Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 06232009 - D.2 (2)RECOMMENDATION(S): ACCEPT report on the status of the Light Brown Apple Moth (LBAM) infestation in Contra Costa County. FISCAL IMPACT: None BACKGROUND: The LBAM was first detected in Contra Costa County in March 2007. Since that time the infestation has been steadily increasing in density in the core area of the original finds and has spread into other areas of the county. It is now found in all geographical areas of the county with recent finds in east county. LBAM is a pest that is detrimental to the environment of the state of California and has quarantine implications in regard to other states and countries. CONSEQUENCE OF NEGATIVE ACTION: APPROVE OTHER RECOMMENDATION OF CNTY ADMINISTRATOR RECOMMENDATION OF BOARD COMMITTEE Action of Board On: 06/23/2009 APPROVED AS RECOMMENDED OTHER Clerks Notes: VOTE OF SUPERVISORS AYE:John Gioia, District I Supervisor Gayle B. Uilkema, District II Supervisor Mary N. Piepho, District III Supervisor Susan A. Bonilla, District IV Supervisor Federal D. Glover, District V Supervisor Contact: Vince Guise 646-5250 I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of an action taken and entered on the minutes of the Board of Supervisors on the date shown. ATTESTED: June 23, 2009 David J. Twa, County Administrator and Clerk of the Board of Supervisors By: June McHuen, Deputy cc: D. 2 To:Board of Supervisors From:Vincent L. Guise, Director of Agriculture/Weights & Measures Date:June 23, 2009 Contra Costa County Subject:ACCEPT Status Report on the Light Brown Apple Moth (LBAM) in Contra Costa County CHILDREN'S IMPACT STATEMENT: ATTACHMENTS Apple Moth 62309 1 Light Brown Apple Moth Report June 23, 2009 Background: The light brown apple moth (LBAM), Epiphyas postvittana (Tortricidae), is a native pest of Australia. It is also found infesting New Zealand, the United Kingdom, Ireland, New Caledonia, and Hawaii. On February 6, 2007, the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) was informed that LBAM had been detected in a light trap in Berkeley maintained by a University of California Professor Emeritus. The sample was identified by Australian entomologist Dr. Marianne Horak. There were two unofficial detections in this trap, on July 19, 2006 and November 19, 2006. In response to these unofficial detections, delimitation traps were placed in February of 2007, in a 2.5 mile radius around the site. During the first inspection of these traps, LBAM were detected in both Alameda and Contra Costa Counties. In response detection and delimitation trapping continued throughout the Bay Area, with a total to date of thirteen Counties having detections of LBAM. Trapping was extended State-wide. Larval finds were subsequently found in several locations. Following the issuance of a State Interior Quarantine and a Federal Executive Order regulating the affected area, an emergency project was initiated under joint County/CDFA/USDA management operating under Incident Command now based in Moss Landing. Program components include detection trapping, diagnostics, and inspection of commodities, plants in nurseries and growing areas, regulatory, and treatment. LBAM is of particular concern because it can damage a wide range of crops and other plants including California’s prized cypress as well as redwoods, oaks and many other varieties commonly found in California’s urban and suburban landscaping, public parks and natural environment. The list of agricultural crops that could be damaged by this pest includes grapes, citrus, stone fruit (peaches, plums, nectarines, cherries, apricots) and many others. The complete “host list” contains well over 2,000 plant species and more than 250 fruits and vegetables. 2 LBAM Program in Contra Costa County The County Department of Agriculture is involved in two key aspects of activity with LBAM, detection trapping and regulatory enforcement of the quarantine. Both are performed under contract with CFDA with most of the funding provided by USDA. Detection trapping consists of placement and bimonthly inspection of pheromone baited insect traps. These traps are placed at the rate of 5/square mile in all urban areas of the county. Rural traps and traps in cropland areas are also placed by both our department and CDFA. The same traps are also used in a delimitation pattern that consists of 550 traps placed in a ten square mile area when a single isolated moth is found outside of the quarantined area. Delimitation trapping is mostly done by CDFA. Regulatory enforcement of the quarantine area is performed to stop the artificial movement of LBAM to areas remote from infested areas. Activities by the County Department of Agriculture assure that those industries involved in the growing and movement of host material can continue to operate if they meet the quarantine regulations. Growers are required to have a Certificate of Compliance Agreement issue by our department. For retail plant nurseries monthly inspections are performed by our department certifying that the nursery is free of LBAM. These inspections are performed twice each month for production plant nurseries. Growing grounds for farmers that sell at Certified Farmer’s Markets are inspected monthly during the harvest season. Large and small fields, orchards and vineyards located inside of the quarantine area that produce non exempt host commodities must be inspected not greater than 30 days prior to harvest. Nurserymen and some growers are also required to have in place an integrated pest management plan designed to reduce or eliminate moths of the Tortricidae family. History in Contra Costa County Intense quarantine regulatory activities have contained LBAM mostly to a natural spread from initial detection areas. Eradication of extremely small satellite infestations in Santa Barbara and Los Angeles Counties has been achieved using pheromone infused twist ties that disrupted mating patterns of the moth. In Contra Costa County two such satellite infestations, one in Oakley and one in Danville were also eradicated in 2007 using the same technique. Unfortunately, the natural progression of the moth from the core infestation area has overtaken these same two areas as well as all of west, central county and portions of east county that includes Pittsburg, Antioch and most of Oakley. In early June 2009 an isolated moth was found in Brentwood. As stated above the first detection traps were deployed in February 2007 with first finds in the Richmond area of our county on first servicing the traps in March 2007. By April 2007 the entire county was trapped at a rate of five traps per square mile in urban areas. At the end of the first full year of trapping (end of March 2008) a total of 187 male LBAM were trapped, mostly in the core area of West County. Most of the traps in the core area contained zero or one or two moths per servicing with six as the highest moth count in one trap. 3 Contra Costa Light Brown Apple Moth Statistics By City 3/31/08 Number of Moths Found Richmond 108 El Cerrito 33 Kensington 3 San Pablo 4 El Sobrante 4 EBRP (Tilden/Wildcat) 14 Martinez 1 Orinda 3 Concord 2 Lafayette 2 Pinole 1 Danville (Eradicated) 6 Moraga 3 Oakley (Eradicated) 3 Briones 3 Totals 187 (This trap shows two LBAM male moths that was more typical in the core area the first year. The rubber eraser looking item is the pheromone infused bait) 4 By the end of the second full year of trapping (end of March 2009) 3,202 LBAM were trapped. In the core areas of the county it was not uncommon to have per trap moth counts in the 20’s, 30’s and 40’s. One trap serviced had 49 moths. Contra Costa Light Brown Apple Moth Statistics By City 3/31/2009 Number of Moths Found Richmond 1715 El Cerrito 1123 San Pablo 57 Kensington 94 El Sobrante 47 Orinda 23 Martinez 23 EBRP (Tilden/Wildcat) 38 Pinole 10 Concord 13 Lafayette 10 Hercules 10 Moraga 4 Danville 9 Walnut Creek 7 Pleasant Hill 4 San Ramon 2 Crockett 1 Alamo 2 Oakley 3 Briones 3 Rodeo 2 Pittsburg 1 Antioch 1 Totals 3202 5 (This trap shows twenty plus LBAM male moths, typical in the core area the second year.) And as of June 17th, 2009 a total of 5,143 LBAM have been trapped. Contra Costa Light Brown Apple Moth Statistics By City Updated 6/17/09 Number of Moths Found Richmond 2852 El Cerrito 1538 San Pablo 136 Kensington 122 El Sobrante 140 Orinda 74 Martinez 55 EBRP (Tilden/Wildcat) 38 Pinole 38 Concord 24 Lafayette 20 Hercules 16 Moraga 14 6 Danville 11 Walnut Creek 12 Pleasant Hill 7 San Ramon 8 Crockett 6 Alamo 5 Oakley 4 Briones 4 Rodeo 5 Pittsburg 4 Antioch 3 Port Costa 2 Canyon 2 Clayton 1 Brentwood 1 Pacheco 1 Totals 5143 Total moths found in Contra Costa County through June 17, 2009 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 3/9/2007 6/9/2007 9/9/2007 12/9/2007 3/9/2008 6/9/2008 9/9/2008 12/9/2008 3/9/2009 6/9/2009 7 Cities in Contra Costa with greater than 100 moths (6/17/09) 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3/9/2007 6/9/2007 9/9/2007 12/9/2007 3/9/2008 6/9/2008 9/9/2008 12/9/2008 3/9/2009 6/9/2009 Richmond El Cerrito Kensington San Pablo El Sobrante 3 /9 /2 0 0 73/9 /2 0 0 83/9 /2 0 0 9 EBRP (Tilden/Wildcat)MartinezOrindaConcordLafayettePinoleHerculesDanvilleWalnut CreekMoragaPleasant HillOakleyBrionesRodeoSan RamonAlamoAntiochCrockettPittsburgClaytonPort CostaBrentwoodCanyon0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Cities/Areas in Contra Costa with fewer than 100 moths (6/17/09) 8 Total Finds by County 35849 34626 9648 8203 5143 3873 3588 528 60 60 59 15 6 3 1 1 10 100 1000 10000 100000Santa CruzSan FranciscoAlamedaMontereyContra CostaMarinSan MateoSanta ClaraNapaSolonoSonomaSan BenitoSanta BarberaYoloSan JoaquinNumber of moths (logrithmic scale) 9 What does the future hold? As demonstrated in the above charts, the LBAM population in West County has greatly increased in density as it has also slowly moved eastward into Central County during 2008 and now, into East County. Unfortunately, the natural progression of this pest has been virtually unabated since aerial sprays of LBAM pheromones were halted in November of 2007. The California Department of Food and Agriculture and the U. S. Department of Agriculture are the lead agencies charged with LBAM eradication. LBAM will continue to spread until the eradication effort resumes. Before the eradication program can begin, an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) must be completed. A lot of work has been put into the EIR and it is due out by the end of June. It is then subject to a 60 day comment period. The primary method which will be used by CDFA and USDA to try to eradicate LBAM will be Sterile Insect Technology (SIT). This method involves the mass rearing and release of large numbers of sterilized male moths which mate with wild female moths. Other techniques will also be considered (see Appendix I). We will keep up to date information on LBAM on our website. CDFA also has LBAM information on it’s website at http://www.cdfa.ca.gov/phpps/PDEP/lbam/lbam_main.html 10 Appendix I LBAM Eradication and Suppression Techniques That are under consideration for use by CDFA/USDA Sterile Insect Technology (SIT): This involves the mass rearing of insects that are sterilized and then released into the wild populations. Mating that occurs between the sterile male moth and a wild female moth does not produce offspring. Eventually the population of wild moths is depleted resulting in eradication. This technology has been used successfully on Mediterranean fruit fly, pink bollworm and other exotic organisms. Mass rearing of light brown apple moth is underway and field trial releases are expected later in the summer of 2009. Mass eradication-type releases are not anticipated until 2010 or 2011 due to the lead time required to build up the moth colonies that will sustain such releases. The California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) and USDA intend for this to be the primary long term method used for eradication of LBAM. Male Moth Attractant Technique (MMAT): This technique involves strategic spraying of “dots” of pheromone bait mixed with an insecticide (pyrethroid based) on tree trunks and telephone poles. The pheromone mimics a perfume-like scent that female moths emit to attract male moths. The dots are two to four inches in diameter, placed at least six feet above the ground. They are applied at a rate of approximately 4,000 dots per square mile. The male moth is attracted to the pheromone in the dot and when he contacts it, the male is killed by the insecticide. This method breaks the breeding cycle. It is used very effectively on Oriental fruit fly as well as some other exotic fruit fly infestations. Trichogramma Wasps: These are very tiny wasps that are smaller than the period at the end of this sentence. There are two species native to California that may be used against LBAM. Both species lay eggs on many types of Lepidoptera (moth and butterfly) eggs. The wasp parasitizes the egg, causing it not to hatch. These wasps are used in many agricultural situations, especially by organic growers. The anticipated release rate is one million wasps per square mile. The wasps are only capable of flying a couple hundred yards so they stay very close to where they are released. They naturally die out when there is a lack of food in the area. This method may be used to knockdown LBAM populations in areas of very high infestation. Baccilus thurengiensis (Bt): This is a naturally occurring bacteria that is used for Lepidoptera and mosquito larva control. It is commonly used in agriculture, on organically grown crops, and by homeowners. It is applied as a spray. When ingested by larvae, it causes them to stop feeding and die within a couple of days. Bt does not affect 11 organisms other than Lepidoptera. This method may be used in smaller areas in order to reduce very high populations of LBAM. Twist Ties: These are pheromone infused plastic “ties” that are placed at a rate of 400 per acre. The ties are a little larger but similar to that used to close a plastic bag. The pheromone is a synthetic mimic to the perfume like chemical that the female moth emits to attract the male moth. Pheromones are used by organic agriculture and homeowners to control codling moth and some other moth pests and are used in insect traps as a way to monitor moth populations. The twist tie method has been used to eradicate very small satellite-type infestations of LBAM. In Contra Costa County they were used successfully in Oakley and in Danville in 2007. Unfortunately LBAM has since spread by natural progression back into these two areas. Though the twist ties have been effective they are extremely labor intensive. 16,977 were placed by hand in an area about two hundred by three hundred yards in Oakley in 2007. They had to be collected and replaced after 90 days. This method will not work in areas where endemic populations are close by because reinfestation will eventually occur. Aerial Spray of Pheromones: This method will not be used over populated areas. CDFA and USDA may opt to use the method over open areas that are not populated.