HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES - 08111992 - 1.42 /.cfL
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF CONTRA COSTA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
Adopted this Order on August 11, 1992 by the following vote:
AYES: Supervisors Powers, Fanden, .Schroder, Torlakson, McPeak
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
SUBJECT: Beilenson Notice
The Board received a letter dated August 7, 1992 from
the Health Services Director with respect to the Beilenson Notice
drafted by the Health Services Department staff.
IT IS BY THE BOARD ORDERED that the aforementioned
notice is ADOPTED and the Health Services staff is DIRECTED to
post the adopted Beilenson Notice in accordance with the
applicable legal requirements; and SET September 11, 1992, at
2: 00 p.m. as the hearing date for the Phase II reductions set forth
in the Beilenson Notice.
I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of
CC• County Administrator an action taken and entered on the minutes of th3
Boar.. of Supervisors on the dates own.
Health Services Director ATTESTED:
PHIL BATCHEL .Clerk of th Board
of Supervisors and County Administrator
Deputy
e- .
Contra
The Board of Supervisors Costa Health Services Department
Tom Powers,1st District County OI 11 1t\/
Nancy C.Fanden,2nd District �V! l l� ���/ OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR
Robert I.Schroder,3rd District s-- c
Sunne Wright McPeak,4th District. Mark FInUCane, Director
Tom Torlakson,5th District -
Administrative Offices
o'
County Administrator 'S 20 Allen Street
•
�° i' California 94553
C
Phil Batchelor O�TA'C(jUN� RECEB�ygynr,��■(
E415),_—
County Administrator n X. (415) 70-5098
.5
DATE: August 7, 1992 AUG 1 1 1992
CLERK BOARD OF SUPERVI
TO: Board of Supervisors �i CONTRA COSTA CO.
FROM: Mark Finucane, Dire or
Health Services Department
SUBJECT: Health Services Department Phase II Reductions
The enclosed Beilenson notice has been prepared at your direction to give required public
notice of the proposed Phase 1I reductions for the Health Services Department. We are also
including reductions in public health programs which County Counsel advises us are not
covered by the Beilenson requirements. These non-Beilenson reductions will be posted with
the Beilenson notice but are identified as such. Later this week we will be providing you
with our recommended cuts to the mental health system which will also be posted.
The nature and magnitude of the cuts are devastating to the county's health care system.
I realize, of course, that the specter of state reductions to counties, as well direct health
care cuts that are under consideration by the Legislature make it necessary for us to be
prepared to further reduce the Health Services Department's budget.
On August 11, 1.992 following the Board's action on the proposed Beilenson notice, my staff
will post the Beilenson notice at the appropriate health care facility sites to meet the state
requirements for a 30 day posting before the scheduled September 11, 1992 hearing date.
MF:LB
Distribution
Supervisor Tom Powers
Supervisor Nancy Fanden
Supervisor Robert I. Schroder
Supervisor Sunne Wright McPeak
Supervisor Tom Torlakson
cc: Phil Batchelor
A-345 (10/90)
August 11, 1992
INSTRUCTIONS TO HEALTH SERVICES DEPARTMENT
AND CONTRACT FACILITY STAFF
The attached Notice of Public Hearing, must bg vosted on August 11. 1992 and must remain
posted continuously prior to the date of the hearing which will be held by the County Board
of Supervisors on September 11, 1992. You are responsible for seeing that this Notice is posted
and remains posted continuously prior to September 11, 1992. If there is more than one
entrance to your facility, please photocopy the Notice and post it at all entrances. Additional
postings at your facility may, be desirable (e.g., bulletin boards, special services entrances, etc.).
Make extra copies in case any of the posted copies disappear and need to be replaced. Thank
you.
Mark Finucane, Director,
Health Services Department
Telephone: 370-5053
BEILE\.POS
• August 11, 1992
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
T'he Board of Supervisors of the County of Contra Costa will conduct a PUBLIC HEARING
pursuant to Health and Safety Code Section 1442.5, on the elimination of and/or reductions
in the level of health services provided by the County, and/or the closing of County health
facilities. The hearing will:be held at the following place and time:
Board of Supervisors Chambers
Room 107, Administration Building
651 Pine Street
Martinez, California 94553
September 11, 1992 - 2:00 p.m.
At the hearing, the Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors will consider the impact on the
health care needs of the County's indigents of the implementation of the changes set forth in
the attached summary.
The Board does not consider all of the program changes in the attached summary to be within
the required coverage of Health and Safety Code Section 1442.5. Its scheduling of this Hearing,
giving this Notice of Public Hearing, the holding of a Hearing, and the making of any findings,
shall not be construed as -an admission by the County of Contra Costa, or the Board of
Supervisors, that any of the actions included in the attached summary are subject to the hearing
provisions of Health and Safety Code Section 1442.5.
13E,LE. m
HEALTH SERVICES DEPARTMENT
BEILENSON SUMMARY
FISCAL 1992/93
ANNUAL
PROGRAM SAVINGS
(1) Eliminate Health Plan Referrals $1,000,000
(2) Remove BACs from Health Plan 2,200,000
3(A) Reduce Urgent Care Services 700,000
3(B) Close Brentwood Health Center 500,000
3(C) & (D) Reduce Ambulatory Care Services 25% 3,200,000
3(E) Eliminate Transportation Services 225,000
4(A) Place Children on Inpatient Adult Units 400,000
4(B) Stop Accepting No-pay Transfers 1,500,000
(5) STD Service Reduction 40,000
(6) Reduce Public Health Lab 85,000
(7) Reduce Family Planning 75,000
(8) Reduce Public Health Nurses 1,200,000
TOTAL $11 ,125,000
sb
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY HEALTH SERVICES DEPARTMENT
REDUCTIONS
FISCAL YEAR 1992-93
1. ELIMINATE ALL HEALTH PLAN OUT-OF-PLAN REFERRALS
The Contra Costa Health Plan (CCHP) refers approximately 2,850 patients annually
to providers in the community for non-emergency outpatient medical (including
psychiatric)and dental specialties and more than 67,000 non-emergency prescriptions
are filled annually for CCHP patients by community pharmacies.
Nature of the Reduction or Change: All of the Contra Costa Health Plan
patients needing non-emergency outpatient medical (including psychiatric),
dental, and pharmacy services would be directed to Merrithew Memorial
Hospital and Clinics for these services, instead of to the approximately 330
out-of-plan (community) providers.
Patients Affected: The Health Plan refers more than 2,850 members/patients
to out-of-plan (community) providers annually for non-emergency medical
(including psychiatric) and dental services, and fills more than 67,000
prescriptions at out-of-plan (community) pharmacies. All of those patients
would be redirected to County services and facilities for those services.
Appointment backlogs and waits for pharmacy services at County facilities
would increase for all of the approximately 56,300 people who use the County
medical, dental, and pharmacy services annually.
EVected Annual Savings: $1.000.000
2. REMOVE BASIC ADULT CARE (BAC) PROGRAM FROM CONTRA COSTA
HEALTH PLAN
The BAC Program is health care services provided under the County's contract with
Contra Costa Health Plan for General Assistance and Medically Indigent Adult
eligibles as described in Board of Supervisors Resolution 85/376. BAC members
receive the minimum health care services and benefits required of all federally
qualified HMO's, including coverage for medical emergencies.
1
Nature of the Reduction or Change: This change would remove all the BAC
members from the Health Plan in order to relieve the County from the
responsibility of paying for out-of-plan emergency services provided to former
BAC members.
Patients Affected: The number of BAC members enrolled in the Health Plan
at any one time is approximately 5,000. Any former BAC member receiving
emergency services at a non-County facility after removal from the Health
Plan would share liability for the cost of those services with the treating
facility and physician. Emergency services would still be available to former
BAC members at Merrithew Memorial Hospital.
erected Annual Savings $2,200,000
3. REDUCE AMBULATORY CARE SERVICES
This program provides primary care and specialty services to the clients of the Health
Services Department. Clinic services are generally provided between the hours of
8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m., Monday through Friday.
&tg5: Clinic Sites: Martinez, 2500 Alhambra Avenue
Richmond, 38th & Bissell Streets
Pittsburg, 550 School Street
Concord, 3052 Willow Pass Road
Brentwood, 118 Oak Street
This program is administered by the Division of Hospital and Clinics of the
Health Services Department.
A. Nature of the Reduction or Change: The Pittsburg, Richmond, and Martinez
ambulatory care clinics would stop providing urgent care services and convert
to an appointment-only basis. Approximately 10,400 annual provider hours
(7,280 physician (MD) hours and 3,120 family nurse practitioner(FNP) hours)
of urgent care services would be eliminated.
RHC PHS MtZ Total Hours
MD 4,160 2,080 1,040 7,280
FNP -- 2.080 1.040 3.120
Total 4,160 4,160 2,080 10,400
2
As a further result, the number of registered nurses (RN's) and licensed
vocational nurses (LVN's) who provide support to the physicians and family
nurse practitioners would be decreased.
i;
I
Staff Reductions: 3.5 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
1.5 Full Time Equivalent Family Nurse
Practitioners (FNP's)
1.5 Full Time Equivalent Registered
Nurses (RN's)
3.0 Full Time Equivalent Licensed Vocational
Nurses (LVN's)
.5 Registration Clerk
ResultingiReductions by Clinics:
I'
Pittsburg Health Center: 1.0 Full Time Equivalent Physician
1.0 Full Time Equivalent FNP
2.0 Full Time Equivalent LVN
Richmond Health Center: 2.0 Full Time Equivalent Physician
1.0 Full Time Equivalent RN
1.0 Full Time Equivalent LVN
Martinez Health Center: .5 Full Time Equivalent Physician
.5 Full Time Equivalent FNP
.5 Full Time Equivalent RN
.5 Full Time Equivalent
Registration Clerk
Patients Affected: Approximately 7,000 patients are seen annually in the
Urgent Care Clinics at the Martinez (1,600 patients), Richmond (2,400
patients),;.and Pittsburg (3,000 patients) sites. Patients requiring immediate
medical services would be directed to the closest emergency department.
Patients who are not in need of same day service would be given the first
available appointment in a family practice clinic. This change would increase
the average appointment waiting time from 6 - 10 weeks to approximately 12
18 weeks.
Expected Annual Savings: $700,000
B. Nature of the Reduction or Change: The Brentwood Health Center would be
closed. Consequently , approximately 4,576 annual provider hours (2,912
physician! hours and 1,664 family nurse practitioner hours) would be
eliminated.
3
Staff Reductions: 1.4 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
.8 Full Time Equivalent FNP
1.0 Full Time Equivalent RN
1.1 Full Time Equivalent LVN's
4.0 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Medical Records, Registration,
Supervising Clerk)
.5 Full Time Equivalent Housekeeper
Patients Affected: Approximately 1,800 patients are seen annually at the
Brentwood Health Center. These patients would be directed to the Pittsburg
Health Center. These additional appointments, along with other reductions
at the Pittsburg Health Center set forth herein, would increase the
appointment waiting time at the Pittsburg Health Center from 8-10 weeks to
approximately 12 - 18 weeks.
Expected Annual Savings: $500,000
C. Nature of the Reduction or Change: The staffing and hours at the Richmond,
Pittsburg, and Concord family practice clinics would be reduced by 25% or by
8,112 annual provider hours. Specifically:
RHC PHQ CHC Total Hours
MD 3,120 3,328 416 6,864
FNP 520 520 208 1.248
Total 3,640 3,848 624 8,112
In addition, the staffing and hours of the specialty clinics in Martinez would
be reduced by 25% or by 4,160 annual physician provider hours. These
reductions would then reduce the number of registered nurses, licensed
vocational nurses, clerical, laboratory and other ancillary staff at those clinics.
Staff Reductions: 5.3 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
.6 Full Time Equivalent FNP
3.8 Full Time Equivalent RN's
3.7 Full Time Equivalent LVN's
6.35 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Registration)
6.5 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Medical Records)
.9 Full Time Equivalent Financial
Counselor
4
2.75 Full Time Equivalent Housekeeper
1.4 Full Time Equivalent Laboratory Techs
.51 Full Time Equivalent Medical Social
Worker
2.25 Full Time Equivalent Pharmacists
.50 Full Time Equivalent Public Safety
Officers
1.0 Full Time Equivalent Radiology Tech
Resulting lReductions by Clinic:
i. Pittsburg Health Center: 1.5 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
.25 Full Time Equivalent FNP
1.5 Full Time Equivalent RN's.
1.0 Full Time Equivalent LVN's
1.9 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Registration)
2.0 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Medical Records)
.40 Full Time Equivalent Financial
Counselor
1.25 Full Time Equivalent Housekeeper
.60 Full Time Equivalent Laboratory
Tech
.26 Full Time Equivalent Medical
Social Worker
1.0 Full Time Equivalent Pharmacist
.25 Full Time Equivalent Public
Safety Officer
.50 Full Time Equivalent Radiology
Tech
Reduction in the Pittsburg Family Practice Clinic Hours:
Eliminate ten (10) clinic hours per week.
Current Hours - Monday-Friday 8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Reduced Hours - Monday-Friday 8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.
ii. Richmond Health Center: 1.6 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
.25 Full Time Equivalent FNP
1.0 Full Time Equivalent RN
1.5 Full Time Equivalent LVN's
3.05 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Registration)
5
4.0 Full time Equivalent Clerical
(Medical Records)
.50 Full Time Equivalent Financial
Counselor
1.50 Full Time Equivalent Housekeeper
.80 Full Time Equivalent Laboratory
Tech
.25 Full Time Equivalent Medical
Social Worker
1.25 Full Time Equivalent Pharmacists
.25 Full Time Equivalent Public
Safety Officer
.50 Full Time Equivalent Radiology
Tech
Reduction in the Richmond Family Practice Cliric Hours:
Eliminate ten (10) clinic hours per week.
Current Hours - Monday-Friday 8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Reduced Hours - Monday-Friday 8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.
iii. Concord Health Center: .2 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
.1 Full Time Equivalent FNP
.3 Full Time Equivalent RN
.2 Full Time Equivalent LVN
.4 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Registration)
.5 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Medical Records)
Reductions in the Concord Family Practice Clinic Hours:
Eliminate eleven clinic hours per week.
Current Hours: Monday, Tuesday, Friday -
8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Wednesday
1:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m.
Thursday
8:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m.
Saturday
9:00 a.m. - 1:00 p.m.
6
Reduced Hours: Monday, Tuesday, Friday:
8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.
Wednesday
1:00 p.m. - 6:00 p.m.
Thursday
8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Closed Saturdays
iv. Martinez Special Clinic: 2.0 Full Time Equivalent Physicians
1.0 Full Time Equivalent RN
1.0 Full Time Equivalent LVN
1.0 Full Time Equivalent Clerical
(Registration)
Reductions in the Martinez Specialty Clinic Hours:
Eliminate; ten (10) clinic hours per week.
Current Hours: Monday - Friday - 8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Reduced Hours: Monday - Friday - 8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.
Patients Affected: Approximately 4,282 patients annually would be impacted
by the combined family practice clinic reductions.
• Richmond.Health Center: 2,592 patients
• Concord Health Center: 226 patients
• Pittsburg Health Center: 1,464 patients
These reductions would increase the overall waiting time for routine family
practice appointments from 6 - 8 weeks to approximately 12 - 18 weeks.
Patients who needed to be seen before their scheduled appointment would be
directed to the emergency departments of local hospitals. Approximately
1,639 patients annually would be impacted by the Specialty Clinic reductions.
Appointment waiting times for specialty services would increase from
approximately 4 - 6 weeks to approximately 8 - 10 weeks.
Expected i:Annual Savings: $3,200,000 (in conjunction with the modification
of the clinic appointment system set forth hereafter).
D. Nature of the Reduction or Change: The clinic appointment system would be
modified to allocate visits by financial class. Insurance/MediCal/Medicare/
Health Plan (excluding BAC's)would be allocated 100% of the appointments
used by those patients in FY 1991-92 or 85,700 appointments. Uninsured
patients would be allocated 20% of the appointments used by BAC patients
in fiscal year 1991-92 (29,608) to a new level of 5,922 appointments.
7
Staff Reductions: See the staff reductions listed in the family practice and
specialty clinic reductions set forth in Section 3.0 above. No additional staff
reductions are anticipated.
Resulting Clinic Reductions: See the clinic reductions listed in the family
practice and specialty clinic reductions set forth in Section 3.0 above. No
additional clinic reductions are anticipated.
Patients Affected: Approximately 5,000 former BAC members would have
their access to available appointments reduced by 80%.
EQected Annual Savings: $3,200,000 (in conjunction with the reductions in
the family practice and specialty clinics set forth above).
E. Nature of the Reduction or Change: Eliminate all non-urgent transportation
service, including taxi and van service,between outlying health centers and the
hospital specialty services. Urgent transportation services would be retained
at current levels. Because of the reduction in the specialty services at
Martinez, there will be fewer patients needing transportation.
Staff Reductions: There would be no staff reductions as a result of this
change.
Resulting Transportation Reductions:
Eliminate all taxi service, approximately 2,557 trips annually.
Eliminate ten (10) van trips per week, per health center.
Current number of van trips per week:
Pittsburg Health Center: 25
Richmond Health Center: 25
Reduced number of van trips per week:
Pittsburg Health Center: 15
Richmond Health Center: 15
Patients Affected: Approximately 350 non-urgent care patients per week
would no longer be provided with van and taxi services for transportation
between the outlying regional centers (Pittsburg and Richmond) and Martinez
Specialty Services. These patients would use alternative means of
transportation, including public transportation. The use of public
8
transportation would increase travel time by approximately two hours (round
trip)fromPittsburg Health Center and approximately three hours(round trip)
from Riclimond Health Center.
erected Annual Saving5: ..$225,000
4. Inpatient Care Services. Merrithew Memorial Ho5Rital
Merrithew Memorial Hospital provides acute inpatient medical, surgical, obstetrical,
gynecological, pediatric, geriatric, and psychiatric services. Patients are admitted by
practicing physicians on the medical staff of Merrithew through the Emergency
Department, as well as through the Ambulatory Care System. Patients are also
admitted to Me�crithew from other hospitals in Contra Costa County, and on
occasion, from hospitals outside of Contra Costa County (the latter for residents of
Contra Costa County only). Hospitals in Contra Costa County also transfer stabilized
patients from their emergency departments to Merrithew for admission. Merrithew
operates 24 hour's per day, 7 days per week.
Merrithew is located at 2500 Alhambra Avenue, in the City of Martinez.
This program is administered by the Division of Hospital and Clinics of the
Health Services Department.
A. Nature of the Reduction or Change: The County's contract with Walnut
Creek Hospital for inpatient care to children requiring acute psychiatric
hospitalization would be canceled. All children requiring acute psychiatric
hospitalization would be admitted to the inpatient psychiatric units (I & J) of
Merrithew Memorial Hospital. Approximately 37 children would be admitted
to I & J Wards annually. I & J Units at Merrithew currently provide acute
psychiatric services to adults. With a State waiver,adult psychiatric units may
admit children.
Resulting I Inpatient Hospital Reduction:
Loss of 24 beds on each unit (I & J).
Patients Affected: This change would result in the admission of
approximately 37 children annually to the adult inpatient psychiatric units (I
& J) at Merrithew Memorial Hospital. I & J units currently have an average
daily census of 37 adults, with 40 available beds. Children admitted to I & J
units would be separated from the adults. As a result, approximately 2 - 4
existing beds, per unit, would be eliminated in order to provide enough space
and security for the children. Annually, this would have a residual impact on
the admission of 50 adults in need of acute psychiatric hospitalization.
9
Fgpgcted Annual Savings: $400,000
B. Nature of the Reduction or Change: Merrithew Memorial Hospital would
stop accepting transfers from other hospitals of the approximately 5,000
former BAC members. Merrithew Memorial Hospital would stop reimbursing
local hospitals for acute hospitalization of former BAC members. Ancillary
support and nursing staff at Merrithew Memorial Hospital would be reduced,
as more particularly set forth below, since the number of patients admitted to
the hospital would be reduced. Reimbursements to local hospitals which total
approximately $1,000,000 annually would be eliminated.
Merrithew Memorial Hospital, 2500 Alhambra Avenue,
Martinez
Staff Reductions: 7.0 Full Time Equivalent Registered
Nurses
2.0 Full Time Equivalent Licensed
Vocational Nurses
6.0 Full time Equivalent Ancillary
Support (Medical
Records, Registration, etc.)
Patients Affected: Approximately 1,068 patients, annually would no longer
be admitted to Merrithew Memorial Hospital. The only former BAC
members who would be admitted to Merrithew would be those presenting
themselves to the Merrithew Emergency Department. Since fewer patients
would be admitted to the hospital, the reduction of ancillary support and
nursing staff would have no effect on patient care. The local hospitals, who
currently are paid by the County for acute hospitalization of BAC members,
would no longer receive payment from the County for hospitalization of
former BAC members.
ExFected Annual Savings: $1,500,000
5. REDUCE SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES PROGRAM SERVICES
Annually this program provides diagnosis and treatment of sexually transmitted
disease for 3,500 Contra Costa County residents as well as field follow-up and contact
investigation.
Sites: 38th & Bissell, Richmond
550 School Street, Pittsburg
2355 Stanwell Circle, Concord
10
Nature of Reduction: The clerical staff of the Sexually Transmitted Disease program
would be reduced by 53% or one clerk. The clerical staff is responsible for receiving,
verifying, and following up reported cases of Syphilis, Gonorrhea, and Chlamydia.
Staff Reduction: 1 FTE Experienced Level Clerk
Patients Affected: Elimination of this clerical position would result in a one to two
week delay in the verification and follow-up of the County's 3,200 annual Sexually
Transmitted Disease cases. The delay in follow-up could result in additional cases
of infection of up to two or three individuals per patient.
erected Annual Savings $40,000
6. REDUCE PUBLIC HEALTH LABORATORY SERVICES
The Public Health Laboratory provides primary and reference laboratory testing for
the Hospital and:Clinics, Planned Parenthood, private medical providers, and other
laboratories in ! Contra Costa County. The laboratory provides testing for
tuberculosis, sexually transmitted diseases, and viral illnesses such as hepatitis,
herpes, and rubella, as well as enteric parasites and bacteria.
it 1111 Ward Street, Martinez
Nature of Reduction or Change: The Public Health laboratory technician staff would
be reduced by 2$% or one laboratory technician. The microbiologist staff would be
reduced by 15% or one microbiologist.
Staff Reduction: 1 FTE Public Health Microbiologist
1 FTE temporary Laboratory Technician
Patients Affected: The reduction in laboratory staff would increase the turnaround
time for test results from the current 4 days to 10 days. The longer turnaround time
would result in a.delay of approximately 7-10 days in the diagnosis and treatment of
38,000 patients seen annually at Merrithew Memorial Hospital, the Public Health
Clinics, Planned`Parenthood, and other private providers.
Expected Annual Savings $85,000
7. REDUCE FAMILY PLANNING SERVICES
The Family Planning program provides health services primarily to low-income
women. The services provided include HIV testing, STD testing and treatment,
11
contraceptive services and supplies, and diagnosis and treatment of reproductive
health problems.
Clinic Sites: 118 Oak Street, Brentwood
550 School Street, Pittsburg
2355 Stanwell Circle, Concord
Juvenile Hall, 200 Glacier Dr., Martinez
38th & Bissell, Richmond
Nature of Reduction or Change: The Concord Clinic would be closed on
Wednesdays, thereby reducing family planning services at that clinic by four (4)
hours. The Pittsburg Clinic would reduce its hours of operation by two (2) hours per
week.
Staff Reductions: .15 FTE Physician
.25 FTE Registered Nurse
.25 FTE Public Health Aide
.30 FTE Exp. Level Clerk
Clinic Reductions:
Eliminate four clinic hours per week at Concord Clinic:
Current Hours - Tuesday, 2-10 p.m.
Wednesday, 4-8 p.m.
Thursday, 9 a.m.-12 Noon
Reduced Hours - Tuesday, 2-10 p.m.
Closed Wednesday
Thursday - 9 - 12 Noon
Eliminate two clinic hours per week at Pittsburg Clinic:
Current Hours - Friday, 8:30 am. to 2:30 p.m.
Reduced Hours - Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m.
Patients Affected: Approximately 15 - 20 low income women per week (780-1,040.
annually) would be unable to obtain or would experience delays in obtaining family
planning services.
Patients affected by clinic site (on an annual basis) would be:
Brentwood 450 people
Pittsburg 620 people
12
Concord 1,400 people
Martinez 200 people
Richmond 2,400 people
Expected Annual Savings: $75,000
8. REDUCE PUBLIC HEALTH NURSING SERVICES
Public Health Nurses provide nursing services to countywide programs, clinics, and
services including: Child Health screening, Tuberculosis, Communicable Diseases,
Immunization, Employee Occupational Health, Health Care for the Homeless, High
Risk Infant, Home Health Agency, Child Abuse follow-up, Child Health and
Disability Prevention (CHDP)/Early Periodic Screening,Diagnosis, and Treatment
(EPSDT), Healthy Start, Family Planning, School Based health programs, CCHP
Advice Nurse, Well Child Care, Refugee/Migrant Health, Acute care follow-up,
AIDS, and California Children's Services. Public Health Nurses are the vital link
between the prevention/early detection Public Health services and follow-up care
and treatment, making in excess of 104,000 patient encounters, i.e. visits, telephone
follow-ups, per year.
Nature of Reduction or Change: The Public Health Nursing staff would be reduced
by 31% or 16 positions. This reduction would result in the following: .
Tuberculosis Follow-up: Approximately 120 people annually in Contra Costa County
are infected with;'tuberculosis. This reduction would result in a delay of 3 - 4 weeks
in the follow-up of infected people. The delay in follow-up will increase the chance
of spreading TB ;throughout the community. The elimination of TB education and
the provision of TB medication only in clinics will increase non-compliance among
patients with the!-possible result of an increase in multiple drug resistant TB.
Refugee Program: Each year, 800 - 1000 new refugees receive health screening and
follow-up services. More than 90% of new refugees are found to have health
conditions. Home visits and follow-up care by Public Health Nurses for TB and
enteric pathogens would be eliminated for all new refugees.
Prenatal Programs: This reduction would eliminate education annually to 1,200 new
mothers of high nsk infants. Follow-up would be limited to children with identified
health problems!!who are in the hospital, only. This reduction would result in an
average delay of. 1 - 2 months in the identification of developing problems and
response to apptoximately 2,300 infants annually and many (approximately 750,
annually) at risk infants would not be evaluated. Home based new mother
prevention education would be eliminated.
Home Health Agency: Reduced in-home care services to 1,150 people annually who
are the homebound frail elderly, acutely ill, infants and children, recent hospital
discharges, drug involved newborns and mothers and women with medical problems.
The result would be prolonged illnesses, increased physician, clinic and hospital visits,
13
hospital admissions, and lengthened hospital stays through convalescence (4,600
annual visits would be eliminated).
Patients Affected on an Annual Basis:
Tuberculosis Follow-up: 720 people
Refugee Program: Approximately 80071000 new refugees.
Prenatal Programs: 1,200 people
Home Health Agency: 1,150 people
Staff Reductions: 16 FTE Public Health Nurses (31%)
General Public Health Nursing: 12 FTE Public Health Nurses (39% reduction)
Home Health Agency: 4 FTE Public Health Nurses (19% reduction)
Expected Annual Savings: $1,200,000
14
r
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY HEALTH SERVICES DEPARTMENT
REDUCTIONS
FISCAL YEAR 1992-93
The reductions listed on the following pages are not subject to the Beilenson requirements,
Sections 1442 and 1442:5 of the Health and Safety Code. However, in order to inform
interested parties of these reductions, they are being posted with this Beilenson notice.
NON-BEILENSON ITEMS
AUGUST 11, 1992
PUBLIC HEALTH LABORATORY
The Public Health Laboratory provides primary and reference laboratory testing for County
Medical Services, Planned Parenthood, private medical providers and other laboratories in
Contra Costa County. The laboratory provides testing for tuberculosis, sexually transmitted
diseases and viral illnesses, such as hepatitis, herpes, and rubella as well as enteric parasites
and bacteria.
Sites: Lab - 1111 Ward Street, Martinez
1.
STD Clinic - 38th & Bissell, Richmond
STD Clinic - 2355 Stanwell Circle, Concord
STD Clinic - 550 School Street, Pittsburg
Nature of Reduction or Change: One Public Health Microbiologist will be on
maternity leave ;for six months from September 1992 through March 1993, five
months of which will not be covered by leave accruals and will not be backfilled. In
addition, effective September 1, 1992 three weekly evening STD Clinics which have
each historically; required staffing by a Public Health Microbiologist receiving
overtime pay, will be staffed via flex-time.
Staff Reduction: 1 FTE Public Health Microbiologist - 5 Months
(mid-October 1992 through mid-March 1993)
Scheduled Microbiologist O.T. - STD Clinics.
Patients Affected: Each action further increases turnaround time for test results
leading to longer time for diagnosis and treatment of patients seen at Merrithew
Memorial Hospital and Public Health Clinics such as the Sexually Transmitted
Disease Clinics.
Expected Annual Savings: $40,000
PUBLIC HEALTH CLINIC SERVICES
Provides combined health clinic management and staffing for Immunization, Sexually
Transmitted Diseases, Family Planning, Tuberculosis, Refugee, and Teen Age Program.
1
Clinic Sites: 118 Oak Street, Brentwood
550 School Street, Pittsburg
2355 Stanwell Circle, Concord ..
Juvenile Hall, 200 Glacier Drive, Martinez
38th & Bissell, Richmond
Nature of Reduction or Change: Eliminate clinic staff overtime through improved
clinic scheduling and staffing practices.
Staff Reductions: Clinic Services staff overtime
Patients15ervices Affected: No Direct Impact
Expected Annual Savings: $20,000
IMMUNIZATION PROGRAM
Provides low cost childhood immunizations to children throughout the county, with
particular focus on infants and those entering school. Across the nation and in this county
children are not adequately immunized.
Sites: Richmond, 38th & Bissell
Concord, 2355 Stanwell Circle
Pittsburg, 550 School Street
Nature of Reduction: Reduce total Immunization Clinic hours from 64 per month to
24 per month ( a 63% reduction). Remaining clinics will be two clinics per month in
each location.
Site Before After Reduction
Richmond 24 hrs./mo. 8 hrs./mo. 16 hrs./mo.
Concord 30 hrs./mo. 10 hrs./mo. 20 hrs./mo.
Pittsburg 10 hrs./mo. 6 hrs./mo. 4 hrs./mo.
Staff Reductions: Reduce hours of two staff RN's 40 hours per month each. Reduce
clerical hours by 80 hours per month for two clerks.
Patients IServices Affected: Reverses a positive trend toward increased childhood
immunizations and decreased immunization-preventable disease. Increased clinic
hours in the past two years have resulted in 13,000 additional immunizations, a 39%
increase. This increase was instituted following 108 cases of measles resulting in 2
deaths in one year. Most cases were not immunized. The County rate of
immunizations for children ready to enter kindergarten has markedly improved with
2
1
the increased clinic hours preventing untold incidents of childhood illness and death.
This reduction would result in 15,000 to 20,000 individuals not immunized.
Expected Annual Savings: $45,000
PUBLIC HEALTH NURSES
Provide Nursing support to countywide programs, clinics, and services including: Child
Health Screening, Tuberculosis, Communicable Disease, Immunization, Employee
Occupational Health, Health Care for the Homeless, High Risk Infant, Home Health
Agency, Child Abuse follow-up, CHDP/EPSDT, ADAPT, Healthy Start, Family Planning,
,
School Based Health Programs, CCHP Advice Nurse, Well Child Care, Refugee/Migrant
Health, Acute Care follow-up, AIDS, and California Children's Services. Public Health
Nurses provide the vital link between the prevention/early detection Public Health programs
and services, and access to and follow-up of treatment.
Sites: Pittsburg, 550 School Street
Richmond, 38th & Bissell
Concord, 2355 Stanwell Circle
Nature of Reduction or Change: Reduce nursing overtime through improved
scheduling, program and clinic staffing practices.
Staff Reductions: Nursing Overtime.
Patients/Services Affected: No Additional Impact.
Expected Annual Savings: $50,000
HOME HEALTH AGENCY
Delivers multifaceted professional medical, supportive and social services to homebound
patients by nurses; physical, occupational, and speech therapists; home health aides, and
medical social workers. The client population includes the frail elderly, infants and children,
the acutely ill, and patients recently discharged from hospitals. The agency further provides
visits to drug exposed newborns and mothers, and to women with medical problems.
is
Sites: Pittsburg, 550 School Street
Richmond, 38th & Bissell
Concord, 2355 Stanwell Circle
Nature of Reduction or Change: Reduce in-home visits to the indigent by Home
Health Aides and Public Health Social Workers from 3,700 visits annually to 1,500
visits annually. Specifically 1,800 annual Home Health Aide visits and 400 annual
PH Social Worker visits to non-payor covered clients would be eliminated. Eliminate
Account Clerk position thus causing delays in billing multiple payors, interrupted
cash flow and possible denial of reimbursement. Eliminate agency staff overtime.
Staff Reductions: 2 FTE Home Health Aides
.5 FTE PH Social Worker
1 FTE Acct. Clerk III
Staff Overtime
Patients IServices Affected: On annual basis, about 550 people would be affected.
Home Health Aides and Public Health Social Workers provide social and supportive
services to home-bound clients.
F,Qected Annual Savings: $160,000
COMMUNICABLE DISEASE/AIDS
The Communicable Disease program offers prevention education for people at highest risk
for STD and HIV/AIDS. Provision of brochures and "safety" kits for people at risk is a
major part of this program. A full range of support and care services are offered which
better enable people to cope with their infection or the infection of a family member.
Sites: Concord - 2355 Stanwell Circle
Richmond - 38th & Bissell
Pittsburg - 550 School Street
Nature of Reduction: Effective September 1, 1992,a reduction of outreach, education
and referral activities to persons at-risk for HIV infection. Reduce the number and
availability to other programs and the community of STD and AIDS Brochures and
education materials, and reduce by 50% the number of Bleach kits provided IV Drug
Users. Eliminate support groups for people with HIV and their families.
Staff Reduction: 1 FTE PH Aide - AIDS Outreach Worker
1 FTE Patient Financial Services Spec. - AIDS
.175 FTE Temp. Sr. Health Ed. Spec. - AIDS
.075 FTE Temp. Health Ed.Specialist - AIDS
Communicable Disease/AIDS staff overtime
Patients/Services Affected: On annual basis 14,000-15,000 persons most at risk for
HIV infection and Sexually Transmitted Disease would be affected.
4
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES COUNCIL
Sites: Martinez - 597 Center Avenue
Richmond - George Miller Center-West
Nature of Reduction: Effective September 1, 1992, eliminate county/department
staff support to the Developmental Disabilities Council.
Staff Reduction: .5 FTE Executive Assistant, Developmental
Disabilities Council
Patients Affected:Advocacy and services coordination for services to developmentally
disabled recipients throughout the county.
Expected Annual SavinEs: $ 40,000
PREVENTION PROGRAM
Sites: Pleasant Hill - 75 Santa Barbara Rd.
Richmond - 38th & Bissell
Nature of Reduction: Effective September 1, 1992, eliminate Administrative Intern
providing media"and public relations support.
Staff Reduction: Temporary part-time Administrative Intern
Patients Affected: None
Expected Savings: $ 16,000