HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 12022003 - C164 elefl
TO: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Contra
FROM: INTERNAL OPERATIONS COMMITTEE -M Costa
DATE: NOVEMBER 3, 2003 County
SUBJECT: STATUS OF IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MULTI-LANGUAGE CAPABILITIES
OF THE EMERGENCY TELEPHONE NOTIFICATION (RINGDOWN) SYSTEM
SPECIFIC REQUEST(S)OR RECOMMENDATION(S)&BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
RECOMMENDATIONS:
1. RECALL that on June 10, 2003, the Board directed the Health Services Department
and the Office of the Sheriff to proceed with the pilot project to provide multilingual
emergency telephone messaging capabilities, to explore the use of public safety
messaging devices as a possible element of a Countywide emergency telephone
notification (ringdown) system, to explore the use of fines as a potential funding
mechanism for associated costs, and to report back to the InternalOperations
Committee.
2. RECOGNIZE that the new emergency telephone ringdown system,to be implemented in
early 2004 will be capable of sending emergency messages in multiple languages.
3. RECOGNIZE that as a potential supplement to the new emergency telephone
ringdown system, a new product called a "public safety messaging device"that can
deliver emergency messages in many languages is now available, and would obviate
the need to maintain an expensive database of languages spoken'at each household.
4. DIRECT the Health Services and Sheriffs departments to proceed with the testing of
the multi-language public safety messaging device to determine its applicability in the
County's emergency notification system, fully evaluate both the current pilot project and
the new device to determine which provides the best solution for the County, and report
back to the 2003 Internal Operations Committee in January 2004 with the preliminary
results of the test.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The costs of conducting the test will be funded through grants received from the California Air
Resources Board and the Bay Area Air Quality Management District Board.
CONTINUED ON ATTACHMENT SIGNATURE:
RE
COMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATORER COMMEN MTI NOF BOARD COMMITTE
APPROVE OTHER
SIGNATURE(
}S: _ �G. � -. �-�2-��.._----
j
AY ! EMA, CHAIR FEDERAL D. GLOVER
ACTION OF BOARD ON December 2, 2003 APPROVE AS RECOMMENDED X __.OTHER
VOTE OF SUPERVISORS I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS A TRUE
AND CORRECT COPY OF AN ACTION TAKEN
X UNANIMOUS(ABSENT, None 1 AND ENTERED ON THE MINUTES OF THE
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON THE DATE
AYES: _ _ - --NOES: SHOWN.
ABSENT: ABSTAIN:
ATTESTED: DECEMBER 2,2003
CONTACT: JULIE ENEA (925)335-4077 JOHN SWEETEN,CLERK OF THE BOARD
OF SUPERVISORS AND COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
CC: INTERNAL OPERATIONS COMMITTEE STAFF
LEWIS PASCALLI,HAZMAT PROGRAM MANAGER
MICHAEL KENT,HAZMAT OMBUDSMAN
LIS KLUTE,SHERIFF'S EMERGENCY SERVICES DIVISION
LAOTION ORGANIZING PROJECT,FAX(540)238.4572
13� 1 7
BY Vd PUTY
Mufti-Language Emergency Messaging Capabilities November 3, 2003
internal Operations Committee Page 2
BACKGROUND:
On December 13, 1999, the Internal Operations Committee was asked by the Board to
receive updates from, and provide additional direction to, the Health Services Department on
the status of implementing the multilingual capabilities of the Community Alert Network, the
current provider of emergency telephone notification services to the County. The IOC has
overseen, and received regular reports on, the progress of the project. Costs of the project
are funded completely by outside grants.
During the course of the project, responsibility for managing the emergency telephone
notification (ringdown) system was transferred from the Health Services Department to the
Office of the Sheriff. Since the transfer, the Health Services Department and the Office of the
Sheriff have worked collaboratively on obtaining and providing emergency notification
services. Recently, the Board of Supervisors approved the implementation of a new
telephone ringdown system in early 2004 that is capable of delivering emergency messages
in multiple languages.
The multi-language pilot project involving the Laotion community, begun in March 2401, has
been led by Michael Kent, Hazardous Materials Ombudsman. The project involved gathering
data about the languages and dialects spoken at each household within the target Laotian
community, and building a database of this information for use by the emergency telephone
ringdown system. Funding commitments were received in the amounts of$100,000 from the
California Air Resources Board and $40,000 from the Bay Area Air Quality Management
District Board. Mr. Kent worked with the community and affected agencies on this project
and provided progress reports to the Internal Operations Committee in March, May, August
and December 2001, in March 2002, and in June and November 2003.
On March 4, 2002, Mr. Kent provided our Committee with a draft work plan developed by
Phaeng Toommaly, the Project Coordinator hired from within the Laotioncommunity to help
facilitate the project. The immediate goals for the project in March were to complete the work
plan, hire and train outreach workers, develop a database for managing the information
collected through outreach efforts, and develop outreach materials. In December 2002, the
IOC reviewed the updated work plan and asked for a six-month update in 2003.
In June, 2003, the IOC received a report prepared by Lewis Pascalli, Hazardous Materials
Program Manager, providing a comprehensive history of the department's efforts to
implement a system that is capable of communicating emergency messages in the language
spoken at each home contacted. Mr. Pascalli advised that the biggest challenge
encountered in the project was the maintenance of information about what language is
spoken at each home. In any system that relies on a central database of information, it is
essential that the data be kept accurate and current.
Concurrently, in the course of researching emergency telephone notification systems, the
Sheriffs Department was introduced to a new device that connects to an',ordinary telephone,
detects the special frequency of emergency messages, and can announce an emergency
situation or an "all clear" signal in any language specified without the resident having to pick
up the receiver. At staffs first assessment, the new device has the potential for being placed
in any household or business in the County for the purpose of receiving emergency
messages. Since the use of such a device, if it can perform as described, would obviate the
need for maintaining a central database, our Committee believes it is important to fully
evaluate both the current pilot project and the new device to determine which provides the
best solution for the County. The IOC will also consider the BAAQMD's policy that fines for
violations of air quality standards be applied to help communities affected by reduced air
quality, as a possible model for funding expenses related to a Countywide emergency
messaging solution.
The Laotion Organizing Project (LOP), at our.lune 2 meeting, indicated that it fully supports
the County's efforts to look at all potential solutions and will continue to actively participate in
the County's pilot project.
Multi-Language Emergency Messaging capabilities November 3, 2003
Internal Operations Committee Page 2
At our November 3, 2003 meeting, the Health Services and Sheriffs departments requested
authorization to proceed with a test in December of this device in 900 households within the
Laotion community, which has been participating in the multi-language pilot project. The test
will involve community outreach and education, installation of devices, and a follow-up
evaluation. The costs of conducting the test include staff to conduct the outreach and
education, the devices at$35 each, and certain telephone company charges. These costs
will be funded through grants awarded by the California Air Resources Board and the Bay
Area Air Quality Management District Board, and will require no additional County funds.
Our Committee recommends that the Board authorize staff to proceed with the test and report
back to the 2003 Internal Operations Committee in January 2004 with the preliminary results.