HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 02021993 - 2.2 r
2. 2
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
Adopted this Order on February 2, 1993 by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisors Powers, Smith, Bishop, McPeak and Torlakson
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
---------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------
SUBJECT: Report Of The Public Works Director On Road Improvement
Agreement For Subdivision 59461 Hal Porter Development
Company, Oakley Area.
IT IS BY THE BOARD ORDERED that the consideration of the report of
the Public Works Director on the Road Improvement Agreement for
Subdivision 5946, Hal Porter Development Company, in the Oakley area
is CONTINUED to February 9, 1993 .
I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of
an action taken and entered on the minutes of the
Board of Supe s re on the date shown.
ATTESTED: A.a
PHIL BATCHELOR, lark of the Board
Supe ors and n Administrator
o
By ,Deouty
cc: Public Works Department
Community Development Department
County Counsel
F
.f5'4�7;•SiC :,d� :,�,`? r1Q z7"�'!4 i?i'..l. '�G',tin...
J
TO: BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
FROM: J. MICHAEL WALFORD, PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR
DATE: February 2, 1993
SUBJECT: Letter From Oak Builders, Incorporated Requesting The County To Assign Interest In
Bond To Them
SPECIFIC REQUEST(S) OR RECOMMENDATIONS) &BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
I. Recommended Action:
ACCEPT recommendation of Public Works Director to remain neutral in negotiations between
Hal Porter Homes and Oak Builders, Incorporated and ACCEPT the improvements for
Subdivision 5946 as complete.
II. Financial Impact:
There will be no financial impact to the County.
III. Reasons for Recommendations and Background:
Subdivisions 6922 (Oak Builders, Incorporated) and Subdivision 5946 (Hal Porter Homes) were
both conditioned to improve the intersection of Highway 4 and Laurel Road to provide a
separated left-turn pocket for southbound traffic on Highway 4 and westbound traffic on Laurel
Road. The Conditions of Approval for either subdivision did not provide for reimbursement to
the other subdivision. Subdivision 6922 constructed the improvements to Highway 4 and would
like to be reimbursed by Subdivision 5946. Public Works has maintained that this is a private
matter between the two developers.
Continued on Attachment: X SIGNATUR
i
_ RECOMMENDATION OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
_ RECOMMENDATION OF BOARD COMMITTEE
APPROVE OTHER '
SIGNATURE(S):
ACTION OF BOARD ON APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED OTHER
VOTE OF SUPERVISORS
UNANIMOUS (ABSENT
AYES: NOES:
ABSENT: ABSTAIN:
MM:fp
c:BO\bo2.t2
Orig. Div: Public Works (E/S)
Contact: Melissa Morton, 313-2347
cc: CAO
CDD
Hal Porter Homes (via PWD/ES)
Oak Builders, Inc. (via PWD/ES)
-paseelaj eq jou pinonn puoq a41
:uollod and}e aN Jo seouen esuoo 'Al
•uollnlosaj elejedes Aq eleldwoo se peldeooe eq pinonn 9t,69 uolslnlpgns
jolt peoLl lajne-1 pue t, Aenn46IH 10 uolloasjalul 84118 sluawanojdwl 841 'sjnouoo sjoslnjadnS
10 pjeog 841 11 quewaaj6e eslwojdwoo a 6u14oeej uI sjadolanep onnl eq� of Inldla4 eq Aew
1841 uollewjolul AUe apinojd of algellene Inq 'leilneu ulewaj of 4slnn am Ie41 pelels osle je1191841
'eUll to lno lou seen sjeplln8 )leo Aq palllwgns ejn6ll OZ'S LL`6L L$ a41 'palluanun 46noglle 1841
palels jallal eU1 -)Ijonn e41 ejeldwoo of swell ja410 to uolllppe e41 pue suejl1ea Aq pelsenbaj
sa6ueyo apnloul lou PIP alewllse puoq leul6ljo 841 legl Ino pelulod seen II 'sawoH jaljod
IeH to Mon8H uqor of luempedea s)ijoM ollgnd 841 w04 L66 L '9 L jegweoea pelep jaiia) A8
-sjadolanap 841 uaannleq Ino paMjonn eq p1no4s sluawanojdwl 841 to 6ulje4s Isoo 9416ulnlonul
sluawaaj6e Ile 1841 peulelulew Iuawljedea sMioM ollgnd Ni 'uolllpuoo enoge a41 Aq pajlnbaj
ue41 sluawanojdwl ejow jel papnloul (9je4s ,sawoH iev0d IeH Senn s141 10 6L'Z£0`LZ L$)
OZ'S LL'6L L$ 10 ejn6ll a411e41 pejeedde 11 'uo1llppe ul '000'ZS$ eq of pelewllse sena lunowe
s141 '.sluewanojdwl uolloesjelul 841 apnloul Aluo of peonpaj sena 000`OZ£$ to puoq Ieul6ljo
841 ajolaja4l 'uollsenb ul uolloesjalul 841 01 sena sawoH jaljod IeH 10 :ped 841 uo uolle6llgo
6ululswaj 841 pue palaldwoo ejann peod lajne-1 to 6uluepina a41 se llem se Meeja 4sjew jano
96pljq etal of suolle ipo a411841 palels sena 11 'L66 L 'L Isn6ny to jallal ,sime-1 -iIN uI paluesajd
senssl 841 to ewos paguelo luampedea sMioM ollgnd 841 'L66 L '£L Isn6ny pelep jenel A9
•sluaujanojdwl aso41 jol i(Illlglsuodsej j1e41 eq of
A4unoa a41 Ag analleq of pal ejann Ae41 legm to sseoxe ul senn 000'6ti$ Aed of 6ulll!m ejann A841
1841 Joel aU11e41 Aes 01 uo Iuann eH '000'6b$ eq of uolle6ligo j1e4110 llwll e41 pajaplsuoo ANI
1841 Pe181s L66 L '8 L tienuer pelep sawoH jaljod IeH 10 MoneH •jVq wojl Aldej pasoloua e41
6L'ZEO'LZ L$ Aed 01 sena sawoH jeljod IeH 'suollelnoleo ,sime-I 'jvq jepun 841
woj16u11}lleueq slot to jegwnu uo peseq eje4s Ieuolljodojd to uollsu6lsep a pue sluawanojdwl
to Isoo 841 jot elewllse ue. papnloul 4o14nn. L66 L 'S L tienuer pelep sawoH jaljod IeH 01 jallai
e pasoloua eH -assedwl ue se pazljaloejego e4 Isgm ul suanjalul luawljedaa s)ijoM olignd
e411841 pelsenbej pelejodjooul 'sjeplln8 )leo to slnnal Ijegoa L66 L 'L Isn6nd palep jal}el A8
-Ino 1! ){john of Aenn Iseq ayl sena sjadolanep onnl a41 ueennleq Iuaweej6e ue Ie41 pezlse4dwe
Inq 'sluawanojdwl a4110 6ulje4s lsoo a ssnoslp of leave sjadolanap at4 Is papuawwo09 Senn
11 'olignd 6ullanejl ay1 01 uolldnjslp SS81 epinojd pinoM 4o14nn (ZZ69 uolslnlpgnS) uolslnlpgns
Mau sU1411M uollounfuoo ul euop 6uleq (9t,69 uolslnlpgnS jot) Mionn e41 peuolslnue sMioM ollgnd
•peoH lajne-1 pue V Aenn46!H 10 uo1loesjelul 84101 sluaujenojdwl 841 eleldwoo of pe4 1111s ANI
'ZZ69 uolslnlpgnS to uolledlollue ul peuodlsod uaeq pe4 uolle6llgo 11a41 46no411e 1841 sawoH
jaljod IeH 10 )lonsH uqor pewjolul 1uawpedea s>ljoM ollgnd 841 '686 L 'Z L eunr pelep jallel A8
-Z- abed
£66 L 'Z fuanjga j
914101 PU08.
ul Isojalul u6lssy o1 i(lunoo e41 6ullsenbaa pelejodjooul 'sjapllns Mep wojd jaa-i uo3f ells
d
a, a
OAK BUILDERS, INC.
395 TAYLOR BLVD., SUITE 120 •'=
PLEASANT H ILL, CA 94523 R E C E WE D
(510) 680-7979
A, 2 6 t'79P
1 71
r-_
January 25, 1993
Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors
c/o Clerk of the Board
901 Pine St.
Martinez, Ca. 94553
Attention: Chairman - Tom Torlakson and Members of the Board:
Be: Agenda item #1.9 Subdivision 5946 - Hal Porter Development
Company, Inc.
This letter is to draw you attention to item No. 1.9 Subdivision
5946 of the Consent Items - Hal Porter Development Company Inc.
(Porter).
There has existed a long outstanding dispute between Oak
Builders, Inc. (Builders) and Porter regarding the "cost sharing"
of the Highway #4 improvements at the intersection of Highway #4
and Laurel Road in Oakley. Under their Conditions of Approval,
both developers were required to construct certain common
improvements which included widening the Highway #4/Laurel Road
intersection to provide a separated left-turn pocket for
southbound traffic on Highway #4 and west bound traffic on Laurel
Road. The design and configuration was to be reviewed and
approved by the Public Works Department and CALTRANS. The Public
Works Department recommended that the developers mutually agree
on some form of "cost sharing" of these improvements.
Builders has completed all of these improvements in accordance
with both CALTRANS and Public Works requirements at a cost of
$179,715..20. Porter's prorate share is $121,020.22 based upon
the total number of units in each developers subdivision.
Builders has requested reimbursement from Porter for its (Porter)
proportionate share of these costs. Porter initially agreed to
pay up the bonded amount of these improvements or approximately
$50,000. Currently, however, Porter is refusing to participate
In any amount of "cost sharing" related to these improvements.
On Agenda item No.1.9 is a request to accept as complete the road
Improvement agreement for Subdivision 5946. In conjunction with
this acceptance, you would release Porter's corporate surety bond
in the amount of $50,900. This bond was required by Porter to
Insure that the Highway #4 improvements would be completed.
Since Porter did not complete these improvements nor participate
In the "cost sharing" with Builders as recommended by Public
Works, it is requested that the bond either be retained by the
GENERAL CONTRACTOR
Page 2
Re: Agenda Item #1.9 Subdivision 5946 - Hal Porter Development
Company, Inc.
January 25, 1993
County until such time as this matter is resolved or the County
assign its beneficial interest in the bond to Builders.
Sinely,
Robert J. Lew
Secretary/Treasurer