Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 02262002 - SD4 SDA THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA Date: February 26, 2002 Matter of Record On this date,the Board viewed a PowerPoint slide show presentation prepared by the Evans/ McDonough Company for the Health Services Department on the results of the various community surveys that were conducted in the areas affected by recent chemical releases. The fallowing suggestions and comments were made by the Board. I. Based on the report Supervisor Gioia suggested staff come back with recommended strategies,to increase public understanding of the system, and work with Community Awareness and Emergency Response Board and the Office of Emergency Systems in various cities. Supervisor Gioia also noted it would be appropriate to acknowledge the current efforts under way, as specifically targeted towards the Laotian community as part of an environmental grant, and contemplate using the knowledge gained to assist tither foreign language populations. 2. Supervisor Gerber indicated the importance of discovering whether the people were aware they should remain indoors and did they knowingly ignore the warning. 3. Supervisor Glover noted a need to focus on educating people on the cultural make-up of the various communities in order to have effective strategy and planning. 4. Supervisor Uilkema stated her desire for examination and information of the correlation between the warning sirens and the resulting behavioral responses and how notification of the"all clear"can occur. THIS IS A MATTER FOR RECORD PURPOSES ONLY NO ACTION WAS TAKEN REQUEST Tib 8VtXK FORM (THREE (3) MINUTE LIMIT) 4 Complete this form and place it in the box near the s' rostrum before addressing the Board. Name: Phone: Address; .' '4/ City; 2 am speaking for myself or organization; ' ' zs S" rs a N (twin*of organisation) ECIC ONE: I wish to speak. on Agenda Item ' ` Date; My comments will be; general for against I wish to speak on the subject of 1. 4o not with to speak but leave these comments for the Board to consider: � � Inco � Contra Costa Health Services Presentation of survey results Prepared for: Contra Costa Health Services Prepared by: Evans/McDonough Company Contra Costa Health Services Presentation of Survey Results Propared for: Contra Costa Health Services Evans/McDonough Company, luc. February 2002 EK Sad*t EwonV?Ad)0n0UW cn. Methodology ■ Telephone survey Equilon a Random selection of Incident date:October 17, residents and;businesses in 2001 the activated and Day:Wednesday appropriate CAN Database Beginning time: 9 am ■ Respondents who were at Ending time. 12 noon the location on the day and Incident place: Martinez date between the time interviewing conducted beginning and time ending October 19-22,2001 were interviewed Total n=518 ±4.2 • Trained,Professional r Residential n=448 Interviewers " Business n-70 NC Skde x Methodology i Golden Eagle • Chevron ■ Incident date:January 26, ■ Incident date:January 31, 2002 2002 Day: Saturday a Jay:Thursday Beginning times.2 pm • Beginning time:2 pm Ending time:4 pm • Ending time:4 pm • Incident place: Martinez • Incident place:Richmond Interviewing conducted • Interviewing conducted January 29-February,5,2002 February 2-February 8,2602 Total n--663;±3-8 • Total n=623,+3.9 • Residential n=613 ■ Residential n=503 ■ Business n=60 • Business n=120 a Evgo Ca,. Community Warning System { (Mot incident specific) £ Heard 0 Haven't tw adlOK 100% s0% so% 40% 20% 0% Egwlon Gokien Chevron Egdlon Goklon Chevron 10117101 Eagle 1131102 10117101 Eagle 1131/02 1126/02 1126102 Residen dal Business Baa wa�co« ,ea. 2 Heard Sirens Before (Not incident specific) Heard a Haven'#tmwd/DK 100% 80% 60%- 40%- 20%. 0%40%20% 0% Egullon Golden Chevron EgWbn Golden Chevron 10/17101 Eagle 1/31102 10/17/01 Eagle 1131/02 1126/02 1126102 Residential Business sbee s Evan~)Wo gh fa. Aware of the type of emergency the sirens signal (Nat incident specific) Eyes M to/DK 100% 80% M_ 60% 40%- 20%- 0%-] 0%20%0% Egdbn Golden Chevron Eglrilon Golden Chevron 10/17/01 Eagle 1131/02 10/17/01 Eagle 1/31102 1126102 1126102 INCResidential Business 81408 Eve Ca. 3 Type of emergency the sirens signal. Residential ENot incidel�t specific) _ ) __... Egtalon IGoideon Eagle.Chevron ..... ._ . -............ Atmospheric poVubom t3 35°°._.. Commrtsrity alec#J'f=aiv r spy 12 '17 8 Refinery Fire Refinery ChemicaVio3do l4 _. Slaeher m place 9 8 7 Should close windows/doors $ 6 !4 Refiicry.--. 7 1 ....... _ Shatrid ggolStay nsxlc 7 5 6 ALusnfSeveralla�ngblascEhl3astleliorn S 21 28 Fox'8hei6�Psoblern at slxe8 ':6 3 1 Refinery Spin.__. .....: Iiaazardaus xr�sterialsfTcacic 4 23 26 Refaxery F.xpic�scan 4 Turn on radio Jbr"rmatiom 3 2 2 .. . .. .. Test a#rrmlPxsctce arm .2 _.. .. 1 _..... 2 . ....... Wait&ar call with�tntetions l 1 1 .2 t know 2 § 2 (Asked of those who know what kind of emergency the sirens signal)K 9th 7 EVOMWOMOUGh Co. Type of emergency the sirens signal: Business (Not incident specific) Egirion Golden Eagle Chmvron _. For Refinery.. ..A ..Atmospheric 1�lon 41% .trn:;rap'. __.. .kni_... ... _.., 6 28% .. Caxtrwmnxrty alert 10 19 .11 Refine Fire 15 - ry.. _....__. 12e�rxery ChemicaVTaxlc 8 Shelter in place 8 3 8 Shoub3 close windows/doors 2 - 2 Refetery Leak_._ 6 1 .. �__ ShouldOlStay lase 4 3 I ifSeveral'lon blast------ stlelllorn 6 28 28 Problem at reffiexy 4 _._...._. Refinery Spill4. ........ - ... 1laz rdaua rlalslla a25 ;20 Refinery Explosion 8 _ Turss on racltt>>3�r rsrmratioa 4 3 Test aJannR'tsctie a atann 2.. 1 Wait frsr call with inshructium►s 3 Natural disaster 4 3 ...___. 4 (Asked of,those when know whatkind of emergency the sirens signal) SIM e Evena�c�nau�ca, 4 Appropriate action when sirens are heard: Residenti L Not incident st ecif Equllon„1 hoiden Eagle Chevron hose w�nmdowaidoor�lweuts 70'l0 _. 'Stay iwide/DonI go oa wie 3 30 3t1 .. _..: Shiehertu placelCo to shelter 3b IS 13 _..._. .. .. .. Tuna on radio for info is 14 i i ........ Slad cll'air 8... . 3 .. Tuan on W fort fvnuatiou 7.__ 4 6 v.. . 6 .9 2 Wait for"All deat�' 3 3 _ 1 Waft for can"Minstructions 3 2 lend cwt fiat'so on..... 2 2 Dou't nse tele�une, 1 1 1 1Swacua�e awe area 1 fl Tanic/cA911 1 Be crefaiJPt on gas meek U . IJ�'t 3 .:__ .. _... (Asked of those who know what kind of emergency the sirens signal) s E"MM:DMOUO CO, Appropriate action when sirens are heard: Business Not rr gkidgqt s etc �.� L _.tom+_..L _....__ -_._. __. EquHon Golden Eagle Chevron .. ... ... 56°l.. ...._ ClosrxIdaoestvcuts 56°fo 41°fo . Stag insnleliDowt go ouiide 31 34 31 Shelter in place/Go to shelter 27 22 18 .- ...._.. __. . Turn on radio'for h& tlaa ��. 6 12 Slulteff air 13 25 4 ... . Turn on TV foriufos°amtios� 2.... _.. 2 .Bring pets in.... Wakfor"Allclese 6 9 Walt for call frith inshwfions 3 �sd out TANt's going on 1 __ .......... Dou'tuse We phone 21 . Ewac to baiWiasgl ave area 4 6 3 1'auirlCall 911 Be atref fflut on gasnwk 2- 6 1 Don't know lr.- .. (Asked of those who know what kind of emergency the sirens signal) SNOW Evattkxwt:�s#;c. 5 Aware of the incident Aware m unaware 100% soy, 60% 40% 20% 0% EgUion Golden Chevron Equilort Golden Chevron 10117/01 Eagle 1/31102 10/17/01 Eagle 1131102 1/26!02 112$102 EK Residential Business + EvrkrmUO:Ca. When you heard about the incident While It was happening ill Ai#er,but later that day Following Clay Ei Other/DK Unsware 100% so% s0% 40% 20% 0% EgOlon Golden Chevron EgUlon Golden Chevron 10/17101 Eagle 1131102 10117101 Eagle 1131102 1126102 1126102 Residsntlal Business Side 12 r CV. ',, Learned about the Incident (Residential) Equbn I Golden Eagle Chevron Heard the situ; 390/0 36% Heard it on the radiD 19 9 is .: - CA zzysbetzsu&>mad caEhriege 28 3{# 31 Saw/Heard on televiBim 18 12 14 Sarrecrne card me 16 22 13 Saw/Smelfedsonrdting t i3 2 3 . CountylCouriyHealfhL partawnt 3 i 0 Neighbor/Friacane over 2 Refinery vrmb eeiCalled reftry 1 Sonvom told rte i - Police or fire depart neat inb..mr.ed me i infenet�Weh 0 4 . ..... Heard heir c ptc _._.. � ....__... .. .. Giber . 9 ._...... . ........... . i Don't know 1 2 EW (Asked of those who were aware of the incident white it was happening) X13 EVWWMcfXnwU9h.Co: I _ Learned about the incident (Business) Eauilon Golden Eagle Chevron. Heard the sie 33% 49% 79°fa Heard i on d e sada 16 z4 :16 _. CAN;:;ya►rtarua6edcasY�rrreearxe.. '35 32 Saw/Heard f an Ickvisian 13 - 4 .. Sarneoree called me 8 } .12 . Sawtsniekd dome ttirIA uanual 26 ...-_... .... ..... CauntyfCauuty tteailit 1fartment ,... _ _. 1. ..... N /Frserrci carne over _ - _ 12efi+isexy erra2ayeelCa➢ed refitxry.., 3. Sonwom told tm 11 Police or fie depammut i&med Im - lyderhedWela 2 2 heard hefcaprers - _ C) 19 2 Don't know_.. _ y EW (Asked of those who were aware of the incident while it was happening) Ski*U E+�pt3awtgyrGa. 7 Heard Sirens/CAN (Residentiao Yes m Notf3K 0 Unaware during 100% 8096 60% 40% 20%, 0 Equilon Golden Chevron Equilon Golden Chevron 10117101 Eadie 1131102 10117/01 Eagle 1131102 1126/02 1126102 EK Sirens CAN X18 E Co. I Heard Sirens/CAN (Business) 10096 Yes mwotok m Unaware during 8096 80% 40% 20% 096 Eq€bn Golden Chevron Egdlsn Golden Chevron 10117/01 Eagle 1131102 10117/01 Eagle 1/31102 1/26102 1126102 Sirens CAN Side 18 8 Stay indoors Uuraflon M Pwt M did not 0 Unawwo during 100% 60% 40% 20% 0% EgUion Golden Chevron Egtilon Golden Chevron 10117101 Eagle 1131102 10117/01 Eagle 1131102 1126102 1126102 Moll Pntiat Business BY+b 97 E Co. i Learned the incident was saver(Residential) f EQUIon 1Golden Eagie Chawon. CAN systersY�tFttxYet1 caIlhssage 43°l0 52°10 41°ln ... Heard I on theradio 20 19 14 SawtStea�ditoixte i20 t5 20 Surneaneoaliesia� _ _. i32 21 1� Heald the Brans 9 12 23 Ttn _ ixre had lm.�! '4 2 � Sdsoot '3 C4nntlCataYYtieallhl3 x ?. d _... Sn-vke W 4;k-areidl4.4MW OK 2 StawJS�lbd txntst�el ,1 1 gbceA5 &Partrrcft H]"T41— TtefaseaY,�kb#--'GreIII.r,y ? (Asked of those T)tin'rJllerra ixxtd 7 who were aware mwWob 0 "t} of the incident) Didn't 4'afe/4{IC{SI' tint W8S 61X51' .-f) 0 i . .;. A#e SozlFnea�d cmne 4ruet 0 Soinoti]tee Wki Bre whxe Iwas ticrr,t kmw. -2 I 2 IC Mde 1$ Eva� Co. 9 r Learned the incident was over (Business) i Equaon .pollen Eagle Chevron CAN gstem(mt omated 58% 58% .. 4I°A, _. Heardi on the radio 2S 27 23 -. ......... . Sawllteffid#on television 5 on 3 t p Someone caller/me_... i S 9 I 6.. __ .. HaNd the sirena As 30 15 _.. Thou¢enwM time had passed 3 S ScTiool CocuiytCt�untyHeaNhbeparnx�rt 3 - smoke bad ckaredfL ook�6 3 . ..... Sawtuatrelled samettmtg 1"Mual P©lice or fire x.fom..ed me _ ..... (Asked of thoW Ddn`t/P7ever heard 2 who were dLVE .4 of the incident} Didn't cweldtdn t du*it was over Net /Frad carne over EKScmnone takl Ire where I was 3 _. 77an t krww 3.. _ 5 Me Ewa /co. �v E r "All Clear" Phone Message � I 100 Received M Did not receive D Unaware during +t9 Tt t 80% .' so%- 40% 20% 0% Egtalon Golden Chevron Equilon Golden Chevron 10117101 Eagle 1/31/02 10/17101 Eagle 1/31/02 1126102 1126102 Mer Rioaao;Idondal Bush>ess SIm 20 �wn�MieCkxwu�+co. 10