Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
MINUTES - 01172006 - D.5
Scanning Worksheet — CCC Clerk Of The Board Pallet number Box number Date processed Number of maps Large Format Non-scan able Prepped by IndeXing Information Form Type X11 In Date (YYYY,Ml7 DD) 940ko—() Hl .4genda Item 16. S Subject T Department 970 Q Description Indexed by Scanning Information Scanned by Page count Flatbed scanner Yes / No Number of Flatbed Scans: Folder Damage Item Name Description Auditing Information Audit performed by COB Scanning Worksheet Rev 2 �. i V � � � .. _ . oeenl�P IN THE MATTER OF RESOLUTION NO. 2006/15 REQUESTING THE GOVERNOR TO RECALL THE NATIONAL GUARD WHEREAS,the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors strongly supports the men and women of the United States Armed Forces serving both on native soil and around the world and recognizes the great sacrifice that each of them has made and is making on behalf of their country;and WHEREAS, the costs associated with the call-up of the California National Guard for deployment outside of our country have been significant in many ways;and WHEREAS, Californians have joined their state's National Guard believing that,in general and based upon customary practices, they would be serving their neighbors, communities and state by helping with California-based emergencies;and WHEREAS, there is reason to believe Shat federalization and deployment of National Guard troops have rendered the remaining National Guard force m Californias ableao carry out its state activities effectively; and WHEREAS, our nationas recent,experience withh-Hurricane Katrina .which lut Louisiana as a Category 4 hurricane on August 29;'2005, breached thesystem of levies designed to protectA Cityof New Orleans and killed approxirr Aely 1,300'people in"the,Southeastern United`Stafes.arid coscan;estimated$�70 to X130 billion in propert14damage caught u's off guard and not adequately prepared toy helpahe public in an emergency; and Ay WHEREAS,fsuch event left tens of thousands ofpeople stranded witliout adequate suppltes,`including food,water and clothing as well<as shelter, even though such eventgave authorities iricludih� the Federal Emergency Managemei%6�gency some time-to""prepare ahead of;time;and R WHEREAS,a significant part of the Louisiana-National"Guard was not able_to help its citizens and respond to the terrible destruction that struck the-area of-New Orleans because many-,of iMinembers had been deployed to 1_ x serve outside of the country;and ar r WHEREAS;"'Cahforrua is susceptible to a yanety,ofznatural disasters ucnth the potential of causing serious or catastropluc,d mage;tupon both people and property including floods,wildfires and earthquakes;and z ) a v WHEREAS,an e'arthquake''w l give no advanced_ warnuig or ability to prepare'd'ays or hours byefore it strikes;and WHEREAS, the approxinately 36"rnilliori the residents of State of California do not want to,be likewise caught off n N 1, guard,aswere so many people m6Louisiana and irt,dhe Southeastern<UiutedgStates, should a natural disaster of epic proportions�striki�our state.- f NOW,THEREFORE,I�BE'ITyRESOLVED, that the Contra Costa°Courity*Board`cf Supervisors call upon the Governor of Cal foci ia�to�erisure that the President and Congress'take.immediate steps to withdraw California National�'_Guzrd"troops servmg_outside-of the country as soon:;as possible;and FURTHER BE IT RESOLVED,.-that the Contra Costa County Board of'Supervisors send a copy of this Resolution to the Governor of California,the President=of`tlie United States,each member of the California :....,,. Congressional Delegation,the Speaker of the California State Assembly and the President Pro Tempore of the California State Senate. . J011N GIOIA Chair District I Supervisor ABSTAIN District GAYLE B.UILKEMA MARY N. PIEPHO District II Supervisor District III Supervisor ABSTAIN MARK DeSAULNIER FEDERAL D. GLOVER District IV Supervisor District V Supervisor fESDLkXT%04 V LO PVT 1 ASS I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of an action taken T0L.F_A_%& SEE ?kDV aN M and entered on the minutes of the Board of Supervisors on the date shown: e11'fL:S'IED: JANUARY 17,2006 JOHN SWEMEN, Clerk of the Board of Supervisors and County Admirustrator By� Deputy Introduced by Supervisor DeSaulmer, District IV ADDENDUM TO ITEM D.5 January 17, 2006 On this day, the Board of Supervisors considered adopting Resolution No. 2006/15 calling upon the Governor of California to ensure that the President and Congress take immediate steps to withdraw California National Guard troops serving outside of the country as soon as possible; and sending copies of the Resolution to specified government officials. Supervisor DeSaulnier introduced this item, noting that similar resolutions have been passed in Alameda and San Francisco Counties. Addressing those who would think that the Board cannot pass a resolution like this and still be supportive of the armed forces, he said he does see this as an opportunity to support the troops and be part of what makes this nation great—providing an opportunity for people to say their piece and to be part of the democratic process. To those who think the Board's priorities are to be focused on those things directly under its control, such as services and financial issues, lie said that historically it Inas often been local governments that have started movements of opposition. The Supervisor said lie thinks it is possible to respect the men and women in the armed services and still disagree with their deployment. Chair Gioia asked for public comment. The following people addressed the Board: • Honorable Karen Stepper, Mayor of Danville, speaking for herself as a citizen, urged the Board to withdraw the resolution as she is concerned it would be a strike at morale; • Councilmember Pete Lawrence, City of Clayton, urged the Board to focus on local, rather than national issues; • Thomas Del Beccaro,Republican Party of Contra Costa, said he thinks the resolution is divisive and that this is not the time or place for such a discussion; • Reverend Phil Lawson, Hercules resident, said that if we want to prevent violence in a comprehensive way,we must not support the use of violence as the solution to problems. He said this resolution speaks to the core of the need to make violence prevention a local priority; • Ken Hambrick, Walnut Creek resident, said the issue shouldn't be about discussing whether to bring the troops home, but about whether this is a concern the Board should be addressing; • Fran Curtis, Antioch resident, noted that the National Guard is trained for combat. He suggested the Board address instead the problems with our levees and our system of emergency response; • Michael Murray,Danville resident,discouraged the County from entering into foreign and military policy issues; • Suzanne Thompson, Alamo resident, said the resolution is a disgrace; • Dale Cook, speaking as a 46-year County resident and a combat veteran, said he opposes this resolution; • Michael Kerr, Bay Point resident, said the war is costing billions of dollars that could go toward funding all those programs that the opponents to this resolution are encouraging the Board to focus on; • Marilynne L.Mellander, El Sobrante resident, noted that she is a long-time Republican but is opposed to the President's actions regarding this war and she voiced support of the resolution; ADDENDUM TO ITEM D.S January 17, 2006 Page 2 of 4 • Susan Swift, El Sobrante resident, said the deployment of the National Guard is a form of a draft for a war that is not drawing enlistment otherwise; • Dan Helix, Concord resident, said the beneficiaries of this resolution would be the Islamic terrorists, and that this resolution would give AI-Qaeda a victory; • Alicia Watson, member of the All American Mom—Delta Nu Psi, said that the deployed National Guard members are good representatives of our country and encouraged supporting them; • William H. Harbin, Martinez resident, noted that the alternative to the National Guard deployment is the draft; • Kathleen Nimr, Martinez resident, spoke in support of the resolution and said that this war was not a response to a threat to national security; • John Baker,Lafayette resident,noted that the terrorists just want to outlast us, and this resolution sends the message to the troops that we no longer support them; • Mike Contelin, San Ramon resident, said that he is the father of two professional soldiers. He noted that the National Guard was not asked for input on this resolution; • Paula Dodd Aiello, San Ramon resident, noted that she was involved in the drafting of this resolution, and in finding a Supervisor to support this resolution. She expressed appreciation to Supervisor DeSaulnier; • Jack Beh-se-resht, Alamo resident, said he is opposed to the resolution; • Nancy Totman, Danville resident, said she thinks the resolution would weaken our Army and embolden the terrorists; • Al Martin, San Ramon resident, said that, speaking as a vet who has a soli who is an Arany Ranger, to pull the troops out now would spread our forces too thin. He said this is a decision best left to the Commander in Chief; • Kris Hunt, Contra Costa Taxpayers Association, said this matter is outside the purview of the Board of Supervisors and is a waste of time; • Tony Carnemolla,VFW Post 75, said an action like this would undermine morale; • John Goerl,Alamo resident, said that we must support our troops overseas. He said that the war in Vietnam was not lost in Asia, but was lost here in the United States. He said passage of this resolution would be doing the same thing; • R.Nathan Green,VFW Post 75, said he opposes the resolution; • Patricia Martin, San Ramon resident, said she is the mother of a vet, and that this kind of tiling undermines morale. She encouraged the polling of veterans groups and the National Guard to see if this resolution has support there; • Lee Halverson, Danville resident, said this is an ill-conceived resolution that would encourage the enemy and demoralize our serving sons and daughters; • Dick Seavey, San Ramon resident and member of the American Legion, recommended rejecting the resolution; • Kathleen Greene, Concord resident, said she does not feel it is disparaging patriotism to discuss the issue; 0 Samual Abbott, Danville resident, said that wars should be fought for the duration; ADDENDUM TO ITEM D.5 January 17, 2006 Page 3 of 4 • John Reese, Walnut Creek resident, said that as a Viet Nam veteran, he knows how it feels to get word that you are not supported back home. He urged the withdrawal of this resolution; • Mike Ketchel, Discovery Bay resident, noted that the Federal government cannot call on more than 50% of the National Guard in any given area, and that the Guard is only fulfilling its intended purpose; • Jack Weir, Pleasant Hill Taxpayers Association, said this is an inappropriate matter for this Board and urged the defeat of the resolution; • John Michael Heller, Danville resident, likened pulling troops out of the Middle East to pulling police out of West County and then hoping for a decreased crime rate; • Paul Morris,Vice Mayor of San Pablo speaking as a citizen, urged the withdrawal of the resolution; • Bob Hanson, Walnut Creek resident, encouraged bringing the National Guard home from an illegal and immoral war. He suggested that we are creating terrorism by occupying Iraq; • John Estes, Concord resident, said this resolution is tantamount to surrender, and suggested that the Supervisors should address national issues as individuals, and in their capacity as a Board should perform duties for Contra Costa County; and • Matthew Del Carlo, speaking for Assemblyman Guy Houston, urged a no vote on the resolution. The following people provided written comments to the Board: ■ Joan Bartulowich,EI Cerrito resident, in support of recalling the National Guard; ■ Donna Marvel, Danville resident,opposing the resolution; ■ Joan Lautenberger, Lafayette resident, in strong support of the resolution; ■ Gail Rodens, Martinez resident, in support of the resolution; ■ Ken and Barbara Norkus,Danville residents, in opposition to the resolution; ■ Gary Hess, opposed to the resolution; ■ Robert Taylor, City of Brentwood, opposed to the resolution; ■ Linda Gampper,encouraging the Board to allow the President to implement his plan; ■ William J. Conroy, Danville resident, opposed to the resolution; ■ Ben Johnson, Pittsburg resident, suggesting that this resolution does not show good judgement; ■ Stephen R. Sonaty, Esq., opposing the resolution; ■ Paul W. Clark, Danville Resident, opposed to the resolution; and ■ Sandy Gregory, urging the Board to vote against the resolution. Chair Gioia returned the matter to the Board. He noted that the time spent discussing this issue today does not mean that consideration time will be taken away from any other important issues. Supervisor DeSaulnier said he thinks this is what the Supervisors are elected to do; that these are the kinds of discussions that should be held, and that there should be a national debate about this war. He said ADDENDUM TO ITEM D.5 January 17, 2006 Page 4 of 4 such debate does not denigrate military service. He said at the essence of democracy is local government taking action. Supervisor Glover encouraged participants not.to challenge each others' patriotism when opinions differ in the discussion. He said that there have been instances when the Board has initiated leadership on national issues by showing what is important at the local level. He said that on this particular issue, he does not feel that the Board is well-enough informed,'and because of that concern cannot support approval of the resolution. He noted lie would be willing to do more research on the issue, and to hear the opinions of those who are better informed. Supervisor Uilkema noted her intention to abstain from those items that are not within the purview of the County's responsibilities. Supervisor Piepho said she would not support any action that would diminish the strength of the troops and the impact our nation is making on the world. She expressed opposition to the resolution, and thanked the vets for their service. Chair Gioia said that debates are important, and that he thinks the Board and the community are stronger for having had this debate. The Board of Supervisors took the following action: Supervisor DeSaulnier moved approval of Resolution No. 2006/15. Chair Gioia seconded the motion. The motion failed with Supervisors Uilkema and Glover abstaining and Supervisor Piepho recording a vote of opposition. Supervisor Glover suggested the Board should have policies in place that define what kind of issues the Board can address, and that this matter should be referred to the Internal Operations Committee for research. Supervisor Piepho asked if this would be a referral to discuss a policy on items that do or do not have any direct relationship to the Board of Supervisors or the business of the County. Supervisor Glover said yes. The Board of Supervisors took the following action: Supervisor Glover moved forwarding to the Internal Operations Committee the issue of looking at guidelines for the types of issues that come before the Board. Supervisor DeSaulnier seconded the motion. By a unanimous vote with none absent, the Board of Supervisors DIRECTED the Internal Operations Committee to return to the Board with research on the items that fall into the purview of the Board of Supervisors. 19255527308 01/17/2006 11: 24 19255527308 BARBARA NOR!<US PAGE 01 January 17, 2006 TO: Contra Costa Board of Supervisors From: Ken and Barbara Norkus/ Danville, CA 925.989.1748 res or fax 925.552.7308 We are asking the Board of Supervisors NOT TO SUPPORT Resolution D-5 which states: D-5 Consider adopting Resolution No. 2006/15 calling upon the Governor of California to insure that the President and Congress take immediate steps to withdraw California National Guard troops serving outside of the country as soon as possible; and sending copies of the Resolution to specified government officials. Again, my wife and I are asking the Board of Supervisors NOT TO SUPPORT Resolution D-5. Sincerely, Ke" Ken and Barbara Norkus Danville CA CONSIDER WITH 9 :49 am January 1 -7 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. GARY HESS GREATLY OPpOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 200 6/ 15 D . 5 CONSIDER WITH 10 : 18 am January 17, 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. ROBERT BOB TAYLOR CITY COUNCELLING CITY OF BRENTWOOD GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION- NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 coNsioEn WITH 9 : 49 am January 17, 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. GARY HESS GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . . 2006/ 15 D ., 5 • �4 <ccOfcontra.napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: 01/16/2006 08:51 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacom ments_form.ht m Username: Linda Gampper UserAddress: UserTel: UserEmail: mike_stoops@msn.com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1). Date: 16 Jan 2006 Time: 08:51:05 Comments I do not agree with the proposal to bring CA National Guard troops back from Iraq. The President has a plan and he should be allowed to implement i t. Stay the course. �4 <cc0@contra.napanet., To: <comments@ cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: Subject: Data posted to form 1 of 01/16/2006 02:16 PM' http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/caolagendacomments_form.ht m Username: William J Conroy UserAddress: 359 Del Amigo Rd, Danville UserTel: 925-838-2226 UserEmail: WConroyCPA@aol.com , AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected Agendaltem: D5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 .(compatible; MSIE 6.0; AOL 9.0; Windows, NT 5.1; SV1; NET CLR 1.1.4322) Date: 16 Jan 2006 'Time: 14:16:15 Comments: I oppose this resolution. It is the first obligation of the president to protect the citizens from those outside and those within who would' da us harm. Hassien and his government were, by their own statemnts, enemies if the US. Unlike most dictators, Irag had the resources to carry out its threat. A viable democracy is the best way to avoid such actions in the future. A democracy in Iraq could very well presage a turn-around of government in the 'Middle East. We have to be successful in .this. Our enemies are banking on our not having the fortitude to do what is needed. I hope none of our Supervisors are cut and run types. <=06contra.napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: Subject: Data posted to form 1 of 01/17/2006 04:52 AM http://www.c6.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: Edward F. Del Beccaro UserAddress: 55 San Gregorio Ct.. .Danville UserTel: 925-279-5565 UserEmail: edelbeccaro@colliersparrish.com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D 5 Remote Name: ' Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; NET CLR 1.1.4322) Date: 17 Jan 2006 Time: 04:52 :52 Comments: Re: Request to Governor. to recall State National Guard from Iraq Dear Supervisors, I read with astonishment the agenda item that the supervisors are considering asking the governor to recall the National Guard from Iraq. The county has many problems such as pension reform, budget deficits, crumbling infrastructure etc. Where on the agenda is discussion of .the grand jury report last year on the county pension problem? For the supervisors to consider as their first act of the year and one of the first acts -_of the new chair a political grandstanding act is irresponsible. The supervisors were elected to solve county problems and provide county services not create political theater. This smells of rank -opportunism. There is much work to do in the county. Let's get on with it. Ed Del Beccaro �1 <ccO@contra.napanet. To: <comm.ents@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: 01/17/2006 06:28 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of hnp://www;co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_fo rm.ht m Username: Ben Johnson UserAddress: 4314 Kingsly Dr Pittsburg UserTel: 925 432 6981 UserEmail: johnben3l@comcast.net AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D.5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP -User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5..1; NET CLR 1.1.4322; InfoPath.1) Date: 17 Jan 2006 Time: 06:28:43 Comments: County Board of Supervisors, If the County Supervisors approve this resolution today and sends this letter to the president they are not showing good judgment, as we do not need the total CA Nation Guard to support any problems within this state. We still have a large number of guard members still here if we need them. It is sending the wrong message to our other troops from other areas as it will become public media and transmitted to all the troops. When this happens it affects the moral of the troops and sends a negative message to them as well as sending •another type of message to the insurgents, to continue their bombing of .the Iraq people as well the other nations troops to continue our being needed there and it is all hyped by the media circus. I am asking as well that we not support this resolution D.5 and I ask that this be read at the Board of Supervisors meeting today. Ben Johnson Disabled Veteran JAN-17-2006 12 :48 PM P. 01 STEPHEN R. SONATY Attorneat Law Y P.O.BOX 6323 MORAGA,CA 94570-6323 TELEPHONE(925)917-5300 January 17,, 2006 FAXED Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors 601 Pine Street, 1' st Floor Martinez, CA 94553 RE: Opposition to the Resolution Requesting the Governor to Recall the National Guard To The Board of Supervisors : I write to express my intense opposition to the resolution today In The Matter of Requesting the Governor to Recall the National Guard. I was informed of the resolution this afternoon and have an appointment waiting, which prevents me from attending the meeting today or fully expressing my disgust for this resolution. This proves local elections are also important . Very truly yours, Step Sonaty, Esq. 7cJ O.J 1 OODU Jan 17 06 12: 32p KaJ Clark 925-837-8850 p. l sop SENA' VIA' FAX (925) 335-1913 To: The Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors From: Paul W. Clark, Danville Date: Tuesday, January 17. 2006 Subject: Resolution 2006/15 ( Item D5 on the Agenda for Today's Board Meeting) T am unalterably opposed to the passage of this resolution for the following reasons: 1. The Board has no Authority regarding the deployment of the California National Guard. i 2. Such a resolution is not supported by a plurality of the citizens of Contra Costa County. 3. It is not binding on anyone and only scarves to advance the political agenda of the Democrats elected to the board. l.just read today in the Contra Costa Times where the Board has seemingly succeeded in wasting some $800,000,on a planning study "Shaping Our Future." It seems to me that the board is derelict in its duty on this matter while wasting its time politicizing the; country's effort in the war on terror. Why don't you all settle down and manage the business of Contra Costa County and leave the management of. the State's MSOurccs to the Governor and the Country's to the President. Those of you who are proposing this resolution should be ashamed ol'your behavior. You arc acting.just like the Democrat's on the Judicary Committee; of the U S Senate. <cc0@contramapanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> . cc: 01/17/2006 09:20 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: Sandy Gregory UserAddress: 735 Winterside Circle UserTel: 925 830-8909 UserEmail: sandymayb@comcast.net AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D-5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; FunWebProducts; SV1; NET CLR 1.0.3705; NET CLR 1.1.4322; Media Center PC 2.8) Date: 17 Jan 2006 Time: 09:20:08 Comments: I urge Contra Costa County Supervisors to vote against Resolution D-5. This is a matter for those with the facts to decide. Passage of this Resolution would be on the basis of emotionalism, not intellectualism. Let us not presume, at the County level, that we have the facts necessary to demand a return of troops. - Sandy Gregory January 17, 2006 Dear Members of the Board, I strongly urge you to NOT support Resolution.D-5. Not only do I feel that it is inappropriate for the Board to consider a resolution regarding our national security, but it shows a lack of support for our soldiers and a rejection of the very values they uphold. Real support of the soldiers would be a resolution commending them for a job well done, for risking their lives to help the Iraqi people, and for serving our country and our country's interests. Sincerely, Barb Wilssi�4 TO/TO'd b092 T28 SEG 311InNUG-113MG-109 2,0:60 9002-LT-NU P092 T28 SZ6 i0'd 1tj101 January 17, 2006 Dear Members of the Board, I strongly urge you to NOT support Resolution D-5. Not only do I feel that it is inappropriate for the Board to consider a resolution regarding our national security, but it shows a lack of support for our soldiers and a rejection of the very.values they uphold. Real support of the soldiers would be a resolution commending therm for a job well done, for risking their lives to help the Iraqi people, and for serving our country and our country's interests. Sincerely, Barb Wils i0/i0'd b09L Z28 SZ6 311IONUG--113MG100 L0:60 900z-2,i-NUf V092 TS8 SZ6 TO•d ldlol ro,e' 1 Vol SAW January 17, 2006 Dear Members of the Board, I strongly urge you to NOT support Resolution D-5. Not only do I feel that it is inappropriate for the Board to consider a resolution regarding our national security, but it shows a lack of support for our soldiers and a rejection of the very values they uphold. Real support of the soldiers would be a resolution commending them for a job well done, for risking their lives to help the Iraqi people, and for serving our country and our country's interests. Sincerely, Barb Wils;SW4 T0iT0'd b09z T28 SEG 911InNUG--n3MG109 L0:60 9002-LT-NH!' P092 T28 SZ6 <cc0fcontra.napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> rE net> cc: Subject: Data posted to form 1 of 01/16/2006 08:51 AM http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: Linda Gampper UserAddress: UserTel: UserEmail: mike—stoops@msn.com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: selected AgendaItem: D5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1). Date: 16 Jan 2006 Time: 08:51:05 Comments: I do not agree with the proposal to bring CA National Guard troops back from Iraq. The President has a plan and he should be allowed to implement it. Stay the course. klz i:>* g000 <cc0@contra.napanet. To: <comments@ cob.cccou nty.us> net> cc: Subject: Data posted to form 1 of 01/16/2006 02:16 PM http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: William J Conroy UserAddress: 359 Del Amigo Rd, Danville UserTel: 925-838-2226 UserEmail: WConroyCPA@aol.com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; AOL 9.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; NET CLR 1.1.4322) Date: 16 Jan 2006 Time: 14:16:15 Comments: I oppose this resolution. It is the first obligation. of the president to protect the citizens from those outside and those within who would do us harm. Hassien and his government were, by their own statemnts, enemies if the US. Unlike most dictators, Irag had the resources to carry. out its threat. A viable democracy is the best way to avoid such actions in the future. - A democracy in Iraq could very well presage a turn-around of government in the Middle East. We have to be successful in this. Our enemies are banking on our not having the fortitude to. do what is needed. I hope none of our Supervisors are cut and run types. ,�.. ���. J <ccO@contra.napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: 01/17/2006 04:52 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: Edward F. Del Beccaro UserAddress: 55 San Gregorio Ct.. -Danville UserTel: 9251279-5565 UserEmail: edelbeccaro@colliersparrish.com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D 5 Remote Name: ' Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; . SV1; NET CLR 1.1.4322) Date: 17 Jan 2006 Time: 04:52:52 Comments- Re: omments:Re: Request to Governor to recall State National Guard from Iraq Dear Supervisors, I read with astonishment the agenda item that the supervisors are considering asking the governor to recall the National Guard from Iraq. The county has many problems such.as pension reform, budget deficits, crumbling infrastructure etc. Where on the agenda is discussion of -the grand jury report last year on the county pension problem? For the supervisors to consider as their first act of the year and one of the first acts of the new chair a political grandstanding act is irresponsible. .The supervisors were elected to solve county problems and provide county services not create political theater. This smells of' rank opportunism. There is much work to do in the county. Let's get on with it. Ed Del Beccaro �1 <cc0fcontra.napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: 01/17/2006 06:28 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: Ben Johnson UserAddress: 4314 Kingsly Dr Pittsburg UserTel: 925 432 6981 UserEmail: johnben3l@comcast.net AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D.5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP. User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; NET CLR 1.1.4322; InfoPath.1) _Date: - 17 Jan 2006 Time: 06:28:43 Comments:. County Board of Supervisors, If the County Supervisors approve this resolution today and sends this letter to the president they are not showing good judgment, as we do not need the total CA Nation Guard to support any problems within this state. We still have a large number of, guard members still here if we need them. It is sending the wrong message to our other troops from other areas as it will become public media and transmitted to all the troops. When this happens it affects the moral of the troops and sends a negative message to them as well as sending another type of message to the insurgents, to continue their bombing of the Iraq people as well the other nations troops to continue our being needed there and it is all hyped by the media circus. I am asking as well that we not support this resolution D.5 and I ask that this be read at the Board of Supervisors meeting today. Ben Johnson Disabled Veteran �,� �,.�__�� �� � t �p <ccO@contra.napanet. To: <comments@ cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: Subject: Data posted to form 1 of 01/17/2006 09:20 AM http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: Sandy Gregory UserAddress: 735 Winterside Circle UserTel': 925 830-8909 UserEmail: sandymayb@comcast.net AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D-5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; FunWebProducts; SV1; NET CLR 1.0.3705; NET CLR 1.1.4322; Media Center PC 2. 8) Date: 17 Jan 2006 Time: 09:20:08 Comments: I urge Contra Costa County Supervisors to vote against Resolution D-5. This is a matter for those with the facts to decide. Passage of this Resolution would be on the basis of emotionalism, not intellectualism. Let us not presume, at the County level, that we have. the facts necessary to demand a return of- troops. - Sandy Gregory JAN-17-2006 12 :48 PN P. 01 STEPHEN R. SONATY Attomey at Law P.O.BOX 6323 MORAGA,CA 94570-6323 TELEPHONE(925)917-5300 January 17, 2006 FAXED Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors 601 Pine Street, 1' st Floor Martinez, CA 94553 RE: Opposition to the Resolution Reque9ting the Governor to Recall the National Guard To The Board of Supervisors : I write to express my intense opposition to the resolution today In The Matter of Requesting the Governor to Recall the National Guard. I was informed of the resolution this afternoon and have an appointment waiting, which. prevents me from attending the meeting today or fully expressing my -disgust for this resolution. This proves local elections are also important . Very truly yours, Step Sonaty, Esq. 7�J �J iOO:JeJ Jan 17 06 12: 32p Kay Clark 925-837-8850 p, 1 O SENT VIA FAX (925) 335-1913 To: The Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors From: Paul W. Clark, Danville Date: Tuesday, January 17. 2006 Subject: Resolution 2006/15 ( Item D5 on the Agenda for Today's Board Meeting) 1 am unalterably opposed to the passage of this resolution for the following reasons: 1. The Board has no Authority regarding the deployment of the California National. Guard. t 2. Such a resolution is not supported by a plurality of the citizens of Contra Costa County. 3. It is not binding on ariyone and only serves to advance the political agenda of the Democrats elected to the board. 1 just read today in the Contra Costa Times where the Board has seemingly succcoded in wasting; some $800,000 on a planning study "Shaping Our Future." It seems to me that the board is derelict in its duty on,this matter while wasting its time politicizing the country's effort in the war on terror. Why don't you all settle down and manage the business of Contra Costa County and leave the management of the States resOurCCS to the Governor and the Country's to the President. Those of you who are proposing this resolution should be ashamed of your behavior. You are aeting.just like the Democrat's on the Judicary Committee of the U S Senate. <cc0fcontra,napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: 01/16/2006 08:51 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacom ments_form.ht m . Username: Linda Gampper UserAddress UserTel: UserEmail: mike_stoops@msn.com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1) Date: 16 Jan 2006 Time: 08:51:05 Comments: I do -not agree with the proposal- to bring CA National Guard troops back from Iraq. The President has a plan and he should be allowed to implement 1 t. Stay the course. <ccOftontra.napanet. To: <commen1s0cob.cccounty.u5> net> cc: Subject: Data posted to form 1 of 01/16/2006 02:16 PM http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments_form.ht m Username: William J Conroy UserAddress: 359 Del Amigo Rd, Danville UserTel: 925-838-2226 UserEmail: WConroyCPA@aol.com Ager_daDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected Agendaltem: D5 Remote Name: dMMMINAmMAwift Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6'.0; AOL 9.0; Windows NT 5.1; Sv1; NET CLR 1.1.4322) Date:. 16 Jan 2006 Time: 14:16:15 Comments: I oppose this resolution. It is the first obligation of the president to protect the citizens from those outside-and those within who would do us harm. Hassien and his government were, by their own statemnts, enemies .if the US. Unlike most dictators, Irag had the resources to carry out its threat. A viable democracy is the best way to avoid such actions in the future. A democracy in Iraq could very well presage a turn-around of government in the Middle East. We have to be successful in this. Our enemies are banking on our not having the fortitude to do what is needed. I ,hope none of our Supervisors are cut and run types. <cc0fcontra.napanet. To: <commentsOcob.cccounty.us> net> cc: Subject: Data-posted to form 1 of 01/17/2006 04:52 AM http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacomments form.ht m Username: Edward F. Del Beccaro UserAddress: 55. San Gregorio Ct.. .Danville UserTel: 925-279-5565 UserEmail: edelbeccaro@colliersparrish._com AgendaDate: 01/17/06 Option: Selected AgendaItem: D 5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; . SV1; NET CLR .1.1.-4322) Date: 17 Jan 2006 Time: 04:52 :52 Comments: Re: Request to Governor to recall State National 'Guard from Iraq bear Supervisors, I read with astonishment the agenda item that the supervisors are considering asking the governor to recall the National Guard from Iraq. The county has many problems such as pension reform, budget deficits, crumbling infrastructure etc. Where on the agenda is discussion of .the grand jury report' last year on the county pension problem? For the supervisors to consider as their first act of the year and one of the first acts of the new chair a political grandstanding act is irresponsible. The supervisors were elected to solve county problems and provide county services not create political theater. This smells of rank opportunism. There is much work to do in the county. Let's get on with it. Ed Del Beccaro <ccO@contra.napanet. To: <comments@cob.cccounty.us> net> cc: 01/17/2006 06:28 AM Subject: Data posted to form 1 of http://www.co.contra-costa.ca.us/depart/cao/agendacom ments_fo rm.ht m Username: Ben Johnson UserAddress: 4314 Kingsly Dr Pittsburg UserTel: 925 432 6981 UserEmail: johnben3l@comcast.net AgendaDate .01/17/06 Option: Selected Agendaltem: D.5 Remote Name: Remote User: HTTP.-User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; NET CLR 1.1.4322; InfoPath.1) Date:. 17 Jan 2006 Time: 06:28:43 Comments: County Board of Supervisors, If the County Supervisors approve this resolution today and sends this letter, to the president .they are not showing good judgment, as we do not need the total CA Nation Guard to support any problems within this state. We still have a large number. of guard members still here if we need them. It is sending the wrong message to our other troops from other areas as it will become public media and transmitted to all the troops. When this happens it affects the moral of the troops and sends a negative message to them as well as sending another type of message to -the insurgents, to continue their bombing of the Iraq people as well the other nations troops to continue our being needed there and it is all hyped by the media circus. I am asking as well that we not support this resolution D:5 and I ask that this be read at the Board of Supervisors meeting today. Ben Johnson Disabled Veteran i0•d 1tj101 too, � January 17, 2006 Dear Members of the Board, I strongly urge you to NOT support Resolution D-5. Not only do 1 feel that it is inappropriate for the Board to consider a resolution regarding our national security, but it shows a lack of support for our soldiers and a rejection of the very values they uphold. Real support of the soldiers would be a resolution commending therm for a job well done, for risking their lives to help the Iraqi people, and for serving our country and our. country's interests, Sincerely, 1 Barb Wils Z0/ZO•d 6092 T2e SZ6 3-n I nNUG-113MG100 2,0:60 9002-Lti-IJtif,. P092 T2e Sz6 i d 4 i rIi r � /1 r i v F` � � r .r Nn i� va -0 G oA y, Q40 y N � - c 0 m O N C W 7 N m o E a `cam -a cT �6 -0 p m Co � W o o a 0 f u05 . ..i CL U �J o � Cy pCD 0 G tt=.�- 16L0 = 0 co D U ai E E w M co . N Lo ° CD, Ln ..e CA O G, N O - CD, CD CD CD CD O ... CD N (D O to OO N o ':�v ca o 5. CD CD C1 m UCD ) ° O c0 Com ' 0) N N CD o o CD °0. O o _ t::;; Qa ZD O a CD CD N N Z N o N ,"*N N O. CND S N. � ',CD � CD Q^ •fir,,. @+ O � m O cOd 0• N CND O 0 CD N N N ° ( . O CD m °IP CD 5. o n -, CD ° off- No CD `° . . >..N 3 ° a- N D s G _ . r, cv 6m ID 0 CD CD OD 0 d CD N CD N � CD } L: 03 m ^ o� c � (1) O �� d -Crf� ❑ Q I f as v — Lo �o 0 IL co w +. E �) { c o o °0 El 0 Ct U ai zf I- CA w X 3 T ~ CD X a N z > it► ct3 p � a� i M RS O c t- CO a o 0 cn w N N .�. w w o c ct �- ,� -0 C1 = a� 21 5 > W H a E �' o tY ._., .c � p � Q rn r1 co r_ a r E a) a U) cu � 4iW c o CL cz o3: 6Y U a) N U � E _❑ ❑ z j N 103 0O � fl N N �L CD o -13 0 3. � 0). N 6 oro. N Cp -., = CD G CD O CD 7 �-+O i- "d CD. CD01 h CD CD 0 o) O CD CD CCD N70 CD p CD - m 'm 3. o o N Z m CD0 14 -n w '" �° a 0 w @ p CD I 0,b tr o m q 0 -- -,P- ,:t o o N . CO — N o 9� N co n O 0 d CD .G CD °'� o (P o c �° 3 m w 3 m CD °- m (P 0 i CD0 N 0 ni 0- to C o CT CD •G O N CD UN @ O 6 T; p 0 O CSD CD �. ¢ : CD . CD 41 � '-r CD ccs o ., O 0 z CO n 0 O ID ` o � 'CScu' � G � CL x u� -C C E o 0 CO O v N °n W to I Aco o T � T OR� co # 0 0 ul C �h, Q U, L N r:. O co —14 N u> v N O O�- ta co U J y � O Q cs� to p� o N N r. CD 7z, @ G ,�- CD CD CD %D 0 N ' CD (D cQ - C1 m iD � m cu 3 . °x Oo g� O CCD N X � ° o �, o F o Q N 2 & D �' �' co O CD O N N Sv N O` CO CD O- %. Sy G oter` CD © om o m CDN o o CD ci O C� CD 7 O @ p1 O3 0 - d N O G o rn CD o cD tU o n O 3. Q N N G N .�L N O O S CD O. - CD N D O Nw CD� O N O 9� CD NCD N cD � N t0 r+- CD o. U (" N O CIS CDM O \ 1�i- m E N � � „ �•,- Q � O o � Q0co ° ZZ S4 ' o L t V N c 1L !j O N L Q N O Q O v � N f" N C1 U En N D t(5 ID Q. N roc � to 7' 0a N 4 N Q �•. U O0 O cd l m GCO N 'd O '3; us �o 0 •� N �� N � Q 0 2 , v N x> U) 0 a 0 00 -o Cr {D CCD �1.- p 5 0 a. to tL N r* 0sv, N is o- CD CD N to O O CD N CD �% CD ':$ Op CD VDSN CD �,G 7 r+ tD CD O CD C7 O CD OCD o CD °0 0- va 0 CD CD 0 -;5 N O CD C � Q . �0 � CD 1p �, � m cs� oo @ o CrN to (0 to tU � (D C) O O CD 7 p O ,Np p n CD LU CD 0CD tc G i- i- a. N 13 -� -+ qx O O O CD Q p r+ •L CSD O to Cr N p N CSD (P CD �_ M tS �. O OCCD CS �tz 0 G, O O CD N tL. � N CD AT CD i. J l CO G C t4 CD t3 Y co o - ti O F- S N 1 n�Lo a F p Co N t�II L G � O C 8 �. F- v o c r N o 0 �Z v W m o _ Q i mo cG': c4 Cn G4 110- 0 3 N O O as %- 9 m CL N O O y N O C Off ' ,? .. 0 .G O CO U O cnc c _ Z Q a... CL j, N " 03 Oil. N N t%. �G O O CD , N �.N.. coCD G _ Cowm CD CO - n �!" CO CD CDCD CD 9 Co OIL3 CD cz cs 3, o m N T . c�tZ m 0,cOn 4- ' N NO { N f ° CO N g. coIS —t N m CD CD CD a ' Qy O CD N ON N m LD N G "� :L C^p n ° 0 "O CD QD Ocecn 0- 3 r" CD o 1.0 �N' G cOCa . cn I CD O ((DDsr ID O N cD N O . O CD �+. Q NN CO A� tD CD G GO tl. Dm CD �" c � o •�j N c � Car �72 co N W m p 3 9 m 11! 1✓ 9 ��_ NGs N 4 Q v p m T °)y N p Cf CO -UU' UN m c Z �O N Ln N •N � m U � V ' Q t N '© CD ., O 0 N O 10 C3- N rn mss . Z NO 1 O N O O O (D .a+ n' 7` N 0 �. CD@ N N 0, 0 Nr O N O O� CD S � p CD N nCD , N 0 O 2 m � a tv+ p o �=� (D "t o10O Q a CD 0 'Z O- N N CD 0 01 N sv O. cn � o cn . .•� � ID_ N CD O -Q N 'fl -0 CD p m «�*N (PCDQ' O N ^ x CD .-+ CD 0 CD Su G R1 CD p CD .G N CD,, N -O N NA �. (�CD oz:r-- O Nd t Cl) N g O O (D 3 CO 00 CD o o � � f0 �, N @ O N CD N --AN � O CD N Q CD CD 0- 0 ct] (D N N O W . '-r .-r CD L.- WE N � d U o 0 co CD CD co U- rn , _ ❑ L o. `° C o a QL o � O U m tl. t? `= sa. cn � � No 0 LL _3 o N LLi ~ a� o NZ co B 1 o 0 05 N m N -00 O N Ul ul co Hca O N U � ul O ) O � (Y 3 co CL ` cn oWo N N N o,@ O p 0 G O m = }C Z N 3 c 0 '3: N N = N Ul ❑ a. � v` co" coT. 0 Q CL Z N • 4 D CA (':I-G N. N CD,Np �' 0 (o. N CD G CD %ti 's CD O 73CD I D% CD CD n N G N 5. CD G 5. O to ty tQ CD cpfl fl � o,G O CD �, NCD p tD os �, � Ste• � � � .� CD CD 0 9► SU CD p ' 4G CD 5 O N ty CD 3 .4 NCD N Q � o cam, Gt p cn .. �! to ro O N 'b N 3 m NCD CSD CD N C ^s �' CD CD N 14 N N N CD 0 N c0 p . p� n -00 O .� 3 O N p SCD C 4) N 4t o .Gm a 0 3 vi CSD is p ui CD N CD CD ti CD O O�. O N CD tip 0- 0 CD N tb N CD .Q o a � fl -ems c 0 o� p � �, fl 0 V ..► 7 vl- o L OY O o� O O v m V 3� .00- 00- 0 G '4"�" � v •r O � N U o N N N ¢ 4 v c N O G GN a o 14- cc, N oo 0 No ` th a� iii ca V .. a CL 0 2 V 1 t(31 ^ CA OO- C N• N t N � NOG CD CD @� N r' o O f' O O, O tD N G O CD CD N -IrN N O CD CD CDCD O ., O O .-� 0 � .:5 � O N Q^ O CD N •G N �Or* 10'. O O 'z (D CD Oa d Cep . O iN Q Gy N �Z 0 0 w CD O N �� O SCD 0 N -b O O N NQ CD N `xO - ON G R1 -ti •-' CD CD N o CD .4 N Cr N -o @ 'QD N Q;, o 1� � o o� c ^ C 0 10 sz3 ° .QD CD �� ^ O -O CD -,n, CD 0 No rn 0- N -* ... 3 3 O O ;:;_r c -c 4 C N CD p N CD iN 0 (D4. O 0O. Q O^ 0 CD (D Cts N CD N CD. N N .-r .-f AVl C-1 v LT 0 01 -0 0 va t6 0 0 -11 *0 0 ,2 co co (1) (Z cn a) 46 -4s 'o e Ul >1 co a) co 'E `� o � � N a' .100 —CL co '77 (D 0 may, p„tff C.) COD Ln 133 0 0 -;3 C-1 un O CD CD 4 CD ID ID cr OD 4 s)) 0 0 t,:r CD CD CD % 5� (P CD 0114 0 CD CD CD 11 CD CD 5 7-% 6 s , 9) 3,): 06 9) S ED oN 14 CD Ive- , o (D ol CD CD CD I'm Im CD 14 to, SCD ol % . CD 0 CD S 'p- CO CD -;5, CD CD 510 -% Op :y CD 1. (,D CD 0 CD lar CD = 14 CD 0 CD 0 N 0 CD CDp. 0 CD 0 CD :3 Lo 90 S. 0- (P 0 0 CD 0 0 I'D0 CD CD '4 - -0 CD -% CT -t. p 14D CD 0 M 0 , -* 0 0- 0 CD N CD w- o .O O G N J � V •Q � O � � o m '� t6 ro Q O m om CDo m N n 0 o p 3 o o co N (13 � ~ C 7 to V CD L- Q W _N o O 0 O r CL U N LS O T N co ' cd tY G N w. � Sl C6 N N o.. co O V v' 14 Nco 7, tll�, N 4 d - C N O G O O co O 2 N 'O Q a a ., p cA c;o N a DS N tll � mm t6 V a E o CD o Z U (3) Ui .p W N -� 0 (�D 3_ N c C to Q- C O "D (D � p• (D C N O CD `G 7C; - An a fn O = (D O :.3..w (D Cr 3 = (D rr O G (n, NiT (D 3 (D -o �(D W (D Q c (~D (D U) CD(CD ta- j O .-r O n o p CDCD - ,c o0 v 3 3 O o v CDD (D Nct 0 Q- C 0 a Q o � ° o o cn c m -� cn (n (D (n O Oi 3 D O CD z 7 O (D '' � 0N -n CD (D ;:t cn O` co CL 7c O CD CD O tD 70 .2+ =r to CD � -1-0, w 0 _D N p (n m O O cn 4, O. cn �' .O `G (D C �. , ° (o 0 cn -3 m � cn �. c (D (D X Co o 3 v -+, N CD o a CD o '� (n �' 0 s Q : 3 v, c CD v v 3 IM CL 3 CD� CD CD cr v. h Q CD (D w I O CD m p -a v (D -9 �- 14. (D ° 3 cQ ° a o CD CD (D -ti +-- C. p O _ (D "* O p = _ ' ^* �_ (D (OD 3 (D sz v Iwo _ i o v rCD Eco N aCL fl o ` omaco ca � CD m N CD d t� �W o 0� v In c m CO N co � co (1) CL �Ca D �✓ N v y 0 ^t W W � J UD = N 0 \V �l p C N c 0 N V ca (D D �,. N C 4i N 1� V Z 4 c'' N • 4 L' � .c oCD o :3 -0 tP i CD. CCDD U N, C5� (P. . t3 cid. Cp f O "O -Co �. A� 4U. N a OD CD CD CD @ ts1 Q f O ct> CD CSDCD r� 6 0 O S rr CD N S 7 a N 0 CD cD 3 14 0- o y o o . 0 3 m 0 ¢ m o- CD N Z �- CD m3. . ° CD .r . . 0 0 �� is @ . co ins N N � m o cD � m C m �� CD w CD (D 3 �i o m N t5 N O G O NOS @ n -0 CD � `G M.a pO O � % Oma•Q.. NCD O c� N m ° °v a � m CD 7 4 m a o 3 c� CD p n tD -� CD CD �• �. o 6 0- 0 0 CD N co i1? CD S CD c! � U N Y CD E co CD a O p � o dY c O O a cpn m a r- ca COOca caO a NW x pL N N cs O O .✓ S S� a Z o nSJ v N o G j O+p O .0.1 N OD o- co, N S � U E 'C3 amu. '' j: N' .O Q W -dD Ul -t Q1 C �, N CD CD on 6) 'Nd ¢� l� cC1. G z M N (•, cD CD cr c� 1 O 6 N,,, O O CD @ CD . tD G ,,G O n � o � � . o s� m . .. CDCD go m • Z3 m. O O• Q ' N Nta CD m 3 co m .:4 N p p to- G, N y. ��• m CO y 4=.CD NO CD CD G N o 4 ,� O m ca is -CD m co � �. 0 0 CD 40 o: N 6 N -,• @ a -.-1 O O (P O O O O (t) to (P Sy cD N O A 'fid (D 9,1_ 0 ' N �+ O D, n -O -a -A S 70 CD 4s 4 N O ._ (0 'OtD 7 N tocr O T N `G 7 N (D N cQ CD. `d 6 p o {' p o 5 CD N c0 U� CD co o .01 CL o m o 1 CD4- � a ,..�✓ 'C i. _ ► O No GCL o O o o y N INA .- �- u N � N d N to I o N N. a G O O CC) CD _ G N c0 CL o a � d G o G �u OM O t0. N tU d a0 t°1n U a N T Q N (011 -2 t44T@o N �i X o= til N Zj D V ' m V N ' W � 4 P6 o -C o (D OD te N -0-a sv to• =; p -° @3_. moo•P CD a . CD 5 -,, G N O -d cs� N to CD m N CDo,� prls O O tD o.sv (� coo opy 2 O N %c 0 . 0' tD 0 0) 't1 3 -3 � -:$.CD N N N 0 I -0. 5 O o CD �- m N cr 2 W n ..� -4 (D @ T p � � c `a o n CD (D 7Q O• N O @ � Cy -% �+ G �' U cz p OO 0 0 CD � a N (0 N G O t) OO C CD N O N N p -p 'O tD W ?� 3 1 COD c 31 10 CD cr .eD- CD o �� N cn (D tr v' m � � N m N CD m CD`- D G (D, O tS (p a 0 (D co N N CD N CD 3 CD LJ N co L) 0 10 CD -0 0 0 co co o LL- W F- 0 co V) co E 0 E 0 U- 13) ll 10 o(n- M o to 0 c! to -0 0 co co 0 al U3 Ww 0 p 0) 46 zr CD 0 0 6- 0 -0 co =5 ul sA 0 cc CLC) W (D w lk 0 0 'mI"- W U) ami N 0- 46 0 (1) 10 0 0 0 10 0) ul o 0U N 0 n 13 C) m Q) M co 0 1 CL � LO o O. N �G N CD N cr a N. oa f m m _ CD N (D O coo or `+ Lo O NCt (D e' 0. 0 �- 'd t!?• CDCD L1 co CD 0 n CD CD rr SU N 4i � 1 -• O � N. Q ', O O_ N Oco sv 0 co '- D m 3 o a u N 2 CD CD co _.r, 0 NNO .d O m mCD cD CD N -q 7 0c (P ) -0 O O @ � LO s, o 0 � (D CD CD Da 0 M. n3 0 ° 0m 3 CD -., - -+ CD o- ctl m CD ICD N m N � 0 N N N ca ?� � Su O S� G , O tS d O O " CDCD CD Ly CD r+ CD Q r "t3 � N � O Q o co Q . m C� Q `o CD co Izz co aj N O co o i 4- C 'a co 1 a (D s 1 �1 N c �' d o CO v G v O Q N Z N Cco N N 'n Cn N N 111 U1 N cam U ?► CC 111N, 9 CD = N N �s — Nc CL. r— Q o Q G N �— O O O u O co NN 0 co O � a 06- 3 1 N � G O CO m 0) 111 N -Op lui to Cl) E T. 0 .0 C15 co o U N o D O C3� CD CDD N Gn N4 'O (D N CD CD � � N coo o CD -� c rn 0 N ..p tSl. (D � O- � -� 4 O CD CD � N O O CD C-) CD D .5 O 6 -501, C 1 r+ 0 O O O Z O (D 7•N N N.. ,.� tD �G O p �y LSU N (D a N -O .r ;. .4 N CD O N \1 .� D O N 'd CY 3 P -d-� CD N O (n NO N �'f N c0 p- �.� D] G m O CD cfir- CCD N N(D 14 N N N CD C N fl;. O 0 Q11.cr N CO G 0 C7 O n 'CS CD O M.N 9% O dp NO O G1 O N 3 CD 0 �N � NCD O 7-. OLS.. `2. N . ..G N m s (D 60 � � o N m N Ncx0 O -O 6 i, OG. O t0 CD (S1 N CD N C0 N OJ CD O CL t4 m m O �'.. Q) cD E ti- CD ; t ✓' o l N a) E Hca c O 0 v coo t v 9 to .CD Ck- Z > cco +. N v� coo °� o N D D as �C9 s G d O T a - o et1 (D 1 o- Wi D a 3 CA t1 o N cn0 co a - C E o 0 0 - m O ✓ �y L w m ...-o 'dud CD 03 U N . U) 0 0 � cr CD C1 G a N m Nr;• CD coLn CD w � 4 It O� CDCD N 9, Nm m o (o o- o � m ;:r CD N o� O CD CD �. G fi N cr ) CD ^ O 0 o v'i CD O 5 o o CA ., O .-. �• a CO �Z N CD �O- (D N iZ N 3• p N 'O 4 CD (D t cII � (R -, Sy ;�*'. N �+ D O N O p N N4 NgoN CD Ci CD. CD O � - � N N .. CD � o o m 1.4 N 6 N @ O �. O O CD 0 G o OCs (P CD 0 � CD � '4 ,fi � S o o -0 m3 � o N 3 0 CD a N 3 3 cn CD N N CD N N N ct2 � N O N CD �' W CD CD O 0 CD 0 Nco 'o 0 0 s (D %0 (D S-- 0 j= 01 0 Cf) -0 27 0 0 0 CIO CSI (f) -�0 -0 co -; -0 D 0 Ln \ 0 nS t1 43) -0.1 O.0 tp N N 1p ID tn 1E CL 00 0 CD UxCA 0 0 (P to CD (D o.. C- CD CD 4 CD — CD Or CD CD CD C) Q) CD �kM 0). W CD 0 (P CD Ott CD 0 CD CD 0 W (D CD 0 CD C) co 0 c,-- -n 0, 0 0 (D %D 0 14 QD 0 0 o 0 CD 0 -0 CD CD �a 0�- --% AL1 LT 0, CD CD 0 0 1 14 (D Z5 (P CD 0 iLp 'C<D 0 ol co CD 0 (P 0 (P —. CD I:r CD CO 0 LD CD CD 0 7 co s 0 0 0"- 1 C: CD 0 g �3 (P to (P iD —CD - O' o 0 C) 0 CD 0 DO CD 'e- CD 14 0 .0 CO tl CD 14 0 -,xz (P tQ CD ---r-0 &I o CD CD to CD (P (D CD CD p .p -o N N � � U O CL "� o -o co o m CD , CD p p) ca m U C1 co LLl `U) N .r al Zn In U N -a dZ x �'� N c c o 0 N f O c3 p m T O. N 0 0c N O G p m O N 'CS N o N 'D N ai m U ca U -aY Q- � Z U N P W d 7 D O LP CD (�9 0- G �' N. CD CD N U tf CD O- N n � •�.G O � �� N. C� � ; CDco N OG G O o . N� CD CSD -� N CD �,G a cD pr' O O ., a Z LO 3 K OS � Q o N O O CD CD (D 0) �c CD L4 ,� O a o �' m3 = o °' s r' CD a CD cn 2 3. 5 -S. o N -a .� co CD, Sp N O � •G N '� 5 k CD SU � ' CD O� -% m :-+ ,ti . N 44.1 .0 O O O CD N N� a ay N m p -, .�- 'CD o N CD N O �` CD O 14 to N Ilk 0.c N a q1 O L N to CD Ci O O CD 7 0 00 0 ' O 0 OCD 0 S N O 0 �. t0 @ 00 N o Us CD Cr 'tl*4 O N Ry (tN CD!CD. CD 0, 4 ID CSD tt1 � 0- N � N CD CD N CD OR U K IS CD CD V o 9. N o i 9 srl Y 7 c W 751A, c3 Q v N (D O O Y ,r v • •. m E d' U ', CL p N U- >,o Its U mco c 2 o;o a , UR c N 1y •O N� o �C V o o @ @ tD O cn CD D� CSD CDD =i to N r+ N p j @ o (o Q O � � MCD -r � S11 � � }OC .� f• Z oa o 70 (D v A 3 0- 0 0 iD N o -0 Z CD � a w -n @ 7d _ to o ccn to N O --1 N . N N --�. O H. @ n o (a N C CD (D � N cs -- a v @ @ a- m o o o o o CL cn 3 cn CD CD Cb @ � o o N Comcn , w cp 0- 0 O O N., N @ @ Oma cD , o V OR m oCD p o CD � o � by o Cil � co CL co O F O s N A !. ) o ii N N i 1 4j) E cv N ? � co `� L 0 :2 cQn U) dy N cU 0 co UUl w coco W L o M co s� OG�' L 0 a. 4 q m G O O �7 Z5 4— p ' U) U co ti` 1/) o co T N 4 o 0 0 G = m 07 111 L N 'O w C:co m o S4- a 1] ul Q NU X 0 0 co U Z N ' `'' d ,( o @ 03 J:) G N o fi@ @ ¢ r, N 'C3 to @ N f. CD 9L CD % CD � �. D S) CD ' 0 CD CD N O,,,G OD O CD N 0 O @ N O O d0 2 0 N O@CD @ CD O D .- OCD11 CD N CD N �r* @ CD O -� v N m N a O� N N @NN O ++ C�- N 9 , G D 0 N Lo N 0 @ O ty (D 14. O O � O a 3 @ �+ NCD O @ID 3 � oN c � ' O Cl. N p @ . 3 Cn CD N O N @ N CD d CD O p @CD CD 0 4 O @ @ N CD N 'r CD � to r-r CD V.1 N �~ CD a co i O Q 43) _Y a� y a o CL r CO to # °v 0 N 9 9 a 0� a CL U > 07 N sy � �' Q N �l C O .100� O � � A� tO .✓ � 27 m .0 Z. 1 j N ' / W 00 O CD CD cr t -a t015 CD y �.S' 'COD G CD iv D N (D cOII 6 .+ O CD T ID CD C} =' tD co s 1.1,11 G m N n fir+ tD ^` O t5 o 0 3 y CD tD m� n a c O 'A CD3. -° o ' -x CD ,.c sy u ca o a CD N ;� � 3. su .n 3 c@n m' m -n o 0, cn ox O to CD 0 (P PtZ ICD � 3 m o. CD o-0- m `m O N motD @ N O m ° cn 6 N cv= N O C ma CD o m v 0 3 0 o c o 3 *A m -,• -, o 0- D 0 tiZ 7 Sv CD O CD CD cz c�0 N tjr t1 O CDN W CD co �v v i y G S�l 0 C1. O. O E p CD p 0 co tt5 s0) ul .r► t 4 Q � 4 � O N co 4 0 ,5 NZ � c � v. o a m x:. c� O •— m ( c > rCO aD co p o 5 m W CL r 'a.3 N N d G CL O co O m T N CL N tom] G °Cd l N t3 i v G 141- O 3 �' En N N .... co a � � _ v 0 N a -oUA o O O (p CD 4 CD7 r+ CQ (::r (DD n CoN O 0) � mN m �, m CD CD O CCD O S �'" N N r* N O N CorD o fi @ =� % O t3 -" O O (0 t0 W -s O co 3• �*` CD m 'OCR 'A 0 o W O N !d -, O- N N N N O CSD -+ Lr'U ? N C m 0 --% 5 CD oCD G N d N C-D+ N fi N O O� C 4� tD �' ..G N � N ?, O rnros 0 C- cv l- coo o -oo NCD CDD , � N N N CDCD Co (gyp�' C� �, �' O p CD cr � �..• 0 O N co t0 N CD (D p� N r,- r,- t , \ t- a� o X, ..O 1 10- .01 O 'Ta CS C) m �} - o CD o Y c� CD C" rrJ� c0 c9 O � N 0011- cE % o !� CO O y-- Q '� SLR. U N v T `..�• tD CO Q off. c4 N ..s p N_ 7 W N *01 1 1 vs G co m J N cU °' It2 CS. • C.� �t t N � � ' V:.. W -d 0o CD CD CD G p:N oCD -o -' 3 CD 4, N u o-N' tD CD %DoCD CD ; TD o cnLO -, G -ACD � G O� Q � D co tp C m rn nCD 0 O p (D. cn ? O -�► o A Q CD Q N N tAO CD CD O C') cf1.-r = -A N G , N La, CD O N 3 ro o (D -v coo o- �. co oCD c� ter, 1 CD CD -01 CD cr CD 3 N o Q� m O U1 to N N. CD t N Q n -p CDCD ID Q �� 0O fl ^ o -° 3 a o cDCD a 0 m cfl 1 -0 d CD O O CL is O r cn CSD 0"CD CD 6 cr � �G (D+ O 0-✓: CD CD. h CD ,t+ } 1 oOo N c V a d p a cC N t- CD ` CD tia {C)� N y0 o O O Cs. o 0 co N N cn ti o G N C L v CD s L r- 4 .0 3 �- 4 0`L N N 3 1 0 co G ` V O SO 4. U .r O co N y t0 0 . T N O c s N O G = n p O y O N Cao p V 0 Q y N NC-- m CD QI °' Z ,- 0 2. C.� N ' a -4 � Cr O cn tDo O f o,. o CD a N. CD CSD N CCD O CD fi (D •- �¢ CY 7 IL CSD :37CD p OCD CD CD a O � � O N. UD o i COD cY rn O ' 0-1 CD o' o cfl�,•� o N CD�•� CD O ,� to o N tv -0 I,, CD -� v. N CD @CD Ck- 3 a N o �CD cD o �' N LO to U^ CD .+ t7 O C�. CD .,! O NCD Q CD, to LO 0.. _. co �' c� cr to tD N O ff+ N f O ID 41 O N tp op 'I c�D css a ' CD N cv CD cD - i It . l 4 iv •O � a O o a d1 C� i o CD m o t tII 1 N N p a O o N � co C� G r L U N ts, LnCLp 7 V► CL v O O I i ce)O r rn N G W tJ1 � m E aco % OG W V--' o� a "a V- m o O O �. as o = a L ca 1 cc m T (U N � U a G oG O , co , ca O O � Z, us O N aj cn () Z a v (D od CL v Z �t 1 t W oo (31CD D o- o-N o `n 3. 0) d (p 3 CD ,t co CD Q 6 w ; CD ,+ N O D N G to CDD O(DD CD Q-h` 0 " C (D 3 o f o su = CD o. 0 Q- CD T63• a ° 2 o a 0 (nCD O �Q v CD co t CD (D Cl- O (D (D �. CD CD S O O r" (D m t ` CD D p -z "d -:3 4?,. CD �at N O -, O N (¢ .• N 9) ? (D CSD O n t7 (D j �G �. N 4` Q -C3 N t O 'O , 3 N r° O py p Q 0 tp 3 3 a c� o tr CD o p i, v, m m � . o � Cw CD ? ° � CD cD '•v t0 � 6 �, �• o �. sv N co 1 1 r_ o CD , 0 CD s CD cco v OL W 6. _ N td ✓ G '� o O Gvy Qi CL G In N T � ca ;� m y CD N� ON) V It m Z L) t ' t N w 00 .G O @ O O N O G .. CD tD �. `L @ CD SD CD CD CD m NW, Cl @ O00 cl, O o 3 ? a -v @ t cs. cs c'o 3. ° m% co acv 0 o cor, `� N CD 01 . t1 7 @tT CD CD ` (DDD CD O _ N t�fl CD O O 3 d CO O N „C �. .L @ per, O Q i G � O (" (D N @ N � � Nom^ CD cs1 0- 0 CDN co m . W 0 CD 0 W CL Ln c Cf) 0) CL ;4 co .01 13) 0 —co .0, (3) -a CO r4 0 m 0 4v ul wo co 'M 46 0 -0 CL 151, 0 G S7- co 0 co UD UD ) 0 .01 00 0 051 - N CL IDa Co — 0 , 6 Na U) UD 00 4 O C3� (D CD Oq' O� N � m � -C, 3 � 'a N CD �• °pro . � 3 `51 Z � � CD n u %D � o CD-N+n O CD ON OG _ , tO '¢ 0- T NN � O C) r+- CD @ X CD CCDDO e- O �. -CDO N N O Q s i CD C7 0- N N 2 m 3 -� cD m Q? CD O rG N CD O O �� r, OCDLo `z Cu OCl N •� G " m 't7 (D0. NN 4- fir+ CD G n1 'N le N N to N CD OCD O Cs '� O 0 to C's ' O � ^ d r� (�D -+,O. CD fl N o ) CD CD CD 110et o o c0 6 Cf tz C 1 3 CD N CD Lo CD ? d CD r+ -+, Q N N N CD 5 . O CD CD o O N - Aa O m CD ou ICP Its -0 O � c . N N 0.T V N C CD W~ CL O-Z o c m C") N O Q �.- -1 �✓ y. � Ca 3 N U.� coco ct L L p d a 1 U i c N NVol N ✓ C" p 11l L N -aO a Un° � D v ai .a co ca V �� a Z V N w -o. o -/_ co c ., p O O 'o N '.' 'd tp, C tG 0- N �G (D - i `^ O CD �.9% N (CSD CD V) ito 0 O CD . 0 CD -::r CD CD O r* CO CND s O CD n C> 7fi (D A O 6 N O LU 0 O �" C7 � pT . (D tD O 93 O % W --- ?� CD O Q3 O O O S, p� C @ t"'D N 'fib Z '11 O N 1:5. CD O tlt ty y O O CDN `z cn A N O G O O N N91 jtc CD �+ O O -S- CD 5 %4-1�. (P � 70 "d O 41 -w tD 0- CD0 ID cCl 3 ;3 N O n ¢ O O O 0 sr CD CD (0 Sp O 4 O 0 CD cD N CD � N r+- CD X11 -a SZZ. 44 � v G h CD �C � T iu N uul to t/1 XO \t. zi c4 N , n 4 Q Z N 3 =' 1 O 3; a co 2 -J. N ay w o -� o CD 03 0o O t3 (� N _ D too• o;O to O i – �L CDD N r. SCD wL CD O C CD N tA- 0 C5 N"r p +, to CD LOD CD CD CD CD O `G O NCD pCD O o O 3 m m D CD O for 7: ? o 0 3 CD a ? w a m O � 3 O`" �^ Z CD N `p p, cQr, p m N N 7+ � O m ° �f CD, CD o .;y N y . CD o: :5. CD C° w - m CD N 6 N -a ow.�. o ° m 3 (01 0 — N - oo. � o cOp � w < CD m ° n -aCD w 3to 0 a �, o c o -° w 'CD ° 0-' (P �. m ° -°O =� w a ,� m — CD N 0 G OCD N CD O G• O O CD C ¢ N CD N CD 4i CD 3 CD } O C N .. - O cow co W �" o ° . o m q ` m co CID`,� o m � v d NZ � CLo � U ,� o 0 0 Ul 111 ` lN Ul rn U o Q) o r m co O � O co46 N CY co o COO Q O G 1 m m '� Z N N 'U o h , o Ngo N wco �, � �. C W 0 CD Cn cn 03 o 0 :5 (P CD 0- C: (P. 0 i F CD CD = 00 CD 0 co (n41 0 CD CD ID 0 CD 16 (ID (0 M 0 S M 6. Q) Cl) CD 0 O, thIn 0 J�CD CD CD 0, 0 CD SE tz�I(D Z5 0- 7 5s. 02. -600 0 (D 0 co 0 'CID 0 (D CD 0 0 0 CDt CD CD% -a :3 1p (P (o (P 0 0 C CD CD 0 0 O 0, 0 (D CD(P 0 0- (D 0 0 CL 0 % --h Cl) CL CD 0 CD cn CD ar tr 0 T. CD 0 -0 (P CD CD -0 b �%CD CD cr P, w 15 0 o, 0 o --s !�- 0 I'll, 0 Cr % I CD M (P CD 0 (P LU CD CD O OSf -0 �aN t2 0 0 cci 77 04 cL -Z CO 0 UA -0 Q) 0 OR Y. o N7 Q N 46 9O1 t3) All i 40 NCO .�M r o 3 � o. N cr 3 a o.N' x. .� m ,41 U)0 o c�tt6 `} N* n O O_O NG^+ G tO, (D O GD CD f CD CD 7 CD n g � o a 'A Sit O 00 .` p—D �. cD 7a_ Cy 'm3 ° P N O .G to CD -� -- z v N ¢ 0 N NO S N -fl 0 (n ca o. a', CD, a,,. co � s O ��� N 6 N cu N p O CD O c�0 n On Od N { o O -0 0 � SCD o Iz D � � ' N. 0- cr o o 3 �• � o- fiCD r,. ��' m CD m v cs �',x. °o 3 (D "� O N 0 N cQ N O d 6 0 p �. (41D (D O �^ 0 CSD CD -=, ¢ N CD N CD v N r+ r+- cD 1 1 � Y ! o V'wa O CD ° CD NN m N m ' CL co O G 0 N G N .� 0 t CL N uJ v 1L1 Ili 10 ccs u� r r, C � CL-- 0 N G GO O C> O >G N o m N C3 3 IZ CO O p c °c L� ilk N O ' Cl. V vn U m V C6 O .•- O Z L1 V �}t 1` Y N • O ',l o CD 03 O ° 3 -0CD 4 CD 1 • �.-- � 4y � ctl, �, rL N rr CD CD 'tD 0 0 � o �a o � �. cv CD --rn N cv -.1.4 O ' ° m �- � ay 11 o cs 1 3aCD co p} �. ) ° °co -0 & 4 m. ALL L3 tD O� N N � 4 CD CD CD vF eta ? N 3 cv o (D p - N p CDCD o= o CD 3 c � oCD ° co -^ N cOt� N N N Cy O Cy j CD �G N CD OM. Q? cA0 Nay 0- coo 1i O ° NO Q 3 G cOCa o 3 co 0 0 1 � � ca ., —• = ° ?� � CD Cr 11 0 CD k � N 6 �„ o p O cQ ��N CD CD N CD (D co CSS CD CD .0s 0 Cl) —Z ZZ Vt. -f-3 tn tr,) Hca 0 Ql- 0 COM 0 N) 0 CD Ul 0) C CD 0 0 e :3. 0 -0 w (n0 0 .0 M CD CD 0) 0) (P 7,.;7 (D ZY CD ( CA D 0 0 CD (D (D CD0- NCD 0 CD 0 0 CD "X = ::5" 0 0 0 lF.. 9�- 3 0 — to 0 (D D) to Xit (D CD (D 0 :4 0) 0- */l , A- CD '93 03 ---1 03 t:5, 0 0- - 0 r O w 'CD CD CD Cr M CD CD :3 Lo (P 0 CD -0 0 0 (0 C 0 CD S a 5 5 Ln CD 0 O4 CD 0- (P CD Ln �k 0 CD N S7 co, CD 0 CD 5 t a CD - CD 0 cr 0 0 CD .5 —cr (p r- (D 0 0 CD 5. oll CD 0 C) 0 0 -0 0.11ii� o CDCl- CD 0 to cn !R CD to -0 0- CD CD 0 0 CD CD 25. 0 CD "Z CD 0 (Z co -0 Ln CD (ji _TZ CD -14 CD CD 0 0 0 s CD (D CD N CD CD _ Y 0 o c G. U v O rCL O co CD m CO jU u' a5 1 m c Na 2 m , cti N Q p pca 106 r � N � v 4- ,r CL v N a� N? m is v L N 111 •, m EO 1-, N _ 5 N Za Z A C. N ((S CL . `ca 'co O O O F om O L " = c o .10 '' 4 N p. �t U N O r- -0 y a�. O W - N °v m w Q 3 0 No,- % V Q 0Z �CD� 0 N ' W tIl N a Ul O .OJLn --Ito e .rZ CD CD O NCD T. 7 r+ O O �� @ to O- tD CD (D ",G 5 1 OCD offCD ; CD �' o LA '_' n O `t!' , tD OQ 7 fi CD G ¢ N Z t1. (D O CD 0O to, c--. C N 1 • a 7 n -+ CD -, � 3 D 0 .9 N CD a• v IID m (D N Q 0 CD o cr c� o t°� 1� m cn o (D3 m oCD o <" 3m 5 , 3 a C) 3 coCD CD CD tT ° o 3 @N O N �O C 'o N �D Cr @. �� a O 9i G, D p 6 CD (D CD o e[ U \� 0 o O o CD a a> E co c 16 N i o. o � ° Q LU v 'm o. Z �' N 0 v � 43 ui N W W O as ° cu _ 4 N N cOi) W +' O c6 cNn o N N b CL p O O0 46 O U O ° G N i. N 3 NQco co 3 0 LU cd Z 0 'D Ln 00 T. 0 CD CD -0 0 CD r* (P CD 4 CD .53 i -% et C) 0 0 6CD tl^ 9) CD CD CD (P 0 CD0 O CD 4 C D O 0CD - LO CD CD ::r CD CD 0 0 (P 0 CD (iD s 1 r- CD CD 0 Q '. 0 CD 'CD sp CD 0 0 0 16 0 0 CD �o S Q) = ' t::�; CD 'z CD 7a_ 0 CD (P Q) CD CD CD 0 M O 0 LO 0 5 -'C<D CD 0 (P 0 , sI U) CD ' -10 0 O.W CD CD CD 0 N CD SO �h , CDto -io 0 to (,ID 0 0 C C- D 0% CO to CD 14 CD 0 0. CD �9 : 0 0 4CD 0 0 CD CD I�P< CD CD CD -1. 0 0 5 0 5 . CL 0 0 Ck- 0 CD tT OD 0 CD CD '4' 0 CD 5 CD CD 5'Ot 0 CD6'". . p CD CD 0 0 , t�. --% 0- 0 0 CD CD C-- CD CD M CD W ca 0 L) 0 CD o CD o co 0 0- s C/3 .la) 0 (D C- W CL 00 0 43) — to co 25 (D a CO 0 0 0 W co cn 46 Z 0) 4S tgl UA 0 0 0 -0 sx co Ul) ca .0 CL co CD co o o 4 o (P. O CD co O "O '0 3 �. N C� D G M O U) CD co co c0 O _ N CSD 0 O '-+ N co pl O O cD CD O T tp Lh C7 N O Ca N' Ate. NN .+ CD '� CD 0 �OO F 03 O 7 N -, o z• N CL rr O ° N Z CD CD -� N CD CD T c N O' O fir+ G O N 9> 0 CD OCD CO p m 41- ° �° N -t CD m co � N N CDD N 0) a 0 CD o N m W -S 9J O O y CD : N O O "4 N O 3 CD O N CD 0 CD SCD 03 0 cl N 0- N vi r� CD O Off. CD co ar 'G. N CD N . ID CD CD o o ° rn N CD N tD N 9J CD w d � r � G L w � o i r dg on Gfl O t � ., t, � •i •a w i i 'ar 1 tn d i t Al t` � � O ca o o m as CA ' N 1 CD .r t i N N tU COO U � , V _ C-- c pam. D. N N 1 to t .341 110- 0 ~ ' SD Cl 3 , cr' � CL o p oma, G o p Jr- L)ovs N N tQ ¢ •� p m O ,1 o O Q ' N G N N Z i O '2, v I w D � -0 CD \ cr CD03 0 o o (P. � cD Nay C= (p G (D 7 cu :R T 6 d' c� N 7 O N !CD O t 6 N c fi C)CD . O N G tz CSD CD -ff OcGD O S �., CD CND r, SO p CD f ', CD CD @ N D 0)O ..G , CO �, rn coo rn 3, OR. ° N Z :' o ctz� m -� ID) m '�► .cD o �n .Q o �; co °-, t 113Q CD o CD CD CD a o *-1 14 N rt ' N V �, -�CD � o o ' NO t�U GM."r CD 0 LS CD m' 3 a m � p 03 o o :5. n N 4CL N 3 --h O 3tf� CD W N 14N (D N, O CD c3 1 N CD N 1. m CD i r+ cD co _„ 0) O co U as tT i O O p LL cc3 e. Q N O tU O Nco oE 0 :R un �- U cCa U. n (D 3 o Q IW- uj a� > N z 0 ~ N NW c — W � -0 a a = oa L W 1-- z cu ai O co (n Q) m COQ CR -G LN O O O Y o � a N 4 E W N I.- N o 0 c cu x Z -° WO a ) — O _ ❑ C3 o Z Q CO U j N W • tCA OCD O 7 -0 CD CD C3- C- W. O SCD CD 9� N N CD O CD w ::3. CD O CD CQ 0 " O r-'O tsl CD 'O@ co CD S @ G O (.0 _ 0-CD 0 O n (D (ND � O71 N n N O Os CD o O CD (D N (D tA� n O O CD y► Cy (D CD a O d CD N O p tQ N CND CD "O CD o cn m 70 p NCD 0 NVQ CD C N U. � N N my O �` (D C:0 CD m c�D o o o N N .. .�. N G (D O COD n O � G x co -e p1 p CD -41 N O CD CD N CD O O �• t2 C!1 � � ti] CD • O CD �. O O CD CD CD � o. Off, CTD -_-r-0 -:3 N CD N all CD (p CT r. Q- © I CD O CD CD O,•r � (D !-r CD Jj -711� 0 o Pot aw Lo -to CL 00- 00 00- 0, 0 00 CD O 0 CD (A O -0 (0 o- (PCD CD 4 CD 0 CD 0- CD 'tD 0 Lo 0 0 _-O 0 5. CD 0 �r CD CD 0 0 0" CD U3 0 0 o CD 0 01 -0 -0 To 0 0 0 0 CD CD CD P. 0 c7 cD, 0 0 (p (o N M ci 0 0 0 CD O 0 B- CCD 0- 9D CD 03 0 0 100 (P CD 44 0 0- CD SP .0 M 0 COD 0 (D 0 0 0- 0 0CD (P (P CD tv CD CD tea 0 0 CD (D S co V\ (D 0 11(5 to. � ,a � Q V _c 0 C�- IS c"a CO C) CA > CO 41W (13 in Ul �Ir .0a. 1 'ZI 0- 3: 0 sti)co 0 U CL CD (D _3 (D v cn CL C = -a CD 0 7c r+ 7c �. CD '— C * Q (D `< ch r O (D O CD fi CD i1 (D (D "O M cn C) (D c0 N v O �' (D v (D (D CCD O CO CD 41 < O zr N O O O O O -� � < o W3 o O — O N .(D X Z 3 C 0 23 v (D Q a ^* o o O x 0 Q) n (D ,C O Q C ;U CDZE (D OCD (D o cn c cn CD cn 0 m m D C Z CD m Q' cn o CD 0 O O (D C -� .� C � 1 (3D ccn o CD =- s (D O Ocn a` O CD Dm (n O CD C OO cn 3 m a)" (D v o c X ... _(n O — 3 � °� m �, N o a CD o m_ x o N � 7z o h Q rn o 0 y Q O (n O v n x cD -7 = a 3CD CY cfl CD '< (D 7 3.O n (D (p (DZIP0 =r r, rt (D - : O (D o v (D (n 3 :Ia cm m CD c�' --h�.s:. , " N o O v h O (D vN CD c (b (D CD 4U; CO S 0 co tr E co 0 0 ) CD (1) 10 S: co 0 0 ca cLS W E 'd 1 ` 1- N W' O c co 10 (Dcz -0 co CL. j-U lu CO o e E/) -M 4� 0 CO W O ca (n U3 co 0 w ul :D CY-' 0 — 0 .45con JU k:— 0 co > o -0 CL co 0 0 co CD CD (D N CD O- N N r. 04 t0 tD �. CD 0 r+ F. O (D 0 N CD Q CD CD CLD .G 7 CSD (� CD CD "� G O Q .► CD v O� CD O 7� ^ O N 7 CD N N O 9� O Sv q1 0 OCD r+ O `L � CD -0fl, --% N 'x CQ `G a M N 2 a s -6 -4. C1 m m T (IDN O O tQN -Z a 3 m �. N ct1 CD p N d N NO t' . 0 (0o CNDya 'kCD, CD N O' fir, Sy N CD0 CD �� (ID CD N CD 0L3 CD, -0 133 a N o CD O CD Q) ci O� CD .G @ S�NU O NCS O G, O U N --1, n N (� O- sz N 3 -t F NLwO C � D .► ¢ o N N t:: 6 CD .G N c{7 CD IC5, C% d CD CD 3 CD as O �� U CD W c o m a u- N co co N R p CO O N N c uj co Y Vim/ N rG, C i W uy m o o 0 p o i!6 o m � i G m ca G # p O 4 `— O tu -a Y O ccs c N m cd a .01 o O N SG N N N' O O cntt= ci rn W us CD •a �c p '� .N o co N cA U31 O U NE Z Z d a CL -P W p d ,. -10 �-- CD N v CD WT+ �' CD C _ t3 N O' CD O U1+ CD t2 t O < Q R. CD ° C7 CD COAD N o ( d � � 3 . . N CD ^t '-" ' CD °-+. 0 O ° CT: ' CV X SD ° 3 Q N a O Z O � p• CD + a:� 07 `C N W N CCD 0 . 0 = Q CD o CD t3 Q ¢ O A sy chi a i cam, CD CD G� CZ tnQ-+ CD •n . . U ° CDo m CL � 70 N • CND t]. D -o " rn. ° @ m s :� m t°n = o w{ = A � o CD 0 m m � c N ;� 3 rn a• t3 Q O O N Q CD @ . 0 W C CD CD . O O Q -C3 CD CD p tt4 3 :n ?3 p O CD CD Sv :n- o - O Q n CD N Q 3 r_ .:3tn. �• SCD CD 0 CL (D 0 Q r �s,,, CD a `C CD �„ t O Ql CD Q•tD O '`t •C © C QcD- CD O . ='-v 0 -, 3 "� C Q 0 CD N (D p� (D �, CD Ryan P. Klobas Chief of Staff � s RECEIVE® JAN 2 5 2006 CLERK BOARD Gr St PERVISORS CONTRA COSTA CO. Office of Supervisor Mary N. Piepho Contra Costa County, District III 309 Diablo Road Danville,California 94526 (925)820-8683•(925)820-6627 FAX ._ -. z, R ,, � r �. ��, 5 . _ ,. . ,.� •, . - � � � . ° - r 4., _ • - , . �; 1, i .1� .. 01/17/2006 03:32 9258660547 CITY OE SAN RAMON PAGE 01/01 wF Snrr� FAX rTILMSPETTAL COVER TO: CONTACT NAME: Supervisor Mary Peipho COMPANY NAMM District III FAX NUMBER: 92S-240-7261 FROM: SENDER: PHONE: 925-973-2532 DEPARTMENT: Mayors Office Date/Time Sent: 12/16/05 12:31 pot Number of ftteq inot IncluoM cover): 2 As Mayor and Councilmember of the City of San Ramon, we wish to forward our opposition to Resolution No. 2006/XX urging the Governor of California to ensure that the President and Congress take Immediate steps.to withdraw the California National Guard troops serving outside of the country. We fully support the men and women of the United States Armed Forces serving both on native soil and around the world and recognize the great sacrifice they make on behalf of their families and their country. Sincerely, H. Abram Wilson Mayor l� Dave Hudson Councilmember This message is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed, and may contain information that is privileged confdential and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this massage is not either the intended recipient or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient you hereby are notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this aommunicatlon in error, please noft us immediately by telephone, and return the original message to us at the above address via the United States Postal Service. Thank you. -�:,. {" f� .:, , F CONSIDER WITH vs 10 : 18 am January 17, 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION Ms . SANDRA GREGORY GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 CONSIDER WITH 10 : 18 am . January 17, 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. ROBERT BOB TAYLOR CITY COUNCELLING CITY OF BRENTWOOD GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 coNsiaEnwiTH 10 : 18 am J.a* nuary 17 , 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION Ms . SANDRA GREGORY GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 CONSIDER WITH 10 : 18 am January 17 , 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. ROBERT BOB TAYLOR CITY COUNCELLING CITY OF BRENTWOOD GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 - D . 5 CONSIDER WITH 10 : 18 am January 17 , 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION Ms . SANDRA GREGORY GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 cuNsioERwirH D� ] 0 : 18 am January 17 , 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. ROBERT BOB TAYLOR CITY COU* NCELLING CITY OF BRENTWOOD GREATLY oppOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 CONS�9EPW��� 1p. lg am IrvIp1�1 V �ZC� OV oYYos Y R GREG Ol`� SAj4v� Voss 15 vt 0� Nn CONSIDER WITH D.f 10 : 18 am January 17, 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. ROBERT BOB TAYLOR CITY COUNCELLING CITYOF BRENTWOOD GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 CONSIDER IMTN 9 :49 am January 17 , 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. GARY HESS GREATLY OppOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 , CONSIDER WITH 9 :49 am January 17 , 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION MR. GARY HESS GREATLY OpPOSSED ON. RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 1JG+JJJL I ...4� 01/17/2006 11: 24 19255527308 BARBARA NORKU'S PAGE -01 January 17, 2006 TO: Contra Costa Board of Supervisors From: Ken and Barbara Norkus/ Danville, CA 925.989.1748 res or fax 925.552.7308 We are asking the Board of Supervisors NOT TO SUPPORT Resolution D-5 which states: -D--- - Consider adopting Resolution No. 2006/15 calling upon the Governor of California to insure that the President and Congress take immediate steps to withdraw California National Guard troops serving outside of the country as soon as possible; and sending copies of the Resolution to specified government officials. Again, my wife and I are asking the Board of Supervisors NOT TO SUPPORT Resolution D-5. Sincerely, Ken and Barbara Norkus Danville CA CONSIDER WITH D� 10 : 18 am January 17, . 2006 VOICE OF OPPOSITION- MR. ROBERT BOB TAYLOR CITY COUNCELLING CITY OF BRENTWOOD GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 1 5 D . 5 To: Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors Subject: Proposed Resolution#2006/15 Sponsored by Supervisor De Saulnier 4h District "Calling upon Governor of CA insure the President and Congress take steps to withdraw CA Ntl Guard troops serving outside the country Gentlemen&Ladies: Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you on this subject. I sincerely hope that you each listen t,*oices of your veterans and constituents and reject this resolution. *ve My name is Dick Seavey. I am a veteran and a member of American Legion Post 246 in Danville. I have had the honor of serving my country as a member of the "Active Duty Forces, The National Guard, and the Army Reserve. I served during Granada, Vietnam and the Persian Gulf.. The views and opinions that I am going to express are my own, but I truly believe that they represent the majority(if not all) of the members of our American Legion Post and those of the Veterans in San Ramon Valley and across the nation. I recommend that the Board of Supervisors unanimously reject the recommended resolution for the following reasons: �v -(4*•��� \ .-'0i r, arc #1. It is completely inappropriate for a my to make such a determination. Those military on active duty, as well as tho in the Reserves and National Guard currently serving on active status, are under ployment according to established national policy. Those who disagree with that po cy should direct their attention to altering, amending or otherwise changing that policy. Our system of government provides for that eventuality and having the governors of each state and territory independently attempt to influence that policy would jeopardize National Security. #2. The National Security of this country depends on the Active Military, The Reserves, and the National Guard. The National Guard is a state militia, but it is funded, equipped, and trained primarily by the Federal Government. Military regulations and laws govern the use and operation of National Guard Forces and the Federal activation of these forces by the Dept. of Defense in support of our National Security. Without such authority the defense of our nation would be put in serious jeopardy. #3. The intent of the proposed resolution appears to be more politically motivated than National Security Motivated. A recent newspaper editorial in the Forum Section of tile, Valley Herald(Common Ground -Bridging the partisian divide in Washington) quotrg two top news media personalities�called for a Civil New Year in 'Putting the Country FTAt Before Politics". pl I �I� •'+••' - t • .. - '.1.. .. 1. - 1.... � f • r .. � ' -? � �i tip_-.' ,. #4. Our Country is at War! There are some who don't wish to believe it,but there is an enemy out there that wishes to destroy our way of life. They have voiced it vocally, a r- demonstrated it with action. If, as a nation, we don't stand firm, defend our freedoms and defeat this threat then future generations will face an even worse crisiWe can't become isolationist and hope to survive. The world has become smaller. T-ke,t'irrror ha)landed on our shores and our lives have changed dramatically. To maintain our freedom and way of life we each have to make sacrifices. Those in uniform take the oath to serve and protect this nation. Those at home have to support them. #5. Passage of the propos resolution would severely damage troop morale, and our nation's image. It woul give encouragement, comfort and hope to the terrorist, indicating that we as a nation didn't have the fortitude to stand up for what we profess and believe in. I have met with active duty personnel returning home on leave and for discharge. They all have proudly served and comment favorably on the accomplishments of our troops. #6. Our military is made up of Combat and Combat Service Support Units. The mix of unit types in the National Guard and the Reserves varies from state to state. Some states have more combat type units than service support units. The activation of such units depends on the Department of Defenses needs and requirements at the time of activation or deployment. In the early stages of a conflict the combat units may be needed more than the support units such as the MP's, Engineers and Civil Affairs. All are required though and all have taken an oath of office to serve. Vikeakp Llt"dAs *V&t,5 R-aS f wart ''a Rvd+�cr�E� T� 3t?.A. Ma-My Thank you again for listening to the reasons for rejecting the recommended proposal. Sincerely Richard W. Seavey U.S. Army Ret San Ramon, CA Whit W too; q .1. .:L .. ,.Ari _ 'f'. ... . ,:,a'J A ,M1^. d, a r h .. - +v.. t 4 v. t. .f ,.! • . j � .. .L i - t y Owl) 1 J'GL'L'JcI JL J M/17/2006 11: 24 19255527106 BARBARA NORKUS PAGE 01 January17 2006 6 TO: Contra Costa Board of Supervisors. From: Ken and Barbara Norkus/ Danville, CA 925.989.1748 res or fax 925.552.7308 Weare-asking the Board of Supervisors NOT TO SUPPORT Resolution yflD-S which states: D-5 Consider adopting Resolution No. 2006/15 calling upon the Governor of California to insure that the President and Congress take immediate steps to withdraw California National Guard troops serving outside of the country as soon as possible; and sending copies of the Resolution to specified government officials. Again, my wife and I are asking the Board of Supervisors NOT TO SUPPORT Resolution D-5. Sincerely, ICS! �- Ken and Barbara Norkus Danville CA consm�`�� 01,C-C �F OVY oSl�IOI� S �uIW• OYY OS��� GR�P'�UT10� �O REgOL � .5 CONSIDER WITH v-,r 10 : 18 am January 17, 200-6. VOICE * OF OPPOSITION - Ms . SANDRA GREGORY GREATLY OPPOSSED ON RESOLUTION NO . 2006/ 15 D . 5 • arces n �/vo vim`/ 2-72 zoa 6 o14 FMA�'F- oF T t FF�db eTW G7 1 . W-,44 LlT K � �d CITATION Rank and or Corporal (then Pfc.), U.S. Army, Company 1, 7th Infantry Regiment, 3r Infantry Division. Place and date: Near Tongmang ni, Korea., 25 April 1951. Entered service at: Marion County, Ark. Born: 24 May 1933, Mountain Home, Ark. G.O.: 2, 11 January 1955. Citation: Cpl. Gilliland, a member of Company. I, distinguished himself by conspicuous gallantry and outstanding courage above and beyond the call of duty in action against the enemy. A numerically superior hostile force launched a coordinated assault against his company perimeter, brunt of which was directed up a defile covered by his automatic rifle. His assistant was killed by enemy fire but Cpl. Gilliland, facing the full force of the assault, poured a steady fire into the foe which stemmed the onslaught. When 2 enemy soldiers escaped his rank firing and infiltrated the sector, he leaped from his foxhole, overtook and killed them both with his pistol. Sustaining a serious head wound in this daring exploit, he refused medical attention and returned to his emplacement to continue his defense of the vital defile. His unit was ordered back to a new defensive position but Cpl. Gilliland volunteered to remain to cover the withdrawal and hold the enemy at bay. His heroic actions and indomitable devotion to duty prevented the enemy from completely overrunning his company positions_ Cpl. Gilliland's incredible valor and supreme sacrifice reflect lasting glory upon himself and are in keeping with the honored traditions of the military service. ,l' j...i .. �� 1 F To: Contra Costa County Supervisors; DeSaulnier, Gioia, Ulkima, Glover & Piepho Re: Proposed Iraq Resolution Vs. Doing Our County Business 1/17/06 Dear Supervisors Mark, John, Gayle, Federal & Mary, I've known most of you for many years through my capacity as Mayor of Clayton and on Veteran related items. I speak to you today, not as a Clayton official, but as a local Combat Veteran, and somewhat as a fhend. In no way would I want your job. We have worked together on some issues in the past, and will do so again. But on some issues we will disagree, and I hope this is not one of them. I understand that the job of being a County Supervisor is difficult, that some things are being done very well such as the running of our County Sheriff s Department, but that while you have been doing your best, our County, one of the richest and most favored counties in the state, is beset by problems, many of which are getting worse day by day. Collectively people say you have made some serious mistakes such as agreeing to pension formulas that are unsustainable, ignoring the budget crisis by refusing to make businesslike cuts in past years until they will soon be reaching the draconian stage, by ignoring the land issues of many cities with stalemates in boundaries, zoning and traffic, ignoring your host City Martinez's desire to have your new building fit in with this local community, and paralysis on the crime and murder problems plaguing many parts of the County that require decisive and harsh police work to get under control. Work that can only be done by your leadership and policy-setting for a ZERO tolerance policy upon truants, drugs, gangs, parolees and multiple repeat offenders. You could be solving these issues, and I, the other cities, everybody in this room and most people throughout the County would help you, support you, and wish you well to be successful, for everybody's sake. But instead, for what appears to be political reasons, you waste precious time and staff resources on other things, things that cost money like a new PR position, when if you did your job you wouldn't need it. Things like closing or moving a perfectly good airport, as if we really need 16,000 more houses in Concord instead of a nearby airport, and I'm sad to say things like this back-stabbing Berkeley Resolution that you've put on today's Agenda. As you know, you all collectively apparently don't know much about solving the Counties problems, much less about foreign affairs, the Middle East, and the War on Terrorism. It's clear to the rest of the Country that the People's Republic of Berkeley and San Francisco are also clueless on almost everything, and are the laughing stock of the Nation. Their pretentious dabbling in matters that are National when they can't even run their cities, build a bridge, control the "homeless", or stop gang killings in their own.localities, is what shows them to be considered crazy and filled with kooks. Contra Costa on the other hand has been fairly level headed. When run in Warren Boggess's Era, then Sunne McPeak's we were a growing and admired County, and with Phil Batchelor, even you guys looked pretty good until recent years. I implore you to get a grip, to. focus upon solving our Countywide problems which are many, to stay away from National politics as a body, to avoid petty"advancement politics", and to throw out this horrible and divisive proposed Resolution, and get back to business. If you ignore this advice and want to go "national" anyway, then at least do it on the side of our United States in this War On Terror. Give our country and our troops support to Victory, not to defeat. Give our Troops a boost in their morale, not the Al Queda enemy a boost by thinking that America's home front is spineless, ignorant and too selfish to win. Yes War in Iraq and anywhere is a horrible thing,just like crime. But if you pulled all our police out of the City of Richmond you would have more crime, drugs, murder and horror. Similarly, if you were to pull all our troops out of Iraq before the job is done, YOU will be responsible for the mayhem, millions of good Iraqi's being killed and beheaded, and for the nation of Iraq becoming the next terrorist haven. You talk about the"Greatest Generation" and how they handled WWII. But after the beachhead was established in Europe and all the deaths at Normandy, they didn't clamor to bring our troops home, but finished the job. And in the Pacific as well, we didn't bring our troops home until Total victory. Roosevelt and the County Supervisors of that era would be ashamed that you are even considering this Resolution today. If your proposed Resolution was to be followed rather than scoffed at, a Democratic Iraq would not be the beginning of that part of the world having a real and historic chance at freedom, stability and peace. Instead you would be giving Al Queda terrorists a platform to topple other nearby countries, and to create chemical, biological and someday nuclear weapons that could and would be unleashed around the world and within the United States. IF such an attack, which has not happened in almost 5 years because our brave troops are on the offensive, happens within Contra Costa County, it will be largely YOUR fault. You need to hope and help our troops to succeed in this War now being fought overseas so that we don't have an anthrax attack in Sun Valley Mall killing tens of thousands. So that a packed Concord Pavilion doesn't have 10 thousand attendees wiped out in one evening, so that our refineries or Livermore Lab are not blown up spewing toxics, or radiation and death countywide, or the Caldecott tunnels, Carquinez and Benicia Bridges etc, aren't collapsed with the loss of hundreds of lives,jobs, and our County's fragile economy. The choice is yours today. I hope you choose to not pass this Resolution or one anything like it, and if you do, we will remember and hold you accountable at the next and every election. THANK-YOU. Pete Laurence A Vietnam "Green Beret" From Clayton, Contra Costa County Days: (925) 939-7920, pete@palaurence.com Cc: VFW, DAV, American Legion, Diablo Valley Vietnam Vets, Etc. NOTICE OF A PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON PLANNING MATTERS ` LAFAYETTE AREA NOTICE is hereby given that on Tuesday, January 17, 2006 at 1:00 p.m. in the County Administration Building, 651 Pine Street, (Corner of Pine and Escobar Streets),Martinez, California, the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors will hold a public hearing to consider the following planning matter: An appeal of the County Planning Commission's decision to approve the application of William Nicora(Applicant& Owner)—Jamil Abu-Hamdeh and Adrian,Betty and Harry Karns (Appellants)to construct a six-foot high retaining wall and a garage addition attached to an existing residence with variances to the front and side yard setbacks. County File#VR041033 The location of the subject property is within the unincorporated territory of the County of Contra Costa County, State of California, generally identified below(a more precise description may be examined in the Office of the Director of Community Development, County Administration Building, Martinez, California): The location of the subject site is 1100 Dunsyre Drive, in the Lafayette area. If you challenge this matter in Court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the County at, or prior to,the public hearing. Prior to the hearing, Community Development Department staff will be available on Tuesday, January 17, 2006, at 12:30 p.m., in Room 108,Administration Building, 651 Pine Street,Martinez, to meet with any interested parties in order to (1)answer.questions; (2)review the hearing procedures used by the Board; (3) clarify the issues being considered by the Board; and(4)provide an opportunity to identify,resolve,or narrow any differences which remain in dispute. If you wish to attend this meeting with staff, please call David Brockbank, Community Development Department, at(925) 335-1237 by 3:00 p.m. on Monday, January 16, 2006 to confirm your participation. Date: January 4, 2006 John Sweeten, Clerk of the Board of Supervisors and County Administrator By4Lgyp`( ��C,Utz Katherine Sinclair,Deputy Clerk Anashia Lloyd To KSinc@cob.cccounty.us <cctlegals@cctimes.com> cc 01/04/2006 09:42 AM Please respond to bcc cctlegals@cctimes.com Subject Re: Publication Request THE FOLLOWING e-mail contains pertinent information; please read it carefully in its entirety. PLEASE NOTE:All of our offices will be closed Presidents'Day, Monday, February 20, 2006. Good Morning. If you have any questions regarding the legal notice confirmed below, please reference the legal number provided. Please only e-mail to cctlegalsAcctimes.com regarding Contra Costa Times,Concord Transcript, or Contra Costa Sun legal notices. Thanks! ** LEGAL SCHEDULE CONFIRMATION** TYPE: In-Column Liner, Classified Section LEGAL NUMBER: 4570 PO#: 1122 Publication: CCT Run Date(s): 01/07 Legal Acct#: 200 4197 Total Amount: $154.00 REVISIONS/CANCELLATIONS: I will need a cancellation request referencing the legal number—or all changes attached in a final draft Microsoft Word Document—e-mailed to cctlegals(a,cctimes.com by no later than 4 PM tomorrow, Thurs., 01/05. Otherwise, the legal will publish as you e-mailed. Thanks! Anashia Lloyd Legal Advertising Coordinator (925) 943-8019 (925) 943-8359—fax Contra Costa Times ATTN: Legal Dept. P.O. Box 4718 Walnut Creek, CA 94596 cctlegals@cctimes.com KSinc@cob.cccounty.us wrote: Hi Anashia, r� Please publish the attached legal notice in the CCTimes: Date: Saturday, January 7, 2006, 1 day only Reference POM 1122 Please confirm receipt of request. Thank you, Kathy Sinclair Clerk of the Board of Supervisors 335-1902 (See attached file: Nicora-011706.doc) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Name: Nicora-011706.doc Nicora-011706.doc Type: WINWORD File(application/msword) Encoding: base64 Download Status: Not downloaded with message Kathy Sinclair/COB/CCC To cctlegals@cctimes.com 11/02/2005 10:00 AM cc bcc dt..h.i i 16•i0 4�iA Subject Publication Request Hi Anashia, Please publish the attached legal notice in the CCTimes: Date: Saturday, January 7, 2006, 1 day only Reference PO#: 1122 Please confirm receipt of request. Thank you, Kathy Sinclair Clerk of the Board of Supervisors 335-1902 WVTl Nicora-01 1 706.doc BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING IN THE MATTER OF William Nicora Notice of hearing for Tuesday, January 17, 2006 at 1:00 p.m., in the County Administration Building, 651 Pine Street, Room 107, Martinez, CA was mailed this day, Wednesday. January 4, 2006. I declare under penalty of perjury that I am now, and at all times herein mentioned have been, a citizen of the United States, over age 18; and that today I deposited Certified Mail with Contra Costa County Central Service for mailing by the United States Postal Service in Martinez, California, first class postage fully prepaid, a copy of the hearing notice, on the above entitled matter to the following: PLEASE SEE ATTACHED LIST I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct, at Martinez, California. Dated: January 4, 2006 Katherine mclair, Deputy Clerk 177120019 177120022 177120029 MOORE GEORGE E BROWN DAVID &LYNN PREBIL ANNA MARIA DETTMER 15172 ND AVE 184 RUDGEAR DR P.O. BOX 1843 WALNUT CREEK, CA 94597 WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596 LAKE OSWEGO, OR 97035 177140001 177140019 177140049 IMANI-TAFTI IRAJ& SIMA NICORA WILLIAM P &TRE WESTVIEW PARK PARTNERS 38 ST. STEPHENS DR 1100 DUNSYRE DRIVE 2960 CAMINO DIABLO#300 ORINDA, CA 94563 LAFAYETTE, CA 94549 WALNUT CREEK, CA 94597 1771120009 177120011 177120022 ADRIAN&BETTY KARRIS JAMIL&KAREN ABU-HAMDEH CARYL TRE ADAMS 1166 DUNSYRE DRIVE 101 PARK AVE 430 N CIVIC DRIVE#315 LAFAYETTE CA 94549 WALNUT CREEK, CA 94595 WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596 177120029 MASSOUD&ZIBA FANAIEYAN NANCY LAPIN AMD LIVING TRUST 38 ST STEPHENS DRIVE 46711 CRAWFORD STREET#14 . P.O. BOX 10113 ORINDA, CA 94563 FREMONT, CA 94539 GLENDALE, CA 91209 CITY OF LAFAYETTE CITY OF WALNUT CREEK PLANNING DEPT. PLANNING DEPT. Contra Costa County Fire 3675 MT DIABLO BLVD, SUITE 210 1666 N MAIN STREET Protection District P.O. BOX 1968 P.O. BOX 8039 2010 Geary Road LAFAYETTE,CA 94549 WALNUT CREEK, CA 94596 Pleasant Hill, Ca 94523 East Bay Municipal Utility District Senior Civil Engineer,Water Service Central CC Sanitary District Planning Building Inspection Street,MS701 5019 Imhoff Place 375—1 PP Oakland,Ca 94607-4240 Martinez, Ca 94553 IJ NOTI-C-F, O_F A PUB I ' Ja-n 11 � vvo� 1i G . You are hereby notified that or, 7:00 p.m. in Room 107, McBrien Administratalifornia,the County Planning Commission B 'PEAL OF A VARIANCE application as des( WILLIAM NICORA (Applicant& (� IAN, BETTY & HARRY KARRIS (Appellants; � .�00 of a Zoning Administrator's approval for a i -that will be attached to the existing residence with variances for an 8-foot side yard (minimum of 10 feet is required)and a 22-foot aggregate side yard (minimum of 25-feet is required); also to build a six-foot high retaining wail, with a variance for a 5-foot front setback (minimum of 20 feet required). The subject site is located at 1100 Dunsyre Drive, in the Lafayette area. (Parcel #177-140-019; General Plan Designation: Single Family Residential Low Density; Zoning Atlas Page: N-13; Census Tract: 3400.02) If you challenge the project in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the County at, or prior to, the public hearing. For further details, contact the Contra Costa County Community Development Department, 651 Pine Street, Martinez, California, or David Brockbank at 925-335-1237. Dennis M. Barry, AICP Community Development Director y f