HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 04251995 - 2.2 TO:, BOARD OF SUPERVISORS �" 2
FROM: ,Phil Batchelor, County Administrator
Anne Marie Gold, County Librarian
DATE: April 20, 1995
SUBJECT: Library Technology Planning
SPECIFIC REQUEST(S) OR RECOMMENDATION(S) & BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
1. ACKNOWLEDGE the need to upgrade public access to library information by the use of new
technologies and AGREE with the need to improve the automation of library services,
particularly in view of the significant increase in the availability of electronic information
resources and the enhancements available for staff efficiencies with new library automation
technologies.
2. ACCEPT the report of the County Administrator and the County Librarian on the results of
contract negotiations with the most responsive vendor which responded to the Request for
Proposal for a new library automation system.
3. APPROVE and AUTHORIZE the County Administrator to execute a contract with CARL
Corporation for purchase of an integrated automated library system over a period of five years
from 1995 to 2000 with periodic payments tied to the successful completion of detailed
milestones.
BACKGROUND
Over the past several years the County Library has taken a number of significant steps toward increasing the
use of automation in the Library. The simultaneous convergence of the development of new automation
capabilities that enhance staff efficiencies with the emergence of the information superhighway dictate that the
library move rapidly in the direction of implementing new technological solutions to enhance library services.
The new solutions will focus on software that enhances end user access to information technologies and
hardware that has the ability to grow and not become obsolete as technology changes and develops. The new
integrated automation system will truly enable the library to become a community information provider without
walls.
Continued on Attachment: YES SIGNATURE:
_RECOMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR _RECOMMENDATION OF BOARD COMMITTEE
_APPROVE OTHER
SIGNATURE(S):
ACTION OF BOARD ON A r i 1 2 5 , 19 9 5 APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED x OTHER.—
VOTE
THER_VOTE OF SUPERVISORS I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A TRUE AND
X UNANIMOUS (ABSENT) CORRECT COPY OF AN ACTION TAKEN AND
AYES: NOES: ENTERED ON THE MINUTES OF THE
ABSENT.-—ABSTAIN.- BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON DATE SHOWN.
Attested April 25 , 1995
Contacts
Phil Batchelor, clerk of the
cc: Library Administration Board of Supe isors and
Coun Admin' ator
By , Deputy Clerk
i:Ms\car].bo
1
Library Technology Planning
April 24, 1995
BACKGROUND (Continued)
At its meeting on June 21, 1994 the Board approved a report on library technology planning which included
authorization for the County Librarian to issue a Request for Proposal (RFP) for a new library automation
system. The RFP was issued in September 1994 and in December 1994 four vendors returned bid responses
for a new integrated automated library system. Included in the RFP were the evaluation criteria for the selection
of a successful bidder. These included the technical capacity of the vendor, experience with similar size
systems, financial stability of the vendor, responsiveness for installation and ongoing maintenance needs,
performance record, familiarity with installation in public libraries, data migration experience, training program,
flexibility and ease of use of proposed system, cost and other factors as may be deemed relevant.
During January and February 1995, library staff, working with consultants, reviewed the proposals in depth,
made site visits to see the installed systems from the vendors, and participated in vendor demonstrations on site
at the library. In addition to library staff evaluation, staff from Data Processing and Purchasing also reviewed
the bids. The bids were also reviewed for MBElWBE compliance. As a result of these evaluations the group
of most responsive vendors was narrowed to two companies, CARL Corporation and Ameritech Library
Services. At its meeting on March 28, 1995, the Board of Supervisors authorized the County Administrator
and the County Librarian to enter into contract negotiations with the most responsive vendor and directed them
to report back to the Board of Supervisors on the results of the negotiations and provide a contract
recommendation.
On April 17 - 18, 1995 the County Librarian, in conjunction with County Counsel, Purchasing and the
consultants, entered into contract negotiations with CARL Corporation for the new integrated library automation
system. CARL Corporation is a Denver-based company which provides library automation services to primarily
the large library market. It is the acknowledged industry leader in end user product development with a proven
track record of successful support for large, highly-networked systems. It currently supports an interconnected
network of 32 CPU locations, which link over 14,000 dedicated terminals and 450 libraries nationwide. The
negotiations were concluded successfully for a system of 376 terminals spread over the entire service area of
the County Library.
CONTRACT
The contract includes the following elements:
HARDWARE
I. Tandem hardware
Tandem is an industry leader in fault-tolerant systems. Its unique architecture of multiple
processors provides both better response time and the redundancy to keep the system operating
24 hours a day, 7 days a week despite the failure of any one processor. The Tandem platform
also features an automated diagnostic system which can dial out to an online support center to
report potential problems before they impact operations.
2. UNIX Gateway Server
The CARL system's Gateway Server will provide potential access to the Internet from every
workstation attached to the new system without the need for modems and individual phone lines.
It will provide library users with all the resources of the Internet, including the capability to
search the catalogs of other local libraries directly from our own public access catalog screens.
TELECOMMUNICATIONS
1. Frame relay telecommunications network
The CARL system's Frame Relay telecommunications network will provide greatly expanded
service to the library locations for much less cost per workstation than the Library currently is
paying because it is no longer necessary to have a single point-to-point line for each terminal.
Frame Relay is a relatively new telecommunications technique that is extremely well-suited to
library transactions which tend to be short bursts of data rather than large file transfers and it
allows multiple users to share the bandwidth of a single large circuit, making it possible to add
new workstations and increase bandwidth without having to install new lines. Installation of the
frame relay equipment and the cabling necessary to support the network will be done by Contra
Costa County's Telecommunications and Data Processing staff.
SOFTWARE FUNCTIONS
1. Public Access Catalog (PAC)
168 public access catalog (PAC) terminals with printers with graphical user interface software
will allow users to search for their own materials and retrieve information as to which library the
2
Library Technology Planning
April 20, 1995
item is in and whether it is on the shelf. The adult software Everybody's Catalog is a graphical
user client/server interface which will allow the user to use the same search strategy utilized for
the catalog to search the community information database and magazine and newspaper indexes
and databases. The children's software Kids Catalog is the acknowledged industry leader in using
a point and click interface to allow children to seek information using age-appropriate skills and
colorful graphics. This software module will replace the current CD-ROM Agile catalog in use
in the library.
2. Readers advisory software NoveList
All Everybody's Catalog PAC terminals will include NoveList software which allows users to
ask for assistance in making reading selections based on books they've read or topics in which
they are interested.
3. Periodicals access software Uncover
All Everybody's Catalog PAC terminals will include access to Uncover software which provides
access to the tables of contents of over 13,000 periodicals, including article citations and
abstracts. The end user can then access the full text of the article either through the library or
on a fee basis through fax delivery.
4. Dial up access
25 dial up ports into the CARL system will operate on a 24 hour basis daily and will allow users
with personal computers and modems to access the full library bibliographic database as well as
NoveList, Uncover and perform all the patron self-service functions from their own computers.
5. Patron self-service
End user software will enhance patron self-service with the capacity to allow patrons to place
their own holds for books and other materials while in the library and check their own patron
records.
6. Voice mail information and notification
A PC-based system will automatically call patrons to notify them that requested items are
available for pick up or that they have an overdue item, and will also allow patrons with touch
tone phones to renew materials and request information about their patron record. The library
and the vendor will be working on development of a module which will allow callers to place
requests for best sellers utilizing touch tone technology.
7. Community information module
All Everybody's Catalog PAC terminals will include access to community information files
which will provide access to the services, organizations and activities of libraries, schools,
communities and colleges. It can handle board agendas, job listings, specifications, and other
unique information resources the library may choose to include, such as local history files.
8. Databases/indexes/informational resources
Utilizing the UNIX Gateway server, access will be provided to informational indexes and
databases such as Infotrac (a general periodicals indexing and abstracting service) at selected
PAC terminals at all locations which is now currently available at only 4 locations. Additional
information resources such as dictionaries and encyclopedias will also be available. Selected
resources will be available through dial-up connections.
9. Internet access
Utilizing the UNIX Gateway server, selected PAC terminals at all locations will have access to
a variety of resources on the Internet, including other library catalogs and the World Wide Web.
This function will expand the Internet access from the current 8 locations to all locations.
10. Circulation control
A full-function software package will provide inventory control for library materials and a
database of borrower records. All circulation control terminals will also be equipped with receipt
printers to provide patrons with printed information on materials checked out.
11. Acquisitions including fund accounting interface to Auditor
3
t
Library Technology Planning
April 20, 1995
Software will manage materials procurement activities and assist in collection management. This
software module will automate current manual procedures in the library. The contract also
includes software development to electronically download invoice information from the CARL
system to the Auditor for payment purposes.
12: Serials
Software will automate the check-in, claiming and invoicing process for all periodicals,
newspapers and serials. It also provides a link to all PAC terminals to allow end users to
determine which periodicals and specific issues the library has available.
13. Bibliographic maintenance and authority control
Software will provide the ability to add and create catalog records for the library's bibliographic
database which serves as the source for the PAC information, as well as cross-referencing for
PAC entries.
14. Source code
The library will be provided with the source code for the CARL software.
ADDITIONAL PERIPHERALSWUNCTIONALITY
1. Laser checkout stations
All staff-based circulation services at 79 terminals will be upgraded to include the use of laser
scanners which will significantly improve through-put time and accuracy of data collection.
2. ADA adaptive equipment and touch screen terminals
4 locations (Concord, Pinole, Pittsburg, Pleasant Hill) will have ADA adaptive equipment which
can be utilized with the PAC plus; touch screen PAC terminals will be located at the Central
Library and all branches.
3. Self-check units
The current seven locations ( Antioch, Clayton, Concord, Pleasant Hill, San Ramon, Walnut
Creek, Ygnacio Valley) which have self-check units will increased by an additional six sites
(Danville, El Cerrito, Lafayette, Moraga, Orinda, Pinole) to enable patrons to check out their own
materials.
4. LAN/WAN
All library locations will be linked to a Wide Area Network which will provide staff access to
word-processing, spreadsheet and electronic mail software which will significantly enhance staff
communication and data transfer capabilities.
SERVICES
1. Data conversion and migration including conversion of patron, item, transaction and title record tapes
and authority control processing
All current library data files including title, item, patron and transaction records will be converted
and migrated to the new system by CARL.
2. Hardware, software, peripheral and telecommunications installation
All Tandem hardware, peripherals and telecommunications equipment that the library is acquiring
from CARL will be shipped, delivered and installed by CARL. The library is responsible for all
necessary site preparation for the new equipment.
4
1
Library Technology Planning
April 20, 1995
3. Training
Training on the system and all software functions will be provided to library staff during 6 site
visits incorporating 15 training days. Tandem system operators will also attend two Tandem
training seminars.
PERFORMANCE STANDARDS
Specific performance standards certifying that the system supplies the necessary resources to support at least
415 simultaneous user sessions are included in the contract, including specified transaction mixes for Year 1
and Year 5 and average and peak response times.
TESTING PROCEDURES
Multiple acceptance tests are incorporated into the contract including the following:
Hardware Functionality Test
Software Functional Acceptance Test
System Reliability Performance Test
Final Acceptance Test
In addition, the library reserves the right to perform additional Full Load Acceptance Tests at any point during
the duration of the contract.
WARRANTIES
The contract also includes appropriate warranties for the hardware and software functionality with a provision
for compensation for non-performance. The County will retain the right to purchase additional equipment and
software from CARL at a set price, thereby locking in current price savings. In addition, the County will be
eligible for further modifications of CARL Corporation software.
TERM OF THE AGREEMENT
The term of the agreement is for five years with options for the County for automatic renewal with ninety (90)
day notice for non-renewal.
MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT
A maintenance agreement for services to maintain the equipment and software is also included for a period of
1 year with options for automatic renewal. The agreement contains specific hardware and software maintenance
responsibilities for CARL including specific response time requirements.
PAYMENT SCHEDULE
The payment schedule for the contract is tied to the successful completion of detailed milestones. The full cost
of the contract will not exceed $2.6 million, plus maintenance costs. Funding will come from the library's
reserve funds which have been held specifically for the purpose of purchasing new library information
technology.
The final contract document is currently being prepared by the consultants for approval by County Counsel.
ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS
In addition to the cost of the new integrated automation system, the library will also experience some one-time
costs in the areas of additional peripherals, facility upgrading, telecommunications installation and furniture.
Operating costs for the maintenance of the new system will be covered in part by a combination of a transfer
of funds used for the current automation system and catalog production costs, and enhanced user fees for the
new technology.
i:\boslcarl.bo
5