Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 05071991 - EA.1 t TO: BOARD OF SUPERVISORSContra FROM: ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE SUPERVISOR NANCY C. FAHDEN, CHAIR .;. _ CJ _JL �Ia SUPERVISOR TOM TORLAKSON County DATE: MAY 7, 1991 SUBJECT: ACCEPT ANNUAL REPORT ON IMPLEMENTATION AND MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM FOR MARSH CANYON SANITARY LANDFILL SPECIFIC REQUEST(S) OR RECOMMENDATIONS) & BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION RECOMMENDATIONS Accept the attached Annual Report on the Marsh Canyon Sanitary Landfill Implementation and Mitigation Monitoring Program as reviewed by the Environmental Affairs Committee on April 22, 1991. FISCAL IMPACT None. BACKGROUND/REASONS FOR RECOMMENDATIONS The Land Use Permit Conditions of Approval for the Marsh Canyon Sanitary Landfill require an annual status report on the project and a Mitigation Monitoring program. The attached report includes the project status and outlines the Mitigation Monitoring program. CONTINUED ON ATTACHMENT: _ YES SIGNATURE RECOMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR xx RtCOMMENDA7OF BOARD COMMITTEE APPROVE OTHER SIGNATURE(S) : /0n Supervisor N ncy, Fanden, Chair Supervisor Tom Torlakson ACTION OF BOARD ON MAY 7 1491 APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED OTHER VOTE SUPERVISORS I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A UNANIMOUS (ABSENT ,� TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF AN AYES: NOES: ACTION TAKEN AND ENTERED ON THE ABSENT: ABSTAIN: MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON THE DATE SHOWN. Oriq: Community Development Department (CDD) ATTESTED MAY 7 1991 cc: County Administrator PHIL BATCHELOR, CLERK OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS D COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR BY , DEPUTY LPA:gms ea:AnualRpt.bo I CONTRA COSTA COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT DATE: April 22, 1991 TO: Environmental Affairs Committee Supervisor Nancy Fanden, Chair Supervisor Tom Torlakson FROM Harvey E. Bragdon, Director of Community Development By: Ray Valone, Project Planner SUBJECT: MARSH CANYON SANITARY LANDFILL IMPLEMENTATION AND MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM ANNUAL REPORT Pursuant to the Land Use Permit Conditions of Approval and Findings, the Community Development Department presents this annual status report for the Marsh Canyon project (a similar report for the Keller Canyon project will be forwarded to your .committee in July of this year). PERMITTING STATUS Land Use Permit 2010-90 was approved by the Board on March 20, 1990. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board - Central Valley Region issued Order 91-044, Waste Discharge' Requirements for the landfill on January 25, 1991 . The project sponsor is pursuing permits from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Section 404 Permit), Bay Area Air Quality Management District (Authority to Construct and Permit to Operate), California Department of Fish and Game (Streambed Alteration Agreement), and California Integrated Waste Management Board/County Health Services Department (Solid Waste Facilities Permit). The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has expressed concern over the sponsor's application for a Nationwide Permit under Section 404. Due to the possible degradation of the aquatic environment, the EPA recommended that the Corps require an individual permit application and strongly consider preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement. The landfill sponsor will be resubmitting the application for a Nationwide Permit in June of this year. If the Corps approves this application, a Section 404 permit could be issued in September or October. If an individual permit is required, there could be a substantial delay in securing such a permit. The sponsor expects the Air Board to issue its permit this summer. The Streambed Alteration Permit is contingent upon issuance of the Corps' permit and thus, subject to the same possible delay as that process., The Solid Waste Facilities Permit would be issued after all other permits are granted. The sponsor estimates that the entire permitting Environmental Affairs Committee Date: April 22, 1991 MCSL Implementation & Mitigation Monitoring Program Annual Report -2- process could be completed by January 1, 1992, if the Corps determines that a Nationwide Permit is sufficient under Section 404; construction could begin during the first quarter of 1992. MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM Back-ground Section 21081 .6 of the California Public Resources Code requires the Board of Supervisors to adopt a monitoring or reporting program regarding CEQA mitigation measures for a project. The first step in the fulfillment of this requirement was taken when the Board determined on December 18, 1990, that the CoSWMP/GPA Environmental Impact Report (EIR) monitoring' program was. satisfied through the second-tier project-level landfill EIR's (Marsh Canyon and Keller Canyon). This action consisted of the identification and the comparison of the CoSWMP/GPA EIR mitigation measures with the landfills' EIRs mitigations and Land Use Permit Conditions of Approval; and subsequent determination that the impact analyses and mitigation programs in the landfill EIRs and Conditions of Approval cover and supersede those in the CoSWMP/GPA EIR. At the same time, the Board determined that future mitigation monitoring on the approved landfills would be done through the projects' own Mitigation Monitoring Programs. Monitoring Program As part of the Land Use Permit (LUP) Findings for the Marsh Canyon project, the Board is required to adopt a monitoring program. Our Department has been developing such a program and the attached chart is hereby presented to your Committee (Attachment 1). This chart is designed to-be used in conjunction the Land Use Permit Conditions of:Approval, and will serve as a tracking device for the implementation of the project's mitigation measures. To help ensure that- the construction and operations of the landfill meet the LUP's Conditions, a Development Coordinator will be retained to review plans and installations under the purview of the County. In addition, a Geotechnical Inspector will inspect the installation and condition of liners, leachate control facilities, and other systems essential to the protection of the groundwater. Both of these consultants, provided for in the LUP Conditions, are to be selected by and be responsible to the County. The positions Will be funded by the landfill sponsor. Section VII-A of the Findings require our department to file a written report with the Board once a year, beginning on or about the first anniversary of the approval of the landfill sponsor's Final Development and Improvements Plan and continuing i - Environmental Affairs Committee rN . Date: April 22, 1991 MCSL Implementation & Mitigation Monitoring Program Annual Report -3- throughout the time of project development and operation. This report shall state the status in implementing the mitigation measures identified in the LUP. The sponsor estimates that the Final Development plan will be completed by the end of the year, though components of it will be submitted to our Department before that time. LOCAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (LAC) The establishment of a local advisory committee to comment and advise on the development of the landfill and its operations is part of the Implementation Program. The committee positions have recently,been filled (see Attachment 2), and we expect to hold the initial meeting of the LAC as soon as litigation issues have been resolved. It is intended that the committee will serve as an important vehicle for communicating the concerns of the local citizens, organizations and elected officials regarding construction and operations of the landfill. RV: ea:MrshRpt4.-22 i 7 7 7 r n �-' F-• �• � 0 0 0 0 0 �r o O rt W N 1• W N / N ~ t, N d W H r r d E E < H y r YO' O H d r. o a a m o to r o aH U) n H to r r r -3 ,q to O U, G a a Z rt W G rt ti r "I r- Z IP U K t H (D G i•' t7 z 0, ID h a C to r N a x r M r O O 5 > N 3 n r It•J ID •L7 ro n n ID x1 :31 v PI r a h m < Y a m H to < n rt y ,n H. b H iy b rt O C ID •< b rD m m (DH a it r ro x110 H 110Ip O O r4 O n O B O m r• O O xu rt .n a U7) x n z rn O ID i-I rt n m 5 r' rt h r• a z (D r y O ro H to a r .Q O R1 N G :3, to ] C tD a H. m R tD < rt w n Ri rr rR r r H. ID rt rrtt E a o w x a r ro ° m _ n 'a ° > rt 10 rIt In ly f0 > k G] r ID O m 1,0 to LQ 0 N a H > Q 0 v H K r '' zz n (D � oo x n r) x 0 r n d0xn o r' O O C 0 U) to d d x C to d r7 b Z n In to xd1 d d d d d to d d t-f a ID t0 b n O P) w �< C 0 M 0 C) En r• � w y z x n ] � z c w z to � 0 � K n to t 4o w n C/1 ~ rx Approval 'H3 f� %D 6-G 1O� N Or rn ✓y rt :r# Q 10 O m ° to E^ E ro 3c H d Z tD Ort �r :3 to G :j < ro G d E a n O H ►t tD :3 O a 1 MfD O• w r m r• z z t] r O G p KA H O a rt rt O H H t-4 tK� ID N (D a rt O '< r-r- fD h H Z 0 rt a (D r w tD r• � rt r 0 O Mi C m < r tD h � N s1 N •1 rt x .% O � o ON m a o El m I z H a �tai WIt rt ta n - o m C d O � N rt W Ort to 3: "d " d PI Ell 1< H < rt w H O1< to t-h � y to d C� 0 x 0 x n In 0 rl G H x �o O O C0E Ctn d Z:I' d tDiO 00 t� U) to777d�dd d d :c d d OT ] y 0 ^ Wn n rrt w H I J H d z x 0 m • ro » x x •• H N h� H H C to 4J E E E E E E E 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 U u Uu u u F.u z 41 z cz F4 0 rZ p 0 " 0 04 Z 6 0 0 U ca Zp a) H p r- 41 064 En d) W 44 0 0 -4 .4 >4 E z t44 z- w It. z a:>) ul z 0 vm fo tp >1 V w 0 0 00 -4 (dq W m 0 Z E-4 $4-A $4 0 E 0 m tr Z. '44 W 0 CD 0) m a) 0 rl. r. w (1) 0 >4 a� JeAoiddV z Z ' z 0 m E-4 zP 14 0 0 >4 0 H 0 0 .l.') z 'CL a �y 0 z �4 Hwa U U. 04 u z V) 0 -4 0 44 0 > >4 u ro % z p C14 W 0 z 010 Q A O 0 0 ac U U m pf1 ao U U u ul U U 44 $4 0 V m u PL40 0 a r.V 0 V) (a r- E 14 $4 m 0) 04 0) O 1-4-4 > m ol 0 0 0 �tryjE Z C6 — 0 W E �t 4-) Cr 0 1-4 U t:) C: C:" 0 0 4 r-4 (d 43 -4 4J 4-J U V 0 id -A EE (d -4 (a r. p .0 04 (d r. r-4 C :C 934 0) V) 4,) -4 ftl 04 14 0 A (1) E-4 g Z r.'0 0) 13. -4 tp 4 '0 CA $4 z 0 G) (1) 4J 04 C: -4 rd 0 4-) 14 a d) U R V 0) .0 0 $4 U 0 a) $4 w v 4 > CL4 C 0 ri ON 1-4 4-) Nf"% 0 4-4 0 - t� U Z 4 H - -4 tn 4 w -4 m 0 c (a (D 4) v ty, 04 o r. c: 41 --1 p -- > M -A m (d .11 (14 >4 -4 0 0 r- -4 ty 3: a a w 0) 4-) 41 0) u p )4 fd ot V 4-) U-4 (L) Q�0 W -A 0) 04 -4 0 .14 ON R. '14 (d V E E W - > V z0 4 u 0 (d Q. o N > W r4 -4 0) $4 (1) 0 A -4 V 0 U V) (d 0 u 1-4 m 044) tt 4-4 m 1-4 t, :4 U t:) -4 04 (d -4 (d ul z -4 lu a) ro C: a U 9 V E [K4 U oo rd C: 0 m V (D w > C: 'A w u (a 0 -4 0 (d r4 Q 0 k (1) Q) :1 u E-1 (d W Z r. U 14 N -4 t)) (d z E-A 0 Z (1144 CI 54 0 M 0 0 " 04 04 0) V G. a -4 -4 9 -4 --4 M U) 't a) C in %D -4 V Id _4 '0 4 u 0) w z a) 14 M _; C 0 m a� �4 0 r4 r4 14;r" 4T' 14 -C4 ••+ OE (Wo $04) z 0 V) (n N H r � r � (D H. 0 h w to n to P 41 ;3 O r w 7p O n rt w O O rt O O a (D z rt (D N a N B N N (D a (D a d rS rt S O to 10 n to O H x7 v F1 kj w O H (D w O w r- :1 Z (D N (D G h J tt 'q rt (D Y LA G) a n O w a O Li < art r (D n r G C r• 0 r Z or- w rt r w HI a (D u- - n [n rt rt 0 rt r- O (D (D r- (D to rt y (D O r{ a n 0 ro a C O O G r• rt :3 r r H. t*1 rt x to to n rt rt > O R+ t7 ::j rt O 4 r v ro D (D ro Y ro G o .- O ro 'o a 3: (D a w rn O to r• (D M ro n < r kD h m w U Z O Z r n to r Y ' n (D p (D H n n w (D (D w r rt G r •< K 5 A ] O qi Q G CL (D w N E Y Y (D a rt1 b ro E :Ir. r ^� 1 ro ro w n �- ro O ro n ro a (D rro r ] O O rt xJ CU N O < C fD 10 ] '-' w to r r w O (D Z t- „ ) 4(D N y ,� F.. � 0 to Z O y n LA C N ro d r ro0 ro0 ron rox0 rox0 ro00oo0 0 0 0 0 5� y d E t7 E t7 E to 0 E to 0 E d0 C t7 t7 t1 t7 O to 2O a (OE z 610 no 0 � � OC/) � zx ZO0 H x x x x x Ab K O N H O cn w N z Approval y � K � m O n o n o n o n to n to O C O G O G O G O G 0w3wE3E39Ei HwwwH rt H_ rt H_ rt H_ rt t-- rt t-- rt rt rt � rt rt ►C 'd O r"( rt rt rnt " rt " rOr'►" rt ro z IV Z z ►aj HI r• r-r- r•r• r-r• r•r• z H 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O d o p tt p n ] tt pts to C7 rt rt rt rt rt b O o O o O x t� H y 7ti r yH 0 ron 0 0 0 00000 t7 :c C7 b t7 t7 4 0 0 0 0 O O t*7 O l7 U O d d OOO dO •• Hz PO O ^ O H 4, 7d H z 0 � ftj H z 0 •• MM �• 0 0 0 0 to --_10r r r• r kO n N N 0 N ri U r• oo rt rt 0 rt 0 m m m C) cv� m r-4 4-) V tO a) U) E 0 K U) z z 44 M E-4 0 w 0 04 Z 0 0 0 0 0 V V V 0 $4 0 r. �4 r- V 0 0 0 0 0 0 U) 34 V W V $4 V $4 V 04 U 040 04 u P---4 0 0 04 0 0 .1N 4-) V W 0 Z E-4 -4 V -4 4.) East A V 0 H H E W E ul E W E tn C: x z oQ C A r_ dQ r_ Q c 0 Ho 0o ao :3 0 :3 0 04 zH to U to a 0 to u (n u tD C) >4 aN IBAoiddV z 0 04 zz uor 04 O.E-4 Z A z 04 0 F-4 Z u to GvMHp, Z C) 0 > >4 0 u 0 01 m 0 0� z C14 0 L) CY 3: tc 3: m w 1-4 �1: �W 0C] a Im U a. 0 m u #4 0 V) � 0 V) m 0 z 0 0:4 4 U M W u 0 L) X m u x U L) u u u u U 0 >1 >4 -4 0 r_ V t:) 0 u 33 H (1) r- En W Q to 0 >4 V -4 W u > U) 0 V .14 rt C r-f a) cz 0 co a N x a En ui CL r-i E to -A "a 0 41 w 4) 0 a) 44 w O to-4 V C< :3 eq ul w (d m 4) m t" u W m > a0 0 0 V 04-4 4J m >4 :3 m 0 4Z N 90) 0 p m tn (d 04 >1 m t(I d) u 41 Ow -4 0) O to 10 V 0) $4 -4 0 .,4 0) UE (d m u -1 u .0 (0 V -4 , 0 :3 tn E — m (D Z .,4 3 P4 2S — W m 1d 14 O 41 H 0 L) 0 -4 rd 0 t" " Q, (d 54 44 V 4) $4 to C) U) 44 V V tP cl m a) d to z a) w r. roo to 0 . a) 0 m :1 0 $4 W kD kD M (n u acv t , i r rr r r J tri J J 05 rt M a. Q} Q, N m ,U 0 o . (D (oz r tD 07 J (D Q, N a G� r rt o tO r-+ (r4 w 0 v, (n o N u a � M a C, rt (D N rt O O N 0 a z a a rt rt 10 r a r- z M a O H. r (D -- rn t7' a r E X B w iti r r- 0 rt r x+ 'U (D a D X r r '*] (D 13 r �I rY (D O r r M r rt rt : 5 rr > (D a rt r a K '0 o r rt ,4 rt (D ro r O ci V) r- G ro O N O w r 14 rt O a n rt r M0 (D rt 0 a a x' O H. ka < O -3 t r (D La :1 :1 t* 0y rt Eh [T] r lu h LQ a t" r 10 0 r O O (D 11 r• :5 O " rt a O rt a M 1k r 10 -- to -- O (T r -- V) M z N rt N ka r• F- 1< K r -- a (D ri r r b rr w (D rt o r H. a Ln O r- > (D a rt r :j rt n r to to :3 m b (D (Dtri �, K 0 (] 00 0 x0 0n n0 > 0 o a � a En a a � a Mro z a a a as a a a Mro 1-9 Ono 000 0W to <! 0 (0n U r � � � o wA z x x 0 K 1 O z rod Z Ln ,h r Approval aa O 0 0 0 0 0 " " Z Lo to to W H ++ OO O O r-3 z n ►•� H. r- H. r• 0 0 Q t-4 zftj 0 G� y 1n a Q � ro y y r H 0 t c 0 C ,pGoo 0ti c Fax a °oao aa (°o ° ° 0 t � C z PO � - 0 :c a r, 0 C) xitnn xm '� m o � En rt (n rt to rt a a H rt rt rt z O O O 0 ro � rxj O M 0 W y Crl r 3 W :7 d H Q U z a z �H c=. a C� O O to Q a v ul m m u an ,1 m o0 H O m x u u m m u m u u m as a a m aia a, Ol a C? az •• o t^oa acs o �o o E %o o g4 C.) c 0 o. 0Q > > cn aaa 0.0 > 0 Q,0 E, xH x �4 ux uu t3 �1ux t:) ti4 x uu z r ty *-t m m O`La HEHr v 1+ C U ri Ot 0 0 w zm 3 44 m to 0) -4 R w w Q oH 3tQ u : U S4 5 O�wV z z 4-) ) ON +) oos+ a m m > a) Ow `.•4 -d-4aE ON O rn 4300E a .v Ln i4 o ro m a a a V 0 aI O fl. 0 O •11 N a1 U w > 41 w -.1 -4 -.l .1.1 r,� a z + E--V a O.a•a o o a -4 W o o '5 4 w w Q r $4 *0 14 $4 E & m 0) ON E O ro W z O ro a td 04 is I 1 1 4-a a 04 '-t0 m >, O oa, aan, w a a a aw•-+ E H .4 --A D U ?+(d Q4 w O O O ti) 04 Ga w Ienoiddd (1. u4 ZZoI a H � 00 ?< >C az ::3 tz+ w ►�7 �►ry•i� U W OHP M•L/ � H 0 (� r U IX1 fnL) U to U '• rpt Q a z 3! 3 3 3 3 r� z a cw? A U) U)i A w uQi 0 �j V)i to O < u U x x u m x u U x x w w a) at V H a m m to r O a F--� •.4 O a tto u m m �ry 3 qi C -rt U m O H O O -11 $44- 1 O •.-1 .--t a 41 u U -# a .a .,t .+ Id I aI rk w $4 a t� w a u E-+ u � u a >O w N ai V � U � W4 O fa ( U tad x p, ii. 41 .t 3 u tP (d A o -4 V 4J -a ro c u a SQ a m -4 a U N u O .t o � m tIdd m a H a k O ro U N O 0 A m H Q1 O N z a) O a r r r r in r Ui r r .-t rt rf .-i -4 r OD 0 C13 00 co OD 0 1, rt ;II * w 0 0 0 v, to c 0 H il � 0 t-4 G r- G a G u O H 0 0 111 ti n tj U) 0 rt 0 CA zu M ro rt to M I v r Z IC: (D 0 I�v ::r 0 P) 0 0 0 o (D n Pi ut iv N 13 0 0 D) 'N < 0 ' x 0 0 rt PI o. 0 rt rt (D 0 In 13 En rt rt 1< X 0 rt I" z (D 0 V) E) z rf ro 0 ti Q rt 0 (D �3 kn0 rt to C: to (A ca U) :z0 0 ri) 00 B cn Ow :c ri) 0 0 z 0 X En 0 U 0 tj a 0 q 10 z �u > 10 K) KD K) 00 0 0 0 0 ca U3 to w 0 cn 0 C/) 0 (0) C) �g m > > to A z ac z w z 0 P. 0 bQ 0 z z H q En 1-1b toL4 C: z > H Approval 0 0 0 CA W 0 0 0 0 H M m tr I4 10 H H 10 I I I Q z X 0 r r 0 0 0 0 1-3 z 0 ::I rt, r r r t" 00 0 ko 0 t- M3 z 0 0 H t ti 00 (t 0 (D Mcu rt Z :J x X 0 rohn xhn C: hrt c H6 � (D CA Ell 0 COQ tO (A (D tO 0 (D 10 0 0 00 OQ0 0 H 0 0 z to .13 :3 :3 " 0 m ::r x to 10 IU EI) 0 �-i 0) (D En rt 0w :c rt rt ti :3 to z 4 V) N N V) M 7. C9 H O m m C7 C C 2 O O ? Ci ?+ r-� •.-1 •rl O G 1� {� E-4 ON a) d a) x 3 m. Q °n m O H a) a a) a r � w of - t~ w Or a z u m A u m OA A u A A w U r� _ O -A C V) •a C LL 00 0 w. A V).04) +� cn•-+ x to -4 ANU x U x x3O m a H z azo u - .1 rr) ., O a 0 A W ° � z w z p 4', c 41 °iu .0 a H tr tT cr w ° tr a) w 0) w ,..1 o a c� o 4 A -°4 $ °43 A 10 ro r. ro a z H ° ° O (d +1 b ° w w O w H H CT tT O+ O+�4 $4 D' .0 A tT .O zy w H O> C C C N 1) LL O O O C O A H x O O O (L m ° O H H O H r+ m 4enotddV Cn H 40 V) '. >40 H tD zz � aa O Hwxa U Ga A H C4 >+ U �. � 0 0 a z 01 01 p p, w A A A A A A A A (n C] z C4 C7ARC A N A A O xU VCA W U W � 41 4J to tn pry. 3O H (n O a) V) ' O {} 0 a-4 w U t v '4m E m V w as V •••a w w m w . baa c a ow a U a w 0 ar o w U)) 4 a o) 1~ sa m o a w a ° u U) 0 S ° i .-a COU N m 04 w w ° >1� •,.1 ° 0 w ° iq a >1 > u U 4,) C u a 41 U 4 VO 04 0 U 0 M 41 r-1 -4 U a 3 w 41 a 14 w z t„ 14 ° ° tr w u! ° •r+ a ° ro o•A w V) -4 U tr U w (a $4 Am a rq G41 �z J V ? N m m o w U) sr � a) N m b w ca m H O a A w U en x H C9 a z t? a H a O H N ri -1 .N - �D A m r) w co m m V ri H H .-t ri .-< ., ott o 0 Oui o 0 0 0 0 0 C) 0 N N N M N N N N N N N N n N tIj t) to Li t,) Ili t) K) 0 N F, Ln 0 in 0 O 0 0 (D . m z �j (D tj N H to z to t-j H CD to 0 ti 0 1— 0 P 0) LI) w Aj 0 - kD t, :5 rt (D :J :3 C-- to t-- to cu LO 0 fl, a CL > in VI H Lj U) t-- Z LO (Din iJ t7 nLn n 21 10 c rn r 0 rt n 0) w - 3z 0 3 (D PO C tt H 0 :4 (D n (D 0 to t-- :10 (D H :3 -3 :3 3 r rt Dy kn IV-4 X U rt 0 :3 (D C) 1< Z 0 :to (D O P 0 w n :3 w ED t.* 0 LO rt* r? to n 1< m O 0 LQ 91 n kQ tj 0 :1 %Q to rt 0 (D m Pi 03 :z 0 x0 >1 :to 0 0 0 0 0 V) 0 W0 0 0 En 0 V z as tj 0 00 a as z m to 0 w 0 0 > 0 0 0 z c z or X x 0 z z :,Poo 00 En z > Approval ,D�-, H .-3 0 0 H Q 0 t- U 10 x H 0 r; :3 :3 ;u C: 0 " 10 H " t-4 0. 0 (D rt 0 rt 1-3 z :j 0 1- a :3(D t" rt 0 (D 00 0' t LQ (D LQ pl-10 0 rt 0 (D z tv z (D :3 rt to a0 0 a ti cc m Z ro ::s 0 ti C. ::j C 0 0 0 0 (D 0 m Pa 03 m (D ::r U t:l 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 0 Z to 0 :5 M :3 0 to t (D (D to 1-3 w to �r to to to a: 0 H 0 0 En En 0 CI z 0 m a H d H U d z � a H fUs. C4 to A mU m W V33,U H 0 gg �. aU, z .. OPJ4 A O A W O �Lv W A A.I*. {} p 0400tH OeaAA O+41UIam 0w OX H r 5 N U D p N U U A N A U x U U a H z ►-� Z H 1� O, co .«1 E 0 w w p A w aOe H m N > fzW U 0 00 G 1 4 E C) z A p 0 0 0 a, f*. Ida. N ;enoiddV 0 0 134 U (azo z a a " wZ U U f=+ AHa z V) o � � 0 > 0 �3 3 U 0.. w is A A a A Aafw AAfvtU=. A � z wc7 3A a a A A aaaaw 0V) p d d W U U U U v U W U b U x A U U 5 w U w -4 N a c u aO H4) E G ro a o �� N w U 0 y� Ln (dN 7 rt! iJ N • •r O (d va N N rn W Ql 0 4) 0#-4 4) VI 4) N La ? ..a � 41 tT Cr m tn O c2f E N C-+ �1ro •14 G a 0 (d ro -Ao mea d V. roa t3) En -i > m N ?+N 9 a a 1-4 N _4 W a N :3a a o rt 044 a A4 U m U a -4 > 44 O zQ $4 v) 4) r: 0) U tT N-4 m N u a A o a fxr �� w tri 4) ww 1 w to C a U 3 W r+ U PC H 4-) w a w 0.,4 O 41 Q1 (d -moi W •11 0) to .0m 4 N 4 U tr 4J r "A m b z•„{ N " a ' H .,) � 10 O C maw 0 a o a 0 a -4i 3 : Hw ' 4) oo v a d Co N m •-i N fn t~ %D .-4 co -14 C7 t N N N N N rt f 4+-) �+ 3 t•) a 0 U N N N N N N N N f1i N N W (d Ln to Ln to LP to (P w 0 LO 0 0 r to IC3 r1 0 0 0 n m 7 ri O H F- 0 0 H, 1U H ut t-t to 1< to LO rtZ M 0 :3 ti H- rt CS 0 r rt n 0 rt (D 0 0 C) ::3 rt 0 IC) r. (D t-- < 0 f-t 0 n :3 rt (D z n 0 rt < rt ft ri -3 0 n n ti t-) (n rt (D ro F' 0 ri 0 C) lu O t rt (t ti 0 :1 n r H 0 w rt (D r 0 0 0 MO (D tj W z < ri (D ro 0 lu 0 0 0 0 0 r (D 4 z to n -3 0 r 0 (D �A C: 0 to to to EA En to to En z CA a a a 0 a a a a rn ro0 z w > --3 0 En0 z tv #--4 0 0 0 F3 A 0 0 7 '0 ° 0 C: z Approval 0 aa %D K ro to t-h Z - 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 X 1-3 w ti m 0 OH :E M m m t . z � 0 to r- 7s F- Q ka to t0 to H." 0 W 1< 0 0 0 0 0ii 0 0-3 z m b< t . F. 00 1 0 0 0 0 9 9V 0 z 0 0 PI 0 H m 0 rt %a c (PID H* CA ty 0 ?", to Fl. to Z X to 0 n a n x n x n x n C; n a n c ri c H x H En 0 0 roto (D to (D In M to (D 10 roto (D 10 (D 10 OO 0 0 Q 0 0 Q 0 z lu (D m0 (D 0 (D Gm (D (D (D 0 w to to a ED PO w to to (n to U) 0 #-3 rt rt. 0 rt 0 rt 0 rt rt rt rt :3 :3 :3 to V) En En 0 t) 1-4 0 1-4 En C3 In E,f V N •• z-. (� N o wa 4t a r r (� U) z x o x o 0 0 0 a u +-J V ,-) -P V V m U m U U U U p � CL 2 •• O .v m r O tr +s m L1 as m 0 .tJ M A 43 MO /'1 C� O O 0,a) --4C to Q+a) .-a C to -A C to •-1 C to .•-t C to - �0 ta4 OX H 5 is to--a x tt to-4 x to-A x US•••t x to-.i x z r�y m m C G C - y H O O � E N a a �`-� . 11 ro V 0 4J QCT � � 4) w0) r. 040.E 04 z wz 0 0 ro z 0 ar o H 0 0 a O E E $4 E to H o H H a o tr On Cr tr+ tr0+a On a W -A -••{ � t t 1 a-4 I •a o to f 4 C C G C tt W G tt -t Z W� C-., :C P. a, O O fl O C14 04 O 04 ��•--tt eno.idd N ta ZE z o a4 NZ �' w z x' Hwa U fl ti4 Na pM� y U c C� 0 P � ° > •• w E• ww% z car r r a r r A ca OU oa a, t7 to r to to Ut to Ua U} 0 3 G x O U04 --U W w � r r � � w m GCg cn to 89 C to G ttnn 0 ro a, W 0, o 4 to (L) u ,..,.a w 3-4 e 04 V td m C wt3 tn b' W C r. rt N ..4ro a .� 04 � as 4J .0 st G G -"t � G U a) -1 N a >. a. (a tro+ w Q w a04 i to H U U U G H I W N N C G G) O) O-tea x 4) O +� 0 b� Ra U •t2 U W 4 4 U) N N 11 .tr t B 6 Q) p O to W W W C.+ W W W 9 H 04 W d' Ln to t` a0 lT r m N z a u) to w . 0 0� U — N N N N N N N N- 'N tj tj ro tj N n () to 0 10 1 0 to (1) C: Lf) U) 14 0 q ti N t-- r t-I (D (D 3 0 0+ :3 ty z 0 0 to a a a (n m m c m t !4 0 rn rn r lu 0) m x tift U)0 (D H. H, t-I 0 rt �u 0 rt rt n r w "I tj 3 t- -4 •< C', m h > 0 1;u ri rt rt (D Pi H w o n to r -j " 9) K ro 7.- :3 rt n 0 m (D 3 rt ro rt n 0 0 0 10 V) IQ Q 0 xw to z I mC-- :3, m 0 0 0) LO "i L11 0 :O rt < cu ::Ito :c > 4Pw (-) H- t, (D w 0 z x m :1 0 :3 CU a Ln (D 0 (D M 0 D " 0 0 (D t1 w y to 0 n ti rt El n mH. (D 0 rt :3 :3 0 rt rt I tta co 0 Ln 0 C: (D ED (D CA tj :1;0 0 Ln *0 0 ha 10 M a to 0 0 0 0 t7 0 0 0 :c 0 :e x 0E ::r 0 tj U 0 0 0 to Oro to 0 " a u 0IZ3 0 zro W 00 :to 0 0 En 0 Uj 1-3 0 0 10 z C: w :P# z 0 0 t-I x >4 X >4 0 z z :,0 0 H q '00 En W z >(:) Approval ,a ro VO to 0 to 0 0 0 H z ti ti tt n 0 ti O :3 0 0 H PI* k" N N � H. :3 1 1 1 z x 0 0 0 0 to O . to to ko M " r4 ti ti II ti ct rt 0 0• 09 0 ti H 0 0 rt (t rt rt z rt, z :3 w 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 kQ " 0 rt rt z ftj z 0 0 0 0 H. t'.a 0 q 10 a to to 0 0 Z (D (D m (D a an C:Ena C) h ti ti ti 0) P) PI 0) to rt rt rt rt H. H* fl, 11 0 0 0 0 Z3 :3 :3 :3 H yl LO to to to Z to n 0 0 0 En n 0 0 0 11 i~ H X 0 0 0 0 :T 0 0 0 0 009 0 CA 0 0 0 0 m " 0 00 0 Z 0tjj 0 :3 0-4 ::1 (D 1-3 7u (D 0 �i ti rt z to 0 F-I z 0 to C: I t N H ux N V� H •• z'a x x x x z �H wa o. z H A a mx H O n�. z cn A A A A 0 �A A O O O A A A A 04 a rc iA U U U U t:) $40 U p+l � z mm r-� E-4 0 0 0 0 v 0 0 waW � N $4 u cd a w a 04 m a 04 �-+ w z 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z z HH 0 0 0 0u a o w w $4 V w w Z w 14 H« z a a s aol a a Q A H°1` lenoiddd a a z u04 z o 04 H a o x 0 UM U wAH � W Z E"' u U °a z > H 04 m •a ar 0 a u q F, .z (1)a, w m � � 0 c .0 E toA A A aAw rAL43 040 0 03 t4 >" 14 3 0 0 M0 A 3A 3 Amo r U 0 rCit oo toa --.0U a 0 x w u U 134 a uxw U W " W L }� U A td 0 E-+ o 0 +- a w c �ry v a a Id E H oa't 0 a w a m w ai H N 0 U roti 0, H .i X . pa wv w w � w w`� cc tD y [ rd C ty rd ,14 4d Oi a) b Aa (d v zo N H u °a o 0 0 w •o 04 0 cn ai a 4 u 0 -4 LS-44 U -A v W 3 H P+ $4 E4 ri H > U) D4.4 w (dw •4 m a ani o 0 A al V u k >+0 T3 1a z '+ v 1 1 u ro u a, b a m 0 m --4 of ar v •.4 E o w 41 N H C s4 A a a a1 a s H •a m H A+ N m 0 3 to W Z4} O% rl r1 r4 r4 0+ H N d' O a a; rn Chrn m E m o a o {) �.. {V N N N N H N m M w 0 to O w w w w w w w w w w wn 0 rt10 +, O O a O O O O O O w O 3a (D m w a rt " tJ t, I✓ 1., N " N OD m U, to 0 P) r- a E ko w ► o 10 r-+ " O O rt N 3i nJ E O H ID `< O O %D to H t=i r+1 '�i O 'T7 r• (D a O I1 10 to rt w -3 0 3 r r• ::3 r- h H rt to 0 O1 a - O M r- tD h h I h (D 'U tD Y- 2 1 ] rt I r h (D (D w (D O h Lr N 0. 0 0 t" ro n r• O O 10 kD M rt (D m w rt n h a b t✓ Ta O Q. (D 'U %D d m x h tit O O rS Y Y O r-h a in C ro n rt (D < 0 K 'U rt h a h n r `G HI a Ic M (D m K 't7 73 (D rt rt .3 a :3 ;1;' a h n E r 'q (D 0 O r- (D M t1 (n rt rt a r- 0 x! LO rt n 0 to O (D G (D r rt :3 " O 0 to H. 0 Z 8 12 r, rt O (D (D < C - 'a G N r- to n rz r h a W h 21 0 'ty :Ir to 0 G h rt 0 rt (D rt n (n x U (D r 0 (D (D aO tD h O O K rt (] (D G m ] h F3 N (D rn rt rt :c w to rt a In rt 5 (D to (D r (D O LO O (D N r� rl rt 0 C 3y - {D Y- r--'t7 O n ::r O n (D 0 xu (D F- K (D ts} (D rtti ti m En G) 0 3 m �' n ro rt to ro n -- t O 4 a K t° H wto h K C� 0 ►�-�r n n trix tnn 'on ron > xO O bfjrob a w v d � o En 0 c� > z � �Zz x x x x x 0 P. � ro z toEn Z H Approval r� n ti K rrot O to O 0 O 0 H H d Oz or 0 0 o a z H kD ro__ Ln m m t to 0 rt rt ( ro a 0 o tD H (D H A �•( xto OH En C7 r+ c� ro x � ro .. H to H Q En H H v) a . N .. z N wa z O N •'I a U �./ 04 Z •. V) O A O A A 11 M A h W Q 0 O 04 4! A A A A -A G it) 0 (� xH u U U U -+ x a H z + m O a d) m 10 F H 4 +J CP O +i V O O y�r V -.i O U V -.1--i m 10 41 (i, w^+ w m ro . 3-a v --+ 3 tr a m ro a >4 CvmE Q Q A V) v a v ,O u 0 w •.s -+ (D v C CL O P+ V d) O O b -,4 Ck O ZU O --t O 4 rt 04 A a m m > O ••°s W z u 4.) 4J w •a a � d) 41 O N O ("4-4 'a ds as O w--4 -t s4 O O U m a +J s., O m v m w w •-+ +) u a 0 Q o 0 a v V 3 0 3 4) - 4J a--+ 4J W -.4 z H �+ 04 • H v v R+m U 'a w-.s w u V O >4 w w o O O a -4 b•-+ O O O 'a O O m a+ x -a E w @m > � > 0z -4 -aa 1 wp N C vv (da) c v0rov 14 s� O A Z H x CL w� a $4 w $4 +,AD a U -+ a Csa a U o Q H°a jenoaddV �7 w r ~ V1 e-t a o � a >c x x se H � U�ja p HCstxa U U rX4 M xzHva �i o FA a >+ 4 w O U -^4 0, �-i aw x A AAx A A A 0 0e0 A C44 A AV) A A A A3 C: x A V) Q aC rL U C-) w U V U w w} v) H PL4 H O �y� H N U m a p a+O �d U N as O� a0 sus A (d LS la t3) r-4 V t3)14 N °' -4 s°, n, a w a'a A w a F+ b e tia ' v a V b� M .-4 O a o o °' a� -�-$4 m o m O w U $4 Cn > +t O O m 4J ao v a ° A u z v "° ro a� w a' >, a a, Ra v O id •a V •-s $4 1HrtNaa 1-4 -a 4F-4 a a> w '4 m V C v U a ON a b Q •a -4 m U r. aVa' A N a m t i z 04 0 4 F v v-A m is >4 O m xy E O V V) U k Id m $4 H G b 0 -4 O v z U U a1 a O td p0E-I � x U •+ 3 O RCx U 04 A O Z V) d in N w r r) M .A tt Vt 04 Oa 1-I 1� Er) .+ (N NroN N C,4 0) U -- rn M -- M ri r, x > M M V L.) w L'i M Li w w LI) Lj w LO w LP Ln w n o to Ln W LAI w 0 0 C - (D Z LO 0 rt C) 10 - 4 Or 0 a P) En cu OU (D '�J t� 0 q rt " rt > 0 :3 r- 0 :3 " t, ITJ o : 0 z En w :J 0 0 (rd H n b rt O a Z LQ " w 0 n n H. 0 0 eQ z h @ 'I rt tq N 0 ro to rt 0 Z @ m 0 LQ rt r LTJ V- M H- ri > 0 rt q (D t-Irt > (D 0 m 0 (D -�< a m rt 0, F- 0 0 �11 0 P, rt z m 0 IV n a a n n a 0 n < (D rt (D HI U) rt 0 n@ H 9 :3 c Pu 0 0 ka rt M w (D rt n :3 w 0 ti I.- M O n Ln (D (D � D 1< 0 z rt -3 � xJ M Iw. to " (A 0 ID 0 0 0 IV ti rt qj (D n 0 0M (D ("t > I.. rt z (D kI. 10 F) H 0 01 (D :3 Mn x 0 0 0 to 0) > 0 LO (tiD EO rt CI i (D �r to (D 0 Oto Uf ZC 00 H- :c a Cn U) 0 H 0 0 En a 14 0 tj 0 0 0 t-to — z w 0 W m w ado 00 rt 0 P to M (D 0 0 0 z 0 P 0 0 z z 0 H 0-3 0 En � C) 0 z C-1 - > Approval �W-"3 %D 0-4 ro 0 N w 0 rt w1-3 :3 0 ti n ::$ 0 0 a 0 r. 9H 0 :3 P. H* 1 0 a 14 z X r- 00 0 tQ t-- NM 0 ;u ct n n 0 0 a 0 �-3 Z 0 1- 0 rt 0 - t-N '-4 rt rt :3 ct :C 0) 1-- m 0 0 0 to H-0) rt P) tu " 0 (D m ct t,- z m ,a ct 0 w rt 0 m 0 0 0 0 0 F- m ::I " z I- ri :3 0 V En 0 rt m ct fD 0 :r" w `ti ry 9 P, X H- -7' r " 0 t 1-3 s-3 0 0 IV 0 0 0 x0 0 tu x ri Q H x 0 0 :c v 0 0 En tj 0 to (D tO 00 tai 0 0 Ou En OQ 0 0 z �O H C) (D 113 m 0 m 0 �-3 0 rt z 0 1-4 cn En V) x d N v'! U z d z C7 M O " is Or m z o o a H a v w 1•4 � ; o spp aa. ao, a 04 o Q o 0a) w umn ,-) ma .ijm0 W 0004 a cn n Q c o •••+ C u) _4 C to -4 C V)zH $4 U UAL) ua•ax ti) _4 En•-Ax as z { a H C H ro ro ro ro 14 4 V V .C4JV Z O H ru z � wa0) az -+ a ) 13 V �r a z E-+ •4 r+ o •a .4 o o V a O o ,G H H E a) $4 E (1) f 4M m M CP z n > a .Q > Q. ) c ) ) HO :10) E aa) E CO C C C Z A Hz V) ammo U O o O �i lenolddy 0o H V1 H a HH z (34 z o E-4 o x x z U U w Q H w d Z H v' d 0 w a o U -4 C E-4 a A .0 Q � Q o p dd v olU UcnU W .� c a 14 L4 z o o eta M N fn m ro 4 41 N a) $4 al w.4 a m to m a aro. m v a w o G -4 O v a) a� .A .4 O a C at 43 a G r•J O 14 +s a E -a a U a O iak w 1} O tT z 4 ••-t a) r- Q1 is d ro tP a) a) •••1 p H p,N $4 +) > a 4-) m 3 to a) >, 41 a) -4 • V •a 044 > 7 — C N r1 G N 00 r- % a O a) oC•a t4 o o NN O a4 a p m o T) to u m v L a n« >. c -a u n) a) #z o C a) 41 d41 V 0) 4J .1 ro u C �A o a $4 •a .4 ro 41 (d (dtr C 4.) o U Um a m O ^a -4 G �4 $4 N C a) m u $4 41 4+ �Q A w C :3 • a) b a m CIO ^.+ w za ro a rd m >,; � V o k o 10 (d a o O m x ++.a C .N • M C It W 04 00 w O •a co •,a a ro A H � w d m O O N U z a. �( O O A m ut N kD a t- Mom) N co r a7 m m a H z a . � . . •a a O a in 4 ua a Ln to C uy v u� ut N ua (n N c*) a M t i ro cl N m (1) M U M rn L.) Li u, ro w w Li W Lj Li — W ON UN Ln Ln Ln W in w 0 (D M z (D (D to K 0 t-3 IV (A 0 H 410 (D a :3 " 0 N 0 a@ w n a r) M 0 t- 0 ra rt :3 :3 (D (A rt " H- Z (D n 0 H 0 tT 0 n tj 0 (A a C. 0 0 t* n rt :3 10 0 (D (D :3 n hi n rt 0 (t n :E r') (t rt > ;O < @@ 0), z 1< 0 1< lu 0 (D 0) (D rt tj (j F- IV 0 N ;n H. " < t.) " w LU 0 zO 0 C 0 H w < V, :3 C " 0 lu < M y :3 " w cu att < (D 0 z > 0 z ru 0 w rt to 9 0 M H. IV rt 0 0 (D -j 0 r-j Li 0 F- tT 0 n rt 9 7 N tI I-- ED rt (D 0 H* (D a H. Pi 0 0) 0 (1) C 0 < N (D M M ft > %D M NO f-I M 0 0 0 Ln G LQ M M rpt rt (D 11) 0 n U3 co to to 03 ro nxa >4 > 0 0 0 0 0 0 :c 0 En to IC C) 10 z EA EA to (A (A d a arAJ 10 z �O 00 > < . ,'� 0 0 t-i x t-I 0 z C: z 0 t-I1-3 0 04 z z 0 0 Z H tu En w K (4 t4 2- > Approval �� H %Dq %D, d � G C., 0 :P' > 2,0 10 10 %Do M ON M 9: 0 " o no :3 :3 0 0 :3 M cr z x (D ZI r: a :3 :3 Li-M to M -3 :3 H " 0 9u m to 0 ti H- M Hz ?.I to M 0 0 :3 m to rt 0 0 0 i-- rt rt to ro0 (D M w tri 0 z M (D rt 10 :3 £ (A " 0 :3 1CL 0) 0 0 rt rt tr• P. a:3 0 H-rt 0i in z N z -.4 < tr (D rt rt :j 0 c H. H- 0 ro 0 0 C: 0 0 0 :3 :3w:3 :3 w H hi rt :31 rt :3 (D Z 1-3 'OW 0w 0 cu 0 tri 0 to 0x x ri C: x lu H 00 00 00 00 00 0 En E/I M tO w ;c 0Otri 0 m 0w am am am as 0. 0 0 0 Z to H M to 0 H 0 �O ft z C) ci z 0 En P to C: C7 -- H zWc� r-a N A z 0 O z W A � E-4 cri � H� N H 004 H z A a U L) 1,4 � z � ° 0 a U 0 z U at W " u a .0 41 4 � a) er+ � as c c +3 m y ---4 a) -a yr W O 4J rouIII U -4C >.mtr > E C x o w-.iA vm4 14 a) a) a) -C N N W O I~-a (1) w w tT m a) rd O 41 C U O Sa to-A•4 (d3 m m>.+1 p -4 +1 O —0 +) -4 -4 ^+1 U 1,4 W - a v a) ro >.C-A ro to .-t v A V .V —00 V r1.-1 V 0 041 0 0 03 z1x 0) 4) 4) C:w 033 RI WO o '0 ld 11 5 a) o 0) W 4 ta U A a-1 C rd4Jtr rt tL $4 P dJ V • r7S -- .-1 -- m C (I) 11. Al a) w 1d-A (d >.--w.0.0 to $41,40) E uam.-, 04 41 >,0mmt3i 0a0aEV >.tr V (dw0) a) 41 -4•,1a) Oto m +1 Q4$.I to a) >..0 C 140 O 044 1» V W W a I-Aedoit3: v tro-,1 Uwldaq •.a U P 3 a) a) M" .-1 a) 0)� a) >+>'N U E 0) a) on ardNA a �(d ` � m (dP+ x id > (-f o $4 b b III (d -a 4+ > m 0 C m td .J .0 r. Q) C cn o -4 at 1:1 rt O >+CC.14.14 M o 9 04U) to U � H U >.1~•au (d (d-AWArx•aua) of Ott w v u G o u UMAto'a 41 oA'av•A tr o ro -4 o ►)w V o 4 •-1 (a 3 0) a) A 7.is » C w+ 0-1 C +} V V.>: (d 134 W +s +3 ro -4 'a V ::% "A W.4 a U m m .1-1 r j U O U V -.1'•11 N -+ A13Wr- •-1••lroUa) roror- (d0U•aroCCV m .0 4roo ro .-4U uWWroU00 .4VOt3m It a oU oU m If a (1) o Oncn 1d 1x1 U U N Q N if x 1 7 tt :3 If If 1 3 � m 11 u co nwu r+ m r� It it 1t M 01 11 A A 11 It O En <n 11 W AUt $4 z str� O AAx1+(Y 11 C3j mIm, n ,� �+ w30U) Ln VDD W m CAmu U UUU UA W W x0C14U) t73 > > t, W ATTACHMENT 2 MARSH CANYON LOCAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (As of April 2, 1991) ORGANIZATION APPOINTED REPRESENTATIVE 1 . City of Antioch (1) Barbara Price 2. City of Brentwood (1) William Doheney 3. City of Clayton (1) Pete Laurence 4. Oakley Municipal Advisory (1) Dennis Nunn 5. Marsh Creek Association (1) Mary Williams 6. Clayton Regency MoHo Park Assoc. (1) Will Cossel 7. Environmental organizations: Audubon Society (1) Declined (seat held open) Sierra Club (1) Dick Vrmeer 8. East County Regional Planning Comm. (1) Vic Catanzaro 9. Transplan (1) Barbara Guise 10. Commercial and Industrial firms: Commercial Representative (1) Declined Industrial Representative (1) Dennis Gripenstraw 11. Park & Recreation District (1) Elgin Martin 12. Contra Costa Water- District (1)7 John Gregg 13. East Bay Regional Park District (1) Kevin Shea 14. Waste Management of N. America, Inc. (1) John Rowden (non-voting member) 15. Delta Board of Realtors (1) Enrico Cinquini VC:gms eCAVC\MC-1aC.Ct8