HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 08121997 - C111RES THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
Adopted this Order on August 12, 1997 by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisors Uilkema, Gerber, Canciamilla, Rogers
NOES: None
ABSENT: Supervisor DeSaulnier
ABSTAIN: None
SUBJECT:
Approval of Side Letter of Understanding }
with the Physicians' & Dentists' Organization)
of Contra Costa (PDOCC) ) Res. 97/ 446
BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of Supervisors of Contra Costa County
conditionally APPROVES the attached Side Letter of Understanding between
Contra Costa County and the Physians' & Dentists' Organization of Contra Costa '
(PDOCC) regarding economic and other terms and conditions of employment for
1996-98 for those classifications represented by that employee organization. Said
approval is conditioned upon a vote of the PDOCC membership, completed no
later than August 22, 1997, approving the attached Side Letter in full.
Orig. Dept.: Human Resources Department (Kathy Ito @ 335-1785)
cc: Auditor-Controller/Payroll
County Counsel
Health Services Department
Stephen Daniels, MD, President of PDOCC
t hereby Cq"that this is a true and correct Dopy of
�n aotian taken and entered on the minutea of tM
board of Supervtaora on the data;� 17
p dd1j.�
��PHII BATCH OR•Clerk of tho board
of Supervisors and County Admhnistratof
I -. OA
Human Resources
Contra
Costa �.=/ Department
x 'IA1 ,
County � '`� Administration Bldg.
s���� 651 Pine Street,Third Floor
Martinez, California 94553-1292
(510) 335-1764
August 5, 1991 Leslie T.Knight
Director of Human Resources
Stephen Daniels MD, President
Physicians' & Dentists' Organization of Contra Costa
PO Box 1803
Martinez CA 94553
RE: ECONOMIC TERMS & CONDITIONS FOR THE PHYSICIANS' &
DENTISTS' ORGANIZATION OF CONTRA COSTA (PDOCC)
1996-98 MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
Dear Dr. Daniels:
This confirms agreement to submit this Side Letter outlining negotiated wage
agreements and other economic terms and conditions of employment beginning
January 1, 1996 through December 31, 1998 for approval by the Board of Supervisors.
This letter expresses wage and benefit changes and other terms and conditions of
employment, agreed upon between Contra Costa County and the Physicians' &
Dentists' Organization of Contra Costa (PDOCC) which shall be implemented upon
approval by the Board of Supervisors and expressed in a comprehensive
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) which is being prepared. The Tentative
Agreements attached hereto are incorporated herein by reference.
A comprehensive MOU will be finalized by the parties as soon as possible and
submitted to the Board of Supervisors for further approval. Pending such further
approval, the terms and conditions of employment of employees represented by
PDOCC are expressed in the last expired MOU, subject to the terms of this Side Letter.
COALITION AGREEMENTS
1. Wage Increases:
July 1, 1996: 3.0%
October 1, 1997: 3.0% or 2.0% with Tier III retirement
October 1, 1998: 3.5%
2. Lump Sum Payment. The July 1, 1996 increase will be paid in a Lump Sum
Payment to each employee for the months of July 1996 through and including
August 1997, without interest, computed as follows:
Employee regular pay, overtime pay and other earnings ordinarily computed as a
percentage of base pay will be added together for each applicable pay period to
determine the "Retro Pay Base" (RPB). This base will then be multiplied by three
percent (3%) to arrive at the employee's lump sum payment. The payment amount
thus computed will be added to the employee's September 10, 1997 paycheck
where it will be listed separately as a "Lump Sum Payment" and will be subject to
normal tax withholding and retirement deduction requirements.
3. Retirement. Subject to the enactment of enabling legislation amending the 1937
Employees Retirement Act to allow such election, and under agreed-upon
conditions, the County will permit certain Tier II employees to elect a Tier III
Retirement Plan.
4. Workers' Compensation. A permanent employee shall receive 87% of regular
monthly salary for all accepted claims filed with the County on or after January 1,
1997, excluding those certain employees entitled to benefits as defined under the
Workers' Compensation Laws of California, Labor Code Section 4850.
5. PERS Long-Term Care. The County will deduct and remit monthly premium and
provide eligible lists to the PERS Long-Term Care Administrator, at no County
administrative cost, for County employees who are eligible and voluntarily elect to
purchase coverage under the PERS Long-Term Care Program.
County employees interested in purchasing PERS Long Term Care may
participate in meetings scheduled by PERS Long Term Care in County facilities
during non-work hours (i.e. coffee breaks, lunch hour).
6. Direct Deposit Administrative Fee. Effective the first of the month following Board
approval of this Letter of Understanding, the one-time $5.00 direct deposit fee
required for participation in the direct deposit payroll program is eliminated.
7. Health Care Si?ending Account. Effective January 1, 1997, the County will offer
incumbents in regular full-time and part-time (20/40 or greater) positions
represented by PDOCC, the option to participate in a Health Care Spending
Account (HCSA) Program regulated under Section 125 of the Internal Revenue
Code.
8. Wellness Incentive Program. A broad-based pilot Wellness Incentive Program
will be developed with input from the joint Labor/Management Wellness
Committee. The purpose of this program will be to reward County employees with
incentives for participating in Wellness Program activities and encourage them to
live healthier lifestyles. The Wellness Committee will work closely with the Human
Resources Department on program design and implementation.
- 2 -
9. Deferred Retirement. Effective two (2) months following Board approval of this
Letter of Understanding, and under certain conditions and limitations, employees
who resign and file for a deferred retirement may continue in their County group
health and dental plan.
10. Grievance Procedure. Without regard to the time limit expressed in the Tentative
Agreement, representatives of the County shall meet and confer with
representatives of the Labor Coalition in order to develop rules and guidelines
governing the conduct and administration of Adjustment Boards.
11. Military Leave. Amend Section by add.ing "Additionally, any employee who
volunteers for service during a mobilization under Executive Order of the
President or Congress of the United States and/or the State Governor in time of
emergency, shall be granted a leave of absence in accordance with applicable
federal or state laws."
12. Child Care. The County will continue to support the concept of non-profit child
care facilities similar to the "Kids at Work" program established in the Public
Works Department.
13. Employee Representation Rights. The County recognizes an employee's right to
representation during any disciplinary interview or meeting which may result in
discipline. The County will not interfere with the representative's right to assist an
employee to clarify the facts during the interview.
14. Sick Leave. Paid sick leave credits may be used by an employee upon adoption of
a child. Paid sick leave credits may be used upon the death of an employee's
domestic partner. Use of additional accruals, including sick leave when
appropriate, may be authorized in conjunction with bereavement leave at the
discretion of the appointing authority.
15. Confidentiality of Information/Records. Any use of employee medical records will
be governed by the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Civil Code Sections
56 to 56.26).
16. Voluntary Furlough Policy. The existing VTO program shall be continued.
- 3 -
UNIT TABLE AGREEMENTS
1. Days & Hours of Work.
a. Set at 20% the administrative time per ten week cycle for physicians and
dentists to be "at risk" to fill in for described absences. Add language
requiring registrars with appropriate medical skills, the Department Head
and Division Heads of the Department of Family Medicine, and the
Residency Director, to be "at risk" for six four-hour blocks of time per
calendar year to fill in for described absences. Registrar eligibility and
scheduling shall be coordinated between the head of the appropriate
department and the headof the Department of Family Medicine. The
decision of the appointing authority or designee regarding eligibility and
scheduling of "at risk" blocks shall be final.
b. Add language which clarifies the allowable usage of staff development
time and outlines the procedures for obtaining approval for the use of staff
development time.
C. Eliminate language which permits registrars to have flexibility of
scheduling as arranged by the appointing authority or designee.
d. Add language which gives physicians rounding on holidays the same pay
as physicians rounding on weekends.
e. Add language which makes New Year's Eve and Christmas Eve paid as
weekends, beginning at 7:00 p.m., under the provisions of Emergency
Room Pay.
2. Education Reimbursement.
Increase reimbursement from $200 and $250 per fiscal year to $500 per calendar
year and expand list of items eligible for reimbursement.
3. New Section - Probationary Period.
Upon initial appointment, employees in classifications subject to this MOU
(excluding Exempt Medical Staff Resident Physicians) shall serve a six (6) month
probationary period commencing on the date of appointment. The probationary
period shall not include time served in temporary appointments or any period of
continuous absence exceeding fifteen (15) calendar days. Employees will receive
an evaluation during the probationary period.
Employees will serve a probationary period unless at the discretion of the
appointing authority, the probationary period is waived for employees who have
previously served one (1) year or more in a permanent position in good standing
- 4 -
in this bargaining unit and who have not been separated from County service for a
period of more than`five (5) years.
During the probationary period, employees are subject to termination by the
appointing authority without cause and without right of appeal or compliance with
Section 14 - Dismissal, Suspension and Demotion, or Section 15 - Grievance
Procedure.
4. Stipends.
Department Head of Nursery is deleted from assignments deemed appropriate to
receive a stipend of $500 per month. Nursery Division Head is added to those
assignments deemed appropriate to receive a stipend of $250 per month. Add
language providing an additional stipend of $75 per month to all registrars who
are required to be "at risk" (as described in No.1 a above).
5. New Section - Work Restructuring.
Upon ratification of the 1996-98 MOU, the parties agree to commence discussions
regarding changes in employment relationships and compensation structures in
order to provide cost reduction incentives. The changes to be discussed may
include, but are not Limited to, alternate staff compensation structures and the
alteration of the employment relationship of staff to create independent physician
associations. In the event of alternate compensation or employment structures,
such alternate structures will have a target implementation date of January 1,
1999.
The parties will meet and confer with respect to implementation of changes by
which county health services are provided and with respect to the work and
compensation of represented employees. The parties also agree to meet and
confer with respect to terms and conditions of employment associated with any
such restructuring, including, but not limited to job security and severance.
Dated:
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
WZ
Kathy Ito I Stephbbaniels MD, President
Labor Relations Manager }'p <<
cc: Leslie Knight, Director of Human Resources
Human Resources Division - Personnel Services Unit
Health Services Department
Auditor/Payroll
- 5 -
r
LABOR COALITION - 1996 NEGOTIATIONS
SETTLEMENT.PACKAGE
Presented: 10/15/96
7:30 PM
COALITION PROPOSALS:
• Duration of Agreement
• 10/01/95 - 09/30/99
• Wages (Cl)
•
07/01/96 - 3.0% increase
•
10/01/97 - 2.0% increase plus Tier III or 3.0% increase
• 1 0101/98 - 3.5% increase
• Retirement
• Tentative Agreement on Management Proposal dated 10/07/96 (10:30 PM)
Special Benefits (C21)
• Tentative Agreement on Management Proposal dated 10/15/96
• Temporary Employees (C23)
• Tentative Agreement on Management Proposal dated 07/25/96_
• PI Employees Health Plan (C31)
• Withdrawn
• Worker's Compensation (C37 & M17)
• Tentative Agreement that on or after January 1, 1997, percentage will be
reduced to 87%.
MANAGEMENT PROPOSALS
• Differentials (M25)
Tentative Agreement on Management Proposal dated 6/10/96
• Bi-Weekly Pay
• Tentative Agreement on Management Proposal dated 8/10/96
• Annual Leave (M26)
• Withdrawn
DATED: /04 ( •d l/FOR COUNTY FOR COALITION
-k J
J ' J
Y
LABOR-COALITION
MANAGEMENT COUNTER TO C2
PRESENTED: OCTOBER 7, 1996
10:30 PM
C2 - RETIREMENT PROPOSAL
Subject to the enactment of enabling legislation amending the 1937 Employees'
Retirement Act to allow such election, the County will permit certain Tier II employees to
elect a Tier III Retirement Plan under the following conditions:
1. The County and the Labor Coalition must agree on the wording of the legislation
and both parties must support the legislation.
2. Except for disability, all benefit rights, eligibility for and amounts of all other benefit
entitlements for Tier III, from and after the date of implementation, shall be the same
as Tier I. The disability benefits for Tier III shall be the same as the current Tier II
disability provisions-
3. The amount of the employee's required retirement contribution shall be established
by the County Employees' Retirement Association and shall be based on the
employee's age at entry into the retirement system.
4. Employees represented by the Labor Coalition and its member employee
organizations (herein referred to as 'Labor Coalition') enrolled in Tier II who have
attained five (5) years of retirement credited service as of the effective date of the
enabling legislation shall have a six(6) month period after such date to make a one
time irrevocable election of the Tier III Retirement Plan expressed herein subject
to action by the Board of Supervisors to..implement the Plan. Thereafter, employees
represented by the Labor Coalition enrolled in Tier II who have attained five (5)
years of retirement credited service shall have a ninety (90) day period to make a
one time irrevocable election of the Tier III Retirement Plan expressed herein.
5. a. The County's employer contributions and subvention of employee
contributions for Labor Coalition employees electing Tier III which exceed
those which would be required for Tier II membership shall:
1. be funded by reducing the general wage increase agreed upon to be
effective October 1, 1997, and the pay equity amounts attributable
thereto, by a percentage sufficient to reduce the County's wage
obligation by three ($3) million dollars per year; and the general wage
increase of all employees represented by the Labor Coalition shall
be reduced accordingly; and
2. in the event the County's costs attributable to the. creation and
operation of Tier III exceed $3 million per year or the County
Employees' Retirement Association's actuaries determine in future
years that the County's retirement costs have increased and that the
increase is attributable to the creation of Tier III and/or the impact of
Tier III on the County's retirement costs, such increase shall be
funded by reducing the general wage increase(s) agreed upon in
future years, and the pay equity amounts attributable thereto, to the
extent that future wage increases are granted; and the general wage
increase(s) of all employees represented by the Labor Coalition shall
be reduced accordingly; and
3. in the event the County's costs attributable to the Tier III Retirement
Plan are less than $3 million per year, the difference shall be divided
by twelve and each twelfth shall be augmented by an amount equal
to the County's common pooled fund interest which would have
accrued if one twelfth had been invested in the first month of the past
year, two twelfths in the second month of the past year and so forth;
and
4. any savings to the County resulting from the creation and operation
of Tier III shall be used to offset future County retirement cost
increases attributable to the creation and operation of Tier III; and
5. County savings shall be held in an account by the Auditor-Controller
which is invested in the County's common pooled fund and will accrue
interest accordingly. The County will report yearly to the Labor
Coalition on a)the beginning account balance, b) the interest earned,
c) expenditures from the account to cover increased costs resulting
from the Tier III Retirement Plan, and d) the ending account balance.
b. Any increased costs to the Couhty"due to Tier 111 participation by employees
not represented by the Labor Coalition, shall not be funded bye-reduction of
general wage increases otherwise due to the employees represented by the
Labor Coalition.
C. Subject to the provisions expressed above, any and all additional employer
and County-paid employee contributions which exceed the sum of the
County's legally required contributions under Tier 11 shall be recovered by
reducing general wage increases to the employees represented by the Labor
Coalition.
d. Any disputes regarding cost or savings shall be subject to binding arbitration
upon demand of the Labor Coalition or the County.
2
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL NO. 13
Presented 08/10/95
SALARIES
The one time $5.00 direct deposit fee required for participation in the direct
deposit payroll program is eliminated effective the first of the month following
Board of Supervisors' approval of this MOU.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED: /7 3
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
-/VA
z
LABOR COALITION- 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS MANAGEMENT PROPOSALNO.20A
Presented:2/29/95
HEALTH CARE SPENDING ACCOUNT
The County will offer regular full-time and part-time (20/40 or greater) County
employees the option to participate in a Health Care Spending Account (HCSA)
Program designed to qualify for tax savings under Section 125 of the-Internal
Revenue Code, but such savings are not guaranteed. The HCSA Program allows
employees to set aside a pre-determined amount of money from their paycheck,
not to exceed $2400 per year, for health care expenses not reimbursed by any
other health benefits plan with before tax dollars. HCSA dollars can be
expended on any eligible medical expenses allowed by Internal Revenue Code
Section 125. Any unused balance can not be recovered by the employee.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED: -
FOR THE COUNTY FO THE EMPLOYEE /ORGANIZATIONS
L
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANfiZATIONS
MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL NO. 21
Presented: 12/07/95
Revised: 02/01/96
WELLNESS INCENTIVE PROGRAM
A broad-based pilot Wellness Incentive Program will be developed with input
from the joint Labor/Management Wellness Committee. The purpose of this
program will be to reward County employees with incentives for participating in
Wellness Program activities and encourage them to live healthier lifestyles. The
Wellness Committee will work closely with the Human Resources Department on
program design and implementation.
PROGRAM DESIGN
The Wellness Incentive Program design will include the development of
additional wellness activities to compliment the current Employee Wellness
Program schedule and collaboration with health plahlcarriers to develop special
programs and activities for County employees and to encourage participation in
their established wellness activities. Special emphasis will be placed on
supporting major programs such as: Smoking Cessation, Nutrition/Weight Loss.
Brown BaQ Seminars, Health Screenings and Health Fairs.
FORMAT
A point value system for program participation will be developed wherein each
wellness activity and program will be assigned a point value. Points will
accumulate and incentive prizes will be awarded to employees upon realizing
certain point levels. The value of the prizes will increase with higher point
values and one (1 ) grand prize will be awarded each year to the emp[byee with
the highest number of points.
INCENTIVES
A series of incentive prizes will be assigned to certain point values In addition
recognition for employee and department participation will be an important
aspect of the Wellness Incentive Program.
REFERRAL
The parties agree to refer the contents of this proposal to the Wellness
Committee for its consideration.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED: /
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE-EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
�Z�
LABOR COALITION 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO # C2.3
PRESENTED JULY 12, 1996
Employees Who File for Deferred Retirement
Effective two months following an approved agreement, employees who resign and file for
a deferred retirement may continue in their County group health and dental plan; the
following conditions and limitations apply:
1. Life insurance coverage is not included.
2. To be eligible to continue health and dental coverage, the employee must:
a. be qualified for a deferred retirement under the 1937 Retirement Act
provisions.
b. be an active member of a County group health and/or dental plan at the time
of filing their deferred retirement application and elect to continue health
benefits.
c. be eligible for a monthly allowance from the Retirement System and direct
receipt of a monthly allowance within 24 months of their application for
deferred retirement.
d. file an election to defer retirement and to continue health benefits hereunder
with the County Benefits Division within 30 days before their separation from
county service.
3. Deferred retirees who elect continued health benefits hereunder may maintain
continuous membership in their.County health and/or dental plan group during
the period of deferred retirement at their full personal expense, by paying the full
premium for their health and dental coverage on or before the 11th of each
month to the Auditor-Controller. When they begin to receive retirement benefits,
they will qualify for the same health and/or dental plan coverage and county
subvention to which retirees who did not defer retirement are entitled.
4. Deferred retirees who elect continued health benefits hereunder may elect not
to maintain participation in their county health and/or dental plan during their
deferred retirement period; and may instead qualify for the same coverage and
county subvention in any County health and/or dental plan when they begin to
receive retirement benefits as retirees who did not defer retirement are entitled;
provided reinstatement to a County group health and/or dental plan with county
subvention occurs no sooner than the first of the month following a full three
calendar month waiting period after the commencement of their monthly
allowance.
5. Eligibility for County subvention will not exist hereunder unless and until the
member draws a monthly retirement allowance within not more than 24 months
after separation from County service.
6. Deferred retirees are required to meet the same eligibility provisions for
health/dental plans as active/retired employees.
T2:OEFER.961
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED:
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
"j
1995 NEGOTIATIONS - LABOR COALITION
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C-17
Presented: 06/06/96
C17. GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE
Following completion of these negotiations, but no later than November 1 , 19961
representatives of the County shall meet and confer with representatives of the
Labor Coalition in order to develop rules and guidelines governing the Conduct
and administration of Adjustment Boards.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED:
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
� r
_J
i�
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C19
Presented: November 30, 1995
MILITARY LEAVE
Any employee who is reqttifed ordered to serve as a member
of the State Militia or the United States Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps,
Coast Guard or any division thereof, shall be granted a military leave for the
period of such service, plus ninety (90) days. Additionally, any employee who
volunteers for service during a mobilization under Executive Order of the
President or Congress of the United States and/or the State Governor in time of
emergency, shall be granted a leave of absence in accordance with applicable
federal or state laws. Upon the termination of such service, or upon honorable
discharge, the employee shall be entitled to return to his/her position in the
classified service provided such still exists and the employee is otherwise
qualified, without any loss of standing of any kind whatsoever.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED: /2
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
` Y
1
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C20
Presented: December 7, 1995
NEW S ECT I O N
CHILD CARE
The County will continue to support the concept of non-profit child care
facilities similar to the "Kid's at Work" program established in the Public
Works Department.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED: I o
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
10"
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C35
Presented: December 7, 1995
Revised: January 18, 1996
EMPLOYEE REPRESENTATION RIGHTS
The County recognizes an employee's right. to representation during any
disciplinary interview or meeting which may result in discipline. The County will
not interfere with the representative's right to assist an employee to clarify the
facts during the interview.
New Section for all Employee Organizations except AFSCME, Local 2700
In addition to this language, the parties agree that upon final adoption of a new
MOU the Human Resources Director will issue to all Department Heads a policy
memo similar to that distributed in Health Services dated 11/20/95 regarding
employee representation rights during an investigatory interview.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED:
FOR THE COUNTY FOD THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
dew
Contra Human Resources
J. t . . .. Department
costa - --�_.
CO f / ^,. . " -.tip Third Floor,Administration Bldg.
�y ? `� 651 Pine Street
(LIN Martinez,California 94553-1292
DATE May 16, 1996
TO: All Department Heads and Personnel Officers
FROM: Leslie T. Knight, Director of Human Resources
SUBJECT: Disciplinary Investigations
From time-to-time, questions arise as to the proper conduct of investigatory
meetings by departmental managers where discipline may result. These general
guidelines are provided to clarify the rights of employees, their representatives
and managers when an investigatorymeeting is held.
EMPLOYEE'S RIGHTS:
► To have a union representative present at any meeting when there is a
potential for disciplinary action. The person holding the meeting should
advise the employee of this right in advance. If the employee declines
union representation, that should be reconfirmed at the beginning of the
meeting. Note: if any employee requests representation in a meeting that
is non-disciplinary (e.g. counselling session or performance evaluation
conference), it is recommended that the manager grant this request rather
than escalate the employee's anxiety.
► To be informed about the subject of the meeting, but only if the employee
or union representative ask. The subject, when given, should not be
either too broad or too specific. For example, "job performance" is too
vague, but "putting false information into the computer" is probably too
specific as it might give the individual a chance to cover his/her tracks.
In this example, an appropriate response might be "concerns about record
keeping practices_"
UNION'S ROLE/RIGHTS:
► Upon request, to have a reasonable opportunity to consult with the
employee in advance of the meeting.
► To speak and actively participate in the investigatory interview_ This does
not take away the employer's right to hear the employee's personal
account of the matter under investigation.
► To ask questions of the employee.
► To offer additional information.
MANAGER'S RIGHTS:
► To hear the employee's account. This can be problematic with a nervous
employee or aggressive union representative. As a practical matter, if the
union rep insists on answering for the employee, the manager should let
him/her do so, then turn to the employee and ask if he/she agrees and/or
has anything to add.
This information is provided for general guidance. Should you have any
additional questions please contact Rich Heyne, Labor Relations Manager at
646-4] 46.
LTKjm
attachment
dIsdmt/)
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C26
Presented: November 16, 1995
ADD NEW SECTION
SECTION 14.3 - SICK LEAVE
New h. Legal Adoption of a Child - Paid sick leave credits may be used by an
employee upon adoption of the child.
fr% Accumulated paid sick leave credits. . . . .
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED:
�J
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
/&w3k
� l
JAN-16-1596 16=11 CCC PIEL DEPT 2ND FL 510 646 4299 P.02
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C28
Presented: December 7, 1995
Revised:January-]8, 1996
Amend Section 14.3 Policies Governing the Use of Paid Sick Leave
g. Death_of Family Member. An employee may use paid sick leave credits for
working time used because of a death in the employee's immediate family
or of the employee's domestic partner but this shall not exceed three
working days, plus up to two days of work time for necessary travel. se
of additional ac r� uals including sick leave when appropriate may be
authorized in conjunction with the bereavem nt leave at the discretion of
the appointing authority
All organizations except UAPD. UAPD Section 9.3 g.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED:
FOR THE COUNTY FO`R THE EMPLO EE ORGANIZATIONS
TOTHL F.0-2
1995 NEGOTIATIONS - LABOR COALITION
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO C-34
Presented: May 29, 1996
NEW SECTION
CONFIDENTIALITY OF INFORMATION/RECORDS
Any.use of employee medical records will be governed by the Confidentiality of
Medical Information Act (Civil Code Sections 56 to 56.26).
Al/
LABOR COALITION - 1995 NEGOTIATIONS
ALL EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO CI
Presented: November 30, 1995
VOLUNTARY FURLOUGH POLICY (VTO)
Last sentence to remain unchanged:
The existing VTO program shall be continued "for the life of the contract."
Sections:
Local One Section 17.3 CCPU Section 10.13
WCE Section 16.3 Local 535 (R&F) Section 16.3
Local 535 (SUPV) Section 17.3 CNA Section 16.3
Local 512 Section 18.3 Local 2700 Section 18.3
Appraisers' Section 16.3
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATED: 7 11?`S
FOR THE COUNTY FOR THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATIONS
A0 Awl
PDOCC - 1996 NEGOTIATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO PDOCC # 5
Presented: 01/29/97
Revised: 03/10/97
Revised: 04/10/97
SECTION 6 - DAYS AND HOURS OF WORK
6.1 Days and Hours of Work. The normal work week for employees, except
Residents, shall consist of five eight-hour days or a total of forty hours, 12:01 a.m.
Sunday to 12:00 midnight Saturday; however, where operational requirements require
deviations from the usual pattern of five eight-hour days per work week, an employee
may be scheduled to meet these requirements. With the exception of Emergency Room
assignments there shall be no split shifts without the employee's consent.
The appointing authority or designee shall prepare written schedules in advance to
encompass the complete operational cycle contemplated. The employee's preferences
as well as Department's operational requirements will be considered in preparing the
schedule.
The basic physician and dental schedule, excluding Registrars, for a 40 hour position
will consist of 36 hours of direct patient care, and 4 hours of administrative time. This
administrative time shall be prorated for all employees working in a 20 hour or greater
position according to the following schedule. The nature of the administrative time
shall be decided by the appropriate Department Head. Administrative time shall be in
blocks of four hours.
Total Hours per Week Average Admin. Hours per Week
36 - 40 4
28 - 35 3
20 - 27 2
° ° 20% of the administrative time per month
ten week cycle will be "at risk to fill in for unscheduled absences and/or for any
absences for ur-gelnit short notice clinics, small clinics with two or fewer providers,
the detention facilities, or at the discretion of the Department Head, to other clinics as
necessary to allow for maximum latitude in approving leave requests. In addition, all
Registrars with appropriate medical skills, the Department Head and Division Heads of
the Department of Family Medicine, and the Residency Director shall be "at risk" for six
four-hour blocks of time per calendar year to fill in for absences as described in this
paragraph. Registrar eligibility and scheduling shall be coordinated between the head
of the appropriate department and the head of the Department of Family Medicine. The
decision of the appointing authority or designee regarding eligibility and scheduling of
"at risk" blocks shall be final. Sixteen consecutive hours per week on call time (paid
1:4) may be scheduled instead of 4 hours of "direct patient care" with the employee's
approval.
Sixteen consecutive hours per week of telephone advice nurse backup on-call time
(paid 1:8) may be scheduled instead of two hours of "direct patient care" at the
discretion of the appointing authority or designee. Individual employees with regular
evening or Saturday clinic, or regular on-call assignments are exempt from this on-call
provision, unless agreed to by the employee.
"Direct patient care" is any time in which the employee's primary responsibility is
delivering health care directly to patients, including clinics, emergency room,
procedures, diagnostic tests, and surgery.
Employees regularly scheduled to work 16 hours per week or more of Family Practice
Clinics and who have majority of their position hours assigned to Family Practice and
Urgent Care Clinics shall be eligible for staff development time. The nature of the staff
development time shall be decided by the appropriate Department Head and could
include such responsibilities as specialty clinic assignments, or activities which
contribute to patients' health, system efficiency or quality care. Employees may apply to
use such time by submitting a proposal describing the goals and process of their work
to the appointing authority or designee for approval. Employees will be notified in
writing of the decision regarding their proposal. Approval of the use of staff
development time shall be for a specific period of time and may be discontinued at any
time with a written explanation, at the discretion of the appointing authority or designee
Employees involved in such work shall be required to submit periodic progress reports
as determined by the appointing authority or designee.
Those employees in 40-hour positions will be assigned 4 hours of staff development
time per week. This staff development time shall be prorated for those qualifying
employees working in a 24-hour or greater position according to the following schedule:
Total Hours per Week Staff Development Hours per Week
36 - 40 4
28 - 35 3
24 - 27 2
All physicians except those assigned to positions in the Emergency Department will be
scheduled to work between the hours of 6:00 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., (normally between
8:00 a.m. and 5:00,p.m.) Monday through Friday.
The schedule for any physician working at least 20 hours per week may include one
four-hour evening clinic per week and/or one 4, 6, or 8 hour weekend clinic every eight
weeks, at the discretion of the appointing authority or designee. Physicians with
regular weekend direct patient care responsibilities are exempt from weekend clinic
assignments. Such clinics will be compensated at the physician's base rate plus $10
per hour. Except for those physicians assigned to positions in the Emergency
Department, additional evening or weekend work will be by mutual agreement. Such
work will be compensated as described in Section 6.6 Emergency Room Pay. This
additional compensation applies only to the scheduled time and does not include
unscheduled work required for patient care needs or inpatient morning rounds.
The normal work week for residents shall be determined by the Residency Program
Director.
Schedules reflecting the administrative hours and staff development hours will be
implemented 90 days after the adoption of this memorandum of understanding.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATE: F- q ( 7 -
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
PDOCC - 1996 NEGOTIATIONS
MANAGEMENT COUNTER PROPOSAL TO PDOCC NO. 6
Presented: 01/15/97
Revised: 01/ 29/97
Revised: 02/05/97
Revised: 04/10/97
Revised: 05121/97
SECTION 17 - EDUCATION REIMBURSEMENT
Employees *R e Glass of Exempt MedmGal Staff Resident Dhvsirian shalt be
inihle for $250 per ral8Rdar year, anr) eanh other permanent full time
employees in classifications subject to this MOU will be eligible for $2-00 500
each calendar year, to be applied to reimbursement for continuing education
courses and associated tests, medical books and journals, medical on-line
computer services (e.g. Grateful Med), computer hardware and software, from a
standardized County-approved list or with appointing authority approval, provided
each employee complies with the provisions of the Computer Use and Security
Policy adopted by the Board of Supervisors. ExGept that employees iR the Glass
of Exempt MediGal Staff Resident Physidan shall be eligible for $250 PeF fisGa4
yeas Unused reimbursement entitlements may be carried over into to the next
calendar year, however, but the maximum reimbursement available in any
calendar year may not exceed twice the annual entitlement. Requests for
reimbursement must be submitted within ninety (90) days of the date the expense
was incurred. Permanent part-time Medical Staff members assigned to positions
of at least twenty (20) hours per week shall be entitled to educational
reimbursement on a prorated basis.
DATE: "cj
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
C .�
Contra 5E ` Human Resources
_l.
_- Department
Costa
County �a� �•, .j,;p Administration Bldg.
firs�U�'ft V'
651 Pine Street, Third Floor
Martinez, California 94553-1292
(510)335-1764
April 10, 1997 Leslie T.Knight
Director of Human Resources
Stephen Daniels, MD., President
Physicians' & Dentists' Organization of Contra Costa
PO Box 1803
Martinez CA 94553
RE: NOTIFICATION OF INVOLUNTARY PERMANENT CHANGE OF ASSIGNMENT
Dear Dr. Daniels.-
This
aniels:This is to confirm tentative agreement reached by Contra Costa County and the
Physicians' & Dentists' Organization of Contra Costa regarding notification of
involuntary permanent change of assignment.
Except in cases of emergency, a twenty-eight (28) day notice will be provided to any
bargaining unit member prior to any involuntary permanent change in work hours, type
of work, or work location. This provision shall not be applicable in disciplinary
situations.
If the above conforms with your understanding, please indicate agreement by affixing
your signature in the space provided below.
Sincerely,
Kathy
Labor Relations Manager
Confir ed:
72 4:
,stephLdn Daniels, MD., President
PDOCC
cc: Leslie Knight, Human Resources Director
William Walker, MD., Health Services Director
Contra ;,F Human Resources
Department
Costa
Cou nt` / Third Floor. Administration Bldg.
Y 651 Pine Street
\\ Martinez, California 94553-1292
(510)646-4064
Leslie T. Knight,
Director of Human Resources
March 5, 1997
Stephen Daniels, MD., President
Physicians & Dentists Organization of Contra Costa
PO Box 1833
Martinez CA 94553
RE: INCREASE IN HOURS
Dear Dr. Daniels:
This is to confirm tentative agreement reached by Contra Costa County and
Physicians & Dentists of Contra Costa regarding increase in hours for permanent-
intermittent and permanent part-time employees.
Permanent-intermittent and permanent part-time employees who wish to have the
hours of their position increased, must make a written request to the appointing
authority during the months of April and/or October for the duration of the new,
MDU.
The Appointing Authority reviewing these requests will evaluate them. within thirty
(30) days of their receipt, considering among other matters the actual hours
assigned to and worked by the employee during the previous 6 months, the
anticipated continuing need for their assignment for additional hours and
operational requirements.
Those requests which are approved by the department for an increase in hours
will be submitted for consideration by the County as a P-300 request within an
additional sixty (60) days. The employee will be notified in writing with an
explanation of requests not approved; PDOCC will be copied on all denials-
If the above conforms with your understanding, please indicate agreement by
affixing your signature in the space provided below.
Sincerely,
Kathy Ito
Labor Relations Manager
Confirmed:
AA—
\J
/� , A
\J � z /
Steph n Daniels, MD., resident
PDOCC
"q
cc. ' Leslie Knight, Human Resources Director
William Walker, MD., Health Services Director
Ken Corcoran, Auditor-Controller
PDOCC - 1996 NEGOTIATIONS
MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL NO. 6
Presented: 05/15/96
Revised: 01/15/97
Revised: 01/29/97
Revised: 03/05/97
Revised: 05/21/97
NEW SECTION - PROBATIONARY PERIOD
Effective with Board of Supervisors' approval of the MOU, upon initial
appointment, employees in classifications subject to this MOU (excluding Exempt
Medical Staff Resident Physicians) shall serve a six (6) month probationary
period commencing on the date of appointment. The probationary period shall not
include time served in temporary appointments or any period of continuous
absence exceeding fifteen (15) calendar days. Employees will receive an
evaluation during the probationary period.
The regular appointment of a probationary employee shall begin on the day
following the end of the probationary period, subject to the condition that the
Director of Human Resources receive from the appointing authority a statement in
writing that the services of the employee during the probationary period were
satisfactory and that the employee is recommended for permanent appointment.
If a clerical or administrative error delays a probationary report and it is
determined that it was the intent of the appointing authority to retain the
probationer, the employee affected will not suffer any loss of pay or benefits.
Employees will serve a probationary period unless at the discretion of the
appointing authority, the probationary period is waived for employees who have
previously served one (1) year or more in a permanent position in good standing
in this bargaining unit and who have not been separated from County service for
a period of more than five (5)years.
During the probationary period, employees are subject to termination by the
appointing authority without cause and without right of appeal or compliance with
Section 14 - Dismissal, Suspension and Demotion, or Section 15 - Grievance
Procedure.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATE: '1-I - G l '
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
21W
PDOCC - 1996 NEGOTIATIONS
MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL NO. 1
Presented: 05/15/96
Revised: 04/10/97
5.14 Stipends. Exempt Medical Staff Members are eligible for the following
additional compensation . An employee may be eligible for and
receive stipends in more than one category. The stipends for Registrar and
Ambulatory recognition are based on continuous service. Neither periods of voluntary
separation nor periods of involuntary separation exceeding two years, will be bridged.
A. The President of the Medical Staff will receive $500 per month.
B. The Department Heads for Ambulatory Family Medicine, Anesthesia,
Dental (excluding the classification Chief of Dental Service), Diagnostic
Imaging, Emergency Medicine, Internal Medicine, Geriatrics, Obstetrics
and Gynecology, Pathology, Pediatrics, misery, Psychiatry,
Rehabilitation and Surgery, and other comparable assignments deemed
appropriate by the appointing authority or designee will receive $500 per
month.
C. The Medical Director for Mental Health, the Residency Director and the
Director of Quality Management will receive $500 per month.
D. The Chairpersons of the Medical Staff committees charged with
considerable responsibility, such as Credentials, Medical Quality
Assurance, Utilization Review, and other comparable assignments
deemed appropriate by the appointing authority or designee will receive
$500 per month.
E. The Division Heads (e.g. Orthopedics, Nursery, Ambulatory Medicine,
and Out Patient Psychiatry, and Detention), the Assistant Residency
Director, the Assistant Surgical Registrar Chief, the Assistant Surgical
Chief and other comparable assignments deemed appropriate by the
appointing authority or designee will receive $250 per month.
F. A registrar stipend of$175 per month will be awarded as follows:
1. A registrar assigned to a position of 32 hours or more in the system
will be eligible for half of the total stipend after completing the first
three years as a registrar and be eligible for the full stipend after
completing a sixth year as a registrar.
2. A registrar assigned to a position of 20 to 31 hours in the system
will be eligible for one-quarter of the full stipend after three years
and a maximum of one-half of the full stipend after six years.
3. A registrar in the system assigned to a position of less than 20
hours will not be eligible for a registrar stipend.
A registrar is defined as a physician designated by the appointing
authority and assigned to the Emergency Room or assigned significant
teaching and inpatient care responsibilities and who possesses expertise
in a given field and acts as a resource to his/her colleagues.
An additional stipend of $75 per month will be awarded to all
registrars who are required to be "at risk" to fill in for absences as
described in Section 6.1 - Days and Hours of Work. This additional
stipend will be awarded in accordance with 5.14.F. 1, 2, and 3 above.
G. An Ambulatory Recognition stipend of $250 per month will be awarded to
Physicians assigned to the Ambulatory System, and to Psychiatrists and
Dentists as follows:
1. An employee assigned to a position of 32 hours or more will be
eligible for one-half of the full stipend after three years, and be
eligible for the full stipend after six years. The full stipend will be
the same as the full registrar stipend.
2. An employee assigned to a position of 20 to 31 hours will be
eligible for one-quarter of the full stipend after three years, and a
maximum one-half after six years.
3. An employee assigned to a positions of less than 20 hours per
week of will not be eligible for the ambulatory recognition stipend.
The above stipends will become effective on the first of the month following the
employee's appointment unless the appointment is effective on the first of the month, in
which case the stipend will commence immediately.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATE.--
CONTRA
ATE:CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
PDO CC - 1996 NEGOTIATIONS
MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL NO. 5
Presented 5/15/96
SECTION 6 - DAYS AND HOURS OF WORK
6.5 Pay for Weekend and Holiday Rounds. A physician whose assignment requires
rounding on weekends and holidays will be paid at the straight time hourly rate for time
spent rounding plus a differential of $30 per hour, with a minimum of three hours pay.
Only one three hour minimum will be paid per each twenty-four (24) hour period.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATE: Z�J 9�-
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
/ ehtaz
--�
PDOCC - 1966 NEGOTIATIONS
COUNTER PROPOSAL TO PDOCC NO. 3
Presented: 02/05/97
Revised: 03/21/97
Revised: 04/10/97
Revised: 05/21/97
NEW SECTION - WORK RESTRUCTURING
The parties recognize that changes in federal and state health care policies and in the
practices of other health care providers require that the County retain the capacity to
plan and carry out changes in the means by which county health services are provided
and in the work of represented employees. The parties also recognize that changes in
federal, state and county health care policies may have significant impact on the
working conditions, practices and careers of represented physicians and dentists.
Upon ratification of this MOU, the parties agree to commence discussions regarding
changes in employment relationships and compensation structures in order to provide
cost reduction incentives. The changes to be discussed may include, but are not
limited to, alternate staff compensation structures and the alteration of the employment
relationship of staff to create independent physician associations. In the event of
alternate compensation or employment structures, such alternate structures will have a
target implementation date of January 1, 1999.
The parties will meet and confer with respect to implementation of changes by which
county health services are provided and with respect to the work and compensation of
represented employees. The parties will also meet and confer with respect to terms and
conditions of employment associated with any such restructuring, including, but not
limited to iob security and severance.
TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
DATE: `
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY PDOCC
f,.
..........