HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 04051988 - 2.3 TD BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
FROM: Phil Batchelor Contra*
County Administrator tJoJICI
DATE: March 31,- 1988 CJ'
SUBJECT: Comparison of Provisions of
Propositions 68 and 73
SPECIFIC REQUEST(S) OR RECOMMENDATION(S) & BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
RECOMMENDATION-
Consider whether to take a position on either proposition.
BACKGROUND:
On . March 22, 1988, the Board .• of Supervisors requested a
.comparison of the provisions ,of two initiative campaign spending
limit, statutes which are on the ballot June 7, 1988. These are
Proposition 68 by Walter B. Gerken and Proposition 73 by Senators
Kopp and Montoya and Assemblyman Johnson.
Attached is a ,chart which compares the essential features of the
two propositions. Proposition 68 refers to "small contributor
political action committees" , "legislative caucus committees" and
11political party committees" whereas Proposition 73 refers to
'Ipolitical' committees" , "broad-based political committees" and
..political parties" . Since these, terms are defined somewhat
differently, we have not equated them . in defining contribution
limits.
Probably the most significant difference between the two
propositions is that Proposition 68 is funded with public money
derived from income tax check-offs and seeks to limit overall
campaign expenditures. Proposition 73 does not limit overall
campaign expenditures, but also prohibits the use of any tax
funds in political campaigns.
CONTINUED ON ATTACHMENT: YES . - SIGNATURE:
A RECOMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR RECOMMENDATIONS OF BOARD COMMITTEE
X APPROVE OTHER *
S 1 GNATURE S
ACTION OF BOARD ON April 5; 1988. APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED x OTHER
REAFFIRMED position in support of Proposition 68 on the June 7 , 1988
ballot (UNANIMOUS)
ADOPTED position in opposition to Proposition 73 on the June 7 , 1988
ballot (III ABSTAINED - concurred with certain portions of proposition)
VOTE OF SUPERVISORS _ see above
3 HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A TRUE
_ UNANIMOUS (ABSENT AND CORRECT COPY OF AN ACTION TAKEN
AYES; NOES: °• AND ENTERED ON THE MINUTES OF THE BOARD
ABSENT: ABSTAIN: OF SUPERVISORS ON THE DATE SHOWN.
cc: County Administrator ATTESTED
April 5 , 1988
County Counsel PHIL BATCHELOR, CLERK OF THE BOARD OF
Elections Supervisor SUPERVISORS AND COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
BY �
382/7-83 ,DEPUTY Al � _
0K•. P) � P) K 00s✓ K 0 (D K 0 00 , Fh
rKr �' a � � 0E o (in0 � � 0Fj- 0rrt
F'
1..4 b I✓ N- rt K ::% (D F- P_ K P) K O
rt b 0 m r rt F'• U) (n (n r_ 0 H rt �l P. (D H
rtO C] F-J (D rt K 13rtf2 ab, to U)
(D F- O Fes- n Q (D P) P) P) N-tQ a (D 0 W r- U)
(D F'• rt 0 F'• (D I-' F-' �3 0 P) F- (D0 a rt H C
m rt F- g (n M F-J a t4 0' c rl) rt a Fl-
F'- Fi• 0 F-J b Fl- F'• •• K rt O n
o rt P) F-'- P) o n F-i bs N a 0 (D 0 N
P) rt F_j rt rt rt 0 P) P: P) Iv F� (n
F-1,. (D rt F'- F'- 0 Ia' U) rt P) F_ t-+ a
(D (D. c O rt O F'• F'• F•' (D O P- (D
(n (D (D . K K F O m a KEl a
Fl- 0 Fl-
In rr
Z OKOO
O K r_ O �) Ul P) Ln P) N (D P) H rh :
I'd (nOhLno � o cul Kxo rhN
a c) p, O Fl- H- O N-1'C
K ro rhLQ 0C) Fl- C) Fl- C) O O 0
O (D.rh (D o o a a a (D U)
C t] g o o P) ro P) ro ro In rt
Fl- F'-.(D (D rt (D rt (D (D P)
U) PL) F-J Kt-, t-r, (D (D F1 OK P) rt,
Fes. F- (D P) O 0 (n In r-h � (D
0' 0 N K K (D (D .. (D a ro
�J (D rt F'- F-J Fl- F-J ift F-J FJ 7d
F- F'• (D U) > (D �J (D N (D F� (D O
(D O 1-' (D (n 0 0 to 0 O Q ro
0 �J (D :� (n P) rt P) rt . rt 0 Fl- O
rt 0 P) (D N- F'- o F'• P) (n U)
N- rt. rt NO NO O0 FAN H
O 0 N- (D V o :3 P) F3
BOO F-J .. ►4 >yrt H
(n.0 �j 0 "C (D (D rt 4 F'• O
rt P) P) P) 3 Oro (D c z
I'd KO0 .0 KP) KP) K 0 (D
K P- :1 a P) x x P) F� .0 01,
0 t7J N 'dF - 0 F'• ro F'- Fra F • 0 00
�r r_ "C a a (D E (D El F- P) (D I-h
F'- rt W F'• K 9 K 9 h-h
Fl- 0ONW o o Pi 0
rt � Ft m rt a �ao 0 o (D t
(D (n (D rh rh a tQ rt' m �d
n0 o o rrtPi " � (� z
W F- o o (D P) F-J O n
wF o o U) F-J a �
0 o N- O (D rt
C) o �:l K aFz
¢ O O N (D N Y
C F-J H FC N- 0 U
F-J N (D P) trJ
P) F� F-
K �--
z z m tf mift P) n H �d
N O O ro F� ro F- Q O :3 Pd
(D o (D o (D 0 0 O
Ln ro ro Oo 0o 0 (nF-J Fd
C) r i K F'• O F'- O 0 rt r_ O
Co O 0 P) - P) Fl- F'• a (A
C C F-''Id F-ro (D rt (D H
ro
Fl- F'- (D (D In r_ U) . F3
(D In U) (D K (D Ft rt H
K F'• N• H H F'• U) O
r t, 0 w (0 Fl- ((DD � w z
FJ- rt.U) rt (n K P) rt __1
o 0 P) 0 w F- I-' (D w
W 0 F- �l F- rt 0 F- )
F� In (n (n Fh (D
(D w w rt, o u) ro
P) K K K (D F� by
Ort
r_ (D0c z
(n m K a (D H
O
ter F- P) O FC
H H 0 F-' F-h >
0 0 0 F-J rh �
0 o P) F'• C-4
O O F-A F-J 0 O
o (D x
rn r-h N 0 (n z
O O F'- P) U)
O
F'- z
rt
P4 1-4 "0 H 0 rt 0 'i3 O ro > r- 12J 131 "4 0 U) rt' Fn O b ~=i b
n n OWOOO Ono Orr " h n wr_ oo (D non a
O o Hrt. B �:s. H N rro o o o � ro O N0 w
F'- N- 10 rt P. t7 F'- H. F1 a" n rt a 10 Fes- (D
rr C N• O " I rt " rt o H• O O "' o rt
O F'- F'- (D rt F✓ P- P. O F- �3 I UI o F-'- a ti 9 N- N F'- bi N
n �l o rt P. o3 o A) 0 _::3 n �:% w rt b' O P. 0 h .
a W 0 (D rt F✓ w a Pi td N 4 a rr N- Fr �:l rt SL O
Ou P- N W (D F,- rt H I N o O N W F'• (D N rr rt (D F'- FJ W
� C r_ U) () N- v g H H � C Fn (D rt Fi• ►C O a
N- F'• " 0 - W O O w n N- F'- w •• 4 (D O tL n I
N a w Fr N O UJ O F+• rt n N a P- (D F-' O tzi
12)rt a rrtm m~o t-� 0 a0 rrtr0 � rt w � m r ro
Pull
FJ• F-J F'- Ul Q A) P- F✓• Fl- (D AU rr H• F-J W E P. N W (D
O (n (D F'• n a rr rr (D N n O U) rt El tt rt a
�j U) O Ui rt F'- rt rr F'• �J Fes• W N• rr (D
.. tj F 6< (n ((D (D F� (CD � .E (A
ttr r z ''d txj z
ui Ln O Lin N H ti >C O
O (D
O o '� o u, O C b
O O n O O O
O O o O O O (n rt O
C H• In C
F'• F'• F'• F'• b b O F .
�J �l En (D (D �l rt U)
F'- tj t'! (n �31 F,-
a a O w (D O
N N N (D (D I-h
FF 1 W ¢1 F-j-
K'i l< �< Fl ti ti
(D (D (D UI
P) a w rr
n Fs n
(D (D (D Ln
Fl. Fl- Fl_. O
O O O O
a a a O
�n
F1
O
Pi
tr
0
c
(D
N N N O N N O In
In ul Ul (n Ui. (D O
O O O ti O O O
O O . O O O O, O
C F-J
((DD ((DD ((DD U) ((DD ((DD. ul ((DD
ti tS ti N- ti. tj Fl-
0 a
F-h tt rh p rh rh �3 t•h
H• F'• F'• Fl- Fl- H-
Ul U! (n U? m (n
P) w w P) a a
N N F� F-' N F-'
(D - (D (D (D (D (D
P) P w w w w
n n tt
ti n n
oown on ann 0h 000 " N an P) �lo 0rrFi a
Hcn o o n O a o F- 0 o P.) o r- o 0 0 rt 0 o w
N (D El rt ro � r r rt. rt P) El a tH rt r• K (D
rt H.
a r �4 O C P. rt n r• H P. (D Ft O
Fl. rt (D rt (D H P) H. P) rt r•r• (D O (D (D a Q r• �J i in w
o rt ro Pi rt PD 0 P. F- a H rt 0 t7 Pi �. P) Pi P) r• t7 a
N 000 (Do Ort, F- H (DWr- 0 O 0 rtwr_ 0 " P)
N (D P. P) (D W rt �V �31 �Y (D H rt o O H
Fl- 0 0 F•' �J (n O m PU r F--' F-
Fd o rt tr Fd r- Pi PL) U) o w " (n o r• • rt O F,-
P) n r• n o rt F_ r o n K �j r• 0 r• rt O
n 0 O F-, rt 0 rt I Pi w a c rt r• O
rrP, P, Fl- (D r r- Fi P) r• (D r rt 0 0
rt (D In o H c r (D 0.) rt
Fl- (D , (D F✓ H,
o (n r• (n r•
Pi rt t7
z z FhH i ift
O 0 trn O O to N LrT
o n rt
I Pi o Ln o 0
n n o U) F� o 0 0 0
O O o. (D o 0 C) o
c co � O
Fl- P. P) rh 'd 'd 'd F,•
In m rh rt (D (D (D �J
Fl- W O (D ti F� Fi
O O K lln P)
hd o (D (D (D
> (D t--' F-' F-' N
m F1 o (D (D (D i
(D (D o rt rt rt (D
�l F- F,- r- F'• P,
t7 (D t-h o O O K
F-' 0 O .
rtn
Fl- (D .
O > ti
d
In r•
(n 0
ul (D p.
C) tr
C) Fr
C)
rn
O ter
tt J
Un
(D o
0. o
P, o
rt
(D
ift ift z z z ift z
U-1 N O O O F� F-A 0
C) Ln 'd Fd 'd o o 'd
0 o F1 n K o o rt
0 o O O O o o O
�d 'd w Fl- Fl- 'LY 'd Fl-
(D (D (n (n (n (D (D (n
r� K r- r r n r-
o o 0 0
rh rn t-h. Fh
r• F'- r• r•
rh
0 0 (1 0
PL) P) Pi Pj
F� N F-+ F�
ki
(D (D (D (D
P) P) ¢
F1 n n n
r- o G, , F3 ro
{
aro 0 1n
W .� FC ,V 02
F'• (D Ffi P
W (D
C)
m O 1-h
F-h �
o rtFl Fl
'rJ
tr a
U2
G� 0 U2 it �1' P_ > O W m O ro rt t r 1d
F' m m m �1 W 0 FJ O F-i W 11 :3' (D n
U) ptj �:% cnrt- H �J mts0 mrt0
(D (D W - 0 F-• O rt 0 a �y FJ- E t)'
o n n rt O t3' �j E n ro. rtP- F'- " (D Fl-
F1 W W (D o F,- 0 m Fj• O N- a.�. (D V
F- N O 0 O b' N O W Fes• 0 :1 Fj-
ts ro rt sr Fl- 0 rt rt o rt
m lTJ ttJ n rt, m W rt rt (D U) 1.1 N (n
n F✓ P F'• O rh x Fl- Fl-1� rt (D
m (D 5 " I✓ rt 10 0 0 m O W nLQ rt
UJC2nW WWW 0PL) Wrt0 0Fl- n
ro rt rr n > u2 F-i n m F-i to W
(D Fes- H-14 U2 U2 (D (D (D (D H N �l
Doo (n En n F, W (n
Pi 0 0 (D rh U2 0 W rt a rt rh
F'- -64 ;5 o rt n b rt W Fi• (D
� ro Ht7n O rt W rtn �31p 0 C n
(Q n 4A H FJ O �:l �4 0 P) 0 (D
O H N)1,4 (] LQ t:r :� (D O .
rt" c -11- W0a O0Fl- Orn
o H. cr1 Lil ro 0 (D a o V Fj• o F W
a- On art U) a q F'• �l rh rt �J 0
rt F'- 0 0 FJ-F-'- O F-'- I ft rt a W
f o �la L 0Fj• Ulrt0 (DFi- 5
P-LQorhWWKJ :� r_ rt ::)" O (D aro
0 Onrtr_ W aft0m0 U2WW
(D0t-hmprt b' mW . rt rtFl-
W 0 m am (D (D sC: 0 " mQ
m Fes• U2 U2 H I-h ro a m U2 pj r- O rh
U2 a m m N. 1ti F1 Fl- rt n 1✓
mW �JElInrnrt FCoOaP. �:%
rt, pi tr'- ro O 0 m �l O W O a
� rt 0
m (D ort N•� nW0 (DD
w o o
(Drt•`� O
ci frt
rh mo (D rt
rt F'- O o ro m W
U2 rt n rt (D
• u2 �- m
w
rtz z � ro
0 0 o P)
rt 0 O
w % ro a �
Fl-
0 a
C2 F� �r W Fl-
Pi Fl- � mm
ro FJ- U2
W rh rt W
F G F-j• O H
w 0 1-c F-I
0a
Fj- rt rt
(n �5 O �r n
ro.L m W
W O I~
0 j (n
a H t-n
F'- F-' I-h 0 m
QE ° �
►C ¢' n O ~'
F-' F h
00 0 as
W rt (n
is F� n ()
a9 O
PL)Pi rt rt Fj• �
rt U2 Fj• rt m
m O rt (D
• (D 0
• m
hL