The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutMINUTES - 07292014 - D.14RECOMMENDATION(S): 1. ACCEPT update regarding efforts to address the approval process of Project Labor Agreements (PLA). 2. DETERMINE that, as PLAs have become a routine aspect of County capital projects, this referral shall be suspended until interest arises in further examination or amendment of the existing policy. FISCAL IMPACT: No fiscal impact. BACKGROUND: Prior to 2008, the Board of Supervisors had a standing referral to the Internal Operations Committee for providing updates on the implementation of the Board’s policy on the use of PLAs in County capital projects. At a November 3, 2008 Internal Operations Committee meeting, the referral was suspended. In 2009, the President of the United States signed an executive order to allow PLAs on federally funded projects, reversing the previous executive order prohibiting the use of PLAs on federally funded projects. Because of this change, the Public Works Department APPROVE OTHER RECOMMENDATION OF CNTY ADMINISTRATOR RECOMMENDATION OF BOARD COMMITTEE Action of Board On: 07/29/2014 APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED OTHER Clerks Notes: VOTE OF SUPERVISORS AYE:John Gioia, District I Supervisor Karen Mitchoff, District IV Supervisor Federal D. Glover, District V Supervisor NO:Candace Andersen, District II Supervisor Mary N. Piepho, District III Supervisor Contact: Steve Kowalewski 925-313-2225 I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of an action taken and entered on the minutes of the Board of Supervisors on the date shown. ATTESTED: July 29, 2014 David Twa, County Administrator and Clerk of the Board of Supervisors By: June McHuen, Deputy cc: Steve Kowalewski D.14 To:Board of Supervisors From:Julia R. Bueren, Public Works Director/Chief Engineer Date:July 29, 2014 Contra Costa County Subject:Update on County’s Experience with the Project Labor Agreements BACKGROUND: (CONT'D) began experiencing difficulty in getting federal approval for the use of PLAs on federally funded transportation projects. No other projects were affected by the change in federal policy. Because of this change, staff brought the issue back to the Internal Operations Committee to discuss and request direction from the Committee on how to proceed on implementing the policy. Since 2009, the issue of implementing PLAs on federally funded transportation projects has been discussed at several Internal Operations Committee meetings. At the April 7, 2014 Internal Operations Committee meeting, Public Works staff presented additional information on the progress made in resolving the issue of approval of the County’s Project Labor Agreements by federal agencies. The difficulty in implementing the Board of Supervisor’s PLA policy was specific to federally funded transportation projects that required Federal Highway Administration and Caltrans approval. County staff worked with Congressman Miller’s office to address the federal government’s concern in approving PLAs on County federally funded construction projects. Both Caltrans and the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) need to approve the use of PLAs on federally funded transportation projects. County staff was successful in having two project PLAs approved that included the following projects: • Vasco Road Safety Improvements, Phase 2, $11.0 million, uncertain construction season • Alhambra Valley Road Safety Improvements, $1.5 million, 2015 construction season Upon successful approval of the above two projects, the County submitted an additional three projects, listed below, that are scheduled for construction in the 2014/2015 construction seasons. • San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement, $2.7 million, 2014 construction season • Marsh Creek Detention Facility Bridge Replacement, $1.1 million, 2014 construction season • Orwood Road Bridge Replacement, $5.5 million, 2015 construction season We anticipated no issues with the approval process. However, with a change in personnel at FHWA and some confusion on the most recent PLA language approved by FHWA on the previous two projects, FHWA had requested additional information on each of the projects. After working with FHWA staff and the Contra Costa Building and Construction Trades Council, we were able to provide the information FHWA needed for the approval process. We received official approval of the use of PLAs on all three projects listed above for the 2014/2015 construction season. As we have worked through the process of obtaining approval for the use of PLAs on federally funded projects, we have determined that the process is becoming routine and we have gained a better understanding of what information is expected by FHWA and Caltrans for the approval process. In addition, at the April 7, 2014 Internal Operations Committee, there was discussion as to whether PLAs resulted in any identifiable negative impacts on the overall cost or schedule for delivery of capital projects. Staff reviewed the readily available contract data that is generated by Public Works (attached). The three spreadsheets attached show bid information related to infrastructure projects of all types administered by the Public Works Department. One of the spreadsheets focuses on County building projects, and the other two spreadsheets focus on road, flood control, and airport related projects. Staff determined that there are a significant amount of variables with each project and therefore there is no conclusive data within the spreadsheets that would either support or not support identifiable negative impacts on cost and schedule of projects that are PLA and non-PLA projects. For example, the amount of bids received for each project may be related to the time of year the project is advertised, or the type of work that the project contains, or the contract dollar amount and not necessarily if the project contains a PLA or not. With all these variables, it is difficult to draw any conclusions as to the source for the number of bidders received on a particular project. It is also difficult to draw any conclusions as to the initial bid amounts as compared to the County’s cost estimate since County staff is not part of the contractor’s bid preparation process and therefore would not know whether contractors adjust their bids to account for contracts that include PLAs. Staff can conclude that there are some minor costs to cover staff time to prepare the PLA justification to submit to FHWA on federal projects, however, non-federally funded PLA projects do not require this justification. The additional cost to prepare the justification is negligible. In addition, it does take time for the contractors to execute the PLA, but this has not had a significant impact on the overall schedule as there are other items that are more likely to drive the schedule. The Internal Operations Committee recommended that the item be referred to the full Board as a short discussion item. Staff recommends that the Board accept this report, and suspend the referral for PLAs until interest arises in further examination or amendment to the existing policy. CONSEQUENCE OF NEGATIVE ACTION: Staff would continue to provide updates on the use of Project Labor Agreements to the Internal Operations Committee. CHILDREN'S IMPACT STATEMENT: Not applicable. CLERK'S ADDENDUM Speakers: Greg Feere, Contra Costa Building Trades Council. Written comment received from: Nicole Goehring, Government Affairs Director, Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. Northern California Chapter (attached). ATTACHMENTS Cap Bldg List of PLA Proj PLA Summary Million Dollar Plus Projs Capital Projects Management PLA Projects 2009 - Present PROJECT NAME NO. OF BIDDERS ENGINEER/ARCHITECT ESTIMATE PLA/NON-PLA DOLLAR AMOUNT OF CONTRACT DAYS TO COMPLETE ADA Path of Travel Btwn CCRMC and the Wellness Center, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 6 75,000.00$ Non-PLA 106,240.00$ 30 Antepartum Room Remodel, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 6 349,176.00$ Non-PLA 390,470.00$ 90 Boiler Replacement at 651 Pine Street, Martinez 5 722,000.00$ Non-PLA 656,000.00$ 120 Chiller Replacement at the Martinez Detention Facility, 1000 Ward St., Martinez 8 581,000.00$ Non-PLA 549,086.00$ 90 G Ward Seismic Upgrades, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 5 211,000.00$ Non-PLA 204,953.00$ 90 Homeless Shelter Expansion w/Respite Care Clinic, 2047 Arnold Ind. Way., Ste. D 6 1,368,000.00$ Non-PLA 782,200.00$ 180 Hope House, 300 Ilene Street, Martinez 4 3,200,000.00$ PLA 2,958,000.00$ 330 Improvements to Tamalpais Unit at Old Juvenile Hall, 202 Glacier Drive, Martinez 6 600,000.00$ Non-PLA 466,829.00$ 120 Iron Horse Corridor Tree Planting, Ridgewood Rd., Alamo 3 50,000.00$ Non-PLA 35,800.00$ 60 Kitchen/Cafeteria Equipment Platform, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 3 50,000.00$ Non-PLA 65,427.00$ 60 Kitchen/Cafeteria Seismic Upgrades, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 8 215,000.00$ Non-PLA 203,700.00$ 120 Landscape Improvements at Driftwood Drive, Bay Point 11 530,000.00$ Non-PLA 351,000.00$ 120 Landscaping Park Improvements at Parkway Estates, Richmond 7 85,000.00$ Non-PLA 99,196.00$ 85 Martinez Health Center Blgd. 2 and Modular Demolition, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 11 153,000.00$ Non-PLA 97,711.00$ 60 Martinez Wellness Center, 2500 Alhambra Avenue, Martinez 10 6,000,000.00$ PLA 3,820,000.00$ 360 New Generators at Fire Stations 1 (Walnut Creek), 5 (Pleasant Hill), and 15 (Lafayette)9 260,000.00$ Non-PLA 278,090.00$ 160 Old Discovery House Demolition, 4639 Pacheco Blvd., Martinez 8 75,000.00$ Non-PLA 47,112.00$ 60 Pacheco Creekside Park, Aspen Drive, Pacheco 3 86,000.00$ Non-PLA 75,830.00$ 110 Painting at Hangar Rows at Buchanan Field Airport, 550 Sally Ride Dr., Concord 11 140,000.00$ Non-PLA 165,000.00$ 91 Parking Lot C Expansion, 2500 Alhambra Ave. Martinez 6 340,000.00$ Non-PLA 295,552.00$ 75 Parking Lot E, 2500 Alhambra Avenue, Martinez 10 400,000.00$ Non-PLA 910,000.00$ 75 Pharmacy Remodel, Building One, 2500 Alhambra Ave., Martinez 11 574,000.00$ Non-PLA 217,244.00$ 90 Phase II Remodeling at 50 Douglas Drive, Suite 100, Martinez 2 70,000.00$ Non-PLA 80,600.00$ 62 Power Upgrade at the End of Monte Cresta Ave., Richmond 3 90,000.00$ Non-PLA 74,872.00$ 60 Remodeling of 30 Muir Road, Martinez for DCD 6 7,000,000.00$ PLA 8,942,877.00$ 300 Remodeling of the 7th Floor, 651 Pine Street, Martinez 10 150,000.00$ Non-PLA 150,417.00$ 75 Renovation of 2425 Bisso Lane, Concord 11 527,000.00$ Non-PLA 569,650.00$ 66 Residential Facility for the Homeless, 4639 Pacheco Blvd., Martinez 2 900,000.00$ PLA 1,295,000.00$ 240 Page 1 of 3 Capital Projects Management PLA Projects 2009 - Present PROJECT NAME NO. OF BIDDERS ENGINEER/ARCHITECT ESTIMATE PLA/NON-PLA DOLLAR AMOUNT OF CONTRACT DAYS TO COMPLETE Salvation Army Building Demolition, 13577 San Pablo Ave., San Pablo 4 50,000.00$ Non-PLA 48,000.00$ 45 Sports Court Refurbishment at Livorna Park, Alamo 3 72,400.00$ Non-PLA 66,297.00$ 45 West County Health Center, San Pablo (see below for Trade Packages) * Trade Package 1A - Demo, Earthwork, Grading & Soil 8 228,000.00$ PLA 245,039.00$ 45 Trade Package 1B - Foundation Piles 5 1,100,000.00$ PLA 956,340.00$ 65 Trade Package 1C - General Requirements 3 720,000.00$ PLA 723,644.00$ 468 Trade Package 2A - Structural Steel & Metal Decking 4 1,298,000.00$ PLA 1,588,161.00$ 143 Trade Package 2B - Concrete/Rebar 5 4,500,000.00$ PLA 4,689,600.00$ 169 Trade Package 2C - Elevators 1 480,000.00$ PLA 395,300.00$ 254 Trade Package 3A - Miscellaneous Metal/Stairs 3 575,000.00$ PLA 880,633.00$ 330 Trade Package 3B - Curtain Wall 3 820,000.00$ PLA 779,179.00$ 330 Trade Package 3C - Drywall/Plaster 7 2,200,000.00$ PLA 1,716,875.00$ 330 Trade Package 3D - Fire Protection 5 550,000.00$ PLA 373,850.00$ 330 Trade Package 3E - Plumbing 4 1,600,000.00$ PLA 1,368,957.00$ 330 Trade Package 3F - Mechanical 5 2,800,000.00$ PLA 2,218,000.00$ 330 Trade Package 3G - Electrical 5 3,400,000.00$ PLA 1,924,885.00$ 330 Trade Package 4A - Site Utilities 2 835,000.00$ PLA 483,607.00$ 284 Trade Package 4B - Roofing/Waterproofing/Arch Sheet Metal 4 850,000.00$ PLA 819,700.00$ 272 Trade Package 4C - Earthwork Phase 2 2 275,000.00$ PLA 364,609.00$ 247 Trade Package 5A - Millwork 2 630,000.00$ PLA 699,860.00$ 237 Trade Package 5B - Site Concrete/Caulking 5 520,000.00$ PLA 990,510.00$ 147 Trade Package 5C - Flooring 4 490,000.00$ PLA 423,280.00$ 147 Trade Package 5D - Doors/Frames/Hardware 1 290,000.00$ PLA 314,754.00$ 237 Trade Package 5E - Acoustical Ceilings 3 290,000.00$ PLA 294,295.00$ 237 Trade Package 5F - Painting 2 205,000.00$ PLA 185,555.00$ 237 Trade Package 5G - Landscaping & Irrigation 5 260,000.00$ PLA 466,964.00$ 147 Trade Package 5H - Miscellaneous Specialties 1 170,000.00$ PLA 149,900.00$ 147 Trade Package 5J - Miscellaneous Metals Phase 2 3 165,000.00$ PLA 208,500.00$ 147 Page 2 of 3 Capital Projects Management PLA Projects 2009 - Present PROJECT NAME NO. OF BIDDERS ENGINEER/ARCHITECT ESTIMATE PLA/NON-PLA DOLLAR AMOUNT OF CONTRACT DAYS TO COMPLETE Trade Package 6A - Overhead Coiling Doors & Grills 2 40,000.00$ PLA 55,455.45$ 242 Trade Package 6B - Ceramic Tile 2 45,000.00$ PLA 30,320.00$ 187 Trade Package 6C - Window Shades 1 30,000.00$ PLA 30,170.00$ 187 Trade Package 7A - Building Signage 5 200,000.00$ PLA 154,479.00$ 68 Trade Package 7B - Communication Systems 3 250,000.00$ PLA 80,255.44$ 71 Tree Restoration at the WCDF, 5555 Giant Highway, Richmond 11 245,000.00$ Non-PLA 246,760.00$ 120 West County Detention Facility Tunnel Repair & Drainage Improvements, Richmond 4 80,000.00$ Non-PLA 65,050.00$ 45 *All Trade Package contracts required a PLA because the combined contract amount for the project exceeded $1,000,000 Page 3 of 3 2014 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of subcontractors (based on bid)Comments Union/Non- Union 3/4/2014 2014 2014 Micro-Surfacing 0672-6U2151-14 n/a $894,000 Telfer Highway Technologies (Windsor Fuel Company) $960,212.35 no 45 3 5 Non-Union 3/4/2014 2014 2014 Discovery Bay Asphalt Rubber Cape Seal 0672-6U2150-14 n/a $1,751,000 American Pavement Systems $1,910,779.30 yes 45 2 10 Union 3/25/2014 2014 2014 Slurry Seal 0672-6U2152-14 n/a $462,000 Sierra Nevada Construction $387,007.00 no 40 7 5 Union 4/1/2014 2014 Clearland Drive Curb Ramp 0662-6R4022-14 n/a $64,000 AME Contracting $35,185.00 no 10 5 0 Non-Union 4/1/2014 2014 Camino Tassajara Shoulder Widening 0662-6R4131 HSIPL-5928(105)$750,000 Grade Tech Inc.$726,868.00 no 40 5 7 Non-Union 4/8/2014 2014 Marsh Creek Road Safety Improvements - 1 mile East of Russelmann Park Road 0662-6R4063-14 HSIPHR3L-5928(096)$551,000 Breneman, Inc.$545,032.00 no 40 3 7 Union 4/15/2014 2014 Deer Valley Road Shoulder Widening 0662-6R4099-14 HRRRL-5928(084)$837,600 Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.$687,054.89 no 50 6 8 Union 4/15/2014 2014 Marsh Creek Detention Facility Bridge Replacement 4660-6X4015 BRLO-5928(068)$1,100,000 TCB Industrial $845,139.72 no 85 6 12 Union 4/22/2014 2014 Stone Valley Road Bike Lane Gap Closure 0662-6R4209 n/a $557,000 Breneman, Inc.$521,062.12 no 25 2 5 Union 4/29/2014 2014 Marsh Creek Road Bridge (28C0142) Wingwall Repair 0662-6U4091 n/a $458,200 Engineered Soil Repairs, Inc.$381,713.00 no 50 3 8 Non-Union 5/6/2014 2014 Walnut Boulevard Pedestrian and Bicycle Project 0662-6R4176-14 n/a $396,000 Grade Tech Inc.$541,469.00 no 40 4 9 Non-Union 5/20/2014 2014 San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement 0662-6R4005 BRLS-5928(067)$2,535,000 Granite Rock Company $2,878,914.19 yes 115 8 10 Union 5/20/2014 2014 Pacifica Avenue Sidewalk - Inlet Drive to Mariner's Cover Drive 0662-6R4026-14 SRTSL-5928(112)$351,000 no 30 5/27/2014 2014 Hillside Drive Sidewalk Gap Closure 0662-6U4071 n/a $89,950 no 20 2014 San Pablo Dam Road Walkability 0662-6R4051 n/a $1,300,000 yes 60 C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2014 2013 CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS WITH ENGINEER'S ESTIMATES OVER $1,000,000.00 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments Union/Non- Union 12/18/2012 2013 Upper Sand Creek Basin 7562-6D8518-10 n/a $12,790,500.00 Goodfellow Top Grade Construction, LLC $9,116,885.00 yes 160 11 7 union 2/19/2013 2013 Marsh Creek Road Shoulder Widening 0662-6R4089-13 HRRRL-5928(085)$897,700.00 SCQ Construction, Inc.$847,998.50 no 40 7 12 union 3/19/2013 2013 2013 Kensington Area Micro-Surfacing 0672-6U2180-13 n/a $358,000.00 Graham Contractors, Inc.$284,597.29 no 25 6 4 non-union 3/26/2013 2013 2013 Rodeo Terminal Blend Cape Seal 0672-6U2181-13 n/a $1,175,000.00 VSS International, Inc.$963,840.00 no 40 5 6 non-union 5/14/2013 2013 Contra Costa Centre Infrastructure Improvements 0662-6R4120-12 n/a $624,200.00 Breneman, Inc.$599,605.24 no 55 5 10 union 5/21/2013 2013 2013 Countywide Slurry Seal 0672-6U2182-13 n/a $634,500.00 VSS International, Inc.$696,552.00 no 40 5 5 Non-Union 9/10/2013 2013 Upper Sand Creek Basin Wetland Restoration 7562-6D8518-13 n/a $276,950.00 SMP Services, Inc.$138,041.90 no 1926 8 0 non-union C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2013 2012 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments Union/Non- Union 1/24/2012 2012 Pacheco Boulevard Sidewalk Closure 0662-6R4028 SRTSL-5928(086)$169,862.00 Hess Concrete Construction Comapany, Inc. $109,470.00 no 20 16 3 Union 3/27/2012 2012 Viera Avenue Bike Lanes 0662-6R4088-12 n/a $252,054.70 Grade Tech, Inc.$163,031.08 no 30 4 6 Non-Union 1/24/2012 2012 Contra Costa Centre Wayfinding System 0662-6R4106 n/a $282,310.00 Thomas Swan Sign Co.$291,800.00 no 25 3 1 Non-Union 4/3/2012 2012 2012 Kensington Area Micro-Surfacing 0672-6U2176-12 n/a $256,620.00 Graham Contractors, Inc.$247,030.70 no 25 4 4 Non-Union 4/10/2012 2012 2012 Tara Hills Terminal Blend Cape Seal 0672-6U2170-12 n/a $1,661,760.00 Graham Contractors, Inc.$1,665,448.53 yes 45 3 8 Non-Union 4/17/2012 2012 Market Avenue & Chesley Avenue Railroad Pedestrian Crossings 0662-6R4024 & 0662- 6R4058 STPLR-7500(155) & STPLR-7500(161) $172,773.00 Malachi Paving & Grading, Inc.$149,198.00 no 30 2 2 Non-Union 5/15/2012 2012 Kirker Pass Road Overlay 0662-6R4003-12 STPL-5928(111)$1,450,463.50 Ghilotti Bros., Inc.$1,295,411.00 no*30 10 3 PLA requirement waived. Union 5/29/2012 2012 Deer Valley Road Safety Improvements- Chadbourne 0662-6R4030-12 HSIPL-5958(089)$574,513.00 O.C. Jones & Sons, Inc.$378,520.00 no 25 2 8 Union 6/5/2012 2012 Arlington Avenue Curb Ramp 0662-6R4207 n/a $137,740.00 Sposeto Engineering, Inc.$152,002.00 no 25 4 6 Union 6/19/2012 2012 Los Altos Drive Repair 0672-6U2519 n/a $311,315.00 ETIC, Inc.$218,577.04 no 25 6 13 Non-Union 6/19/2012 2012 Willow Pass Road Safety Improvements- Phase 2 0662-6U4056-12 n/a $202,601.00 Bruce Carone Paving & Grading, Inc. $196,123.00 no 20 3 4 Union C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2012 2011 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments 11/16/2010 2011 Clyde Pedestrian Path 4660-6X4114-10 n/a $415,955.00 FANFA, Inc.$329,685.00 no 40 17 6 Union 1/18/2011 2011 Aspen Drive Curb Ramp 0662-6R4205-09 n/a $65,810.00 James Breneman $38,444.34 no 20 13 1 Union 1/25/2011 2011 Willow Pass Road Safety Improvements 0662-6RU4031 n/a $289,262.00 Lister Construction, Inc.$215,755.00 no 40 7 2 Non-Union 2/25/2011 2011 Vasco Road at Camino Diablo Intersection 0662-6U4012-10 n/a $854,590.00 Grade Tech, Inc.$508,109.50 no 50 9 7 Non-Union 4/12/2011 2011 Market Avenue Sidewalk Improvements 0662-6R4116 n/a $154,765.00 Malachi Paving & Grading $136,408.00 no 20 3 6 Non-Union 4/19/2011 2011 Alhambra Valley Road Safety and Bicycle Facility Improvements 0662-6R4095 HRRRL-5928(083)$894,615.00 Maggiora & Ghilotti, Inc.$712,712.00 no 55 5 7 Union 5/10/2011 2011 Montalavin Manor Pedestrian and Transportation Access Improvements 4660-6X4109-11 RPSTPLE-5928(097)$962,525.00 Grade Tech, Inc.$1,003,010.70 no 60 4 9 PLA requirement waived.Non-Union 5/10/2011 2011 Countywide Bridge Deck Methacrylate 0662-6R4208-11 BPMP-5928(101)$779,242.35 Amland Corp.$461,830.80 no 55 3 1 5/17/2011 2011 Byron Highway Shoulder Widening - Phase 1 0662-6R4021 n/a $651,857.00 RGW Construction $533,758.00 no 40 11 8 Union 5/24/2011 2011 Camino Tassajara Shoulder Widening 0662-6R4023 n/a $534,892.00 Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.$464,054.80 no 35 4 5 Union 6/7/2011 2011 Countywide Arterial Micro-Surfacing 0662-6R4066 STPL-5928(106)$2,020,540.00 Valley Slurry Seal Co.$1,984,110.96 no 45 3 2 PLA requirement waived.Non-Union 6/14/2011 2011 BFA Runway 1L-19R Rehabilitation 4855-4690-SAS-6X5381 AIP 3-06-0050-18 $2,744,720.00 Ghilotti Bros., Inc.$2,858,190.00 yes 25 11 8 Awarded to the low bidder Union 6/14/2011 2011 BFA Security Upgrades 4855-4690-SAS-6X5382 AIP 3-06-0050-12 $245,000.00 Electronic Innovations, Inc.$427,485.00 no 60 2 Union 6/21/2011 2011 Pomo Street Arch Culvert Corrosion Repair 0662-6U4090-10 n/a $99,000.00 Pleasanton Engineering Contractors $68,900.00 no 20 7 2 C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2011 2010 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments 12/10/2009 2010 Vasco Road Safety Improvements- Phase 1 0662-6R4254-09 ESPLDEMO-5928(093)$11,823,367.80 Teichert Construction $8,574,239.05 no 340 12 33 PLA not required.Union 5/13/2010 2010 2010 Discovery Bay Terminal Blend Cape Seal 0672-6U2152-10 n/a $1,702,220.30 Graham Contractors, Inc.$1,653,980.55 yes 40 3 2 Non-Union 6/22/2010 2010 Wildcat Creek Basin 2010 Sediment Removal 7527-6D9715 n/a $287,100.00 Pacific States Environmental Contractors, Inc. $110,300.00 no 20 9 2 Union C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2010 2009 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments 3/10/2009 2009 Iron Horse Trail Pedestrian Overcrossing 0662-6R4078-05 CML-5928(048)$7,744,623.66 Robert A. Bothman, Inc.$6,858,300.00 no 255 9 11 PLA not required.Union 3/10/2009 2009 Delta De Anza Trail Gap Closure 0662-6R4001-08 RSSTPLE-5928(074)$191,530.00 Steiny & Co., Inc.$100,973.00 no 45 7 3 Union 3/24/2009 2009 Bethel Island Road Bridge Replacement 0662-6R4043-02 BRLS-5928(024)$12,269,434.50 C.C. Myers, Inc.$10,278,713.00 no 360 7 28 PLA not required.Union 3/31/2009 2009 Willow Lake Road Sidewalk 0662-6R4086-09 SRTSL-5928(087)$138,990.00 Coastside Concrete $57,250.00 no 25 13 1 6/9/2009 2009 2009 Vasco Road Overlay 0662-6R4069-09 ESPL-5928(091)$2,779,094.00 Ghilotti Construction Co., Inc.$1,996,155.00 no 50 9 11 PLA not required.Union 6/9/2009 2009 Knightsen Avenue Sidewalk 0662-6R4094-09 n/a $81,352.00 Wayne E. Swisher Cement Contractor, Inc. $64,445.00 no 25 14 1 Union 7/28/2009 2009 Montalvin Manor Sidewalk Improvements 4500-6X5470-09 n/a $188,414.00 Malachi Construction $149,818.60 no 35 8 Non-Union 8/4/2009 2009 Marsh Drive Bridge Emergency Repairs 0662-6U4111-09 n/a $33,600.00 Hess Concrete Construction Co., Inc. $30,585.00 no 20 10 0 Union C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2009 2008 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments 10/9/2007 2008 Camino Tassajara Shoulder Widening (Johnston Rd. to Highland Rd.) 0662-6R4020-07 RPSTPLE 5928 (072)$605,376.50 Grade Tech, Inc.$308,800.50 no 50 18 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Non-Union 10/9/2007 2008 2008 Byron Highway Overlay 0662-6R4224-07 STPL 5928 (071)$1,813,430.00 Teichert Construction $1,189,576.00 no 40 10 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 2/15/2008 2008 2008 Slurry Seal 0672-6U2849-08 n/a $788,014.95 Graham Contractors, Inc.$824,660.21 no 40 5 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Non-Union 3/25/2008 2008 Goodrick Avenue Rehabilitation & Widening 0662-6R4250-08 n/a $425,547.25 MCK Services, Inc.$323,290.60 no 35 7 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 4/1/2008 2008 Stone Valley Road Rehabilitation 0662-6R4055-08 n/a $548,636.00 MCK Services, Inc.$322,821.61 no 50 6 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 5/8/2008 2008 Crockett Area Reconstruction 0662-6R4214-08 n/a $448,410.00 MCK Services, Inc.$349,372.69 no 50 8 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 5/20/2008 2008 San Pablo Dam Road Rehabilitation 0662-6R4148-08 STPL-5928(078)$2,465,644.00 Ghilotti Bros., Inc.$2,111,192.10 no 65 3 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 5/27/2008 2008 Alhambra Valley Road Pedestrian Bridge 0662-6R4059-08 n/a $182,953.00 E.E. Gilbert Construction, Inc.$201,409.17 no 35 6 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 6/3/2008 2008 2008 Tara Hills Drive Curb Ramp 0662-6R4211-08 n/a $125,454.00 Malachi Construction $115,809.50 no 25 9 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Non-Union 6/24/2008 2008 York Street Pavement Reconstruction 0662-6R4263-08 n/a $204,175.00 Ghilotti Bros., Inc.$160,649.00 no 35 3 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union NOTE 1: INFORMATION IS IN LONG TERM STORAGE C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2008 2007 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments 2/27/2007 2007 2007 Slurry Seal 0672-6U2853-07 n/a $724,569.65 American Asphalt Repair & Resurfacing Co. $618,886.45 no 45 5 NOTE 1 NOTE 1 Non-Union 3/20/2007 2007 Walnut Creek Area Overlays 0662-6R4209-07 n/a $275,830.00 MCK Services, Inc.$214,400.40 no 30 6 NOTE 1 NOTE 1 Union 3/27/2007 2007 Crockett Downtown Upgrade (Phase I)0662-6R4122-05 n/a $134,500.00 W.R. Forde Associates $175,906.00 no 40 4 NOTE 1 NOTE 1 Union 3/27/2007 2007 Las Trampas Creek Bank Repair Restoration @ Glenside Dr. 7520-6B9M12-07 n/a $302,610.00 James Freethy Backhoe Services $191,724.00 no 45 10 NOTE 1 NOTE 1 Union 4/17/2007 2007 Pacifica Avenue Improvements 0662-6R4106-07 n/a $566,340.00 W.R. Forde Associates $394,001.00 no 40 8 NOTE 1 NOTE 1 Union 8/14/2007 2007 2007 Curb Ramp Project - Appian Way 0662-6R4226-07 n/a $70,836.00 Acequia Cement $58,480.00 no 25 12 NOTE 1 NOTE 1 7/31/2007 2007 2007 Lower Walnut Creek Emergency Interim Protection Measures 7520-6B8345-07 na $4,791,000.00 Pacific States Environmental Contractors, Inc. $2,802,888.20 no 60 7 NOTE 1 NOTE 1, Emergency project.Union NOTE 1: INFORMATION IS IN LONG TERM STORAGE C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2007 2006 Advertise Date Year Construction Started Project Name County Project #Federal Project #Engineer's Estimate Contractor Contract Amount PLA? # of Working Days # of Bidders # of Subs (based on bid)Comments 2/14/2006 2006 Parker Avenue Reconstruction 0662-6R4215-02 n/a $6,538,401.30 Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.$6,009,497.55 yes 250 3 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 2/14/2006 2006 Pacifica Avenue Sidewalk 0662-6R4111-05 n/a $183,957.00 Bruce Carone Paving & Grading, Inc. $215,863.27 no 35 6 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 2/21/2006 2006 Bay Point Overlay 0662-6R4096-06 n/a $568,442.00 MCK Services, Inc.$447,716.00 no 25 5 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 3/21/2006 2006 2006 Surry Seal 0672-6U2867-06 n/a $352,211.55 CPM Co., Inc.$380,038.66 no 35 5 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Non-Union 4/25/2006 2006 San Ramon Creek Bank Restoration @ Fostoria 7520-6B9317-04 n/a $489,350.00 Hess Concrete Construction Co., Inc. $550,840.00 no 40 3 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 5/2/2006 2006 2006 Walnut Creek Channel Desilt 7520-6B9353-06 n/a $514,000.00 Pacific States Environmental Contractors, Inc. $633,963.00 no 35 5 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 5/2/2006 2006 2006 Grayson Creek Channel Excavation 7520-6B9354-06 n/a $357,870.00 FANFA, inc.$616,046.90 no 25 3 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 5/16/2006 2006 Pinehurst Road Retaining Wall Replacement 0662-6U4063-05 n/a $315,243.00 Cumiskey Construction, Inc.$387,140.00 no 55 5 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 8/22/2006 2006 Appian Way at LaPaloma Road Traffic Signal 0662-6R4162-05 n/a $234,840.00 W. Bradley Electric, Inc.$210,969.00 no 50 4 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 6/6/2006 2006 Danville Boulevard (Alamo) Improvements 0662-6R4072-06 n/a $327,485.00 Richard A. Heaps Electrical Contractor $389,765.00 no 45 2 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 6/20/2006 2006 Coggins Drive Pedestrian Crossing 0662-6R4137-06 n/a $49,184.00 Milochek Construction Co.$59,395.92 no 25 3 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 9/12/2006 2006 Alhambra Valley Rd.Embankment Repair 0672-6R6113 & 0672- 6114 n/a $416,629.00 Valentine Corporation $469,268.00 no 55 6 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 12/5/2006 2006 Port Costa Treatment Facility Upgrade 7380-6X9E49 n/a $250,000.00 Valentine Corporation $359,269.00 no 100 4 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Union 11/7/2006 2006 Reliez Valley Road Pedestrian Path 0662-6R4286-05 RPSTPLE 5928 (065)$592,918.50 Grade Tech, Inc.$731,808.20 no 65 6 SEE NOTE 1 SEE NOTE 1 Non-Union NOTE 1: INFORMATION IS IN LONG TERM STORAGE C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\PLA Review for SK 2006 1 of 4 County Project No.Federal Project No.PLA? Number of Bids Union Non-Union Unknown 0662-6R4215-02 n/a Parker Avenue Reconstruction yes Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.Ghilotti Bros., Inc.Ghilotti Construction Co., Inc. 5029 Forni Drive 525 Jacoby Street 246 Ghilotti Avenue Concord, CA 94520 San Rafael, CA 94901 Santa Rosa, CA 95407 7520-6b8345-07 n/a 2007 Lower Walnut Creek Emergency Interim Protection Measures no Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 0662-6R4224-07 STPL 5928 (071)2008 Byron Highway Overlay no 8th Bidder 9TH Bidder 10th Bidder 0662-6R4148-08 STPL 5928 (078)San Pablo Dam Road Rehabilitation no 0662-6R4078-05 CML 5928 (048)Iron Horse Trail Pedestrian Overcrossing no 8th Bidder 9th Bidder 0662-6R4043-02 BRLS 5928 (024)Bethel Island Road Bridge Replacement no UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES Ghilotti Brothers, Inc.Windsor Fuel Company UNION CONTRACTOR? 2006 2007 2008 2009 YES $6,009,497.55 $2,802,888.20 $1,189,576.00 $2,111,192.10 Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder Teichert Construction MCK Services, Inc.Ghilotti Construction Company, Inc. P.O. Box 1118 P.O. Box 5697 246 Ghilotti Ave. Stockton, CA 95201-1118 Concord, CA 94524 Santa Rosa, CA 95404 [265 Val Dervin Parkway, Stockton, CA 95206][865 Howe Rd., Suite B, Martinez, CA 94553] 4th Bidder 5th Bidder 6th Bidder Watsonville, CA 95076 7th Bidder Granite Construction Company RGW Construction, Inc.Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.DSS Company P.O. Box 50085 P.O. Box 2910 P.O. Box 6227 P.O. Box 6099 Livermore, CA Concord, CA 94524 Stockton, CA 95206 [585 W. Beach Street, Watsonville, CA 95077][550 Greenville Rd., Livermore CA][5029 Forni Dr., Concord CA 94520][655 W. Clay St., Stockton CA 95206] Desilva Gates Construction L.P.O.C. Jones & Sons, Inc.J.A. Gonsalves & Sons Construction, Inc. P.O. Box 2909 1520 Fourth St.P.O. Box 6553 Dublin, CA 94568 Berkeley, CA 94710 Napa, CA 94581 [11555 Dublin Blvd., Dublin CA 94568][1100 Soscol Ferry Rd., #2, Napa CA 94558] YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder Granite Construction Company 525 Jacoby Street 9600 Windsor Rd. (P.O.Box 38)585 W. Beach St., Watsonville, CA 95076 San Rafael, CA 94901 Windsor, CA 95492 P.O. Box 50085, Watsonville, CA 95077-5085 (415) 454-7011 (707) 838-9751 (831) 724-1011 YES YES YES $6,858,300.00 580 Crespi Drive, Suite A6-134 UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES YES YES YES YES Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder 5th Bidder 6th Bidder 7th Bidder $10,278,713.00 C.C. Myers, Inc. Robert A. Bothman, Inc.West Bay Builders Flatiron West, Inc.Proven Management, Inc.RGW Construction, Inc.Disney Construction, Inc.Golden State Bridge, Inc. 250 Bel Marin Keys Blvd., Bldg. A 2100 Goodyear Road 712 Sansome Street 550 Greenville Road YES Disney Construction, Inc.Flatiron West, Inc.Golden State Bridge, Inc.Viking Construction Company, Inc.RGW Construction Inc.MCM Construction, Inc. 3286 Fitgerald Road 580 Crespi Drive, # AG-134 Valentine Corporation MCM Construction, Inc. [mail: same as above][mail: same as above][mail: same as above][mail: same as above][mail: P.O. Box 2901, Livermore,CA 94551][mail: same as above][mail: same as above][mail: P.O. Box 9337, San Rafael,CA 94912][mail: P.O. Box 620, North Highlands,CA 95660] 901 Howe Road 111 Pelican Way 6413 - 32nd Street San Jose, CA 95112-2604 Novato, CA 94949 Benicia, CA 94510 San Francisco, CA 94111-1704 Livermore, CA 94550 Pacifica, CA 94044 Martinez, CA 94553 San Rafael, CA 94901 North Highlands, CA 95660 650 Quinn Avenue YES NO Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder 5th Bidder 6th Bidder 7th Bidder 2100 Goodyear Road 901 Howe Road 11315 Sunrise Gold Circle, Suite A 550 Greenville Road 6413 32nd Street Rancho Cordova, CA 95742-6811 Pacifica, CA 94044 Benicia, CA 94510 Martinez, CA 94553 Rancho Cordova, CA 95741 Livermore, CA 94551 North Highlands, CA 95660 [P.O. Box 2948,Rancho Cordova, CA 95741][P.O. Box 1508, Rancho Cordova, CA 95741][P.O. Box 2910, Livermore, CA 94551][P.O. Box 620, North Highlands, CA 95660] UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES YES YES YES YES NO BidProject Name 0%100% 033 3 2 0 10 10 0 100%0% 3 3 0 100%0% 9 8 1 89%11% 7 6 1 Pacific States Environmental HSR General Engineering Granite Construction Company Contractors, Inc.Contractors (DBA HSR Inc.)585 West Beach Street 11555 Dublin Blvd.530 Aldo Avenue (P.O. Box 50085) Dublin, CA 94568 Santa Clara, CA 95054 Watsonville, CA 95077 Fax: 925.803.4334 Fax: 408.562.9957 Fax: 831.768.4021 UNION CONTRACTOR? YES could not reach YES 67%0% 86%14% 0 0% 1 33% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Union Contractor or Not 7/15/2014 2 of 4 County Project No.Federal Project No.PLA? Number of Bids Union Non-Union UnknownBidProject Name 0662-6R4069-09 ESPL 5928 (091)2009 Vasco Road Overlay no 0662-6R4254-09 ESPLDEMO 5928 (093)Vasco Road Safety Improvements- Phase 1 (ARRA)no RGW Construction, Inc. 550 Greenville Rd. (Business) Livermore, CA 94550 0672-6U2152-10 n/a 2010 Discovery Bay Terminal Blend Cape seal yes BUSINESS PHONE:(408) 293-9516 BUSINESS PHONE:(209) 523-0734 BUSINESS PHONE:(925) 427-5266 FAX NUMBER:(408) 293-3633 FAX NUMBER:(209) 523-4927 FAX NUMBER:(925) 427-1216 CONTACT:Che Corlett CONTACT:Shawn Simmons CONTACT:Mike Fain 4660-6X4462 ESPL 5928 (103)SR4BP Segment 3 RHMA Overlay (ARRA)no 4660-6X4109-11 RPSTPLE 5928 (097)Montalvin Manor Pedestrian & Transportation Access Improvements waived 0662-6R4066 STPL 5928 (106)Countywide Arterial Micro-Surfacing waived UNION CONTRACTOR? NO YES 860 Lonus Street 140 Empire Avenue 2010 2011 P.O. Box 6227 P.O. Box 1728 Concord, CA 94524 San Jose, CA 95159 Modesto, CA 95352 Pittsburg, CA 94565 Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder San Jose, CA 95126 Modesto, CA 95354 Pittsburg, CA 94565 MAILING ADDRESS:MAILING ADDRESS:MAILING ADDRESS: P.O. Box 26770 P.O. Box 4760 P.O. Box 1029 Graham Contractors, Inc.George Reed, Inc.Windsor Fuel Company BUSINESS ADDRESS:BUSINESS ADDRESS:BUSINESS ADDRESS: $1,984,110.96 $1,003,010.70 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder Bay Cities Paving & Grading Inc.Grade Tech, Inc.W.R. Forde Associates Ghilotti Bros., Inc. 5029 Forni Dr.10250 Crow Canyon Rd. Concord, CA 94520 Castro Valley, CA 94583 1150 Willow Pass Road YES 987 Hensley St.525 Jacoby Street Richmond, CA 94801 San Rafael, CA 94901 Same as above n/a $1,996,155.00 Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder 5th Bidder 6th Bidder 7th Bidder 8th Bidder 9th Bidder Ghilotti Construction Co., Inc.Sierra Equipment Rental, Inc.Granite Construction Company MCK Services, Inc.DSS Company RGW Construction, Inc.A. Teichert & Son, Inc.Desilva Gates Construction, Inc.Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc. 246 Ghilotti Avenue 8176 Country Road 44 585 W. Beach Street 865 Howe Road, Suite B dba Knife River Construction 550 Greenville Road dba Teichert Construction 11555 Dublin Boulevard 5029 Forni Drive Santa Rosa, CA 95407 Glenn, CA 95943 Watsonville, CA 95076 Martinez, CA 94553 655 W. Clay Street Livermore, CA 94551 265 Val Dervin Parkway Dublin, CA 94568 Concord, CA 94520 Stockton, CA 95206 Stockton, CA 95206 UNION CONTRACTOR? YES could not reach YES YES YES YES YES YES YES $1,705,829.25 $1,653,980.55 $8,574,239.05 Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder 5th Bidder 6th Bidder 7th Bidder 8th Bidder 9th Bidder 265 Val Dervin Parkway, Stockton, CA 95206 1520 Fourth Street 50 Contractors Street P.O. Box 2909, Dublin CA 94568 246 Ghilotti Ave.431 Payran St., Petaluma,CA 94952 5029 Forni Dr. Concord, CA 94520 585 W. Beach St, Watsonville 95076 Stockton, CA 95210-1118 Berkeley, CA 94710 Livermore, CA 94551 10th Bidder 11th Bidder A. Teichert & Son, Inc. (dba Teichert Contr.)O.C. Jones & Sons, Inc.Top Grade Construction, Inc.DeSilva Gates Construction L.P.Ghilotti Construction Company, Inc.North Bay Construction, Inc.Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.Granite Construction Company, Viking Constuction Company, Inc.DSS Company, dba Knife River Construction 655 W. Clay St. Stockton 95206 Mail: P.O. Box 2910 P.O. Box 1118 1520 Fourth Street 50 Contractors Street 11555 Dublin Boulevard 246 Ghilotti Ave.P.O. Box 6004 P.O. Box 6227 P.O. Box 50085 P.O. Box 1508 P.O. Box 6099 Dublin, CA 94568 Santa Rosa, CA 95407 Petaluma, CA 94955 Concord, CA 94524 Watsonville, CA 95077 Rancho Cordova, CA 95741 Stockton, CA 95206-0099 UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES San Ramon, CA 94583 925-687-6666 510-733-0390 510-215-9338 415-454-7011 925-687-2122 510-733-0389 510-215-9867 415-454-8376 Benjamin L. Rodriguez Jr.Eric Remson Donald J. Russell Thomas G. Barr, P.E. UNION CONTRACTOR? YES NO YES YES Low Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder Valley Slurry Seal Company Graham Contractors, Inc.Intermountain Slurry Seal, Inc. 3785 Channel Dr.860 Lonus Street 585 West Beach Street West Sacramento, CA 95691 San Jose, CA 95126 Watsonville, CA 95076 P.O. Box 987330 P.O. Box 26770 P.O. Box 50085 West Sacramento, CA 95698 San Jose, CA 95159 Watsonville, CA 95077-5085 916-373-1500 408-293-9516 831-724-1011 916-373-0183 408-293-3633 831-768-4021 Alan Berger David Graham Scott Youngren 916-709-3138 UNION CONTRACTOR? NO NO NO 89%0% 11 11 0 4 3 1 75%25% 3 0 3 100%0% 3 2 1 67%33% 0%100% TEICHERT CONSTRUCTION KNIFE RIVER CONSTRUCTION GHILOTTI CONSTRUCTION TOP GRADE CONSTRUCTION MCK SERVICES BAY CITIES PAVING GRANITE DESILVA GATES 8 8 0 100%0% 9 8 0 UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder 5th Bidder 6th Bidder 7th Bidder 8th Bidder 1 11% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0% C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Union Contractor or Not 7/15/2014 3 of 4 County Project No.Federal Project No.PLA? Number of Bids Union Non-Union UnknownBidProject Name UNION CONTRACTOR? C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Union Contractor or Not 7/15/2014 4 of 4 County Project No.Federal Project No.PLA? Number of Bids Union Non-Union UnknownBidProject Name 4855-4690-SAS-6X5381 AIP-3-06-0050-18 BFA Runway 1L-19R Rehabilitation yes 0672-6U2170-12 n/a 2012 Tara Hills Terminal Blend Cape Seal yes Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 0662-6R4003-12 STPL 5928 (111)Kirker Pass Road Overlay waived 7562-6D8518-10 n/a Upper Sand Creek Basin yes Of all projects TOTAL: Of projects without PLA 77 69 6 2 Of projects with PLA 20 17 3 0 2013 415-454-7011, Tom Barr 925-449-5764, Robert Fisher 860 Lonus Street 135 S. State College Blvd, Ste 400 2012 Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder 5th Bidder $2,858,190.00 6th Bidder Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.O.C.Jones & Sons, Inc.Granite Construction Co.Vintage Paveing Co., Inc.Ghilotti Construction Co. Inc.Desilva Gates Construction LPGhilotti Bros., Inc.Top Grade Construction, Inc.Interstate Grading & Paving, Inc.Granite Rock Company dba Pavex Construction DivisionRGW Construction, Inc. 7th Bidder 8th Bidder 9th Bidder 10th Bidder 11th Bidder 246 Ghilotti Ave., Santa Rose, CA 95407 11555 Dublin Blvd., Dublin, CA 94568/P.O. Box 2909, Dublin, CA 94568128 So. Maple Ave., So. SF, CA 94080 120 Granite Rock Way, San Jose, CA 95136550 Greenville Rd., Livermore, CA 94550 925-687-6666, Ben Rodriguez Jr.510-526-3424 831-768-4021 525 Jacoby Street, San Rafael, CA 50 Contractors St., Livermore, CA 94551 5029 Forni Dr, Concord, CA 94520 1520 Fourth St. Berkeley, CA 94710 585 W. Beach St, Watsonville, CA 95076 530-795-0132 119 Main St., Winters, CA 95694/P.O. Box 461, Winters, CA 95694 707-585-1221/707-585-1601 925-829-9220/925-803-4263 650-952-7333/650-952-6851 408-574-1400/408-365-9548 YES YES YES YES 925-606-2400/925-961-1925 YES YES YES YES YES YES Graham Contractors, Inc.Western Pavement Solutions International Surfacing Systems YES 3785 Channel Dr San Jose, CA 95159 Brea, CA 92821 W. Sacramento, CA 95691 San Jose, CA 95159 Brea, CA 92821 W. Sacramento, CA 95798 PO Box 26770 135 S. State College Blvd, Ste 400 PO Box 980430 $1,295,411.00 $1,665,448.53 Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder UNION CONTRACTOR? UNION CONTRACTOR? David Graham Anthony Lino Alan Berger NO YES NO (408) 293-9516 (714) 578-9600 (916) 373-2420 (408) 293-3633 (714) 578-9672 (916) 375-1654 Ghilotti Bros., Inc.RGW Construction, Inc.Ghilotti Bros., Inc. 525 Jacoby Street 550 Greenville Rd.525 Jacoby Street San Rafael, CA 94901 Livermore, CA 94550 San Rafael, CA 94901 (415) 454-8376 (925) 961-1925 (415) 454-8376 (925) 687-2122 Thomas G. Barr, Vice President Bill Stewart Thomas G. Barr, Vice President Benjamin L. Rodriguez, Jr. Concord, CA 94520 same as above same as above same as above (415) 454-7011 (925) 606-2400 (415) 454-7011 5029 Forni Dr. Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc. (925) 687-6666 Concord, CA 94524 P.O. Box 6227 6th Bidder Ghilotti Construction Company, Inc. 246 Ghilotti Ave. Santa Rosa, CA 94570 same as above (707) 585-1221 (707) 585-1601 Thomas Smith, Estimating Manager 5th Bidder Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc. 5029 Forni Dr. Concord, CA 94520 P.O. Box 6227 Concord, CA 94524 (925) 687-6666 (925) 687-2122 Benjamin L. Rodriguez, Jr. 7th Bidder 8th Bidder 9th Bidder 10th Bidder Ghilotti Bros., Inc.Top Grade Construction, Inc.Bay Cities Paving & Grading, Inc.Vintage Paving Co., Inc. 525 Jacoby St.50 Contractors St.5029 Forni Dr.119 Main St. (415) 454-8376 (925) 449-5875 (925) 687-2122 (530) 795-5734 Thomas G. Barr, Vice President John Looper Benjamin L. Rodriguez, Jr.Robert Nickelson San Rafael, CA 94901 Livermore, CA 94551 Concord, CA 94520 Winters, CA 95694 same as above same as above P.O. Box 6227 same as above Concord, CA 94524 UNION CONTRACTOR? YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES (415) 454-7011 (925) 449-5764 (925) 687-6666 (530) 795-0132 4 4 0 11 11 0 100%0% 3 1 2 101 89.1%8.9% 33%67% 10 10 0 0% 0 89.6%7.8%2.6% 85.0%15.0%0.0% 0% 0 0% 0 0% 2 2.0% 100%0% 990 0 100%0% Lowest Bidder 2nd Bidder 3rd Bidder 4th Bidder Goodfellow Topgrade Construction Da Silva Gates Construction, LP Gordon N. Ball, Inc.Ford Construction Company, Inc. 50 Contractors Street 11555 Dublin Boulevard 333 Camille Avenue 639 E. Lockeford Street Livermore, CA 94551 Dublin, CA 94568 Alamo, CA 94507 Lodi, CA 95240 same as above P.O. Box 2909 same as above same as above Dublin. CA 94568 YES YES YES YESUNION CONTRACTOR? (925) 449-5764 (925) 829-9220 (925) 838-5675 (209) 333-1116 (925) 449-5875 (925) 803-4263 (925) 838-5918 (209) 333-8597 Rick Morales Michael A. Kloos Sophea Sem Jerry Middleton C:\Users\skowalew\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\QBM6FRY2\Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Million Dollar Plus Projects_2012-01-08Union Contractor or Not 7/15/2014 July 27, 2014 Supervisor Mitchoff, Chairman of the Board Contra Costa County 651 Pine St. Martinez, CA 94553-1229 Re: Oppose: D.14 ACCEPT an update regarding efforts to address the approval process of Project Labor Agreements (PLA); and, DETERMINE that, as PLAs have become a routine aspect of County capital projects, the referral to the Internal Operations Committee shall be suspended until interest arises in further examination or amendment of the existing policy, Countywide. Dear Chairman Mitchoff: Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC NorCal) Northern California is a non-profit construction trade association of 500 construction and construction related firms representing 22,000 workers. Many are located in Contra Costa County and have performed work for Contra Costa County. Our members range from some of the largest construction companies in the Bay Area to small businesses with five or fewer employees. Most ABC NorCal members perform commercial, industrial, and public works construction. ABC also operates State and Federally approved apprenticeship programs in several trades and trains 275-300 apprentices per year. ABC supports fair and open competition and increasing opportunities for all workers regardless of their affiliation. Before you make any decision to limit transparency by eliminating yearly public reporting on the progress of the Project Labor Agreement in the Internal Operations Committee, please consider the following: The Contra Costa County Project Labor Agreement language constantly needs to be monitored. You are requiring contractors to sign contracts with unions. Are you concerned about something that will be revealed? This issue is not routine as your agenda item suggests. It continues to be highly controversial. ABC is still getting numerous complaints from its contractors about having to change their business practices in order to bid on PLA projects. Where is your data on local hire and hiring of veterans, women and minorities and improved compliance with State Labor Law? Between 2002 and 2012, an internal audit by ABC NorCal found 78% of Contra Costa County bids were awarded to companies outside Contra Costa County. Only 4% of the total companies that performed work under the Project Labor Agreement could be identified as non-union. The Project Labor Agreement has created a monopoly for union contractors from outside the county. A recent audit of the Contra Costa County New West County Health Center revealed no internal labor compliance was being done on Project Labor Agreement projects. In addition, just 9% of the total hours worked were from West Contra Costa County residents and 28% from the remainder of the county. One contractor, Guarantee Glass, was assessed $104,008.43 for unpaid wages and penalties under Labor Code 1775 and 1813. PLAs do not ensure projects are built on time and on budget. The First and Second Floor Remodel and Parking Lot Expansion at 1650 Cavallo Road, Antioch for the Contra Costa County Employment and Human Services Department built under a Project Labor Agreement was completed 385 days late and $350,000 over budget. The project experienced numerous delays, excessive change orders and liquidated damages. The General Contractor was found in breach of contract for failure to pay bills for labor and materials on the project. As a result, over 26 stop notices totaling more than $1.7M were filed on the project. Two subcontractors filed lawsuits. Many subcontractors and suppliers slowed or cut off the supply of labor and materials to the project, causing the work on the project to progress erratically and at a slow pace. In your August 5, 2003 staff report, you refer to Project Labor Agreements in conjunction with certain large, complex County construction projects involving numerous contractors and employees in different trades, having critical timelines for completion, and requiring a skilled and properly trained workforce to successfully complete the work properly and timely. Project examples include reservoir, wastewater, and other large, complex construction projects. In addition, when this issue is taken out of the hands of elected officials and placed before the electorate, the electorate overwhelmingly supports Fair and Open Competition. Recent examples where Fair and Open Competition prevailed by voters include: San Diego County 76%, Oceanside 54%, Chula Vista 56%, and the City of San Diego Prop A 58%. Nationwide, 21 states have banned the use of PLAs. For these reasons, we urge you to reject D. 14, increase your threshold up to $20M to only cover complex projects and take-up your existing Project Labor Agreement policy in your next Internal Operations Committee meeting and look for solutions that will include the Contra Costa County workforce and benefit the community in its entirety. Please include our opposition in your 7/29/14 minutes. Thank you for your consideration of this request. Sincerely, Nicole Goehring Government Affairs Director Cc: John Gioia, Vice Chair, 1st District Candace Andersen, 2nd District Mary N. Piepho, 3rd District Federal D. Glover, 5th District Julia R. Bueren, Public Works Director/Chief Engineer Steve Kowalewski, Public Works Deputy Director Visit www.thetruthaboutplas.com for the latest news, facts, studies and current information about PLAs before you make any decisions to limit competition for public contracts.