Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 12142004 - C117 TO: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS �-� . ontra n: Costa FROM: DENNIS M. BARRY, AICP County DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT = 1 r' C'OUI'i� DATE: DECEMBER 14 2004 SUBJECT: PREPARATION OF AN INCLUSIONARY HOUSING ORDINANCE SPECIFIC REQUEST(S) OR RECOMMENDATIONS(S) & BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION RECOMMENDATIONS ACCEPT staff report regarding the major components of an Inclusionary Housing Ordinance, and DIRECT Community Development staff to work with County Counsel to prepare a draft Inclusionary Housing Ordinance for review by the County Planning Commission. FISCAL IMPACT No impact to the General Fund. CONTINUED ON ATTACHMENT: X YES SIGNATURE: COMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR REC NDATION4 BOARD COMMITT PROVE OTHER )Iztecllo 4� SIGNATURE(S). ACTION OF BOARD ON APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED X OT029 VOTE OF SUPERVISORS I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A X UNANIMOUSABSENT - TRUE AND CORRECT ( ) COPY OF AN AYES: NOES: ACTION TAKEN AND ENTERED ON THE ABSENT: ABSTAIN: MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS 9 THE DATE SHOWN. r Contact: Patrick Roche,335-1242 ATTESTED Orig: Community Development JOHN SWE TEN,CLERK cc: CDD/CDBG OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS County Administrator AND COA M R er County Counsel BY EPUTY Auditor-Controller BACKGROUND / REASONS FOR RECOMMENDATIONS On February 24, 2004 the Board of Supervisors authorized Community Development staff to prepare an Inclusionary Housing Ordinance. The County is receiving technical assistance from HUD through the HOME program to research issues and develop alternatives to structure the Ordinance. Attached is a table highlighting the components of an Inclusionary Housing Ordinance. Staff recommendations are in the middle column with clarifying comments and/or alternative approaches included in the third column. Also attached is a table summarizing Inclusionary Ordinances in Brentwood, Concord, Danville, and Walnut Creek. KD\\fs-cd\users$\kdouglas\kdouglas\New\Board Orders\2004\lncl Ord 2.doc COMPONENTS OF AN INCLUSIONARY HOUSING ORDINANCE L - � � � �-► GJ � � O ccs � � vi O O a 4-J vcu X ._ CL) CL CL) I O C! O O L c� V s L VI �+ U L i O (v N (L) L LA 4-1 L- •ito •- , p ;-+ O L Q V > L L O Q dJ �' 4J •� 4-1 p c� iJ 4J vi L! 4J +�+ GJ 41 L.Lp L .� '� V to + 'E V ._ �_ — }•+ 4J L 4-P CJ Ln V •— ._ i C �t1,1 Q ce �n > O p in u �' � O I 4-0 I — 4, 4-00 ._ 4-JL � � � � O 4J —_ > c� L E O p V L OL 4-J CL 4-0 �" >, � L L 0 4j v' u E O p LA 4-J '� L aJ cCf L O S — E g Q O s > O s ,� p L p O — O V tm4-0 O J ° � c� — Z s ,� GJ LA W CC O p an O O _ ver iC1. � .O � � � .� � --• � >, — 4-1 CL }, O 0) >' UF Q > Q s O `" o a ° °' °1 o = U = I s L QJ O V Q Q 411 O .V N O CC C CL �.., O Q a� Q woo- WOO*O 3� 0 V., 0 0 ,�,,, �.t'� c 'C3 S, y i• � �' O tv © ,� �, O ,-�,, 00- W 0.:3 C. (k) 00- ti � � '� RS � RS �" '� � � � y O � � V ,� cd woo tae. ca � � ? ss s '� = N s�- ° �' �' � � Clo W 000- 10000 cd .03 �.. � � 'ted V*l cd CO. V-1 v-1 4-1 Aj 0 0 'Q co OOOOP spj cd oo*- ..0- woo" (d cid 3 ca vn W 00000 w fool, ? N -ter 0 O tp td 4 �' �' cd ASSO W 0 W ASS) Iyin �7 0 00-10 .4000 Sao- %4000 3� W 0 0 %P000, 000000 43) 0 MOOOOS soosop 03 0 wS3 3� 0 ASS' -0 W 0 :3 wopo* %0- 0 0 0 *7 ASSO ro. 0 W %ow goom %ow CO. 0 .00- S:5 s: .27 00 cn 3� 0 '405 %SS. -000 A-J .000, cd 0 W %400P go- %4.0. is W :3 0 %0- 0 -0 -�; W 1� (L) -0 00-01 :3 Sooc—d 0 A-# 0 o 0 0000P %0- 0 .4.0 0 -0 43) -0(01") loop wo- oo— Soo oo. .00- IS6000 0 w 10 %40- OOW :3 1:3 0 3� 0 3� 0 w o °� ca w SSSSSS CIS ccS W t'r .� 7- td O Soo S.SoSS cd -.:3 s c .0 RS 43) cd o 0 V, do 0 U- %*.S. 0000 00-0 offim Soon 43) cd 0 ro. 43) Cod 0 %ow %4000 co 0,00. 3� Swoop 0 *000 w 0000 0 0 .0, %0. spolool w 00000 0 0 3� -Scood, A-J 101- 3; JC %0 6 0 0 0 0000, V-1 j� 3� %00 00000 0 wo- so- 00000 VOOO Soo %low3� A-J 0 a X: 3� 0 w 0 %� %s w so- SSO -:5 3� 0 %wo 0-000 %4— 3� 00000 00 00000 0 0 0V 0 0 0�- 0 ui.- �1-0 -0 3� 3� oo 0 0 %n c (,- wow 7- 0 0 00000 0-01 �g o 0 Improo, 0 0 .00- zoo., 0 -.0000. %001 3� oo 0 0 00 Cd IMPS 0 0 V.. %00- � 0 Jod S:� SSS s -owoo �2 '"IS un -0 0 3� �C 0 %04 0 o ul-SS V. � o *too- 0 ............. L 4- O tA jA L O a..► :..j — ctS -0 •— a tA � 4-0L vii �. 'O p 4.j ._ LA 4- 4-JQ O v� L w u r cn cCS � L � 4-1 s Ln Ln L tA _ � L — 4-j tA 4-+ — ce c� 3: •`^ > 4L-+ r� O Ln N1 Ln � 0 L 4..r 4-J � � V O 0 L Q �O N O t E a� L aJ Qvj Q L 4-j O u tcoLQ L O OO Q v (L)L�� a, a-+ O a-+ cu Q O 4-+ 4-J cu s U 111 4- _ .� eftO >` c� •- .- c� •V >' i� cn i� L 111 O � — �� O ff-' � •� � t L �- a S 111 ., 4J V M E — .— 4.. L Q O u� Q _ �--► E S > w "E ,- .- •- u LZO - cZ �-' v i > O L ch CL) CUa..+ 4— Q a E L E .2 U c� 0 4-J 4-J CZ L2 LA a 6 CU LA u :3 4-J u aJ >• .� RS 4- O ccS 4-J CUO 4 4-o L 4-1 4— O L (.0 " 4— L C Q a U CU L _ Q. Q tA CO O L � •� O — .� O b4 L11 O i 111 Q V •� .L •L 4-J G1 OV (Z >- oC Z 4-JU Cd Ln a i °n L- � O U 4- 0 O CU � L O N 4- 0a � an •— u L - O L 4_ a O ct 4-J O CU Q E O GJ to O •� >- .!n U E N � O � O C N 4- 0 J � � I .E Q O ..0- .000 V-1 0 W 0 %00 10 0 Y 0 0 7S 0 0 go- o %- %000 U -o-P 0 ts) 00. 000 cy 'GC' .SZ tl. %00 0 19000 ago- 0000 o %00 0- 'wo 0 'Z'' 0:5 00. 0 0- MOOo Q' 6 (k)(k) -0 p- %A NSC�0 o 0 4.4 ..j (d 7 v� s W 0 so- %00 (k) W 0 0 o 0 ' �� N Q' N i wow co UnS cd N 4J N �.- '"' A-J' A-5 U- %A V-1 y n yea 0 C). 0000 Z�-- -0co do c %4010 s 0000 o o 0 0 0:5 .:$ (d ***) 0 a 00000 op .00- (d 3� P. 0 co 0 wow co 6c 0 %A - VI ..-o -0 0 S:� 0 0 0 4010 0000o 0 00 c 0 00 0 40- low %00 NOO 0 0 00 c 3� 0 0 W 0 tV 0 o tp c tV tp N cd 0 00 %00 1:� un W c 0 :id ILI VI .O 4� o V-1 0 0 o G) 0 .00 %00 0.. 0 i v,.O %00 -S Co%..- 0 0 � dr %4010 0 0 0- MONO 0 0 d � o 00 G) 00 s 0 0 0Iwo %40- 0000 0- UPO 0 0 0 4-1 'cd 4.0 07 0 w 0 0 Q -000 0 0 0 of woo- (L) '' N N CIO ON r4 un VI (1) roop N 0 C> .600 .00- C. 00000 o S (1) 46 401 o 0:5 w 0 0 0 ;P. oc 0 U00 0 00-0. moop V (d 3� 0 -p b U. coo C.0 w 000 .0ow tV � � ctSV WOOOP W ? 0 4-1 V 6n yn 0 0 %A 07- 0000, C.- w jt� s 4-1 00000, ro-O .0000 .000 0- om- U- C. Cd 000- iE 0 0 0 WOOP V. -0 0 N � � ?, `'n' cd cd 0 � ctS ,� a � 0 'AOJ .00- SO- C) 0 0 0:5 Cd W 0 00000 0 0 .00- poop w 0 0 U00 0 0 U 000 0 3� 0vn 0 cu Soo- *go- 4-1 �A c .:3 WOW 0 Q rw **-so Q 401 0 o o t1} RS T 4J Q � c+d S � +ct' 0 go- :5 0 opow 0 "Opla .o- f 00000 C 0 co roo. 0 0 .000 0 0 wo- T U- .0000 0 0 w w 0 C) 401 4-00 0 saw *goo c 0 o � � Q 4) 00000 aJ t4 v; td ', i i *;ro Soo 66000 y V t1i 'v► V1 *woo -woo 'o 0000 4-- L OtA L s O Q� 4- O �.J Q �-J O L s s O - N OtAa� L tA L s a� a� a O a a� L vi O O OLn4- a� O c� ._ a� L , a� L V s _ s 0 s O O cn > — O V 4•J W w ._ .....xa: O .— •— s p — L tA - L NA 4-J tA CLO cz 0 L s ._ O c� O a� L O >> . ......> L s �L L L o a� -- O � o s a� O O a O FunLn a� 4-0 — a fun Ln ,_ .� •— L O L 04 0 s - p - O V 4, cn411 O O O V L ._ o0 ._ ._ L Z W G� O L - N c� N Q s a.J L11 WDC O L � L > O O O � 4- L O 4- O RS G� G1 L O W L V � L CYL 4- Z CJ L c� L oC c� cit O O W � O Z L �.J L V L cit O cit O O 4- 4- 4- p 4- 4— �n �n 4- � »» ,:..::::::. a� tA E E E O O - V s O 4-J O s � o •- v O -- O O rsjvi C* cn Q Q - o . . O O O O 4J 0 s tn O 4- O 00 O O O 0 O O O 4- )C 0 s s O O O N ro � O c N L V � Q V) V., 0 woo 00 60*0 un C. %4— V-1 000- 0 0 4* o '.ti••+ (d 3 V-1 00 p Q o� s N 000- 00000 000, o 3� U00 00 00000 U-0 �, ? � '� cv cd ,�,� �, rC3 � � cd o� �, � '77 0 0 co W co %A ,10 vn -0 00 000- 400 0 t 0 00- .00-0 0 00 0 00 V, o 0 .:5 0 4.j 0 00000 0000 U00 .0000 .000 Co *000 -V; 0 (:) o .000 id Q -0 W U00 0) 000000 0 -Ow s 3 o rd 0 � V �, N t3) U.- V, co co 4^ G) S �: *go- !:1 0 id 4po %4000 ORwr- -.:5 • O o t, Od J�� Oo U0. %00 0 0 oeo G) V 7, W 0000 co- *000 00 0 0 Jo (d o 00 w 00-0 yam-" �" '' �,, �' N O 00 0 16- %.- (1) 0 %A 0 '"CS ci ccs 0 00 0 0 %410 CO. 0 C� w 0 43) Co %00 0000 oolp 4w e Vol %A %4-' 4) 0 uop (1) (d %400 .0- 3� 0 olo 40A :5 000ow W W .00 CO. V -0 --t; o roo. 0 0 '�) %A :5 0.� %wo .000fool 0) %00 0 46 V, W�� 0 - 00 .0010 '.0- 7-P 3� o' %A .0 Co 0 CI woo go- O e (L) C.- U %A 0, A-'j 0 0) �P Co .0 .0 06) ..5 0 U00 i lip 00 (1) U-0 0 0 (d cd %00 6 Cd 0 C- 3� e 00000, e %00 0 0 o A-J' 0) 401 ---d- 0 c 0000 cd 00 o �2 (1) (1) e - 0 00000 %00 W 0 000 c- cd 0 %400 %00 U- 0.005V; 3� 0 0. 0- C'o tn 0 .000, C. CO. %400 40-1 '00- 3—� q) wo' OPOW 0 0 e r, 0 vi qr� W 0000 %oo co tV '�3 � � � � ? N cd � � � S+ 0-10 :5 0 0 -000 0:5 Co. o .000 U00 ..o- 3� 0 00 0. .0 S d-A vi 00 Cd �a 0 0 0 -06 sopoo %ow 0000 Aoj 0 C' V" VOOO C> U-0 i VOOO, tv O. L. %00 %1100 os:o 00000 .0000 �-70. 0 W (d 0005 o e j 7pp-- 43) 0 VOOPO Ln 000 Wit. e 0 W O00 %000 000- 0 ukool 0- 7- e '000 %4000 0 %4(odop -000$ 0 0000 0 o 0 0 0,00 0 *sow 0 00 000- S i O i p .Q i - a-J cCf *.+ 4J O cn aJ cif O O ... ° i >< < N cu w > < Q O 4-0 VO 4-+ �_ p O <'` '` t > p O O O v� O a •— ._ •— CO .- o o �, •- a — — v,c� a..r aJ 4-► O p a •— t O 04-j GJ V }•' ._ O 4-0 Cu tAi w tA � �. w v� •— v� — C .� O oL 4- G � + V CY Ind — O r� 0 O O Z EJ o\° o O 4— O O m ;..+tA > M tA 4-0 4-1 Z cu 4- _ o CC Ou O E OV V O V u � X w X � c�S O *..+ o � O O O O a O O 4-0 CD O V 4J 4-J w Ln cc LnO CL -0 .— `' O O c O c V0 4 ._ 4-j• a� a� ._ Ln co ° O = 3 ° O — '- CD LA 0 CD 00 O-J 0 Ln U- ._ N oC � *, u Cr Q � L O � O •- O a s � 4mj — > a v� — ._ a Q L t/1 •- a L v� — ._ .�. OO 4+ O Q Q O c� O ao L •- Q F- o s Ln 4-J O 4-0 ' cu Q w A' • W w 4-J .a--+ LO LA o Ln 4-Jp — cCS _ a.., — cCS O V s O o L V E LA LA L > LA 4-J cn •— O CL • •— •— V •— c� — Oa Lin an ._ c�S a > cu - a a Q a O � a c� cts O L M > Q O � cit cn ctf i— O f-- Z O H cn a - O Z > O 4 , U a o an �► L u u L 0) _ a ! O a •- L •- a L 4-, V ! > cr a LU U c� 4— c� ,� y= co V c N • LO 4W Eof ; •i r..., _ O O Q Q V Q %A W VI) w dwo .00- 0-10, Cs -:� 6 'o- A-j 00 0 -� s 4.0 woop S� 60*0 y .000 7 0 0 J5, W w 0 V.0 0 cn ,odo- U- 0 (1) w 0 W Vi W 0 00*00 tv 't3 ter► ? � � S, ,;,� 0 %boo 4o) %00 Aoj c .0000 U-0 W 0 c %A -Cvi 40A S , %00 00 0 00*W 0 00,00 U4000 0 00000 .0000 .00 1.00 %00 00 w J -0- 0 %4-* 0 :'� Co ca -0-0 0 Jc�0 0 .00 OOOP 0 .000 00 (d --%- -0 0 voi 0 W w UOO oo 00000 0 0 .0.5 0000 0 WOO -ter 0 o 00000 7s Ali 0000 .go- JC 00,00 00 00100 .9� id aj U00 "77 w00 jo 0** 0 3� -0 • o co 0 %ow 43) 0 ted U.-O 0 to- woloo 7 V-) 0 C 0 %600,0 0 V.- CP o "000- '"=3 � v � 1r'` d 0 %J60 moo'o (1) (1) 3� 0 00 0- Goop o Wo A-i AOJ, 0 00 0 tU n 00 w 3� •so- 00000 000 00 0-6s -.-Q- 0 C, 0000 0 04) 00 odoloo ro. s s •-W 0 ..00.5 'op tp wit COMPARATNE SUMMARY OF INCLUSIONARY HOUSING ORDINANCES— Selected Cities in Contra Costa County 0 %00 C: %0. 000 doo- .0000 0 .:3 W 0 Ir . !,::1 .000 Zo 0 .00- 0-10 %goo %000 . �"�" O .�'-go- V; ', Q s.. ° O S 0 CU ............................. �° = apowo .00- 0000 o ss ° o ° o `� .0 No- tU o 43) si .00- (3) '�, o V-1 0000 0 fieL400 la C) Co 0 --3 o VO) 0 -Ocodo .0000 C. un C. 0 0 ce. C. IF- 3� v t=e 'I ",w .00 o v-j �77 00- 4-0 P tp c uncd 0 0 00- os (1) %oo cd -7- 3- .5:� -� tY O 06- © ,tv V .0%4.00 0 woopo 00- go- 0 103 3� 0 0 %400 4.d VI cv 00,00 C, V-1 �;A 0 0 0 0 0 %400 00000 U dO5 or .0- 0:3 3� 3; Oo W-0 0 1000 0:3 0o 0 0 0 00000 .00- 0000 -0 i� s .o- cu .5 0000 G d i y 1Y 0 12 **- %A uo V% 3-, 4a) 0 % 0 .00 .0000 (11tvas tv Woo 0 00- 00000 CL 0 00000 w w U0. 00000 0 0 o dO 000 No. ods- 00 c- 0 0. 0 00000 00000 4-0 0 U. 0 id 0 0 oop ca 3� 006 0 4j %wo O --codo la 0 M0 o. o roo, 0, W O 0 S *goo A-J u (:I,. V-1 cl. cn Moo 00 0 0 95-00 0 0 o - 1 clo 0 V41 Oo C: 00 too 0000 0 00 o 00 0 00 V 000 U00 td O W CIO 48 0 w %00 goo 0 0 0 C. j.J ..0- 3� Vol 0 wo- W WOOP 4-0 -0 0 c cd 0- W OR 0) b ...- v O v °'n O'o o 48 C) Co 0 c VII %00 CIO 0 0 4.0 0 o 0 Cid tA c C). V; ............................ 0 :5 o W cd 0. 0 C( wot- t4 :010 .6 'A 0 .o 3�, %oo 0 w R S A 8 00 0 m0000 ca ill 0 .0 op v. 6:5 0 w S loo it z 00%) U.- coo Cd U- - Clo o :3 W C. woo 0 cd i'd 0 v- roo -0 0000 oo b A-i Jr. 0 Vol 0 VolA-i C. S -0 vi 0) 0 48 W Vol oo0ow l00000 woo 3 v. 4oi VA) uo o;$ *woo 0 0770 0 0 ils 1E un Vn t: co 4) -oo-- .o OV4) 0 (:1. ..-o 3-� ,Qwo- 4-1 U*l o 0 vi r000 Ul ..o r-o V41 Nor, %4-oo 0 W W c 00 %A w %wo 18 Oo 0 W s cl. 0 V-1 C) V-% �. O- �' � G � a� ct3 Q- co f0000 %6000 U O b d «3 b�A O 1.4a O 'C7 U Q .� O N 3 .� E EU 0 C13 Z b `of rU+ U L N U w O L O cn 'i cd 0 L O 3 0 = O 0 >- .- Vf `- O v O O O � U) O lfl v1 a1 GJ Q L M Mw c� M E 111 OJ to w d- E N i a1 O 00 O C: a1 O E E 0 u O 0 E W O Q1 •— Eo O •- ro u m ou — +� � •- 0 I '- w .91 r > O W Q L' i O c E O a--+ 0 -.,,o O O Ln lD d' to ton 4� 4- 0 a 0 0 L E 0 u