecessary in- age restrict how onen.particular that would trusion into a local matter. agency implements its rates makes no AB22031imits the EBMUD boards sense and is an unnecessary intrusion. ability to set tiered water rates.A sec- and bill,AB2346,would facilitate cut- The impact of AB2346 is even more ting EBMUD into two or three water detrimental. It would make it easier districts.Both of these bills sprang from for multi-county districts to be split by a highly publicized controversy last giving decision-making power to the year. Rate payers on the hot side of the LAFCO in the county where residents hills rose up in protest over outrageous Fant to form a new district.1n addi- water bills due to a new four-tiered rate tion,cost of a new district would be structure approved last summer. $300 million or more in capital costs, After talks of secession led by which probably would force up the ' trustee John Coleman,the district price of water. modified its rates. In December,the Such a bill runs counter to a board reduced the highest tier by 36 statewide trend to consolidate to avoid percent and increased the third tier by duplication of'many costs and to reap 5 percent. the economies of scale. This bill is The upshot is that the system now set for a hearing in the Local worked. Unfortunately, in the process Government Committee on May 8. of the revolt, Coleman had enlisted INeither of these bills should make Rainey's help to seek a legislative so- it out of committee. EBMUD and its lution.That effort should have ended —ratepayers ratepayers proved that the democratic when the new modified rates were system still works.There's no need for adopted. But it didn't. state involvement. Tab — 4 1 LL w O U. w U O a c� z w U w a u� w p oG 2 �3 NU d av r 2 ct� '� v� DG � d Y � 70 p 0 00 0 c4 CD 0 0 -j: d) 0 °r N 2 � o. o 40) wan 0 0 w V. 40 C4, 7 pv Wp � � ° � ti1 0 %4 CD to to CD 100 CP ol to to m vo ie n m U O ._ 4a CL W 0 Q _ 0 �O O D O to ._ NLU m co .O = O .�.+ M -O 44 3 ._ L M = O ,0 VLM O _ ,♦, L V _ (� N .�.+ O ca E .- s O CL O .N M 0 a. D o L i v O E m L N O L .� 0 .� O